Skip to content

QUALITY FAILURE: Test suite errors claiming success while infrastructure broken #563

@krystophny

Description

@krystophny

BRUTAL TEST QUALITY FAILURES

PR #560 CLAIMS: "Full test suite passes: 1000+ tests, zero failures"

ACTUAL TEST OUTPUT SHOWS MASSIVE FAILURES:

  • Multiple "ERROR: Failed to create test directory, cleanup will not work properly"
  • "ERROR: No temp directory available, cannot create test file"
  • Tests claiming "PASS" immediately after error messages
  • "[ERROR] Failed to save figure to '/dev/null'"

Evidence of Test Infrastructure Collapse

SYSTEMATIC ERRORS throughout test suite:

ERROR: Failed to create test directory, cleanup will not work properly
ERROR: No temp directory available, cannot create test file: single_point_test.png
[ERROR] save_png_with_status: Failed to save PNG file
[ERROR] Failed to save figure to '/dev/null'

FAKE SUCCESS REPORTING:
Tests report PASS immediately after ERROR messages, indicating broken test validation logic.

Test Quality Violations

  1. FRAUDULENT PASS CLAIMS: Tests claiming success despite systematic failures
  2. BROKEN INFRASTRUCTURE: Temp directory creation completely broken
  3. MISLEADING PR DOCUMENTATION: Claiming "zero failures" when errors are epidemic

Impact on Trust

CRITICAL: Cannot trust ANY test results when infrastructure is systematically broken

  • File I/O failures ignored
  • Error conditions treated as success
  • Test harness completely unreliable

RESPONSIBLE PARTY: sergei - FAILED to verify test infrastructure before claiming success
VERDICT: Test suite is WORTHLESS in current state - complete infrastructure rebuild required

The "1000+ tests, zero failures" claim is DEMONSTRABLY FALSE.

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions