Skip to content

Optimization 12h Envelope filter statistics 2026 11 04

odashi edited this page Nov 16, 2026 · 1 revision

Envelope / Filter:対応のある測定の全統計量

過去の調査・実験ログです。本文の版・条件・結果は記録当時のものです。分類索引 · 技術資料

単位はステレオ1サンプルあたりのns。差は変更後−変更前。ブロック数・自由度・Holm補正の対象ケース数は各節に記す。各ケース内の95%信頼区間を併記する。差未検出は同等性を意味しない。中央値・最小/最大・全実行順・全ブロック値は併記JSONに保存する。

E1: reciprocal

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61041。生データ: reciprocal-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 37.155 ± 0.410 34.712 ± 0.286 -2.443 ± 0.233 [-2.609, -2.277] -33.229 9.9725e-11 1.8948e-09
saw-bass 61.781 ± 0.392 58.230 ± 0.444 -3.551 ± 0.364 [-3.812, -3.291] -30.822 1.9515e-10 3.5128e-09
triangle-pluck 114.404 ± 2.768 115.197 ± 1.083 0.792 ± 2.874 [-1.264, 2.848] 0.872 0.40598 1
square-lead 61.260 ± 0.501 58.995 ± 0.183 -2.265 ± 0.446 [-2.584, -1.947] -16.076 6.1707e-08 1.049e-06
saw-chords 364.667 ± 3.598 361.850 ± 2.691 -2.817 ± 4.023 [-5.694, 0.061] -2.214 0.054056 0.37839
slow-pad 463.979 ± 0.797 465.693 ± 28.994 1.713 ± 29.231 [-19.197, 22.624] 0.185 0.85706 1
three-osc-keys 305.430 ± 2.455 308.420 ± 2.158 2.990 ± 1.162 [2.159, 3.821] 8.136 1.9347e-05 0.00030955
phase-mod-bell 174.968 ± 1.260 173.900 ± 1.047 -1.069 ± 1.435 [-2.095, -0.042] -2.355 0.042924 0.34339
soft-bass 86.472 ± 0.295 86.819 ± 0.400 0.347 ± 0.406 [0.057, 0.638] 2.709 0.024025 0.22467
hard-lead 71.967 ± 0.170 72.412 ± 0.419 0.444 ± 0.397 [0.160, 0.728] 3.536 0.00635 0.0762
idle-pad 139.196 ± 1.327 136.881 ± 4.890 -2.314 ± 4.552 [-5.570, 0.942] -1.608 0.14232 0.85393
auto-cutoff 377.053 ± 2.138 376.178 ± 3.205 -0.876 ± 2.904 [-2.953, 1.202] -0.954 0.36523 1
auto-resonance 420.048 ± 4.873 415.602 ± 2.624 -4.446 ± 3.480 [-6.936, -1.956] -4.039 0.0029311 0.038104
auto-drive 603.907 ± 2.239 611.250 ± 5.256 7.343 ± 5.262 [3.579, 11.107] 4.413 0.0016887 0.02533
auto-mix 604.412 ± 3.422 610.695 ± 2.558 6.283 ± 4.513 [3.054, 9.512] 4.402 0.001715 0.02533
auto-pan 407.396 ± 2.477 408.356 ± 5.185 0.960 ± 5.307 [-2.836, 4.756] 0.572 0.58137 1
auto-volume 390.039 ± 2.013 387.588 ± 2.215 -2.451 ± 2.818 [-4.467, -0.435] -2.750 0.022467 0.22467
auto-width 403.557 ± 3.170 400.202 ± 2.506 -3.356 ± 3.704 [-6.005, -0.706] -2.865 0.018626 0.20489
auto-phase-mod 206.974 ± 1.941 207.475 ± 2.633 0.501 ± 2.814 [-1.512, 2.513] 0.563 0.58734 1

E2: linear envelope

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61042。生データ: recurrence-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 37.759 ± 2.233 30.777 ± 0.208 -6.982 ± 2.257 [-8.597, -5.367] -9.782 4.2971e-06 2.5782e-05
saw-bass 61.798 ± 0.370 54.809 ± 0.372 -6.989 ± 0.199 [-7.131, -6.847] -111.259 1.9434e-15 3.4981e-14
triangle-pluck 113.628 ± 0.808 108.856 ± 0.755 -4.772 ± 0.780 [-5.329, -4.214] -19.350 1.215e-08 1.5795e-07
square-lead 61.359 ± 0.530 56.365 ± 0.125 -4.993 ± 0.534 [-5.375, -4.611] -29.572 2.8234e-10 4.5174e-09
saw-chords 363.516 ± 2.420 342.360 ± 3.571 -21.156 ± 2.688 [-23.079, -19.233] -24.888 1.31e-09 1.965e-08
slow-pad 464.929 ± 2.944 437.642 ± 2.562 -27.287 ± 0.700 [-27.788, -26.786] -123.206 7.7648e-16 1.4753e-14
three-osc-keys 309.457 ± 6.686 291.836 ± 1.990 -17.621 ± 7.076 [-22.682, -12.559] -7.875 2.5108e-05 0.00010043
phase-mod-bell 174.945 ± 0.605 166.330 ± 1.930 -8.615 ± 2.175 [-10.171, -7.059] -12.524 5.3456e-07 4.2765e-06
soft-bass 86.596 ± 0.620 86.050 ± 0.579 -0.546 ± 0.403 [-0.834, -0.257] -4.282 0.002045 0.0040901
hard-lead 72.219 ± 0.360 71.254 ± 0.569 -0.965 ± 0.517 [-1.334, -0.595] -5.901 0.00022882 0.00068646
idle-pad 139.902 ± 1.891 126.921 ± 0.918 -12.981 ± 2.031 [-14.434, -11.529] -20.213 8.2694e-09 1.1577e-07
auto-cutoff 379.127 ± 5.878 364.047 ± 1.964 -15.080 ± 5.649 [-19.121, -11.039] -8.442 1.4369e-05 7.1846e-05
auto-resonance 419.449 ± 2.082 400.102 ± 2.120 -19.347 ± 1.454 [-20.387, -18.307] -42.084 1.2046e-11 2.0478e-10
auto-drive 604.733 ± 3.995 620.127 ± 3.358 15.394 ± 2.948 [13.285, 17.503] 16.514 4.8813e-08 5.8575e-07
auto-mix 613.347 ± 31.705 621.104 ± 3.782 7.757 ± 28.512 [-12.639, 28.153] 0.860 0.41194 0.41194
auto-pan 410.026 ± 3.791 393.025 ± 2.729 -17.000 ± 4.894 [-20.502, -13.499] -10.984 1.6294e-06 1.1405e-05
auto-volume 390.284 ± 2.390 375.391 ± 2.393 -14.893 ± 2.925 [-16.985, -12.801] -16.101 6.0882e-08 6.697e-07
auto-width 402.961 ± 1.423 388.880 ± 2.608 -14.080 ± 3.029 [-16.247, -11.914] -14.701 1.3437e-07 1.2093e-06
auto-phase-mod 207.003 ± 1.905 198.825 ± 1.338 -8.178 ± 1.638 [-9.349, -7.006] -15.788 7.2247e-08 7.2247e-07

