Skip to content

[Bug] Threat Intel Hash Indicator Matches Empty Hash Fields #2954

@MakoWish

Description

@MakoWish

Describe the bug
Quite a lot of Threat Intel indicators contain empty fields for the hashes. This is causing false positives for events that do not do not contain the field.

Expected behavior
Rule should not match events to indicators with empty indicator fields.

Screenshots
hash_match_empty

Desktop (please complete the following information):

  • OS: Any
  • Version: Any

Additional context

In the following threat intel document from MalwareBazaar, the field threat.indicator.file.pe.imphash is empty, and this is causing an incredible number of false-positive matches.

{
    "input": {
      "type": "httpjson"
    },
    "agent": {
      "name": "Redacted",
      "id": "cdcd8072-1d30-414a-aa71-c96d2cb5e259",
      "type": "filebeat",
      "ephemeral_id": "e58cd5a2-1d47-4b89-b490-c1e13b364d7f",
      "version": "8.8.1"
    },
    "@timestamp": "2023-06-22T07:35:41.076Z",
    "ecs": {
      "version": "8.8.0"
    },
    "related": {
      "hash": [
        "B9DAFC265A8BFEAA7EB30A2BA415310235381E48",
        "8E45F8B7642FA964FE628039040D5D77A7D3F177687A6969ECD000C83826EA4C94E3F6B615A5091DA0CDBFE86D183CCE",
        "7CC8EF889A24D8BE46158ED9525EDB3EFE4B872709EDFE4C565FB562271969EE",
        "T102C59EE8D06B40D2FC076EC468287AD7073231B3DEE50438276E7A089F7BDA95549E5E",
        "24576:JILK2NYDAYN0O6PUCD65X8HVLTFBQICQT/UC/FVWG/X5YIEYBF1KMXMWLKRA:",
        "67274E089D17FCBDB0A31877D7155622",
        ""
      ]
    },
    "data_stream": {
      "namespace": "default",
      "type": "logs",
      "dataset": "ti_abusech.malwarebazaar"
    },
    "abusech": {
      "malwarebazaar": {
        "intelligence": {
          "downloads": 109,
          "uploads": 1
        },
        "tags": [
          "exe"
        ],
        "anonymous": 0,
        "code_sign": []
      }
    },
    "elastic_agent": {
      "id": "cdcd8072-1d30-414a-aa71-c96d2cb5e259",
      "version": "8.8.1",
      "snapshot": false
    },
    "threat": {
      "indicator": {
        "geo": {
          "country_iso_code": "NL"
        },
        "first_seen": "2023-06-22T07:31:33.000Z",
        "file": {
          "extension": "exe",
          "size": 2740224,
          "mime_type": "application/x-dosexec",
          "pe": {
            "imphash": ""
          },
          "name": "67274e089d17fcbdb0a31877d7155622.exe",
          "hash": {
            "sha1": "b9dafc265a8bfeaa7eb30a2ba415310235381e48",
            "sha384": "8e45f8b7642fa964fe628039040d5d77a7d3f177687a6969ecd000c83826ea4c94e3f6b615a5091da0cdbfe86d183cce",
            "sha256": "7cc8ef889a24d8be46158ed9525edb3efe4b872709edfe4c565fb562271969ee",
            "tlsh": "T102C59EE8D06B40D2FC076EC468287AD7073231B3DEE50438276E7A089F7BDA95549E5E",
            "ssdeep": "24576:jIlK2NYDaYn0o6PuCD65x8HvLtFBqicQT/UC/FVWg/X5YIEYBF1kmXmWLKRa:",
            "md5": "67274e089d17fcbdb0a31877d7155622"
          },
          "elf": {}
        },
        "provider": "abuse_ch",
        "type": "file"
      },
      "software": {}
    },
    "event": {
      "agent_id_status": "verified",
      "ingested": "2023-06-22T07:35:43Z",
      "created": "2023-06-22T07:35:41.076Z",
      "kind": "enrichment",
      "category": "threat",
      "type": "indicator",
      "dataset": "ti_abusech.malwarebazaar"
    },
    "tags": [
      "forwarded",
      "abusech-malwarebazaar"
    ]
  }

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

Type

No type

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions