No audit log is generated when a bot add/remove a role from a member

[champymarty]

Description

When removing or adding a role to a member by a bot, it used to generate an audit log event. It does not seems to do it anymore

Steps to Reproduce

Do api call to add/remove a role from a member

Expected Behavior

Audit log is generated for the role change by the bot

Current Behavior

No audit log is generated

Screenshots/Videos

No response

Client and System Information

Using Discord window 11 client

[AlexFlipnote]

Can confirm that it is not logged, both with two different bots and listening to the gateway event itself

[valzargaming]

Can also confirm. One of my bots have role reactions built-in and the last time the audit log was touched was 7:42pm EST on 10/3, but it has continued adding and removing roles from people since.

[Pekka893]

I can confirm that too. When a member gets a role from it it doesnt send it into AuditLog last log where was given it was on 3 OCT at 5:57PM GMT+1

[tallypaws]

I can also confirm, my bot used to give roles based on other roles, but without this my bot doesnt know when roles are added

[Hibonaparte]

Also happening in our Discord Server,
and at least 2 different Discord Bots giving automatic / temprole roles are not putting it in logs

[GamingGeek]

As a workaround for now, the PATCH /guilds/:id/members/:id still produces results in audit logs so editing the roles array through that rather than the single add/remove endpoints will allow you to change roles with audit log entries

My bot uses this endpoint for any role changes and has not been impacted by this issue but if I try the single ones, I get the same result

[Polsy]

I can also confirm, my bot used to give roles based on other roles, but without this my bot doesnt know when roles are added

You should probably do this from role update events anyway, since those are a free permission and audit log access is not

[champymarty]

I can also confirm, my bot used to give roles based on other roles, but without this my bot doesnt know when roles are added

You should probably do this from role update events anyway, since those are a free permission and audit log access is not

By detecting role change with audit log, you are able to process the changes in order they occured, which is needed for my bot. Also, you can know what is the last role change you process. So if the bot loses connection or is down, you can fetch the missed audit logs entry.

[danielclancy]

Still an issue as of October 11

[tallypaws]

any estimated date on when this will be fixed?

[champymarty]

Not sure how we can make discord aware of this. Also created a bug report on discord. This is breaking key funtionnality of my bot 🥲