docs(roadmap): refresh -- add #279, #272, #269 to Phase 1, #274 to Phase 1 Cleanup#280
docs(roadmap): refresh -- add #279, #272, #269 to Phase 1, #274 to Phase 1 Cleanup#280MScottAdams merged 5 commits intomasterfrom
Conversation
…hase 1 Cleanup - #279 (Phase 1 Adoption Blocker, t1.14.1): deft-review-cycle Approach 2 idle stoppage -- yield ends turn in Warp execution model, breaking swarm polling loop; add warning, ! rule preferring Approach 1 for swarm agents, anti-pattern - #272 (Phase 1 Adoption Blocker, t1.16.1): deft-setup agent conflates framework directory with project root during bootstrap -- reads ./PROJECT.md relative to framework clone instead of pwd, silently skips setup; add ! rule anchoring paths to pwd at skill entry - #269 (Phase 1 Adoption Blocker, t1.17.1): Warp auto-approve silently self-answers deft-setup interview, producing garbage USER.md/PROJECT.md; add post-interview confirmation gate + document Always Ask Warp setting; absorbs #271 - #274 (Phase 1 Cleanup, t1.15.1): extend mandatory pre-commit file review with semantic accuracy check for counts/claims in CHANGELOG entries and ROADMAP changelog lines - Analysis comments posted on all 4 issues; no stale entries
Greptile SummaryThis documentation-only PR triages four issues (#279, #272, #269, #274) into Phase 1, files three additional issues (#281, #282, #283), and adds spec-task skeletons for all seven in Confidence Score: 5/5Safe to merge — documentation-only changes with one minor semantic wording inconsistency. All changed content is documentation. The only finding is P2: ROADMAP.md describes the current deft-roadmap-refresh review as "4-check" when it currently has 3 checks. The SPECIFICATION.md correctly says "fourth check category." The t2.8.1 regression flagged in the prior review is now fixed. No code paths, schemas, or tests are affected. ROADMAP.md line 20 — the #274 entry wording. Important Files Changed
Flowchart%%{init: {'theme': 'neutral'}}%%
flowchart TD
A[4 Incoming Issues<br/>#279 #272 #269 #274] --> B{Triage}
B --> C[Phase 1 Adoption Blockers<br/>#279 t1.14.1<br/>#272 t1.16.1<br/>#269 t1.17.1]
B --> D[Phase 1 Cleanup<br/>#274 t1.15.1]
C --> E[Spec task skeletons<br/>added to SPECIFICATION.md]
D --> E
E --> F[3 New Issues Filed<br/>#281 t1.18.1<br/>#282 t1.19.1<br/>#283 t1.20.1]
F --> G[Phase 1 Cleanup<br/>+ Spec skeletons]
G --> H[ROADMAP.md<br/>phase bodies + index + history]
E --> H
H --> I[CHANGELOG.md<br/>Roadmap Refresh 2026-04-10]
Prompt To Fix All With AIThis is a comment left during a code review.
Path: ROADMAP.md
Line: 20
Comment:
**"4-check" count doesn't match the current review state**
`deft-roadmap-refresh/SKILL.md` Phase 4 currently lists three mandatory file-review checks (encoding, duplication, structural). `SPECIFICATION.md` t1.15.1 correctly describes the fix as adding a "fourth check category." The ROADMAP description "extend the **4-check** pre-commit review" implies the review already has four checks, which contradicts both the current skill file and the spec task — and is exactly the class of semantic inaccuracy #274 is designed to prevent.
```suggestion
- **#274** -- Add semantic accuracy check to mandatory pre-commit file review: extend the 3-check pre-commit review in deft-roadmap-refresh (and add a 5th check in deft-build, which gained a semantic-contradiction check via #251) to verify counts and claims in CHANGELOG entries and ROADMAP changelog lines match actual data (t1.15.1)
```
How can I resolve this? If you propose a fix, please make it concise.Reviews (5): Last reviewed commit: "fix: restore # Changelog H1 heading stri..." | Re-trigger Greptile |
- SPECIFICATION.md t2.8.1: restore [completed] status and full title suffix stripped during new spec task insertion - ROADMAP.md + SPECIFICATION.md: add #281 (Phase 1 Cleanup, t1.18.1) -- WinError 448 pytest-current symlink cleanup fails on Windows 11 24H2+ - CHANGELOG.md: update 2026-04-10 Roadmap Refresh entry to include #281
- SPECIFICATION.md t2.7.8: restore Traces #81 (was corrupted to #281 by PS regex replace) - SPECIFICATION.md: remove ghost empty ## t2.8.1: heading inserted by PS regex replace - ROADMAP.md + SPECIFICATION.md + CHANGELOG.md: add #282 (Phase 1 Cleanup, t1.19.1) -- deft-review-cycle MCP capability detection + task check pre-existing failure carve-out
- CHANGELOG.md: strip UTF-8 BOM introduced by [System.Text.Encoding]::UTF8 shorthand - ROADMAP.md: add #283 (Phase 1 Cleanup, t1.20.1) -- AGENTS.md ! rule for BOM-safe PS file writes - SPECIFICATION.md: add t1.20.1 skeleton for #283 - CHANGELOG.md: update 2026-04-10 Roadmap Refresh entry to include #283
Summary
Roadmap refresh triaging 4 new issues into the phased roadmap, with spec task skeletons for each.
Related Issues
N/A -- triage PR, no issues closed by this PR directly.
Checklist
Post-Merge