Error Codes

Error codes

Every framework failure is an UltimateError carrying a stable X_* code, a concrete cause, and the exact command or edit that fixes it. Same content in the terminal, the dev overlay, the HTTP body, the MCP tool result and --json.

X_DB_DRIFT: schema differs from migrations
  cause: table "posts" has column "publish_at" not present in any migration
  fix:   x db gen "add publish_at"

{"code":"X_DB_DRIFT","title":"schema differs from migrations","cause":"table \"posts\" has column \"publish_at\" not present in any migration","fix":"x db gen \"add publish_at\"","docs":"https://ultimate.dev/errors/X_DB_DRIFT"}

Rule	Detail
Lookup	x errors explain <CODE> --json, or the MCP errors.explain tool — same content as this page
Uniqueness	one code is owned by exactly one package; a collision throws X_ERROR_CODE_DUPLICATE at registration
Stability	codes never change meaning. A renamed concept gets a new code and the old one stays documented
fix	always runnable or editable as written. If a fix reads "do the right thing", that is a bug — file it
Bare Error	never thrown by the framework. Anything caught is normalised through toUltimateError()
Registration	a code exists when its owning package calls registerErrorCodes(). That one call is what makes it explainable, unique and documented-or-fail — a code emitted as a Finding rather than thrown is registered the same way
Enforcement	the errors step of x verify fails on an empty or advice-only fix (X_ERROR_FIX_INVALID), on a declared code with no row on this page (X_ERROR_CODE_UNDOCUMENTED), and on a row this page presents as live that no package registers (X_ERROR_CODE_UNREGISTERED)

As of 2026-08 every code above Reserved codes resolves through x errors explain, with one exception the gate knows about: this repository's own gate scripts (X_BOUNDARY_VIOLATION, X_ROADMAP_*, X_REFERENCE_APP_*, X_SETUP_INSTALL_FAILED, X_ADMIN_FLATTENER_VIOLATION) never ship, so no package may own them. See Troubleshooting for symptom-first triage and CLI reference for the commands named in the fixes.

Core and runtime

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_ABORTED	operation aborted	the request's AbortSignal fired: client disconnected or a deadline passed	none — stop work and return
X_INTERNAL	unexpected internal framework error	a non-Ultimate error escaped into framework code	fix the failure named in cause, then re-run
X_INVARIANT	invariant violated	framework state that "cannot happen" happened	report it with x doctor --json output attached
X_UNREACHABLE	unreachable branch was reached	an exhaustive switch met a value the type says cannot exist	narrow the union at the call site
X_NOT_IMPLEMENTED	this driver does not implement the requested feature	an interface-complete driver whose remote half is unwritten	use the default driver, or implement the named method
X_NO_CONTEXT	no request context is active	framework code called outside the ALS context	runWithContext(createContext({ … }), fn)
X_SERVICE_MISSING	service is not registered on the request context	ctx.<service> used without providing it	pass it in createContext({ services: { … } })
X_SERVICE_DUPLICATE	a service name is registered twice	two defineService('name', ...) calls used the same name	rename one of the two declarations
X_ROLE_INVALID	ROLE is not a known runtime role	typo or an old role name in the env	set ROLE to web, sync, worker, scheduler, migrate or replicator
X_DRAINING	process is draining and refuses new work	work arrived after SIGTERM	retry against another replica; the LB should already have removed this one
X_SHUTDOWN_TIMEOUT	graceful shutdown exceeded its deadline	an in-flight handler outlived DRAIN_TIMEOUT	raise configureLifecycle({ deadlineMs }) or shorten the slow handler
X_ID_INVALID	value is not a valid id	a hand-built string passed where a typed id is required	generate ids with uuid() / typedId<'post'>() from @ultimat3/core
X_CURSOR_INVALID	pagination cursor is malformed, tampered with or from another query	signature mismatch — an edited cursor, or ULTIMATE_CURSOR_SECRET rotated — or a cursor built for a different query, filter or sort order	drop the cursor and request the first page (after: null)
X_CURSOR_SECRET_DEV	cursors are signed with the shipped development key	ULTIMATE_CURSOR_SECRET is unset in a production environment, so the signing key is the constant published in @ultimat3/core and a client can forge a page position. Reported by x doctor, never thrown	export ULTIMATE_CURSOR_SECRET="$(openssl rand -hex 32)"
X_ERROR_CODE_DUPLICATE	error code registered twice	two packages declared the same code	rename the colliding code in the registering package's src/errors.ts
X_REGISTRAR_MISSING	no registrar is loaded for a primitive kind	the owning package is absent from the graph, so nothing announced a registrar — defineApi({ queries }) without @ultimat3/query. meta.kind names the kind, and the owner is @ultimat3/<kind>; importing it is what announces	bun add @ultimat3/<kind>
X_REGISTRAR_CONFLICT	two different registrars are loaded for one primitive kind	two copies of @ultimat3/<kind> in the dependency tree, each with its own registry, so half the primitives register where nothing reads them. bun pm why @ultimat3/<kind> names the dependents when ranges genuinely disagree	bun update @ultimat3/<kind>

Images

One pipeline in @ultimat3/core serves storage, seo and pwa. It decodes and encodes PNG and JPEG only; WebP, AVIF, GIF and SVG are identified and measured — enough to inline width/height and keep CLS at 0 — but never synthesised. A variant in one of those formats comes from a CDN or an ImageTransformDriver, never from a silent passthrough.

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_IMAGE_UNSUPPORTED	the built-in image pipeline cannot read or write this format	a WebP/AVIF source, a request for an AVIF variant, or a colour that is not hex or transparent	transformImageBytes(bytes, { format: 'png' }) (or 'jpeg'), or pass an ImageTransformDriver that produces the format — meta.format names the one refused
X_IMAGE_DECODE_FAILED	image bytes are malformed, truncated or internally inconsistent	a partial upload, a corrupted file, or a header that disagrees with the data that follows	file <path> to confirm the type, then re-export the image and retry
X_IMAGE_TOO_LARGE	image exceeds the pipeline pixel ceiling	a header declaring more than 64 megapixels — usually a decompression bomb, occasionally a real scan	transformImageBytes(bytes, { width: 4000 }) before it reaches the pipeline, or raise MAX_IMAGE_PIXELS deliberately

