Claude/language comparison table oog22

CLAUDE-INSTRUCTIONS.md

@@ -0,0 +1,66 @@
+# Instructions for Claude Sessions
+
+## STOP - Read Before Working
+
+This repository is the **hub** for 8 programming languages in the MAAF ecosystem. Before making any changes to satellite repos, you MUST understand the current state.
+
+## Critical Rules
+
+### 1. GitHub is Source of Truth
+All work should be on GitHub. GitLab/Codeberg/Bitbucket are mirrors.
+
+### 2. Check Migration Status First
+Before working on any language repo, check `MIGRATION-STATUS.md`:
+- If status is "NOT SYNCED" → sync from GitLab first
+- If status is "DIVERGED" → consult user before making changes
+- If status is "SYNCED" → safe to work on GitHub version
+
+### 3. Never Create Parallel Implementations
+**WRONG:** "I'll implement this feature from scratch on GitHub"
+**RIGHT:** "Let me check if this exists on GitLab first, then build on that"
+
+### 4. Preserve Original Work
+The GitLab repos contain months of human effort from Aug-Oct 2025. This includes:
+- Design documents
+- White papers
+- Original implementations
+- Research notes
+
+Do not overwrite this with new implementations.
+
+## The Language Ecosystem
+
+```
+nextgen-languages (this repo - hub)
+├── My-Language Family (progressive complexity, ages 8-18)
+│   ├── me (base)
+│   ├── solo (age 8-10)
+│   ├── duet (age 11-14)
+│   └── ensemble (age 15-18, dialect of my-lang)
+├── Foundational
+│   ├── betlang (Racket, probabilistic programming)
+│   └── julia-the-viper (Rust, Harvard Architecture)
+└── Specialized
+    ├── phronesis (practical wisdom, Elixir)
+    ├── eclexia (creative synthesis, Rust)
+    ├── oblibeny (favorite things modeling)
+    ├── anvomidav (real-time systems)
+    └── wokelang (social awareness)
+```
+
+## Related Repos (not languages)
+- `7-tentacles` - orchestration
+- `me-dialect-playground` - experimentation
+- `my-newsroom` - content pipeline
+- `my-ssg` - static site generator
+
+## Before Starting Work
+
+1. Read `MIGRATION-STRATEGY.md` for the overall plan
+2. Check `MIGRATION-STATUS.md` for current state
+3. If repo is not synced, sync it first
+4. Update status file after completing work
+5. Commit to the correct branch
+
+## Questions?
+If unclear about anything, ask the user rather than guessing.

MIGRATION-STATUS.md

@@ -0,0 +1,41 @@
+# Migration Status Tracker
+
+Last updated: 2025-12-16
+
+## Phase 1: Language Repos
+
+| Repo | Status | Notes |
+|------|--------|-------|
+| eclexia | NOT SYNCED | Priority 1 - has 70-page white paper on GitLab |
+| phronesis | DIVERGED | GitLab: original, GitHub: Claude Elixir impl |
+| wokelang | DIVERGED | GitLab: original, GitHub: Claude Rust impl |
+| oblibeny | DIVERGED | Needs manual merge |
+| anvomidav | NAMING ISSUE | GitLab calls it "betlang" incorrectly |
+| betlang | TO VERIFY | Check if synced |
+| julia-the-viper | TO VERIFY | Check if synced |
+| solo | TO VERIFY | Part of my-lang family |
+| duet | TO VERIFY | Part of my-lang family |
+| ensemble | TO VERIFY | Part of my-lang family |
+
+## Completed Syncs
+
+| Repo | Date | By | Notes |
+|------|------|----|-------|
+| (none yet) | | | |
+
+## Repos Needing Manual Review
+
+| Repo | Reason | Decision |
+|------|--------|----------|
+| phronesis | Both have implementations | TBD |
+| wokelang | Both have implementations | TBD |
+| oblibeny | Significant divergence | TBD |
+
+---
+
+## Update Instructions
+
+When you complete a sync:
+1. Move repo from "Phase 1" to "Completed Syncs"
+2. Add date and notes
+3. Commit this file with message: `docs: update migration status - synced {repo}`

MIGRATION-STRATEGY.md

@@ -0,0 +1,83 @@
+# GitLab → GitHub Migration Strategy
+
+## Goal
+**GitHub is the single source of truth.** All development happens on GitHub, then mirrors out to:
+- GitLab (gitlab.com/maa-framework)
+- Codeberg
+- Bitbucket
+
+## Current Problem
+- Original work (Aug-Oct 2025) lives on GitLab
+- GitHub repos created Dec 2025, some with parallel Claude implementations
+- Result: diverged repos, missing content, confusion
+
+## The Fix (4 Phases)
+
+### Phase 1: Language Repos (This Week)
+Priority repos - the 8 languages in this ecosystem:
+
+| Repo | GitLab Status | GitHub Status | Action |
+|------|---------------|---------------|--------|
+| eclexia | 13 commits, 70-page white paper, Rust compiler | 1 commit (template) | **SYNC FROM GITLAB** |
+| phronesis | 11+ commits, original design | Claude Elixir impl | Evaluate both, merge best |
+| wokelang | 20+ commits, original design | Claude Rust impl | Evaluate both, merge best |
+| oblibeny | 40+ commits | 30 commits, diverged | Manual merge |
+| anvomidav | Mislabeled as "betlang" | Correct name | Sync + rename on GitLab |
+| betlang | Correct | Correct | Verify sync |
+| julia-the-viper | Original | Check status | Sync if needed |
+| my-lang (solo/duet/ensemble) | Original | Check status | Sync if needed |
+
+### Phase 2: Full Audit
+Run reconciliation script to categorize all 400+ repos:
+```bash
+export GITLAB_TOKEN="glpat-..."
+export GITHUB_TOKEN="ghp_..."
+python scripts/repo-reconcile.py > audit-results.json
+```
+
+Categories:
+- **gitlab-only**: Create on GitHub, sync content
+- **github-only**: Keep (new work) or archive (abandoned)
+- **synced**: Set up mirror
+- **diverged**: Manual review needed
+
+### Phase 3: Consolidate
+For each diverged repo:
+1. Compare commits on both sides
+2. If GitLab has original work + GitHub has useful additions → merge
+3. If GitHub work is just parallel implementation → replace with GitLab
+4. If GitHub work is better → keep GitHub, archive GitLab
+
+### Phase 4: Mirror Setup
+Once GitHub is authoritative:
+```
+GitHub (source)
+    ├── → GitLab (push mirror)
+    ├── → Codeberg (push mirror)
+    └── → Bitbucket (push mirror)
+```
+
+GitHub Settings → Branches → Add mirror for each target.
+
+---
+
+## Instructions for Claude Sessions
+
+**READ THIS BEFORE WORKING ON ANY REPO IN THIS ECOSYSTEM**
+
+1. **GitHub is source of truth** - always pull from GitHub first
+2. **Check this document** for repo status before making changes
+3. **Never create parallel implementations** - if GitLab has content, sync it first
+4. **Update MIGRATION-STATUS.md** after completing any sync operation
+5. **Preserve original work** - GitLab content represents months of human effort
+
+## Immediate Priority
+**Sync eclexia first** - it has a 70-page white paper and Rust compiler that only exists on GitLab.
+
+```bash
+# Preserve GitLab work to GitHub
+git clone git@gitlab.com:maa-framework/4a-languages/eclexia.git
+cd eclexia
+git remote add github git@github.com:hyperpolymath/eclexia.git
+git push github main --force
+```