Skip to content

MCP discovery exposes no launch config or source path — blocks viewing/editing discovered servers #1518

@AsafMah

Description

@AsafMah

Summary

When a session discovers MCP servers (mcp.discover / the session McpServerList), the returned shapes expose only identity and status — not the resolved launch config (command/args/url/env/headers) nor the origin file path of the declaration. This makes it impossible for an SDK consumer to (a) show where a discovered server came from, or (b) offer edit / override of a discovered workspace/plugin server, because the consumer never receives the config it would need to display or round-trip.

Current shapes (from dist/generated/rpc.d.ts / session-events.d.ts, beta.9)

// DiscoveredMcpServer (rpc.d.ts ~2657)
{ name: string; type?: string; source: McpServerSource; enabled: boolean }

// McpServer (rpc.d.ts ~4148)
{ name: string; status: string; source?: McpServerSource; error?: string }

// McpServerSource (session-events.d.ts)
type McpServerSource = "user" | "workspace" | "plugin" | "builtin";

None of these carry:

  • the resolved launch configurationcommand / args / env for stdio, or url / headers / type for http/sse;
  • the origin file path (e.g. which .mcp.json / .github/mcp.json the entry came from), only a coarse source enum.

mcp.config.enable/disable is enough to toggle a discovered server (and persists — thank you), but viewing and editing a discovered server's definition is not possible from the SDK surface.

Ask

Extend the discovery surface so consumers can render and edit discovered servers. Either is fine:

  1. Add the resolved config + origin to DiscoveredMcpServer (and/or McpServer), e.g.

    {
      name: string;
      source: McpServerSource;
      enabled: boolean;
      // new:
      config?: McpServerConfig;   // command/args/env | url/headers/type
      sourcePath?: string;        // absolute path of the declaring file
    }
  2. Or add a dedicated rpc, e.g. mcp.config.get({ name }) → resolved config + origin path, so consumers can fetch on demand.

Either unlocks: showing the source file in a server detail view, and an edit/override affordance for discovered workspace/plugin servers (today only user-source servers we wrote ourselves can be edited, because we hold their config; discovered ones are opaque).

Context / why

We're a desktop UI (Dafman) over the Copilot agent. Users expect to see where a discovered MCP server is defined and to tweak its args/env without hand-editing JSON files they may not know the location of. Toggle persistence already works; this is the remaining gap for a full MCP management UI.

(Filed from downstream tracking issue AsafMah/dafman#9. Happy to provide a repro or test against a beta.)

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type
    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions