Crashing when Loading ImmediateWindowProvider SimpleCustomEarlyLoading

[Samsterbam]

This might be unsolvable but my game keeps crashing the moment I start it with the last reported log being :
[18:32:29] [main/INFO]:Loading ImmediateWindowProvider SimpleCustomEarlyLoading

The first few times it loaded fine until all of a sudden it stopped working. I added no other mods during the time after I added this mod.

No crash report is generated and the launcher simply says exit code 1.

I reset the configs to its default and it still crashes:

Entire log:

[18:31:32] [main/INFO]: ModLauncher running: args [--username, samlambbam, --version, neoforge-21.1.174, --gameDir, C:\Users\sammy\curseforge\minecraft\Instances\DEV PixelTech ForgeNEO, --assetsDir, C:\Users\sammy\curseforge\minecraft\Install\assets, --assetIndex, 17, --uuid, 146b45a1ca584421aa1ed4e62c04fdfa, --accessToken, ❄❄❄❄❄❄❄❄, --clientId, NmQyZjIwYjgtNGIxZi00MDFiLWJhYzUtNDYwZTFlZGU2OTZi, --xuid, 2535425898768126, --userType, msa, --versionType, release, --width, 1440, --height, 1440, --quickPlayPath, C:\Users\sammy\curseforge\minecraft\Install\quickPlay\java\1750037490302.json, --fml.neoForgeVersion, 21.1.174, --fml.fmlVersion, 4.0.39, --fml.mcVersion, 1.21.1, --fml.neoFormVersion, 20240808.144430, --launchTarget, forgeclient]
[18:31:32] [main/INFO]: JVM identified as Microsoft OpenJDK 64-Bit Server VM 21.0.7+6-LTS
[18:31:32] [main/INFO]: ModLauncher 11.0.4+main.d2e20e43 starting: java version 21.0.7 by Microsoft; OS Windows 10 arch amd64 version 10.0
[18:31:32] [main/INFO]: Loading ImmediateWindowProvider SimpleCustomEarlyLoading

This is my fml.toml in case I missed something:

disableConfigWatcher = false
#Should we control the window. Disabling this disables new GL features and can be bad for mods that rely on them.
earlyWindowControl = true
#Max threads for early initialization parallelism,  -1 is based on processor count
maxThreads = -1
#Enable NeoForge global version checking
versionCheck = true
#Default config path for servers
defaultConfigPath = "defaultconfigs"
#Disables Optimized DFU client-side - already disabled on servers
disableOptimizedDFU = true
#Early window provider
earlyWindowProvider = "SimpleCustomEarlyLoading"
#Early window width
earlyWindowWidth = 1440
#Early window height
earlyWindowHeight = 1440
#Early window framebuffer scale
earlyWindowFBScale = 1
#Early window starts maximized
earlyWindowMaximized = true
#Skip specific GL versions, may help with buggy graphics card drivers
earlyWindowSkipGLVersions = []
#Squir?
earlyWindowSquir = false
#Define dependency overrides below
#Dependency overrides can be used to forcibly remove a dependency constraint from a mod or to force a mod to load AFTER another mod
#Using dependency overrides can cause issues. Use at your own risk.
#Example dependency override for the mod with the id 'targetMod': dependency constraints (incompatibility clauses or restrictive version ranges) against mod 'dep1' are removed, and the mod will now load after the mod 'dep2'
#dependencyOverrides.targetMod = ["-dep1", "+dep2"]
dependencyOverrides = {}

I set the earlyWindowControl = true to false and the game loaded to the main menu fine

I can provide the modpack folder in its entirety if need be.

[Samsterbam]

Okay setting earlyWindowProvider = back to fmlearlywindow also crashes?

[lukaskabc]

Okay setting earlyWindowProvider = back to fmlearlywindow also crashes?

That's weird, remove the mod and try removing the fml configuration and see if you can run it with the default configuration.
If yes, try enabling the earlyWindowMaximized = true, test it, and then re-add the mod.

Do you also have some custom configuration for the loading screen? If so, try removing it.

[Samsterbam]

Ok, after much removing mods and files it seems that the culprit is the options.txt file.
After removing it and generating a new one the game works fine.

It seems like this is a NeoForge issue rather than an CustomEarlyLoading issue but I provided the file just in case:
options.txt

[Piotr1628]

options.txt
options.txt.bak.txt

normal: doesn't work
.bak : works

I have no ideaa

[lukaskabc]

and the "normal" is working just fine when you remove the mod and set the window provider back to fml default?

earlyWindowProvider = "fmlearlywindow"

[Piotr1628]

Let me test that quick

[Piotr1628]

Nope, doesn't work
mod removed, fmlearlywindow

[Piotr1628]

It's hard to find anything, debug and latest show nothing, this is really strange that those 2 options file aren't really different, yet 1 works and the second does not.

[Piotr1628]

Ok, some hotkey is the culcript

[lukaskabc]

Okey, the issue is probably in the (neo)forge early window then. You can try reporting it to them.

Its very good that you have a working and non-working version, you can check the differences.

You can try changing the values one by one or so, to find what exactly is causing the issue.
I dont expect it to be one of the keybindings, so I would logicaly start with the options related to video settings.

[lukaskabc]

no idea how would early loading be related to keybindings 😅

[Piotr1628]

Ok I have found the issue
key_key.open_menu:key.keyboard.f8

Can't bind stuff to F8 I guess

[Piotr1628]

Not F8, it's key_key.open_menu:key.keyboard

[Piotr1628]

So well, it's not Your mod's fault, thx for helping.

[lukaskabc]

hm the file from Samsterbam does not contain it