Config and environment

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_CONFIG_INVALID	a configuration this process cannot boot on — env or app.config.ts	a field failed its schema, a required field is missing, or two keys that each parse contradict each other (selectMailDriver, selectPurgeDriver)	x doctor --json and fix the named key; see Configuration
X_ENV_MISSING	required environment variables are missing or invalid	a key absent at boot; validation runs before the server listens	x env check --fix, then set the keys it names
X_BUN_VERSION	Bun is older than the framework floor	Bun < 1.3	bun upgrade
X_NOT_IN_APP	command must run inside an Ultimate app	no app.config.ts at or above the cwd	x new myapp && cd myapp
X_PORT_IN_USE	the dev port is taken	another x dev or an unrelated process holds it	x dev --port 3001, or stop the other process

Schema and validation

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_VALIDATION_FAILED	value did not match its schema	a parse boundary rejected input	read cause for the failing path; correct the value or widen the schema deliberately
X_SCHEMA_UNSUPPORTED	the active schema provider cannot do this	a Standard Schema implementation without JSON Schema export	drop the configureSchemaProvider() call and use t, the shipped dependency-free builtin provider

HTTP

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_ROUTE_NOT_FOUND	no route matches this request	path typo, or the route was never generated	x routes --json, then x g route <path>
X_METHOD_NOT_ALLOWED	route exists but not for this method	GET against an action endpoint	call it with the method in cause, or add that method
X_ROUTE_CONFLICT	two routes claim the same path	a copied route file	x routes --json, then remove or rename one
X_BODY_INVALID	request body failed its schema	client sent the wrong shape	x actions describe <name> --json, then match the input schema
X_UNAUTHENTICATED	route requires an authenticated actor	no session cookie or bearer token	send credentials, or set the route's auth to 'public'
X_FORBIDDEN	policy denied this actor	the actor exists but the policy said no	x policy explain <path> --json
X_RATE_LIMITED	rate limit exhausted for this key	bucket empty	retry after Retry-After, or raise rateLimit.buckets in app.config.ts
X_BUILD_SKEW	client build id does not match the server build id	a tab open across an incompatible deploy	reload; the SW fetches the new build manifest. See PWA and offline
X_SERVER_NOT_STARTED	server handle used before start()	reading url() too early in a test	await createServer({ … }).start() first
X_PIPELINE_NO_RESPONSE	a pipeline stage produced no response	a middleware returned undefined	return a Response from the stage or from the handler

Policy and authz

A denial is X_FORBIDDEN, above — @ultimat3/policy owns it and every surface adapter throws it, so there is one code for "the policy said no" wherever it was decided.

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_POLICY_MISSING	an action was declared without a policy	a new action shipped with no policy:	add policy: can('<resource>:<verb>'), or allow('public') to say so explicitly
X_PERMISSION_UNKNOWN	permission string is not in the permission set	typo, or a permission never declared	add it to definePermissions([…])
X_TENANCY_UNSCOPED	a tenant-scoped query has no org predicate	a repo call that forgot the tenant	pass { orgId }, or wrap the plan with orgScoped(entity, orgId, plan)
X_ACTION_POLICY_MISSING	an action was registered without a policy	build-time check on the action registry	add policy: can('<name>') to the declaration
X_QUERY_POLICY_MISSING	a query was registered without a policy	same, for reads	add policy: can('<name>') to the query
X_QUERY_NOT_PAGEABLE	a read returned rows with no id, so a cursor cannot name a position	a projection or aggregate that drops the primary key — the id is the tiebreak that makes the sort order total	return the key from the query's sql:, e.g. db.posts.select({ id: true, … })

Auth and sessions

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_SESSION_EXPIRED	session passed its idle or absolute expiry	cause names which of the two clocks ran out	POST /auth/sign-in { email, password } for a fresh session, or raise session.absoluteTtlMs / session.idleTtlMs in defineAuth
X_MFA_REQUIRED	password proven, second factor outstanding	the user has TOTP enrolled	POST /auth/mfa/verify { code } with the 6-digit code, then retry
X_OAUTH_STATE_INVALID	state, nonce or PKCE verifier did not match	a replayed callback URL, a handshake that expired, or a token minted for another browser	restart the flow at GET /auth/oauth/<provider> — a callback URL is single-use
X_OAUTH_EXCHANGE_FAILED	the provider refused the exchange or returned no usable identity	wrong client secret, an unregistered redirect_uri, a spent code, or a missing scope	meta.stage is token or userinfo: for token, match <PROVIDER>_CLIENT_SECRET and the registered redirect_uri, then x doctor --json; for userinfo, restart at GET /auth/oauth/<provider>
X_OAUTH_TOKEN_INVALID	the id token failed its issuer, audience or expiry check	the client id in .env is not the one the authorize URL was built with, or this host's clock is skewed	match <PROVIDER>_CLIENT_ID to the id beginOAuth() used, then restart the flow
X_PASSWORD_WEAK	strength check rejected the password	too short, or a known-common password	choose a longer, uncommon password — or relax defineAuth({ password: { minLength } })
X_ACCOUNT_LOCKED	per-ip or per-account bucket is inside its lockout	repeated failed attempts	x auth unlock <key> — cause names the key and the remaining seconds — or raise defineAuth({ rateLimit })
X_API_KEY_INVALID	key unknown, revoked, expired or wrong	one shape for all four — a precise message is an enumeration oracle	x auth keys list --json, then issue a fresh key
X_AUTH_WRITE_FAILED	an adapter write returned no row, so it cannot be confirmed	an insert … returning * wrote nothing — the table is missing its migration, or a trigger or RLS policy swallowed the row	x db migrate, then confirm the table with x db query "select 1 from x_users limit 1" --json

Entity and database

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_DB_DRIFT	schema differs from migrations	a column exists in code but in no migration	x db gen "<describe the change>" then x db migrate
X_ENTITY_DUPLICATE	two entities claim the same name	copy-pasted entity({ name })	rename one; x entities list --json
X_INVARIANT_VIOLATED	a domain invariant rejected this row	a CHECK or a declared invariant failed	x entity explain <entity> --json to see the invariant and its SQL
X_NOT_FOUND	no row for that id	stale id, wrong tenant, or already deleted	confirm with x db query "select id from <table> limit 5" --json
X_DB_UNAVAILABLE	cannot reach the database	nothing listening on DATABASE_URL, a statement the embedded driver refused, or @electric-sql/pglite not installed for a pglite:// url	set DATABASE_URL to a reachable Postgres, or x dev for the embedded PGlite — bun add @electric-sql/pglite when the url is pglite://
X_MIGRATION_CONFLICT	the migration ledger disagrees with this build	a ledger row from an app version this build does not ship, or an applied migration whose file was edited so its checksum moved	x db status --json — then deploy the version cause names, or x db gen "fix <migration>". Never edit an applied migration
X_MIGRATION_IRREVERSIBLE	this migration cannot be reversed without data loss	a generated plan that drops a column or a table	x db gen "<name>" --allow-destructive, or keep the column and deprecate it
X_BRANCH_EXISTS	that branch database already exists	x db branch create <name> twice — or a drop aimed at the database this session is connected to	x db branch drop <name>, then re-create, or pick another name. To drop the connected one, reconnect elsewhere first: DATABASE_URL=.../postgres
X_SQL_UNSAFE	SQL was built by string interpolation	a non-scalar interpolated into a sql template, or an identifier or branch name that is not [a-z0-9_-]+	pass a scalar (it becomes $n), a nested sql fragment, or wrap audited SQL in raw() — cause numbers the interpolation
X_READONLY_VIOLATION	a mutating statement reached a read-only client	an INSERT/UPDATE/DELETE sent through readOnly(db())	use db() instead of readOnly(db()), or rewrite the statement as a SELECT
X_DB_GEN_FAILED / X_DB_MIGRATE_FAILED / X_DB_BRANCH_FAILED / X_DB_STUDIO_FAILED	the underlying x db step failed	Postgres rejected the statement, or the DB is unreachable	read cause — it carries the SQL error verbatim

Actions

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_ACTION_DUPLICATE	two actions registered under one name	duplicate export names across features	rename one; names are global. x actions list --json
X_INPUT_INVALID	input failed the action's schema	wrong shape from a client or an agent	x actions describe <name> --json
X_OUTPUT_INVALID	the handler returned a value its output schema rejects	the handler drifted from the declared output	x actions describe <name> --json, then fix the handler or the schema
X_ACTION_FOREIGN	a value that is not an action was projected as one	a hand-rolled object with kind: 'action', or an action from a duplicated copy of @ultimat3/action	declare it as export const name = action({ input, output, policy, handle })
X_ACTION_UNREGISTERED	an action was projected before it was registered, so it has no name	.tool() / .client() / .job() / .openapi() on an action registerActions() never named	registerActions(await import('./actions')) at boot, before mounting routes
X_IDEMPOTENCY_CONFLICT	idempotency key reused with a different payload, or still in flight	a retried request mutated its body	send a fresh Idempotency-Key for a different payload; otherwise retry after the first settles
X_CONTRACT_DRIFT	the published contract changed	input/output shape moved without a version bump	give new inputs a .default(), or bump the package version
X_RPC_FAILED	the typed client could not reach the action or the query	gateway, network, or a non-JSON response	check the gateway, then x actions describe <name> --json (x queries describe for a read)

Queries and live queries

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_QUERY_DUPLICATE	two queries registered under one name	duplicated export	rename one; x queries list --json
X_QUERY_FOREIGN	a value that is not a query was projected as one	a hand-rolled object with kind: 'query', or a query from a duplicated copy of @ultimat3/query	declare it as export const name = query({ input, policy, sql })
X_QUERY_UNREGISTERED	a query was projected before it was registered	.tool() / .client() / .live() on a read registerQueries() never named	registerQueries(await import('./live')) at boot, before serving reads
X_MATCHER_UNSUPPORTED	the live matcher cannot evaluate this SQL incrementally	a join, aggregate or unbounded predicate under live: true	simplify the sql, add orderBy + limit, or drop live

Jobs

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_IDEMPOTENCY_REQUIRED	the job has no idempotencyKey	the field was omitted — normally a compile error, checked again at registration	add idempotencyKey: (input) => '<stable>:' + input.id
X_JOB_DUPLICATE	a name or a live key already has a job	a second enqueue inside the dedupe window, or a second job/task registered under a name already taken	pass onConflict: 'dedupe' or make the key narrower; for a name clash, rename one export
X_STEP_DUPLICATE	two step.run calls share a name	copy-paste inside run()	rename one — step names are the replay key
X_JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS	the job exhausted its retries	a step kept failing	x jobs show <id> --json for the step trace, then x jobs retry <id>
X_JOB_TIMEOUT	a job exceeded its wall-clock limit	one long step	raise timeout, or split the work into more step.run() calls
X_OUTBOX_NO_TX	enqueue outside a transaction	<job>.enqueue called with no ambient tx	wrap in ctx.tx(async (tx) => …), or enqueue with { outbox: false } deliberately
X_DRIVER_UNAVAILABLE	the queue driver is unreachable	Redis/NATS down, or the URL is wrong	x doctor --json; check the driver URL in app.config.ts

Realtime

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_TOPIC_FORBIDDEN	the actor may not subscribe to this topic	no guard, or the guard denied	hub.guard('<topic>', ({ actor }) => …)
X_SUBSCRIPTION_LIMIT	socket or tenant hit its subscription cap	a component subscribing in a loop	raise realtime.limits.perSocket / perTenant, or unsubscribe unused live queries
X_PROTOCOL_VERSION	client and sync node disagree on the wire protocol	a client from an older build	x build and redeploy the client; the node sends update-available before draining
X_CURSOR_STALE	the resume LSN is outside the change buffer	a long disconnect	pass snapshot to resumeFrom() so the fallback re-snapshots
X_REBASE_CONFLICT	a local mutation could not be rebased	server state moved incompatibly	set conflict: 'server-wins', or return a row from custom(merge)
X_TRANSPORT_UNAVAILABLE	the fanout bus is unreachable	the nats-server NATS_URL names is down or misconfigured	x doctor — then check NATS_URL
X_TRANSPORT_PROTOCOL	the bus does not speak the protocol this build speaks	nats-server older than 2.11, JetStream not enabled, or something that is not NATS on the port	run nats:2.11-alpine or newer with -js; reconnecting cannot fix it, so this never retries
X_REPLICATION_FAILED	the replication connection was refused	wal_level not logical, no publication, a slot another replicator holds, wrong credentials	the message names the object; the fix is the exact ALTER SYSTEM / CREATE PUBLICATION / pg_drop_replication_slot statement
X_REPLICATION_PROTOCOL	the WAL stream cannot be decoded	a server or pgoutput version this build does not speak, or a proxy on the replication port	x doctor db — point the URL at postgres itself, on a server ≥ 14
X_REPLICATOR_SLOT_HELD	another replicator already owns this database	replicator scaled to more than one replica, or a rolling deploy started the new replicator before the old one exited — nothing is wrong with this process, the database already has its one replicator	scale the replicator to 1 per database: kubectl scale deploy/replicator --replicas=1
X_LIVE_CLIENT_MISSING	a realtime hook ran with no LiveClient registered	useLive / useConnection / useMutation / useMutationQueue on a page whose entry never registered one	setLiveClient(new LiveClient({ signal: createSignal, connect, buildId })) in the app entry, above the first render
X_LIVE_ROW_UNIDENTIFIED	a live query returned a row with no id	a live: true read whose projection selects columns but not the primary key — patches, cursors and the local store all address a row by id	select the primary key in that query's sql(), or drop live: true from it

Cache

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_CACHE_TAG_UNKNOWN	a tag no entity declared	typo in invalidates: [tag.pots]	x manifest to regenerate the tag graph, then fix the tag
X_CACHE_TOO_LARGE	one entry exceeds the tier's byte budget	caching a whole row set	raise cache.<tier>.maxBytes, or cache a projection
X_CACHE_DRIVER_UNAVAILABLE	a tier's backing store is missing	no Redis binding, or a purge driver built without FASTLY_API_TOKEN / CLOUDFLARE_API_TOKEN	provision the tier, or drop it from app.config.ts
X_CACHE_PURGE_FAILED	the CDN refused a purge	a wrong or unscoped API token, a zone without tag purge, a throttle, a key carrying whitespace or a comma	meta.retryable === true → the identical purge can land again; false → set the env key the fix names, then x dev

Storage

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_STORAGE_CHECKSUM_MISMATCH	bytes do not match the declared checksum	a truncated upload, or a sha256 computed over different bytes than the ones sent	recompute the checksum over the exact bytes you send, or omit it and let the driver hash
X_STORAGE_DISK_UNKNOWN	no disk with that name is configured	disk('<name>') for a disk storage.disks never declared	add "<name>" to storage.disks in app.config.ts, or call one of the names cause lists
X_STORAGE_NOT_FOUND	no object at that key	a stale key, the wrong disk, or an object already deleted	list the prefix and compare: await disk('<disk>').list({ prefix: '<dir>' })
X_STORAGE_PATH_UNSAFE	object key escapes its prefix	an absolute key, a .. segment, or a backslash	build the key with scopedKey(orgId, ...parts) — relative, forward slashes, no ..
X_STORAGE_TOO_LARGE	payload exceeds the upload size limit	a file over the policy's maxBytes; cause carries both numbers	uploadPolicy({ maxBytes: <bytes> }) for a higher limit, or compress the file first
X_STORAGE_TYPE_REJECTED	content type is not allowed for this upload	a type absent from allowedContentTypes, or magic bytes that disagree with the declared Content-Type — the bytes win	add the declared type to allowedContentTypes in the upload policy, or re-upload with the Content-Type cause sniffed

Routes, render and budgets

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_ROUTE_MODE_INVALID	render mode not allowed on this surface	stream on a site/ route	use static, isr or ssr in site/; stream, spa or ssr in app/
X_ROUTE_OFFLINE_MISSING	the route's offline strategy is missing or contradictory	precache on an ssr route	set a compatible offline, or change the render mode
X_ROUTE_META_MISSING	required metadata missing	no meta.title, or no description on a site/ route	add it to meta in the route file
X_ROUTE_UNNORMALIZED	a route was registered without defineRoute	registerRoute({ config }) was handed the author's own object, so meta and budget were never normalized and every descriptor reader would read them wrong	wrap it: registerRoute({ file, config: defineRoute({ … }) })
X_ROUTE_DUPLICATE	two route files resolve to one URL	a copied page directory	delete or rename one
X_ROUTE_FILE_INVALID	a route file is not named for its surface	site/pricing.tsx or site/blog/index.tsx instead of <dir>/page.tsx	mkdir -p <dir> && git mv <file> <dir>/page.tsx — route.ts under api/
X_SURFACE_BOUNDARY	a surface imported across the hard boundary	site/ reached app/, transitively	x fix boundary <file>, or move the shared module out of shared/ui
X_BOUNDARY_SITE_TO_APP	site/ imported app/	the classic transitive import	the chain is printed in cause; break it at the named hop
X_BOUNDARY_APP_TO_API	app/ imported api/ at runtime	a value import instead of import type	use import type, and call the typed client
X_BOUNDARY_ROUTE_TO_DB	a route touched the database	SQL in a page file	move it into repo.ts and call a query
X_BOUNDARY_SERVICE_TO_HTTP	a service imported HTTP	request awareness inside business logic	take the values as arguments so a job can reuse the service
X_BOUNDARY_SHARED_LEAF	shared/ imported a surface	shared/ is a leaf	invert the dependency
X_ADMIN_FLATTENER_VIOLATION	a production @ultimat3/admin file read $meta or called $describe() directly	a new admin module reached past entity-columns.ts for column facts	take AdminColumnFacts from entity-columns.ts instead
X_BUDGET_EXCEEDED	a route blew its JS or LCP budget	a heavy transitive import	x routes --json for the chain; move it behind hydrate: 'interaction' or raise the budget deliberately
X_BUDGET_UNMEASURED	a route declares a JS or LCP budget the build never measured	the route is absent from .x/build-stats.json	x build, then x verify
X_PRERENDER_FAILED	a prerendered path threw during build	prerender() returned an id that no longer resolves	fix the data source, or narrow prerender()

SEO

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_SEO_META_MISSING	a site/ route is missing required metadata	no title, description or og.image	add it to meta; the file is named in cause
X_SEO_META_TOO_LONG	title or description exceeds what results render	a description over 160 chars	shorten it — cause carries the measured length
X_SEO_DUPLICATE_META	two routes share a title or description	copied metadata	make each page's meta unique
X_SEO_CANONICAL_MISMATCH	canonical URL does not match the route path	a hand-written canonical	delete it — canonicals come from the route table
X_LD_INVALID	JSON-LD node is missing a required schema.org field	an ld.* helper called with a partial object	supply the field named in cause
X_SEO_BUDGET_EXCEEDED	route exceeded its performance budget	a js/css/lcp/cls/inp budget broken in the SEO report	x routes --json for the route's budget, then cut the regression cause names
X_SITEMAP_TOO_LARGE	sitemap exceeds the 50,000-entry limit	too many prerendered URLs in one file	enable sitemap index splitting in app.config.ts
X_IMAGE_QUERY_INVALID	a minted image URL's ?w=/?q= value is present but unusable	?w=0, ?w=-5, ?q=150 on a URL responsiveImage() minted	request a positive integer, e.g. ?w=640 (quality is 1-100, e.g. ?q=75)

