x/build: we should run at least one windows builder as each of Administrator and non-Administrator

[alexbrainman]

Some tests do not run unless they are run by Administrator.

Compare normal user runs:

c:\>go test -v -short os | grep -i skip
--- SKIP: TestStatError (0.00s)
        testenv.go:189: skipping test: cannot make symlinks on windows/amd64: you don't have enough privileges to create symlinks
--- SKIP: TestReaddirNValues (0.00s)
        os_test.go:515: test.short; skipping
--- SKIP: TestReaddirStatFailures (0.00s)
        os_test.go:601: skipping test on windows
--- SKIP: TestSymlink (0.00s)
        testenv.go:189: skipping test: cannot make symlinks on windows/amd64: you don't have enough privileges to create symlinks
--- SKIP: TestLongSymlink (0.00s)
        testenv.go:189: skipping test: cannot make symlinks on windows/amd64: you don't have enough privileges to create symlinks
--- SKIP: TestLargeWriteToConsole (0.00s)
        os_test.go:1817: skipping console-flooding test; enable with -large_write
--- SKIP: TestStatRelativeSymlink (0.00s)
        testenv.go:189: skipping test: cannot make symlinks on windows/amd64: you don't have enough privileges to create symlinks
--- SKIP: TestSleep (0.00s)
        os_test.go:2072: Skipping in short mode
--- SKIP: TestRemoveAllRace (0.00s)
        os_test.go:2182: skipping on windows
--- SKIP: TestPipeThreads (0.00s)
        os_test.go:2217: skipping on Windows; issue 19098
--- SKIP: TestDirectorySymbolicLink (0.03s)
        os_windows_test.go:397: skipping some tests, could not enable "SeCreateSymbolicLinkPrivilege": Not all privileges or groups referenced are assigned to the caller.
--- SKIP: TestNetworkSymbolicLink (0.00s)
        testenv.go:189: skipping test: cannot make symlinks on windows/amd64: you don't have enough privileges to create symlinks
--- SKIP: TestShareNotExistError (0.00s)
        os_windows_test.go:547: slow test that uses network; skipping
--- SKIP: TestStatSymlinkLoop (0.00s)
        testenv.go:189: skipping test: cannot make symlinks on windows/amd64: you don't have enough privileges to create symlinks
--- SKIP: TestRemoveAllLarge (0.00s)
        path_test.go:176: skipping in short mode
--- SKIP: TestMkdirAllWithSymlink (0.00s)
        testenv.go:189: skipping test: cannot make symlinks on windows/amd64: you don't have enough privileges to create symlinks
--- SKIP: TestMkdirAllAtSlash (0.00s)
        path_test.go:234: skipping on windows

c:\>

to Administrator runs:

c:\>go test -v -short os | grep -i skip
--- SKIP: TestReaddirNValues (0.00s)
        os_test.go:515: test.short; skipping
--- SKIP: TestReaddirStatFailures (0.00s)
        os_test.go:601: skipping test on windows
--- SKIP: TestLargeWriteToConsole (0.00s)
        os_test.go:1817: skipping console-flooding test; enable with -large_write
--- SKIP: TestSleep (0.00s)
        os_test.go:2072: Skipping in short mode
--- SKIP: TestRemoveAllRace (0.00s)
        os_test.go:2182: skipping on windows
--- SKIP: TestPipeThreads (0.00s)
        os_test.go:2217: skipping on Windows; issue 19098
--- SKIP: TestShareNotExistError (0.00s)
        os_windows_test.go:547: slow test that uses network; skipping
--- SKIP: TestRemoveAllLarge (0.00s)
        path_test.go:176: skipping in short mode
--- SKIP: TestMkdirAllAtSlash (0.00s)
        path_test.go:234: skipping on windows

c:\>

We have 5 windows builders at this moment. Perhaps we could make some run as Administrator to cover more tests.

Thank you.

Alex

[mvdan]

Do the linux tests run as root? Perhaps this is done on purpose to avoid breaking the machines. Is there a way to grant privileges to create symlinks, but no more?

[bradfitz]

Perhaps this is done on purpose to avoid breaking the machines

Naah, we create new ephemeral VMs or containers per build for almost all the builders.

I don't know why Windows runs as a normal user. @johnsonj, you remember?

The Linux builders mostly run as kinda-root: the root that you have in a Kubernetes container, which can do most things, but not all. We used to run a VM-based Linux builder too so we could have real root, but that's been disabled for some time now.

[johnsonj]

The only special user thing I remember is we needed to run as a real logged in session and not as SYSTEM. I don't think there is a reason why they can't run as an elevated user.

Does it need to be the actual 'Administrator' user or just a user in the group?

[alexbrainman]

Does it need to be the actual 'Administrator' user or just a user in the group?

I think it needs to be the 'Administrator'. See my original output was produced by the user who is in local 'Administrator' group. And the second output was produced when I started cmd.exe via "Run as Administrator". Just jump on the builder and run some tests that were skipped above and see what you get.

Thank you

Alex

[bradfitz]

This bug might be about the opposite now, if I understand #24855 correctly. This bug should be more generally about making sure we test as both admin & non-admin.

[alexbrainman]

This bug should be more generally about making sure we test as both admin & non-admin.

Yes. We do not actually know if builders run as admin or non-admin. So we need to run both kind of builders. It is fine for this bug to be about that.

Alex