E2 + F1: rational tan

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61043。生データ: recurrence-rational-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 37.146 ± 0.326 30.711 ± 0.105 -6.435 ± 0.365 [-6.696, -6.174] -55.776 9.6326e-13 1.6375e-11
saw-bass 61.774 ± 0.129 56.709 ± 0.291 -5.065 ± 0.261 [-5.251, -4.878] -61.441 4.0414e-13 7.6787e-12
triangle-pluck 113.448 ± 1.192 108.083 ± 0.651 -5.365 ± 1.375 [-6.349, -4.381] -12.336 6.0844e-07 4.2591e-06
square-lead 61.196 ± 0.310 56.181 ± 0.191 -5.014 ± 0.412 [-5.309, -4.720] -38.503 2.6712e-11 3.7397e-10
saw-chords 378.601 ± 47.352 340.243 ± 0.945 -38.358 ± 47.587 [-72.399, -4.316] -2.549 0.031246 0.062493
slow-pad 464.496 ± 0.976 426.079 ± 1.762 -38.417 ± 2.047 [-39.881, -36.953] -59.357 5.5092e-13 9.9166e-12
three-osc-keys 304.745 ± 0.885 292.902 ± 2.446 -11.843 ± 2.458 [-13.601, -10.085] -15.237 9.842e-08 7.8736e-07
phase-mod-bell 174.817 ± 0.508 165.259 ± 0.568 -9.557 ± 0.738 [-10.085, -9.030] -40.978 1.5292e-11 2.2938e-10
soft-bass 86.533 ± 0.304 86.915 ± 0.272 0.382 ± 0.378 [0.111, 0.653] 3.194 0.01094 0.043761
hard-lead 72.040 ± 0.166 70.714 ± 0.174 -1.326 ± 0.208 [-1.474, -1.177] -20.197 8.3268e-09 9.1595e-08
idle-pad 139.451 ± 1.575 125.878 ± 0.899 -13.573 ± 1.780 [-14.846, -12.300] -24.115 1.7335e-09 2.0802e-08
auto-cutoff 379.464 ± 6.594 354.292 ± 0.552 -25.172 ± 6.668 [-29.942, -20.402] -11.938 8.0479e-07 4.8287e-06
auto-resonance 418.294 ± 4.151 391.903 ± 1.155 -26.391 ± 4.733 [-29.778, -23.005] -17.632 2.7513e-08 2.7513e-07
auto-drive 603.286 ± 0.938 602.384 ± 0.961 -0.902 ± 0.984 [-1.606, -0.199] -2.901 0.017573 0.052718
auto-mix 604.803 ± 4.235 602.060 ± 1.093 -2.743 ± 4.112 [-5.684, 0.199] -2.109 0.064152 0.064152
auto-pan 410.200 ± 4.276 384.793 ± 1.002 -25.407 ± 4.761 [-28.813, -22.001] -16.874 4.0414e-08 3.6372e-07
auto-volume 389.718 ± 0.873 366.934 ± 0.887 -22.785 ± 1.379 [-23.771, -21.798] -52.231 1.7366e-12 2.7785e-11
auto-width 402.341 ± 1.903 377.889 ± 1.835 -24.451 ± 2.639 [-26.339, -22.563] -29.297 3.0684e-10 3.9889e-09
auto-phase-mod 206.048 ± 1.277 198.295 ± 4.441 -7.753 ± 4.815 [-11.198, -4.309] -5.092 0.00065218 0.0032609

E2 + F3: stereo SSE2

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61044。生データ: recurrence-sse2-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 37.341 ± 0.616 31.160 ± 0.278 -6.181 ± 0.396 [-6.464, -5.898] -49.400 2.8627e-12 3.7215e-11
saw-bass 62.018 ± 0.574 53.391 ± 0.627 -8.627 ± 0.262 [-8.815, -8.440] -103.973 3.5737e-15 6.7901e-14
triangle-pluck 113.731 ± 1.271 102.477 ± 0.865 -11.254 ± 0.545 [-11.643, -10.864] -65.356 2.3205e-13 3.9449e-12
square-lead 61.483 ± 0.667 53.348 ± 0.567 -8.135 ± 0.355 [-8.389, -7.881] -72.388 9.2645e-14 1.6676e-12
saw-chords 367.627 ± 6.084 320.253 ± 2.773 -47.373 ± 6.495 [-52.020, -42.727] -23.064 2.5741e-09 1.0296e-08
slow-pad 467.978 ± 5.079 423.159 ± 3.776 -44.819 ± 2.234 [-46.418, -43.221] -63.436 3.0329e-13 4.5493e-12
three-osc-keys 308.410 ± 4.401 277.420 ± 2.837 -30.989 ± 3.682 [-33.624, -28.355] -26.614 7.2177e-10 4.3306e-09
phase-mod-bell 175.684 ± 1.803 165.439 ± 1.380 -10.245 ± 1.137 [-11.058, -9.431] -28.492 3.9334e-10 2.7534e-09
soft-bass 86.901 ± 1.064 83.789 ± 0.843 -3.113 ± 0.380 [-3.385, -2.841] -25.898 9.1992e-10 4.5996e-09
hard-lead 72.894 ± 1.959 67.871 ± 0.727 -5.023 ± 2.094 [-6.521, -3.525] -7.585 3.3791e-05 6.7582e-05
idle-pad 140.154 ± 2.178 123.640 ± 1.214 -16.515 ± 1.523 [-17.604, -15.425] -34.301 7.509e-11 8.2599e-10
auto-cutoff 378.828 ± 3.194 334.532 ± 2.899 -44.296 ± 2.169 [-45.848, -42.745] -64.581 2.5829e-13 4.1326e-12
auto-resonance 420.771 ± 4.162 379.040 ± 4.046 -41.731 ± 3.965 [-44.568, -38.895] -33.283 9.8283e-11 8.8455e-10
auto-drive 607.039 ± 5.702 575.453 ± 4.970 -31.585 ± 1.933 [-32.968, -30.202] -51.679 1.9101e-12 2.6741e-11
auto-mix 605.935 ± 5.091 591.365 ± 53.348 -14.570 ± 50.473 [-50.676, 21.536] -0.913 0.38512 0.38512
auto-pan 411.522 ± 3.873 367.800 ± 3.814 -43.722 ± 3.300 [-46.082, -41.361] -41.899 1.2531e-11 1.5037e-10
auto-volume 392.129 ± 3.918 349.758 ± 6.803 -42.370 ± 6.017 [-46.675, -38.066] -22.266 3.5159e-09 1.0548e-08
auto-width 404.976 ± 5.934 361.278 ± 7.970 -43.698 ± 4.052 [-46.597, -40.800] -34.105 7.9044e-11 8.2599e-10
auto-phase-mod 207.089 ± 2.392 196.966 ± 2.399 -10.123 ± 1.073 [-10.891, -9.355] -29.822 2.6194e-10 2.0955e-09

E2 + E3: cutoff recurrence

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61045。生データ: cutoff-recurrence-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 37.978 ± 3.172 31.355 ± 0.322 -6.623 ± 3.054 [-8.808, -4.438] -6.857 7.4115e-05 0.00059292
saw-bass 61.670 ± 0.103 53.723 ± 0.160 -7.947 ± 0.122 [-8.034, -7.859] -206.243 7.5349e-18 1.4316e-16
triangle-pluck 118.108 ± 14.706 111.109 ± 0.603 -6.999 ± 14.719 [-17.529, 3.530] -1.504 0.16691 0.16691
square-lead 61.097 ± 0.187 56.803 ± 0.144 -4.294 ± 0.273 [-4.490, -4.098] -49.652 2.7352e-12 4.9234e-11
saw-chords 367.072 ± 5.304 350.151 ± 4.988 -16.921 ± 7.676 [-22.412, -11.430] -6.971 6.5283e-05 0.00058755
slow-pad 466.534 ± 7.052 437.228 ± 2.656 -29.306 ± 7.862 [-34.931, -23.682] -11.787 8.9667e-07 1.076e-05
three-osc-keys 307.195 ± 6.731 296.957 ± 1.308 -10.237 ± 6.931 [-15.196, -5.279] -4.671 0.0011674 0.0058368
phase-mod-bell 174.834 ± 0.549 167.067 ± 0.615 -7.767 ± 0.963 [-8.456, -7.078] -25.515 1.0505e-09 1.7858e-08
soft-bass 86.351 ± 0.255 84.804 ± 0.185 -1.547 ± 0.349 [-1.796, -1.297] -14.010 2.0377e-07 3.0565e-06
hard-lead 71.895 ± 0.138 71.740 ± 0.124 -0.155 ± 0.139 [-0.254, -0.055] -3.509 0.0066296 0.019889
idle-pad 140.075 ± 1.469 143.227 ± 1.021 3.151 ± 1.990 [1.728, 4.575] 5.007 0.00073219 0.0051253
auto-cutoff 378.109 ± 3.862 361.792 ± 1.503 -16.317 ± 3.904 [-19.109, -13.524] -13.217 3.3686e-07 4.7161e-06
auto-resonance 422.371 ± 9.098 401.155 ± 4.032 -21.216 ± 9.394 [-27.936, -14.496] -7.142 5.4118e-05 0.00054118
auto-drive 605.466 ± 4.368 609.317 ± 2.944 3.851 ± 5.672 [-0.207, 7.908] 2.147 0.060334 0.12067
auto-mix 604.218 ± 3.571 610.305 ± 3.471 6.087 ± 3.852 [3.332, 8.842] 4.998 0.00074137 0.0051253
auto-pan 412.132 ± 13.588 394.713 ± 5.908 -17.418 ± 11.917 [-25.943, -8.893] -4.622 0.0012508 0.0058368
auto-volume 390.473 ± 3.245 373.974 ± 1.606 -16.498 ± 3.552 [-19.039, -13.957] -14.687 1.3543e-07 2.1669e-06
auto-width 403.602 ± 5.380 385.761 ± 1.199 -17.841 ± 4.676 [-21.186, -14.496] -12.066 7.3484e-07 9.5529e-06
auto-phase-mod 205.938 ± 0.903 200.439 ± 1.143 -5.499 ± 1.697 [-6.713, -4.285] -10.245 2.9237e-06 3.2161e-05

E2 + F1 + F5: stage cache vs baseline

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61046。生データ: filter-stage-cache-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 37.059 ± 0.332 31.230 ± 0.210 -5.829 ± 0.252 [-6.009, -5.648] -73.075 8.5102e-14 1.6169e-12
saw-bass 61.973 ± 0.481 57.400 ± 0.617 -4.573 ± 0.408 [-4.864, -4.281] -35.462 5.5755e-11 9.4784e-10
triangle-pluck 113.137 ± 0.611 108.527 ± 0.582 -4.610 ± 0.581 [-5.026, -4.194] -25.071 1.2276e-09 1.8414e-08
square-lead 62.639 ± 4.722 57.044 ± 0.557 -5.595 ± 4.307 [-8.676, -2.514] -4.108 0.0026438 0.015863
saw-chords 367.293 ± 4.192 340.722 ± 2.645 -26.571 ± 4.610 [-29.869, -23.274] -18.228 2.0544e-08 2.4653e-07
slow-pad 466.070 ± 4.741 426.328 ± 2.595 -39.742 ± 5.024 [-43.336, -36.147] -25.013 1.2534e-09 1.8414e-08
three-osc-keys 306.658 ± 6.577 293.052 ± 1.633 -13.606 ± 6.708 [-18.404, -8.807] -6.414 0.00012322 0.00086257
phase-mod-bell 175.006 ± 1.147 164.943 ± 1.594 -10.064 ± 1.034 [-10.803, -9.324] -30.786 1.9722e-10 3.1555e-09
soft-bass 87.769 ± 3.845 87.389 ± 0.579 -0.380 ± 3.934 [-3.194, 2.434] -0.305 0.76702 1
hard-lead 72.087 ± 0.606 73.900 ± 8.116 1.813 ± 8.228 [-4.073, 7.699] 0.697 0.50347 1
idle-pad 139.429 ± 1.329 126.963 ± 3.081 -12.466 ± 3.228 [-14.775, -10.156] -12.210 6.639e-07 6.1613e-06
auto-cutoff 377.735 ± 2.127 353.814 ± 2.514 -23.921 ± 1.362 [-24.895, -22.946] -55.538 1.0008e-12 1.8015e-11
auto-resonance 420.857 ± 8.324 393.266 ± 2.604 -27.591 ± 7.083 [-32.658, -22.524] -12.318 6.1613e-07 6.1613e-06
auto-drive 607.078 ± 5.625 601.185 ± 4.159 -5.892 ± 4.709 [-9.261, -2.524] -3.957 0.0033196 0.016598
auto-mix 605.619 ± 7.363 602.512 ± 4.899 -3.107 ± 5.818 [-7.269, 1.055] -1.689 0.12555 0.50219
auto-pan 409.135 ± 4.992 404.610 ± 57.606 -4.525 ± 58.078 [-46.071, 37.022] -0.246 0.81092 1
auto-volume 391.786 ± 3.492 366.862 ± 3.235 -24.925 ± 4.415 [-28.083, -21.766] -17.852 2.4677e-08 2.7145e-07
auto-width 403.026 ± 3.436 380.711 ± 7.570 -22.316 ± 7.991 [-28.032, -16.599] -8.831 9.9662e-06 7.973e-05
auto-phase-mod 207.427 ± 1.912 195.586 ± 1.886 -11.841 ± 1.863 [-13.174, -10.508] -20.100 8.6891e-09 1.1296e-07

F3 refined vs F3 initial

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61047。生データ: sse2-refined-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 31.183 ± 0.301 31.154 ± 0.360 -0.029 ± 0.369 [-0.293, 0.236] -0.244 0.81244 1
saw-bass 53.208 ± 0.403 56.417 ± 0.301 3.209 ± 0.546 [2.818, 3.599] 18.600 1.7202e-08 3.0964e-07
triangle-pluck 104.334 ± 6.123 105.373 ± 4.979 1.039 ± 8.109 [-4.762, 6.839] 0.405 0.69494 1
square-lead 53.291 ± 0.419 57.070 ± 0.458 3.779 ± 0.636 [3.324, 4.234] 18.783 1.5785e-08 2.9992e-07
saw-chords 319.234 ± 2.769 338.044 ± 2.158 18.810 ± 3.885 [16.031, 21.589] 15.313 9.429e-08 1.5086e-06
slow-pad 421.743 ± 2.770 441.322 ± 4.905 19.579 ± 5.717 [15.490, 23.669] 10.831 1.8346e-06 1.8346e-05
three-osc-keys 277.086 ± 1.957 283.305 ± 3.926 6.220 ± 4.347 [3.110, 9.329] 4.525 0.0014368 0.0071841
phase-mod-bell 164.654 ± 0.817 165.082 ± 1.208 0.428 ± 1.414 [-0.583, 1.439] 0.958 0.36331 1
soft-bass 83.588 ± 0.443 87.224 ± 0.792 3.637 ± 0.926 [2.974, 4.299] 12.423 5.7307e-07 7.4499e-06
hard-lead 68.047 ± 0.985 71.545 ± 0.901 3.498 ± 1.514 [2.415, 4.581] 7.307 4.5329e-05 0.00036264
idle-pad 123.704 ± 1.568 126.805 ± 1.529 3.101 ± 1.890 [1.749, 4.453] 5.189 0.00057214 0.0034329
auto-cutoff 335.329 ± 5.928 354.429 ± 5.743 19.099 ± 9.148 [12.555, 25.643] 6.602 9.9014e-05 0.0006931
auto-resonance 379.398 ± 4.668 402.204 ± 3.719 22.806 ± 5.260 [19.044, 26.569] 13.712 2.4545e-07 3.4363e-06
auto-drive 575.596 ± 3.789 605.618 ± 7.166 30.022 ± 8.512 [23.933, 36.111] 11.153 1.4326e-06 1.7191e-05
auto-mix 573.549 ± 1.566 602.730 ± 5.152 29.181 ± 5.289 [25.398, 32.965] 17.447 3.0166e-08 5.1283e-07
auto-pan 366.024 ± 2.934 384.316 ± 7.342 18.292 ± 5.387 [14.439, 22.145] 10.739 1.9715e-06 1.8346e-05
auto-volume 347.774 ± 4.557 364.119 ± 1.084 16.345 ± 4.704 [12.980, 19.710] 10.987 1.6257e-06 1.7882e-05
auto-width 359.269 ± 2.774 375.113 ± 1.718 15.844 ± 3.418 [13.399, 18.289] 14.658 1.378e-07 2.067e-06
auto-phase-mod 197.118 ± 2.190 195.356 ± 2.601 -1.762 ± 3.802 [-4.482, 0.958] -1.466 0.17681 0.70723