PWA and build skew

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_PWA_NO_OFFLINE_FALLBACK	pwa.offline.fallback is not set	the required field was removed	set pwa: { offline: { fallback: '/offline' } }
X_PWA_ICON_MISSING	no source icon to generate from	the configured icon path does not exist	add an SVG or >=1024px PNG and point pwa.icon at it
X_PWA_MANIFEST_INVALID	the generated web manifest failed validation	a bad start_url or scope	fix the pwa block; cause names the field
X_SW_SCOPE_INVALID	the service-worker scope cannot serve the routes it precaches	a scope narrower than the app	serve sw.js from the app root
X_BUILD_ID_MISSING	no immutable build ID	a build produced outside x build	build with x build; never use a timestamp or latest
X_PWA_STRATEGY_EXHAUSTED	a caching strategy had no cache, no network and no fallback	staleWhileRevalidate with no StrategyOptions.fallback and the network failed	pass fallback to the strategy, or set pwa.offline.fallback
X_PWA_SYNC_FLUSH_FAILED	the background-sync outbox flush was rejected	POST /_x/outbox/flush returned a non-2xx	confirm @ultimat3/realtime mounts the flush endpoint and it returns 2xx on success
X_PWA_SYNC_INCOMPLETE	the background-sync outbox flush left mutations queued	the flush endpoint reported remaining > 0	check the realtime outbox worker is draining, or raise the sync retry ceiling

i18n, money, time

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_LOCALE_UNSUPPORTED	locale is not in the supported set	a URL or header requesting an unconfigured locale	x i18n add <locale>
X_CATALOG_MISSING_KEYS	a catalog is missing keys used in source	a new t() key with no translation	x i18n sync <locale>
X_CATALOG_INVALID	a catalog entry is malformed	bad interpolation or a non-string value	x i18n check --json
X_CURRENCY_UNKNOWN	currency code not in the currency table	a typo, or a currency the table lacks	x money add-currency <ISO> --exponent <n>
X_CURRENCY_MISMATCH	two Money values in different currencies	adding EUR to USD	convert(value, '<target>', rate) first
X_MONEY_NOT_INTEGER	a Money.minor that is not an integer	a float leaked in	fromDecimal('12.99', 'USD'), or pass an explicit rounding mode
X_ALLOCATION_INVALID	split ratios or part count are unusable	zero parts, or all-zero ratios	pass a positive part count, or finite non-negative ratios
X_RATE_MISSING	no FX rate for the pair	no RateProvider registered	register one — there is no default, because a wrong rate is worse than a missing one
X_TIMEZONE_INVALID	not an IANA zone	CET, +02:00, or a typo	use Europe/Berlin, America/New_York, UTC
X_INSTANT_INVALID	not a parseable instant	a date string with no offset	pass ISO-8601 with Z or an offset
X_DURATION_INVALID	not a parseable duration	'3 days'	use '3d', '2h30m', '250ms', or ISO-8601 PT2H30M
X_CRON_INVALID	not a parseable cron expression	wrong field count	5 fields (m h dom mon dow) or 6 with seconds
X_SCHEDULE_INVALID	a wall-clock field is out of range	hour: 24 or minute: -1 in a schedule spec — cause names the field and its range	pass an integer inside the range cause prints; wall-clock fields are never wrapped or clamped, because a silently shifted schedule is worse than a failed one
X_DST_AMBIGUOUS	the local time occurs twice	a fall-back overlap	pass { overlap: 'first' } or { overlap: 'second' }
X_DST_NONEXISTENT	the local time does not exist	a spring-forward gap	pass { gap: 'next' } or { gap: 'previous' }
X_LOCALE_INVALID	not a well-formed BCP 47 tag	en_US, '', or a raw Accept-Language value reaching describeCron	pass en, en-GB, de-DE — screen header input with Intl.DateTimeFormat.supportedLocalesOf([tag])

Mail

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_MAIL_LOCALE_MISSING	send() was called without a locale	a JS caller, or a cast that dropped the required field	send(mail, data, { to, locale: ctx.locale })
X_MAIL_TEMPLATE_UNKNOWN	no mail is registered under that id	the module holding defineMail({ id }) was never imported (also raised for an unregistered layout)	export the defineMail and import it at boot
X_MAIL_DUPLICATE	two mails claim the same id	a copy-pasted defineMail	rename one of the two declarations
X_MAIL_TEXT_MISSING	the rendered mail has no plain-text part	a template of images and buttons only	add a text-bearing block: blocks.paragraph('mail.<id>.body')
X_MAIL_DRIVER_UNAVAILABLE	no mail driver is configured	setMailDriver was never called	setMailDriver(createMemoryDriver()) in dev, createSmtpDriver({ url: env.SMTP_URL }) live
X_MAIL_HEADER_INVALID	a header value carries a line break	interpolated data with a CR/LF reached Subject — header injection	reject the value at its own boundary — t.string().pattern(/^[^\r\n]*$/) on the field that feeds the header — then re-send. Never strip the break: a silently rewritten header hides the injection attempt
X_MAIL_SEND_FAILED	the mail transport refused the message	a rejected recipient, bad credentials, a throttle, a dead socket, or a peer that never completes a reply	meta.retryable === true → requeue with sendMailJob; false → fix what meta.stage names, then x doctor --json. meta.stage is the SendStage union in packages/mail/src/errors.ts: auth → SMTP_URL credentials, tls → openssl s_client -connect <host>:465 for the implicit-TLS certificate, starttls → openssl s_client -starttls smtp -connect <host>:587, recipient → the address, reply → point SMTP_URL at the SMTP port itself, since a proxy or an HTTP port answers like this

