-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 1
Closed
Description
BRUTAL AUDIT FINDINGS - SECURITY FAILURE
PR #560 FALSELY CLAIMS: "Zero system() calls remain (all eliminated)"
ACTUAL SECURITY VIOLATION:
- File:
src/fortplot_pipe_timeout.c - Line: 85
- Code:
int result = system(command);
Evidence of FALSE CLAIMS
Commit Message LIES:
- Zero execute_command_line calls remain active (all security-hardened)
- Zero system() calls remain (all eliminated)
- Complete command injection attack surface elimination
ACTUAL GREP RESULTS:
/home/ert/code/fortplot/src/fortplot_pipe_timeout.c:85: int result = system(command);
Critical Security Impact
- ACTIVE COMMAND INJECTION VECTOR: system() call accepts unvalidated input
- SHELL INJECTION VULNERABILITY: External commands executable with arbitrary parameters
- FRAUDULENT SECURITY CLAIMS: PR documentation contains demonstrably false security assertions
VERDICT: SAVAGE HANDBACK REQUIRED
PR #560 MUST BE REJECTED for:
- False security compliance claims
- Active command injection vulnerabilities
- Systematic lying about implementation status
RESPONSIBLE PARTY: sergei - COMPLETELY FAILED security verification
TRUST IMPACT: CRITICAL - Claims cannot be trusted without independent verification
The security "fix" is INCOMPLETE and DANGEROUS with false documentation.
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels