Resolve merge conflicts in PR #49 by integrating upstream changes #3
Conversation
Change-Id: I7e5df1a8b1f269488e08c0ca9b18f77a08e2f80a
Change-Id: I4ef04e2bfa1cd9bce8298baba041ad761eccc9d8
Change-Id: I6b19d26db85220f25bbbf9509cd083fbd159b1dd
…s/ci/add-release-please ci: add release-please workflow
…tomatically This adds explicit commit steps to the implement command for: - Track completion status updates in tracks.md - Project documentation synchronization - Track cleanup (archiving or deleting) BUG=16
…s/fix/issue-16-auto-commits fix(conductor): ensure track completion and doc sync are committed automatically
…s/fix-checkbox-issue fix: standardize Markdown checkbox format for tracks and plans
Change-Id: Ieb55f9aee5525f95681407ff01b4b73b2baef714
…s/chore/bot-release-token chore(github-actions): use dedicated bot token for release-please
Change-Id: Ibfc098f2460f8d12293018e41f0b425408f7c361
Updates GEMINI.md with the resolution protocol and refactors all commands (implement, revert, status, newTrack) to resolve file paths dynamically via index.md, removing hardcoded defaults.
…e Resolution Protocol
Ensure that styleguide templates comply with POSIX standards by ending with a newline character. This improves compatibility with command-line tools and ensures consistent formatting for generated files. Modified files: - templates/code_styleguides/go.md - templates/code_styleguides/html-css.md - templates/code_styleguides/javascript.md - templates/code_styleguides/python.md - templates/code_styleguides/typescript.md Signed-off-by: Nathen Harvey <nathenharvey@google.com>
…arvey/newline-eof style(templates): add trailing newlines to styleguide templates
…s/feat/introduce-index-md-files feat: introduce index markdown files and the Universal File Resolution Protocol
…s/release-please--branches--main--components--conductor chore(main): release conductor 0.2.0
…eguide docs: introduced C++ google style guide summary
Resolves merge conflicts by: - Taking upstream .toml files (latest prompt improvements) - Taking upstream styleguides (POSIX-compliant newlines) - Keeping fork's README.md (multi-platform documentation) - Keeping fork's CHANGELOG.md (will sync with release-please later) - Keeping fork's .gitignore (includes Node and VSIX entries) - Adding new upstream files: cpp.md, release-please config
- Regenerated all skill files from updated templates - Added .antigravity and conductor-vscode/skills directories - All 27 tests passing Co-authored-by: edithatogo <15080672+edithatogo@users.noreply.github.com>
|
Important Review skippedBot user detected. To trigger a single review, invoke the You can disable this status message by setting the Comment |
PR Compliance Guide 🔍Below is a summary of compliance checks for this PR:
Compliance status legend🟢 - Fully Compliant🟡 - Partial Compliant 🔴 - Not Compliant ⚪ - Requires Further Human Verification 🏷️ - Compliance label |
|||||||||||||||||||||||
PR Code Suggestions ✨Explore these optional code suggestions:
|
|||||||||||||||||||||||||
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Pull request overview
This PR resolves merge conflicts from PR gemini-cli-extensions#49 by integrating upstream changes with multi-platform support additions. The merge brings together upstream improvements (typo fixes, POSIX-compliant newlines, C++ style guide, release-please configuration) with fork additions (multi-platform documentation, Node.js/VSIX .gitignore entries).
Changes:
- Added POSIX-compliant newlines to all style guide files (TypeScript, Python, JavaScript, HTML/CSS, Go)
- Added comprehensive C++ style guide covering naming, formatting, classes, functions, and modern C++ features
- Regenerated skill files across all platforms (skills/, .antigravity/skills/, conductor-vscode/skills/) with updated prompt templates including phase numbering, improved git commands, and clarifications
- Added release-please configuration files and GitHub Actions workflow for automated releases
- Updated command TOML files with prompt improvements
Reviewed changes
Copilot reviewed 24 out of 29 changed files in this pull request and generated 12 comments.
Show a summary per file
| File | Description |
|---|---|
| templates/code_styleguides/*.md | Added POSIX-compliant newlines to style guides |
| templates/code_styleguides/cpp.md | New comprehensive C++ style guide |
| skills/conductor-*/SKILL.md | Regenerated with updated templates |
| .antigravity/skills/conductor-*/SKILL.md | Regenerated platform-specific versions |
| conductor-vscode/skills/conductor-*/SKILL.md | Regenerated VS Code versions |
| commands/conductor/*.toml | Updated with prompt improvements |
| release-please-config.json | Release automation configuration |
| .release-please-manifest.json | Release version manifest |
| .github/workflows/release-please.yml | GitHub Actions release workflow |
| GEMINI.md | Added trailing newline |
💡 Add Copilot custom instructions for smarter, more guided reviews. Learn how to get started.
| "type": "feature", // or "bug" | ||
| "status": "new", // or in_progress, completed, cancelled | ||
| "created_at": "YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SSZ", | ||
| "updated_at": "YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SSZ", | ||
| "description": "<Initial user description>" | ||
| } | ||
| ``` |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
There is an inconsistency in the metadata.json documentation. The example JSON includes comments (// or "bug" and // or in_progress, completed, cancelled) which are not valid JSON syntax. JSON does not support comments. These should either be removed and the valid values documented separately (as done in skills/conductor-setup/SKILL.md line 418), or the example should use placeholder syntax without comments.
| "type": "feature", // or "bug" | |
| "status": "new", // or in_progress, completed, cancelled | |
| "created_at": "YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SSZ", | |
| "updated_at": "YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SSZ", | |
| "description": "<Initial user description>" | |
| } | |
| ``` | |
| "type": "<type>", | |
| "status": "<status>", | |
| "created_at": "YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SSZ", | |
| "updated_at": "YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SSZ", | |
| "description": "<Initial user description>" | |
| } | |
| ``` | |
| Where `"type"` is `"feature"` or `"bug"`, and `"status"` is one of `"new"`, `"in_progress"`, `"completed"`, `"cancelled"`. |
| - If `STEP` is "2.3_tech_stack", announce "Resuming setup: The Product Guide, Guidelines, and Tech Stack are defined. Next, we will select Code Styleguides." and proceed to **Section 2.4**. | ||
| - If `STEP` is "2.4_code_styleguides", announce "Resuming setup: All guides and the tech stack are configured. Next, we will define the project workflow." and proceed to **Section 2.5**. | ||
| - If `STEP` is "2.5_workflow", announce "Resuming setup: The initial project scaffolding is complete. Next, we will generate the first track." and proceed to **Section 3.0**. | ||
| - If `STEP` is "2.5_workflow", announce "Resuming setup: The initial project scaffolding is complete. Next, we will generate the first track." and proceed to **Phase 2 (3.0)**. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The reference "Phase 2 (3.0)" is confusing. The section being referenced is "## 3.0 INITIAL PLAN AND TRACK GENERATION" which is titled as "PHASE 2" in its heading. The instruction should either say "proceed to Section 3.0" (consistent with other similar instructions) or "proceed to Phase 2", but not both. The mixed notation is unclear.
| - If `STEP` is "2.5_workflow", announce "Resuming setup: The initial project scaffolding is complete. Next, we will generate the first track." and proceed to **Phase 2 (3.0)**. | |
| - If `STEP` is "2.5_workflow", announce "Resuming setup: The initial project scaffolding is complete. Next, we will generate the first track." and proceed to **Section 3.0**. |
|
|
||
|
|
||
| ### 2.0 Project Inception | ||
| ### 2.0.1 Project Inception |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
There is an inconsistency in section numbering. The heading shows "### 2.0.1 Project Inception" but it should be "### 2.0 Project Inception" to match the consistent numbering pattern used throughout the document (2.1, 2.2, 2.3, etc.).
| ### 2.0.1 Project Inception | |
| ### 2.0 Project Inception |
| - **2.1 File Size and Relevance Triage:** | ||
| 1. **Respect Ignore Files:** Before scanning any files, you MUST check for the existence of `.geminiignore` and `.gitignore` files. If either or both exist, you MUST use their combined patterns to exclude files and directories from your analysis. The patterns in `.geminiignore` should take precedence over `.gitignore` if there are conflicts. This is the primary mechanism for avoiding token-heavy, irrelevant files like `node_modules`. | ||
| 2. **Efficiently List Relevant Files:** To list the files for analysis, you MUST use a command that respects the ignore files. For example, you can use `git ls-files --exclude-standard -co` which lists all relevant files (tracked by Git, plus other non-ignored files). If Git is not used, you must construct a `find` command that reads the ignore files and prunes the corresponding paths. | ||
| 2. **Efficiently List Relevant Files:** To list the files for analysis, you MUST use a command that respects the ignore files. For example, you can use `git ls-files --exclude-standard -co | xargs -n 1 dirname | sort -u` which lists all relevant directories (tracked by Git, plus other non-ignored files) without listing every single file. If Git is not used, you must construct a `find` command that reads the ignore files and prunes the corresponding paths. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The git command has been changed to use xargs -n 1 dirname | sort -u which lists directories instead of files. However, in skills/conductor-setup/SKILL.md line 91, the same command uses git ls-files --exclude-standard -co which lists files. This creates an inconsistency between the two versions. The skills/conductor-setup/SKILL.md version (which lists files) appears more appropriate for the context as the protocol mentions "list the files for analysis" and the subsequent steps reference "files" and "filtered list of files".
| 2. **Efficiently List Relevant Files:** To list the files for analysis, you MUST use a command that respects the ignore files. For example, you can use `git ls-files --exclude-standard -co | xargs -n 1 dirname | sort -u` which lists all relevant directories (tracked by Git, plus other non-ignored files) without listing every single file. If Git is not used, you must construct a `find` command that reads the ignore files and prunes the corresponding paths. | |
| 2. **Efficiently List Relevant Files:** To list the files for analysis, you MUST use a command that respects the ignore files. For example, you can use `git ls-files --exclude-standard -co` which lists all relevant files (tracked by Git, plus other non-ignored files). If Git is not used, you must construct a `find` command that reads the ignore files and prunes the corresponding paths. |
| * **CRITICAL:** You MUST ask questions sequentially (one by one). Do not ask multiple questions in a single turn. Wait for the user's response after each question. | ||
| * The last option for every multiple-choice question MUST be "Type your own answer". | ||
| * Confirm your understanding by summarizing before moving on to the next question or section. | ||
| * Confirm your understanding by summarizing before moving on to the next question or section.. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
There is a double period at the end of this line: "section.." should be "section."
| * Confirm your understanding by summarizing before moving on to the next question or section.. | |
| * Confirm your understanding by summarizing before moving on to the next question or section. |
| "type": "feature", // or "bug", "chore", etc. | ||
| "status": "new", // or in_progress, completed, cancelled | ||
| "created_at": "YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SSZ", | ||
| "updated_at": "YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SSZ", | ||
| "description": "<Initial user description>" | ||
| } | ||
| ``` | ||
| * Populate fields with actual values. Use the current timestamp. Valid `type` values: "feature", "bug", "chore". Valid `status` values: "new", "in_progress", "completed", "cancelled". | ||
| * Populate fields with actual values. Use the current timestamp. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
There is an inconsistency in the metadata.json documentation. In the skills version (lines 122-123), the type and status fields use angle bracket placeholders like "<feature|bug|chore>" which suggest these are template placeholders to be replaced. However, in the commands version (lines 121-122), these are shown with JSON comments like // or "bug", "chore", etc. which would be invalid JSON syntax. The skills version documentation on line 129 clarifies valid values, while the commands version on line 128 omits this clarification. Both approaches should be consistent, and JSON comments should not be included in example JSON as they are not valid JSON.
| **PROTOCOL: Follow this sequence to perform a guided, interactive setup with the user.** | ||
|
|
||
|
|
||
| ### 2.0.1 Project Inception |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
There is an inconsistency in section numbering. The heading shows "### 2.0.1 Project Inception" but it should be "### 2.0 Project Inception" to match the consistent numbering pattern used throughout the document (2.1, 2.2, 2.3, etc.). This is the same issue found in skills/conductor-setup/SKILL.md.
| ### 2.0.1 Project Inception | |
| ### 2.0 Project Inception |
| **PROTOCOL: Follow this sequence to perform a guided, interactive setup with the user.** | ||
|
|
||
|
|
||
| ### 2.0.1 Project Inception |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
There is an inconsistency in section numbering. The heading shows "### 2.0.1 Project Inception" but it should be "### 2.0 Project Inception" to match the consistent numbering pattern used throughout the document (2.1, 2.2, 2.3, etc.). This is the same issue found in skills/conductor-setup/SKILL.md and .antigravity/skills/conductor-setup/SKILL.md.