MCP and AI

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_MCP_TOOL_UNKNOWN	no such tool for this caller	a stale tool name, or one this caller may not see	call tools/list to read the catalog
X_MCP_ARGS_INVALID	tool arguments failed the input schema	guessed arguments	re-read inputSchema from tools/list and resend
X_MCP_SCOPE_DENIED	the connection's token does not carry the tool's scope	a read token calling a write tool	x token grant <scope>, then reconnect — scopes are fixed for the life of a connection
X_MCP_QUERY_REJECTED	db.query was not given one read-only statement	empty input, a batch, a non-read leading keyword, a mutating keyword anywhere at statement level (including a data-modifying CTE), a locking clause (FOR UPDATE/FOR SHARE), EXPLAIN ANALYZE, or a call from a banned function family matched by prefix (pg_read_*, pg_ls_*, lo_*, dblink, pg_advisory_*, pg_sleep*, set_config, …)	send exactly one read-only SELECT/WITH/EXPLAIN/SHOW/TABLE/VALUES statement. db.query has no write path at all: change data by calling an action exposed with mcp: { expose: true }, and change schema with db.migrate after x db branch <name>
X_MCP_NOT_BRANCH_DB	db.migrate was aimed at a database that is not a branch	a production-tagged target, or any shared/long-lived database	x db branch <name>, then retry db.migrate; production migrates through ROLE=migrate in the deploy hook, never through MCP
X_MCP_PROTOCOL	the MCP handshake or auth is wrong	missing bearer token, or a user-shaped actor	send Authorization: Bearer <token>; resolve MCP callers as agents
X_MCP_TOOL_UNDECLARED	defineAppMcp lists a primitive that declares no MCP exposure	an action or query named in actions:/queries: with no mcp block, or mcp: { expose: false }	add mcp: { expose: true, description } beside the primitive's policy — or drop it from the list and let include: 'exposed' project what opted in
X_MCP_TOOL_UNSAFE	an MCP tool declares no policy	a hand-written tools: entry written without policy	add policy: '<resource>:<verb>', reusing the permission its action uses
X_MCP_TOOL_DUPLICATE	two primitives project to one MCP tool name	a tools: record key colliding with an exposed action, or an action and a query sharing a name	rename one — the tool name is the primitive's export name, or the tools record key
X_MCP_SCOPE_UNKNOWN	defineAppMcp scopes a tool this server does not project	a scopes entry in defineAppMcp names a tool by a name absent from the projected catalog — a typo, or the primitive was renamed, or dropped from actions:/queries:/tools:	spell it as one of the projected tool names cause lists, or drop it from that scopes entry
X_MCP_SCOPE_CONFLICT	two scopes claim one MCP tool	one tool name listed under two different scopes entries, or under one entry while the tool already carries a different scope of its own	keep the tool under the single scope a token must hold for it, and remove the other entry
X_AI_BUDGET_EXCEEDED	a model call would exceed its budget	prompt too large, or cost cap reached	raise ai.budget for the scope, or shorten the prompt
X_AI_GATEWAY_MISSING	an llm() action ran with no gateway installed	boot never called configureAi	configureAi({ gateway: createGateway({ providers: [new AnthropicProvider()] }) }) at boot
X_AI_PROMPT_VERSION	prompt version or slots are wrong	an edited prompt with no version bump, or a missing variable	bump the version in definePrompt, then x manifest
X_AI_PROVIDER_UNAVAILABLE	the model provider is unreachable	a non-2xx, an in-band error event, or a stream cut before message_stop	retry a 429/5xx (the gateway already does); fix the request a 4xx names
X_AI_KEY_MISSING	the provider API key is not set	ANTHROPIC_API_KEY / EMBEDDINGS_API_KEY unset and no apiKey passed	export ANTHROPIC_API_KEY=<key>, or pass { apiKey } to the provider
X_AI_REQUEST_INVALID	the provider would reject this request	a reasoning control the chosen model does not have — effort or adaptive thinking on a pre-4.6 model, or thinking: 'disabled' above a model's effort cap	set model: on the llm() declaration to one whose MODELS row has the control, or drop effort/thinking from definePrompt — editing the template alone leaves the control in the request
X_LLM_OUTPUT_INVALID	structured output failed its schema on the answer and on the repair turn	the model would not produce the shape	describe the shape in the prompt template and bump its version, or widen output in the llm() declaration
X_LLM_REFUSED	the model declined the request	the provider's safety classifiers refused; stopDetails.category names why	set model: on the llm() declaration to another blessed model (the thrown fix: names one), or edit the template in definePrompt and bump its version
X_LLM_TRUNCATED	the answer hit its maxTokens ceiling before it was complete	the ceiling is below what the output schema asks for	set maxTokens: on the llm() declaration to double the ceiling the fix: names, or drop fields from its output schema
X_EVAL_THRESHOLD	an eval scored below its tolerance	a prompt edit regressed cases against the recorded baseline	x test <eval> for per-case scores; ULTIMATE_EVAL_RECORD=1 x test eval to accept new numbers as a reviewed diff
X_EVAL_BASELINE_MISSING	an eval has no recorded baseline to gate against	a new eval, or a baseline: that is not import.meta.resolve('./…')	ULTIMATE_EVAL_RECORD=1 x test eval, then commit the baseline file
X_EVAL_BASELINE_INVALID	a recorded baseline cannot be read	a hand-edited or half-merged baseline file	ULTIMATE_EVAL_RECORD=1 x test eval to re-record it
X_EVAL_MISSING	a prompt has no eval	a definePrompt with no defineEval naming it	add defineEval({ prompt, cases, scorers, tolerance, baseline }) beside the prompt
X_EVAL_RECORDING	the gate ran with baseline recording switched on	ULTIMATE_EVAL_RECORD was exported in the shell, or set on the CI job, that ran x verify	env -u ULTIMATE_EVAL_RECORD x verify — record with ULTIMATE_EVAL_RECORD=1 x test eval instead
X_VECTOR_DIM_MISMATCH	embedding dimensions differ from the store	the embedder model changed	use the original embedder, or x ai reindex
X_VECTOR_SCOPE_WIDENED	a derived vector scope tried to leave its tenant	a handler re-scoped the store it was handed	derive from the unscoped store: vectorStore.scoped({ tenant })
X_AI_EMBEDDER_INVALID	an Embedder returned fewer vectors than texts it was given	embedOne got an empty batch back from embed([text])	return one vector per input text from embed(), in the order the texts arrived

Admin and manifest

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_ADMIN_ENTITY_UNKNOWN	the admin references an entity that does not exist	a renamed entity	x g entity <name>, then x manifest
X_ADMIN_POLICY_MISSING	an admin-exposed subject has no policy	a screen added without authz	add policy: can('<subject>') to the definition
X_ADMIN_FIELD_UNSUPPORTED	a column type the admin cannot render	an exotic Postgres type	supply a custom field renderer, or hide the column
X_ADMIN_DENIED	the actor may not use this admin surface	missing admin:* permission	grant the permission through the normal policy layer
X_ADMIN_TOOL_FORBIDDEN	an admin MCP tool was called without permission	agent acting beyond its user	nothing to fix — the policy is correct
X_ADMIN_INVALID	an admin tool's arguments failed the resource schema	the agent built a row from a stale tool schema	x manifest, then re-read the tool's JSON Schema from tools/list
X_DEV_DASHBOARD_IN_PROD	/_x was mounted outside dev	the dev dashboard shipped in the image	delete the /_x mount from the production entrypoint
X_MANIFEST_DRIFT	a committed manifest differs from the code	a primitive changed without regenerating, or the file was hand-edited so its buildId no longer hashes its own contents	x manifest — bun run manifest for this repo's own framework.manifest.json
X_MANIFEST_STALE	openapi.json is stale	the committed spec does not match the actions the code registers	x manifest, then commit
X_MANIFEST_BREAKING	a published contract was removed or narrowed	a breaking change with no version bump	bump the major version, or restore the contract
X_AGENTS_MD_MISSING	no AGENTS.md	the human-authored file was deleted	write it by hand — short: stack, commands, conventions
X_AGENTS_MD_TOO_LARGE	AGENTS.md grew past its cap	generated facts pasted into it	move facts into x.manifest.json; keep conventions only

Testing

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_TEST_DB_UNAVAILABLE	no Postgres for the test template	nothing listening	run x dev (embedded Postgres), or set TEST_DATABASE_URL
X_TEST_FIXTURE_UNAVAILABLE	a declared fixture has no driver in this process	destructuring page, budget, signIn, deploy or subscribe with no browser or replicator installed	defineFixtures({ <name>: () => yourDriver() }) in the test preload — cause names what the fixture needs
X_TEST_FIXTURE_UNKNOWN	a test requested a fixture nobody registered	a destructured fixture name no defineFixtures call declares	defineFixtures({ <name>: () => buildIt() }) at test setup — cause lists the registered names
X_TEST_NETWORK_OFFLINE	the test network is offline	a request made after network.offline() or network.drop()	network.online() before the call — or assert the offline path instead of the request
X_TEST_NETWORK_SEALED	a test tried to reach the network	an unmocked external call	mockFetch('<url>', …), or allowHost('<host>') if it must be real
X_TEST_NONDETERMINISTIC	a test read wall-clock time or unseeded randomness	Date.now() in the code under test	wrap in frozenClock() / seededRandom(), or remove the read
X_TEST_EVAL_THRESHOLD	an evalTest() score fell below its threshold	a prompt or output regressed against options.threshold	improve the prompt under test, or lower the threshold passed to evalTest()
X_TEST_SCHEMA_EXPECTED	a matcher expected a Standard Schema and got something else	toRejectInput/toAcceptInput called on an action instead of action.input	call toRejectInput(action.input) — the schema, not the action or the query
X_TEST_JOB_EXPECTED	a matcher expected a job declaration and got something else	toEmitSteps/recordSteps called on job.run or an unrelated value	call toEmitSteps(myJob) with the job export, not toEmitSteps(myJob.run)
X_TEST_NETWORK_RACE	a request raced unsealNetwork() and lost the patched fetch	unsealNetwork() called while a request from the same seal was still in flight	do not call unsealNetwork() while a request from the same test is still pending

UI

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_TOKEN_UNKNOWN	design token role does not exist	a typo, or a raw colour that was never a token	use a role from @ultimat3/ui tokens; see Theming
X_THEME_INVALID	theme is not light or dark	a bad data-theme value	set light or dark, or clear the attribute to follow the OS
X_UI_RUNTIME_MISSING	a host capability the component needs is absent	IntersectionObserver or localStorage unavailable	render the no-JS fallback path
X_UI_INVALID_VALUE	a formatting component received an unrenderable value	NaN money, or an invalid date	fix the value upstream; formatting never guesses

