Tracking issue
Tracking the work in #2732 — "Add reaction tools for issues and pull requests" (by @timrogers, co-developed with Copilot).
add_issue_reaction — react to an issue
add_issue_comment_reaction — react to an issue comment
add_pull_request_review_comment_reaction — react to a PR review comment
Why this tracking issue exists
Validating that reactions can be driven end-to-end through the consolidated issue tooling (add_issue_comment for issue/PR reactions, add_reply_to_pull_request_comment for PR review comment reactions).
Test performed via MCP (results)
Finding
The consolidated toolset reacts cleanly to issues / PRs (add_issue_comment) and to PR review comments (add_reply_to_pull_request_comment). However, there is no consolidated tool to react to a standalone issue comment by id. Attempting to route an issue-comment id through the PR-review-comment reaction tool hits POST /repos/.../pulls/comments/{id}/reactions and fails (403, wrong namespace).
This is exactly the gap add_issue_comment_reaction in #2732 closes. 👍 for shipping it.
Filed automatically as part of a reactions smoke test.
Tracking issue
Tracking the work in #2732 — "Add reaction tools for issues and pull requests" (by @timrogers, co-developed with Copilot).
Scope of #2732
add_issue_reaction— react to an issueadd_issue_comment_reaction— react to an issue commentadd_pull_request_review_comment_reaction— react to a PR review commentWhy this tracking issue exists
Validating that reactions can be driven end-to-end through the consolidated issue tooling (
add_issue_commentfor issue/PR reactions,add_reply_to_pull_request_commentfor PR review comment reactions).Test performed via MCP (results)
add_issue_comment— cleanadd_issue_comment— cleanadd_issue_comment— cleanFinding
The consolidated toolset reacts cleanly to issues / PRs (
add_issue_comment) and to PR review comments (add_reply_to_pull_request_comment). However, there is no consolidated tool to react to a standalone issue comment by id. Attempting to route an issue-comment id through the PR-review-comment reaction tool hitsPOST /repos/.../pulls/comments/{id}/reactionsand fails (403, wrong namespace).This is exactly the gap
add_issue_comment_reactionin #2732 closes. 👍 for shipping it.Filed automatically as part of a reactions smoke test.