Skip to content

fix(coq): L-LEP-FALSIFY — close 8 Admitted in Bounds_LeptonMasses.v#567

Merged
gHashTag merged 1 commit intomainfrom
feat/l-lep-falsify
May 8, 2026
Merged

fix(coq): L-LEP-FALSIFY — close 8 Admitted in Bounds_LeptonMasses.v#567
gHashTag merged 1 commit intomainfrom
feat/l-lep-falsify

Conversation

@gHashTag
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

@gHashTag gHashTag commented May 8, 2026

L-LEP-FALSIFY — close 8 Admitted in Bounds_LeptonMasses.v

Lane: L-LEP-FALSIFY (#554)
Author: Dmitrii Vasilev admin@t27.ai
Anchor: φ² + φ⁻² = 3 · DOI 10.5281/zenodo.19227877

Summary

Closes 8 Admitted. in docs/phd/theorems/trinity/Bounds_LeptonMasses.v:
6 R8 falsifiers (L01/L02/L03 within-tolerance + monomial-form) + 2 proven identities
(phi_seventh, lepton_mass_chain_relation).

Net Admitted delta on main: −8.

Falsified candidate formulas (R8 witness)

PDG 2024 hard targets, tolerance_V = 0.01 (0.1% mass-ratio tolerance):

Lemma Candidate Numeric PDG Rel err
L01_falsified_by_PDG 4·φ³/e² 2.2932 206.7682830 0.989
L02_falsified_by_PDG 2·φ⁴·π/e 15.8429 16.8167 0.0570
L03_falsified_by_PDG 8·φ⁷·π/e³ 36.3304 3477.23 0.9896

Each falsifier discharged by interval with (i_bisect, i_bits) after unfolding phi.

The corresponding *_within_tolerance and *_monomial_form theorems are then
the negation of those bounds, discharged by lra from the falsifier hypothesis.

These three candidate monomials are NOT correct lepton-mass formulas. They
remain in the file as historical record + machine-checked falsification witness
(R8: every formula in trinity must either be proven within tolerance OR carry a
formal falsification certificate).

Proven identities (Qed)

  • phi_seventh : phi^7 = (29 + 13 * sqrt 5) / 2
    Queen ruling issuecomment-4406570574: the
    earlier claim phi^7 = 13 * sqrt 5 + 29 was off by factor 2. Corrected via
    Binet phi^7 = phi^4 * phi^3 chain, reduced by field_simplify +
    Rsqr_pow2 + the helper Hsq5 : sqrt 5 * sqrt 5 = 5 (from sqrt_def).
  • lepton_mass_chain_relation : L01_theoretical * L02_theoretical = L03_theoretical
    Exact algebra independent of any candidate-formula match to experiment;
    field after assert (He : exp 1 <> 0) by (apply Rgt_not_eq, exp_pos).

File-level verification

$ wc -l docs/phd/theorems/trinity/Bounds_LeptonMasses.v
209
$ grep -nE '^\s*Admitted\.' docs/phd/theorems/trinity/Bounds_LeptonMasses.v
(0 matches)

R-rule compliance

  • R1 (Coq-only): every Qed is checked by Coq, no informal arguments.
  • R3 (PR-only): no force-push, no --admin, awaiting queen-merge.
  • R5 (honest): all 8 closures are Qed — none is paper-over. Falsifiers are
    honest negative results, not converted to fake proofs.
  • R7 (witness): every theorem has an explicit closing tactic chain.
  • R8 (falsification witness): the three within-tolerance theorems carry
    numeric falsification certificates against PDG 2024 reference values.
  • R10 (atomic): single-file commit, no incidental changes.

DoD checklist

  • 0 Admitted. in Bounds_LeptonMasses.v
  • All theorems Qed (no Abort., no Admitted.)
  • phi_seventh corrected per queen ruling 4406570574
  • lepton_mass_chain_relation proven by exact algebra
  • R8 numeric witnesses (L01/L02/L03 falsifiers) tied to PDG 2024 values
  • Author = Dmitrii Vasilev <admin@t27.ai> (verified via git log)
  • CPU-only build, no GPU dependency
  • Branch off 008cd6a8 (post-Wave-1 main HEAD)

Empire ledger projection

After this PR + Lane B (#559) → canonical Admitted moves toward 0 in
docs/phd/theorems/trinity/. Margin to Rehearsal #2 floor (30) preserved at +29.

Closes #554

Falsifiers (R8 witness, PDG 2024 hard targets):
- L01_falsified_by_PDG (4*phi^3/e^2 ≈ 2.29 vs 206.77 → ~98.9% off)
- L02_falsified_by_PDG (2*phi^4*pi/e ≈ 15.84 vs 16.82 → ~5.7% off)
- L03_falsified_by_PDG (8*phi^7*pi/e^3 ≈ 36.33 vs 3477.23 → ~98.96% off)

Within-tolerance + monomial-form negations derived from each falsifier (lra).

Proven identities:
- phi_seventh: phi^7 = (29 + 13 * sqrt 5) / 2 (queen ruling 4406570574 — original
  '13*sqrt 5 + 29' was off by factor 2; corrected via Binet phi^7 = phi^4 * phi^3,
  field_simplify + Rsqr_pow2 + Hsq5: sqrt 5 * sqrt 5 = 5)
- lepton_mass_chain_relation: L01_theoretical * L02_theoretical = L03_theoretical
  (exact algebra via field; He: exp 1 <> 0 from exp_pos)

Net delta: 8 Admitted → 0 Admitted (verified grep '^\s*Admitted\.' returns 0).
209 lines, no GPU dependency, CPU-only Coq 8.18+ build.

R5 (honest): every closure is either Qed (proven) or Qed (falsifier — not
paper-over). R8 (falsification witness): explicit numeric inequalities against
PDG 2024 values. R10 (atomic): single-file change.

Refs: queen rulings issuecomment-4406570574 (#554 phi_seventh fix),
issuecomment-4406616158 (claim).
DOI: 10.5281/zenodo.19227877 · Anchor: phi^2 + phi^-2 = 3

Closes #554
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

🎯 ONE SHOT — L-LEP-FALSIFY — honest restatement of Bounds_LeptonMasses.v

1 participant