CLI and verify

Code	Means	Typical cause	Fix
X_CLI_UNKNOWN_COMMAND	not a command	a typo	x help — the suggestion is in fix
X_CLI_BAD_FLAG	flag rejected	unknown flag, or a bad value	x <command> --help
X_CLI_UNEXPECTED	the CLI itself failed	a bug, or a broken environment	x doctor --json and attach it to an issue
X_VERIFY_FAILED	one or more verify steps failed	the gate is red	x verify --json — every step's findings arrive in one run
X_TYPECHECK_FAILED	tsc failed	a type error anywhere in the workspace	bunx tsc -b --pretty false
X_LINT_FAILED	Biome failed	any, a default export, a bare Error, a raw hex colour	bunx biome check --write .
X_TEST_FAILED	a test type failed	a red test	the fix is the exact bun test … invocation the step ran
X_TEST_NO_FILES	the test selection matched no files	a type or --filter that matches nothing, or x test run outside the app	drop the filter (x test), or point it at the right root: x test --cwd <repo root>. A green run over zero files is the most expensive false pass
X_TEST_SHARD_FAILED	a test shard exited non-zero	a red test inside one worker of a sharded run	the fix replays that shard alone, carrying the whole selection that produced it: x test <type> [--filter <text>] [--sample <n>] --workers <n> --worker <i>. Dropping --sample would reshard a different corpus, so the fix keeps it
X_FILE_TOO_LONG	a source file is over 500 lines	one file doing several jobs	split it; the fix names the file
X_PACKAGE_SHAPE	a workspace package is missing a contract file	a package added by hand	bun run scripts/new-package.ts <pkg> --only <file>
X_ERROR_FIX_INVALID	an error's fix line is not a runnable instruction	the errors step read a fix: that is empty, or one that advises (check, make sure, try, see the docs) with no command, call or file path in it	the fix names the offending <file>:<line> — rewrite that fix: as a runnable command, a call, or an edit naming a file
X_ERROR_CODE_UNDOCUMENTED	a shipped error code has no row in the error reference	a package declared an X_* code and the same pull request never added its row	add a row for the code to wiki/Error-Codes.md — this page
X_ERROR_CODE_UNREGISTERED	the error reference documents a code no package registers	a row written for a code that was renamed, never built, or emitted as a Finding without a registerErrorCodes() call	register it in the owning package's src/errors.ts, or move its row under Reserved codes
X_APP_PACKAGE_INVALID	the app's package.json has no usable name/version — the manifest never fabricates app@0.0.0, because its version is the compatibility gate	a malformed or hand-trimmed package.json	bun pm pkg set name=<app> version=0.1.0
X_BUILD_FAILED	x build failed	a static check or the bundler	read cause; the failing step is named
X_DEPLOY_FAILED	a deploy step failed	the compose/helm command exited non-zero	run the printed command directly for full output
X_SETUP_INSTALL_FAILED	bun install failed during bin/setup	a conflicted lockfile, or a half-written node_modules	rm -rf node_modules bun.lock && bun install
X_RELEASE_VERSION_SKEW	a workspace is not at the lockstep version	a package bumped on its own, or a release that stopped half-way	bun run scripts/release.ts --bump patch --dry-run --json to see the realignment, then run it without --dry-run and review the package.json diff
X_GENERATE_CONFLICT	a generator would overwrite a file	the name is taken	x g … --force, or choose another name
X_GENERATE_JSON_INVALID	a generator's own merge: 'json' output does not parse as a JSON object	a bug in the template that produced it — never a file already on disk, which X_GENERATE_CONFLICT covers	fix the template that emits it, then bun test packages/cli/src/cmd-generate.test.ts
X_SCAFFOLD_PATH_ESCAPE	a generated path resolves outside the scaffold sandbox	a .. segment or an absolute path in a template's GeneratedFile.path	make the path relative to the app root with no .., then bun test packages/cli/src/scaffold-typecheck.contract.test.ts
X_NOT_IMPLEMENTED	a planned command, or a driver whose remote half is unwritten	one of the commands in CLI reference's planned table	the fix names the closest shipped command — never "not a command", which would send you looking for a typo
X_ERROR_CODE_UNKNOWN	no package registered this error code	a typo, or a code from a package this process could not import	x errors list --json — the nearest real code is in fix, and data.unavailable names any package that would not load
X_DECLARATION_UNKNOWN	no declaration with this name is registered	a typo, or a module that never imported	x actions list --json (or queries / entities); the nearest real name is in fix
X_JOB_UNKNOWN	the queue holds no job with this id	a stale id, or a job already reaped	x jobs ls --json
X_FIX_TARGET_UNKNOWN	the named file is not one of the app's source files	a path outside apps/*/{site,app,api,shared}, or a typo	x fix boundary <nearest real path> — fix carries it
X_ROADMAP_FILE_MISSING	docs/idea/14-roadmap.md does not exist, so no status or artifact can be checked	the roadmap was deleted or moved — every other roadmap rule would otherwise pass silently	git checkout -- docs/idea/14-roadmap.md
X_ROADMAP_STATUS_MISSING	a milestone has no row, or its row's status cell holds neither ✅ nor 🚧	docs/idea/14-roadmap.md edited without keeping the marker	put ✅ or 🚧 in the second cell of the row fix names, then bun run scripts/roadmap.ts --json
X_ROADMAP_MILESTONE_UNVERIFIED	a milestone the table marks ✅ is missing a package or file its own Ships column names	the artifact was deleted or renamed after the milestone was marked shipped	git checkout -- <the paths in fix>, or put 🚧 in that row's status cell
X_REFERENCE_APP_REGRESSED	a step of examples/dummy's own gate that was passing now fails — or the gate produced no step table at all	a framework change broke the reference app, and the step is not one of the pinned entries in EXPECTED_RED	cd examples/dummy && bun run ../../packages/cli/src/bin.ts verify
X_REFERENCE_APP_PIN_STALE	a step pinned as failing in EXPECTED_RED now passes	the app was repaired and the pin was not lowered — the ratchet only shrinks	delete the named entries from EXPECTED_RED in scripts/reference-app-gate.ts
X_REFERENCE_APP_UNREFERENCED	examples/dummy typechecks but the root tsconfig.json does not reference it	the app came off the typecheck pin without joining the root tsc -b solution, so the packages' emitted .d.ts are never proved consumable	add { "path": "./examples/dummy" } to the references array in tsconfig.json

Reserved codes

Everything above this heading is live: x errors explain <CODE> answers for it today, and the errors step fails the build if it does not (X_ERROR_CODE_UNREGISTERED). Everything below is documented for a different reason and is deliberately outside that rule.

Not thrown yet

Reserved, not registered. The name is spoken for — the design docs use it and no future code may reuse it — but nothing raises it in this build, so x errors explain refuses it. The right-hand column is what actually happens today.

Reserved code	What happens today
X_TIMEOUT	no deadline is enforced per request. A cancelled request is X_ABORTED; a job past its deadline is X_JOB_TIMEOUT. @ultimat3/http already maps the code to 504 for the build that raises it
X_MIGRATE_CONCURRENT	ROLE=migrate takes no advisory lock, so two overlapping deploys both migrate. Serialise them in the deploy pipeline until this ships — roadmap milestone 11
X_SW_HAND_EDITED	sw.js carries no checksum, so a hand edit survives x build and is silently overwritten on the next one
X_SW_UNCACHEABLE	an offline strategy contradicting the route's render mode is accepted; X_SW_SCOPE_INVALID covers only the scope half
X_CACHE_UNTAGGED_QUERY	a query no tag covers is cached and never invalidated. X_CACHE_TAG_UNKNOWN catches the opposite mistake — a tag no entity declared

Names used in the design docs

Some design docs predate the implementation. As of 2026-08 these are the mappings; the right-hand column is what the framework actually throws. The old name stays here because a code never changes meaning — a renamed concept gets a new code and the old one keeps its row.

Design doc name	Implemented code
X_JOB_NO_IDEMPOTENCY_KEY	X_IDEMPOTENCY_REQUIRED
X_JOB_DUPLICATE_STEP	X_STEP_DUPLICATE
X_JOB_STEP_FAILED	X_JOB_MAX_ATTEMPTS (retries exhausted) or X_JOB_TIMEOUT
X_SEO_NO_TITLE / X_SEO_NO_DESCRIPTION	X_SEO_META_MISSING
X_BUDGET_EXCEEDED thrown by @ultimat3/seo	X_SEO_BUDGET_EXCEEDED — X_BUDGET_EXCEEDED is @ultimat3/render's, and one code is owned by exactly one package
X_POLICY_DENIED	X_FORBIDDEN, wherever in the stack the policy decided
X_PWA_NO_ICON_SOURCE / X_PWA_NO_FALLBACK	X_PWA_ICON_MISSING / X_PWA_NO_OFFLINE_FALLBACK — x doctor reports the package's own codes, never a CLI twin of them
X_BOUNDARY_VIOLATION	X_BOUNDARY_SITE_TO_APP and the other X_BOUNDARY_* codes. The bare name is still this repo's own tier-table finding, above
X_TEST_NETWORK_EGRESS	X_TEST_NETWORK_SEALED
X_LIVE_QUERY_LIMIT	X_SUBSCRIPTION_LIMIT
X_ENV_INVALID	X_ENV_MISSING

New codes are added in the owning package's src/errors.ts and registered through registerErrorCodes(); add the row here in the same pull request, or the errors step of x verify fails the build with X_ERROR_CODE_UNDOCUMENTED — see Contributing.