155 game of life llm feedback #156
Conversation
- Set default seed value to 42 for consistency - Enhance prompt instructions for clarity - Improve content extraction logic from text - Ensure generation number is displayed and incremented
|
Automatic code review is enabled for this repository. Reviewing this PR now. |
|
I'm getting to work. See my steps and track my cost here.
I always see new activity while actively working. When paused, I'll only respond when tagged unless this box is checked. |
|
🚀 PR Preview deployed! Preview URL: https://pollinations.github.io/hive/pr-156/ |
1 similar comment
|
🚀 PR Preview deployed! Preview URL: https://pollinations.github.io/hive/pr-156/ |
Testing .mentatTesting ai-chatTesting static HTML app: ai-chat Testing graphics-editorTesting static HTML app: graphics-editor Testing llm-feedbackTesting static HTML app: llm-feedback Testing millionaire-gameTesting static HTML app: millionaire-game Testing placeholder-generatorTesting Node.js app: placeholder-generator Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found BuildingTesting pollinations-image-showTesting Node.js app: pollinations-image-show Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found BuildingTesting prompt-guessing-gameTesting Node.js app: prompt-guessing-game Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found BuildingTesting svg-feedbackTesting static HTML app: svg-feedback ❌ HTML tests failed for svg-feedback Testing tarot-readerTesting Node.js app: tarot-reader Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found Building |
![devloai[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/886113?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I've reviewed the Game of Life integration changes. There's one important bug fix needed in the text extraction logic - the order of extraction should be reversed to properly handle code blocks before tags. I've also suggested two improvements for better code organization and maintainability: using constants for default values and implementing a more structured approach for model-specific message handling. The changes look good overall and can be merged after addressing these comments, particularly the text extraction fix.
| const match = text.match(/```([\s\S]*?)```/); | ||
| return match ? match[1] : text; | ||
|
|
||
| // Then check for content before </think> |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The order of extraction should be reversed. Currently, we check for </think> first and then code blocks, but if there's a code block before </think>, we'll miss it. We should check for code blocks first, then fall back to </think> extraction.
Here's how the function should be structured:
function extractDisplayContent(text) {
// First try to extract content from code blocks
const codeMatch = text.match(/```([\s\S]*?)```/);
if (codeMatch)
return codeMatch[1];
// Then check for content before </think>
const thinkMatch = text.split('</think>');
if (thinkMatch.length > 1)
text = thinkMatch[1].trim();
// If neither pattern matches, return the original text
return text;
}| elements.start.textContent = 'Generating...'; | ||
|
|
||
| let seed = elements.seed.value && elements.seed.value !== '-1' ? | ||
| parseInt(elements.seed.value) : |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The default seed handling could be improved. Instead of hardcoding 42, consider defining it as a constant at the top of the script for better maintainability. Also, the condition could be simplified.
Add this at the top of the script with other constants:
const DEFAULT_SEED = 42;Then simplify the seed assignment to:
let seed = elements.seed.value ? parseInt(elements.seed.value) : DEFAULT_SEED;| const messages = [ | ||
| { | ||
| const model = getSelectedModel(); | ||
| const messages = model === 'deepseek-r1' ? |
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The model-specific message structure could be better organized using a configuration object. This would make it easier to add support for more models in the future.
Consider refactoring to use a model configuration object:
const modelConfig = {
'deepseek-r1': {
formatMessage: (instructions, state) => [{
role: "user",
content: instructions + "\n\n# Current State\n\n" + state
}]
},
'default': {
formatMessage: (instructions, state) => [{
role: "system",
content: instructions
}, {
role: "user",
content: state
}]
}
};
// Then use it like this:
const messages = (modelConfig[model] || modelConfig.default)
.formatMessage(formatInstructions, currentState);![mentatbot[bot]](https://avatars.githubusercontent.com/in/837875?s=60&v=4){kind=small}
There was a problem hiding this comment.
The changes look well-structured and focused on adding Conway's Game of Life functionality to the llm-feedback app. I have a few observations:
-
The Game of Life preset is well-designed:
- Clear rules explanation in the prompt
- Good initial state visualization
- Appropriate temperature setting (0.1) for deterministic behavior
-
Good improvements to text handling:
- Added support for content after tags
- Maintained backwards compatibility with code block extraction
- Fallback to original text if no patterns match
-
Nice optimization of the seed handling:
- Changed from random to fixed default (42)
- Still maintains ability to set custom seeds
There is a test failure in the svg-feedback app, but this is unrelated to your changes as it's a missing styles.css file in that app. This should be addressed separately.
Overall, this looks like a good addition to the llm-feedback app. The changes are focused and well-implemented.
There was a problem hiding this comment.
I've reviewed the changes and agree with devloai[bot]'s assessment. The three issues identified (text extraction order, default seed constant, and model configuration structure) should be addressed before merging.
The rest of the changes look good, particularly:
- The Game of Life preset is well-designed with clear rules and visualization
- The UI changes are clean and maintain consistency with other presets
- The temperature setting of 0.1 is appropriate for the deterministic nature of Game of Life
Once you've addressed the code organization and bug fix suggestions from devloai[bot], this will be ready to merge.
- Introduce `.state-block` class for styling state displays - Add iteration labels above each state in the history - Ensure each state is wrapped in code blocks for clarity - Improve UI by grouping iteration labels with state blocks
|
🚀 PR Preview deployed! Preview URL: https://pollinations.github.io/hive/pr-156/ |
1 similar comment
|
🚀 PR Preview deployed! Preview URL: https://pollinations.github.io/hive/pr-156/ |
Testing .mentatTesting ai-chatTesting static HTML app: ai-chat Testing graphics-editorTesting static HTML app: graphics-editor Testing llm-feedbackTesting static HTML app: llm-feedback Testing millionaire-gameTesting static HTML app: millionaire-game Testing placeholder-generatorTesting Node.js app: placeholder-generator Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found BuildingTesting pollinations-image-showTesting Node.js app: pollinations-image-show Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found BuildingTesting prompt-guessing-gameTesting Node.js app: prompt-guessing-game Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found BuildingTesting svg-feedbackTesting static HTML app: svg-feedback ❌ HTML tests failed for svg-feedback Testing tarot-readerTesting Node.js app: tarot-reader Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found Building |
Testing .mentatTesting ai-chatTesting static HTML app: ai-chat Testing graphics-editorTesting static HTML app: graphics-editor Testing llm-feedbackTesting static HTML app: llm-feedback Testing millionaire-gameTesting static HTML app: millionaire-game Testing placeholder-generatorTesting Node.js app: placeholder-generator Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found BuildingTesting pollinations-image-showTesting Node.js app: pollinations-image-show Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found BuildingTesting prompt-guessing-gameTesting Node.js app: prompt-guessing-game Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found BuildingTesting svg-feedbackTesting static HTML app: svg-feedback ❌ HTML tests failed for svg-feedback Testing tarot-readerTesting Node.js app: tarot-reader Installing dependenciesℹ️ No tests found Building |
|
🚀 PR Preview deployed! Preview URL: https://pollinations.github.io/hive/pr-156/ |
1 similar comment
|
🚀 PR Preview deployed! Preview URL: https://pollinations.github.io/hive/pr-156/ |
No description provided.