[Outcome Report] Outcome Report — Safe Outputs — 2026-05-26

[github-actions]

Outcome Scorecard — 2026-05-26

Metric	Value	Status
Acceptance rate	71.4%	🟡 60-80%
Zero-touch rate	0%	🔴 <25%
Waste rate	8%	🟢 <10%
Median time to resolution	1h 15m	—
Accepted	5 / 25	—
Rejected	2	—
Zero-touch	0 / 5	—
Pending	18	—
Runs checked	6	—

🔴 Action Items

1. Regressing acceptance rate — Acceptance dropped from 100% (2026-05-25) to 71.4% today. Two workflows had rejections: "Design Decision Gate 🏗️" and "Test Quality Sentinel" both have 50% waste rates with items pending >45 minutes. Review these workflows' prompts and output quality.

2. Stuck pending items — 18 items pending, with 4 PR review items pending >45 minutes ("Matt Pocock Skills Reviewer" and "PR Code Quality Reviewer"). These may be blocked on external events or timeouts. Investigate if these workflows need timeout logic.

3. Zero zero-touch outcomes — All 5 accepted items required manual review/edits. This indicates output quality issues across accepted items. Review agent prompts for clarity and accuracy.

Per-Workflow Breakdown

Workflow	Accepted	Rejected	Pending	Acceptance	Waste	Status
Design Decision Gate 🏗️	0	1	1	0%	🔴 50%	Needs investigation
Test Quality Sentinel	0	1	1	0%	🔴 50%	Needs investigation
Matt Pocock Skills Reviewer	0	0	4	N/A	0%	All pending >45min
PR Code Quality Reviewer	0	0	4	N/A	0%	All pending >45min
Issue Monster	3	0	3	50%	0%	Healthy
Smoke Copilot	2	0	5	29%	0%	Many pending <4min

Detailed Outcomes

Accepted Outcomes

1. Smoke Copilot — create_discussion (discussion copilot was here #34823)
2. Smoke Copilot — create_issue (issue Smoke Test: Copilot - 26426709615 #34824)
3. Issue Monster — add_comment on issue [deep-report] [quick-win] Fix 3 broken doc-link anchors in main_workflow_schema.json #34686
4. Issue Monster — add_comment on issue [performance] Regression in ParseWorkflow: +34.3% slower #34694
5. Issue Monster — add_comment on issue [refactor] Duplicate engine MCP/log scaffolding and dead SafeOutputStepConfig type in pkg/workflow #34800

Rejected Outcomes

1. Test Quality Sentinel — add_comment on PR perf(validation): remove YAML parse hot path in permission scope validation #34797 (closed PR, resolution 1h 15m)
2. Design Decision Gate 🏗️ — add_comment on PR perf(validation): remove YAML parse hot path in permission scope validation #34797 (closed PR, resolution 1h 15m)

Critical Pending Items (>45 minutes)

• Matt Pocock Skills Reviewer (4 items) — create_pull_request_review_comment pending 45+ minutes
• PR Code Quality Reviewer (4 items) — create_pull_request_review_comment pending 45+ minutes
• Test Quality Sentinel (1 item) — submit_pull_request_review pending 46+ minutes
• Design Decision Gate 🏗️ (1 item) — push_to_pull_request_branch pending 46+ minutes
• Smoke Copilot (5 items) — Various safe-output operations pending 0-4 minutes

Trend Analysis

⬇️ Regressing: Acceptance rate dropped 28.6 percentage points (100% → 71.4%). First rejections observed today. Zero-touch rate remains at 0%.

Previous day (2026-05-25): 100% acceptance, 0% waste, 29 outcomes, 14 runs

Today (2026-05-26): 71.4% acceptance, 8% waste, 25 outcomes, 6 runs

📊 Measured by Outcome Collector · haiku45 29.4K

• expires on Jun 2, 2026, 1:33 AM UTC