Cronos Community pool #1320
Unanswered
oheikura-ctrl
asked this question in
Ideas
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Discussion: How Should the Cronos POS Community Pool Be Used?
Abstract
The Cronos POS Community Pool represents a unique community-owned asset.
Historically, the primary discussion around the Community Pool has focused on burning CRO in order to reduce circulating supply. While burning is a simple and transparent way to create deflationary pressure, I believe it is worth asking whether permanently destroying the funds is necessarily the highest-value use of the Community Pool.
Instead of looking only at the question of "How much CRO should we burn?", I would like to open a broader community discussion:
I would like to explore several possible approaches.
1. Continue Burning CRO
The simplest option is to continue periodically transferring Community Pool CRO to a provably inaccessible burn address.
Advantages
Disadvantages
Burning may therefore be the safest option, but is it necessarily the option with the highest long-term value?
2. Create a Community-Owned Validator
Another possibility would be to use a portion of the Community Pool to establish one or more community-owned validators.
The CRO would be delegated to the validator rather than sold into the market.
This could potentially provide several benefits:
For example, a community validator could operate under transparent governance with publicly visible finances and voting.
The key question would be how the validator should be governed and how its rewards should be used.
3. Community-Owned Liquidity
Another option would be to deploy a portion of the Community Pool into strategic CRO liquidity pools.
Rather than simply burning the CRO, the community could use its capital to improve liquidity and potentially generate trading fees.
Potential benefits include:
However, this option would introduce additional risks, including impermanent loss, smart-contract risk and liquidity-management requirements.
Therefore, any liquidity strategy should only be considered after a proper risk analysis.
4. Establish a Cronos Community DAO / Treasury
A more ambitious option would be to establish a community-controlled DAO or treasury.
The Community Pool could become a long-term productive treasury rather than simply being periodically depleted.
The treasury could potentially fund:
The important principle would be that the principal should be protected wherever possible, while only a defined portion of treasury income is used.
This could turn the Community Pool into a permanent economic resource for the Cronos ecosystem.
5. A Hybrid Model
Perhaps the best solution is not to choose only one option.
For example, the Community Pool could potentially be divided into several strategic buckets:
The exact percentages should not be decided before the community has evaluated the alternatives.
Questions for the Community
I would particularly like to hear the community's opinion on the following:
Should Community Pool CRO continue to be burned?
Would a community-owned validator create more long-term value than burning the same CRO?
Should the community own strategic CRO liquidity?
Would establishing a Cronos Community DAO be a useful long-term structure?
Should the Community Pool be divided between several of these purposes?
Should treasury-generated revenue be:
What governance and transparency requirements would be necessary for a community-owned validator, liquidity position or DAO?
Proposal
At this stage, I am not proposing a specific allocation or asking for an on-chain vote.
The purpose of this discussion is to determine whether the Community Pool could create more long-term value for CRO holders and the Cronos ecosystem if at least a portion of it were used productively instead of being permanently burned.
If there is community support, the next step could be to develop a concrete proposal with:
The Community Pool is a community-owned resource.
The question is not simply how we can reduce its size, but whether we can use it to create a stronger, more valuable and more sustainable Cronos ecosystem.
What do you think is the best long-term use of the Community Pool?
All reactions