| ### 2.0.1 Project Inception | |
| ### 2.0 Project Inception |
| i. Automatically generate a detailed `spec.md` for this track. | ||
| ii. Automatically generate a `plan.md` for this track. | ||
| - **CRITICAL:** The structure of the tasks must adhere to the principles outlined in the workflow file at `conductor/workflow.md`. For example, if the workflow specificies Test-Driven Development, each feature task must be broken down into a "Write Tests" sub-task followed by an "Implement Feature" sub-task. | ||
| - **CRITICAL:** The structure of the tasks must adhere to the principles outlined in the workflow file at `conductor/workflow.md`. For example, if the workflow specifies Test-Driven Development, each feature task must be broken down into a "Write Tests" sub-task followed by an "Implement Feature" sub-task. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
There is a spelling error: "specificies" should be "specifies".
| i. Automatically generate a detailed `spec.md` for this track. | ||
| ii. Automatically generate a `plan.md` for this track. | ||
| - **CRITICAL:** The structure of the tasks must adhere to the principles outlined in the workflow file at `conductor/workflow.md`. For example, if the workflow specifies Test-Driven Development, each feature task must be broken down into a "Write Tests" sub-task followed by an "Implement Feature" sub-task. | ||
| - **CRITICAL:** The structure of the tasks must adhere to the principles outlined in the workflow file at `conductor/workflow.md`. For example, if the workflow specificies Test-Driven Development, each feature task must be broken down into a "Write Tests" sub-task followed by an "Implement Feature" sub-task. |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
There is a spelling error in line 417: "specificies" should be "specifies".
| - **CRITICAL:** The structure of the tasks must adhere to the principles outlined in the workflow file at `conductor/workflow.md`. For example, if the workflow specificies Test-Driven Development, each feature task must be broken down into a "Write Tests" sub-task followed by an "Implement Feature" sub-task. | |
| - **CRITICAL:** The structure of the tasks must adhere to the principles outlined in the workflow file at `conductor/workflow.md`. For example, if the workflow specifies Test-Driven Development, each feature task must be broken down into a "Write Tests" sub-task followed by an "Implement Feature" sub-task. |
User description
PR gemini-cli-extensions#49 adds multi-platform support (Qwen, VS Code, Claude, Codex) but had merge conflicts with upstream main. Upstream evolved significantly since PR creation (Jan 4), adding Universal File Resolution Protocol, C++ style guide, and prompt improvements.
Conflict Resolution Strategy
Preserved fork additions:
.gitignoreAdopted upstream improvements:
.tomlprompt templates (typo fixes, better git commands, phase numbering)Skill Regeneration
Synced all generated skill files from updated templates:
skills/conductor-*/SKILL.md.antigravity/skills/conductor-vscode/skills/This ensures platform-specific artifacts reflect the merged prompt improvements while maintaining multi-platform compatibility.
Result
The fork now contains both upstream's latest fixes and the multi-platform additions, resolving all merge conflicts. Ready for upstream review and merge.
Original prompt
✨ Let Copilot coding agent set things up for you — coding agent works faster and does higher quality work when set up for your repo.
PR Type
Enhancement, Bug fix, Documentation
Description
Resolves merge conflicts from PR Update to Codex-based approach, Addition VSCode-based and Qwen Code gemini-cli-extensions/conductor#49 by integrating upstream changes with multi-platform support additions
Regenerated all skill files across platforms (VS Code, Antigravity, core) from updated templates to reflect merged improvements
Added comprehensive new skills:
conductor-setup,conductor-implement,conductor-newtrack,conductor-revert, andconductor-statuswith multi-phase workflows and state managementIntegrated upstream improvements: latest
.tomlprompt templates with typo fixes, improved git commands, and phase numbering correctionsAdded C++ style guide template and POSIX-compliant newlines across all style guide files
Implemented release-please automation with GitHub Actions workflow and configuration files for versioned releases
Fixed multiple documentation inconsistencies: section numbering, user prompt wording (number vs letter), metadata field clarifications, and trailing whitespace
Preserved fork's multi-platform README, architecture documentation, and
.gitignoreentries while adopting upstream's latest fixesDiagram Walkthrough
File Walkthrough
10 files
SKILL.md
Add comprehensive Conductor setup skill for VS Codeconductor-vscode/skills/conductor-setup/SKILL.md
lines of detailed protocol
detection, product definition, tech stack selection, and track
generation
from last successful step
setup_state.jsonSKILL.md
Add Conductor setup skill for Antigravity platform.antigravity/skills/conductor-setup/SKILL.md
protocol
environments
initialization procedures
SKILL.md
Add Conductor implement skill for VS Code executionconductor-vscode/skills/conductor-implement/SKILL.md
Conductor framework
documentation synchronization, and track cleanup protocols
workflow.mdis the singlesource of truth for task lifecycle
completed tracks
SKILL.md
Add Conductor implement skill for Antigravity platform.antigravity/skills/conductor-implement/SKILL.md
protocol
and VS Code platforms
cleanup procedures
SKILL.md
Add Conductor new track creation skill for VS Codeconductor-vscode/skills/conductor-newtrack/SKILL.md
Conductor framework
sequential questioning
updates
artifacts
SKILL.md
New conductor-newtrack skill for track creation.antigravity/skills/conductor-newtrack/SKILL.md
generation
requirements
and track artifact management
SKILL.md
New conductor-revert skill for Git-aware work reversalconductor-vscode/skills/conductor-revert/SKILL.md
execution planning, and verification
commits
SKILL.md
New conductor-revert skill for .antigravity platform.antigravity/skills/conductor-revert/SKILL.md
verification
SKILL.md
New conductor-status skill for progress overviewconductor-vscode/skills/conductor-status/SKILL.md
conductor/tracks.mdand individual track plan filesprogress percentage
SKILL.md
New conductor-status skill for .antigravity platform.antigravity/skills/conductor-status/SKILL.md
tracking
4 files
setup.toml
Refine setup protocol documentation and examplescommands/conductor/setup.toml
protocol
2.0.1to2.0for Project Inceptiongit ls-files --exclude-standard -co| xargs -n 1 dirname | sort -ufor better directory listingindentation consistency
comments
newTrack.toml
Refine newTrack command documentation and formattingcommands/conductor/newTrack.toml
protocol
lists
revert.toml
Clarify revert command user choice handlingcommands/conductor/revert.toml
(A, B, C)
cpp.md
New Google C++ style guide templatetemplates/code_styleguides/cpp.md
functions, and modern C++20 features
ownership patterns
constexpr usage
5 files
implement.toml
Fix implement command prompt wordingcommands/conductor/implement.toml
"letter" for consistency
protocols
SKILL.md
Bug fixes and documentation improvements in setup skillskills/conductor-setup/SKILL.md
2.0to2.0.1for Project Inceptiongit ls-files--exclude-standard -co | xargs -n 1 dirname | sort -utogit ls-files--exclude-standard -codescription
for
typeandstatusSKILL.md
Minor fixes and documentation clarifications in newtrack skillskills/conductor-newtrack/SKILL.md
of comments
typeandstatusfields in metadataSKILL.md
Documentation and section numbering corrections in implement skillskills/conductor-implement/SKILL.md
relative to repository root"
6.0 SYNCHRONIZE PROJECT DOCUMENTATIONto4.07.0 TRACK CLEANUPto5.0SKILL.md
Clarification of menu selection logic in revert skillskills/conductor-revert/SKILL.md
instead of A/B/C options
option
3 files
release-please.yml
New release-please GitHub Actions workflow.github/workflows/release-please.yml
authentication
release-please-config.json
New release-please configuration for versioningrelease-please-config.json
gemini-extension.jsonas extra file to include in releases.release-please-manifest.json
New release-please version manifest.release-please-manifest.json
7 files
status.toml
POSIX newline compliance fixcommands/conductor/status.toml
typescript.md
POSIX newline compliance fixtemplates/code_styleguides/typescript.md
javascript.md
POSIX newline compliance fixtemplates/code_styleguides/javascript.md
go.md
POSIX newline compliance fixtemplates/code_styleguides/go.md
html-css.md
POSIX newline compliance fixtemplates/code_styleguides/html-css.md
python.md
POSIX newline compliance fixtemplates/code_styleguides/python.md
GEMINI.md
POSIX newline compliance fixGEMINI.md