E4: configure envelope vs corrected E2

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61048。生データ: envelope-config-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 31.283 ± 0.798 30.944 ± 2.637 -0.339 ± 2.844 [-2.373, 1.695] -0.377 0.71499 0.71499
saw-bass 55.295 ± 0.552 55.113 ± 0.821 -0.181 ± 0.392 [-0.462, 0.100] -1.459 0.17856 0.35713
triangle-pluck 110.048 ± 1.369 108.312 ± 2.222 -1.735 ± 2.147 [-3.271, -0.200] -2.556 0.03089 0.12356
square-lead 56.728 ± 0.625 56.273 ± 0.710 -0.454 ± 0.376 [-0.723, -0.185] -3.816 0.0041153 0.020576
saw-chords 345.271 ± 3.130 334.205 ± 3.000 -11.066 ± 1.820 [-12.368, -9.764] -19.228 1.2845e-08 1.7982e-07
slow-pad 442.534 ± 3.442 429.891 ± 3.965 -12.643 ± 2.246 [-14.250, -11.037] -17.802 2.529e-08 2.9523e-07
three-osc-keys 296.089 ± 2.742 284.148 ± 2.738 -11.941 ± 2.115 [-13.453, -10.428] -17.858 2.4602e-08 2.9523e-07
phase-mod-bell 166.992 ± 1.428 160.513 ± 1.428 -6.480 ± 1.481 [-7.539, -5.420] -13.832 2.276e-07 2.0484e-06
soft-bass 86.478 ± 0.896 85.792 ± 0.867 -0.686 ± 0.470 [-1.022, -0.350] -4.617 0.0012606 0.0075633
hard-lead 72.311 ± 2.628 70.733 ± 0.847 -1.577 ± 2.063 [-3.053, -0.102] -2.418 0.038732 0.12356
idle-pad 126.439 ± 1.696 129.319 ± 1.648 2.879 ± 1.695 [1.667, 4.092] 5.373 0.00044888 0.0031421
auto-cutoff 367.118 ± 3.354 348.762 ± 3.160 -18.356 ± 1.392 [-19.352, -17.360] -41.704 1.3066e-11 2.4825e-10
auto-resonance 403.858 ± 3.394 386.751 ± 5.691 -17.107 ± 2.958 [-19.223, -14.991] -18.290 1.9942e-08 2.5924e-07
auto-drive 622.895 ± 5.529 595.623 ± 4.733 -27.272 ± 3.337 [-29.659, -24.884] -25.842 9.3797e-10 1.5007e-08
auto-mix 625.125 ± 6.961 595.377 ± 5.260 -29.748 ± 4.045 [-32.641, -26.854] -23.258 2.3898e-09 3.5847e-08
auto-pan 398.625 ± 4.297 380.191 ± 3.528 -18.434 ± 1.924 [-19.810, -17.058] -30.301 2.2722e-10 3.8628e-09
auto-volume 378.730 ± 3.235 359.750 ± 2.966 -18.980 ± 1.516 [-20.065, -17.896] -39.603 2.0757e-11 3.7363e-10
auto-width 395.066 ± 5.871 373.455 ± 4.386 -21.611 ± 4.258 [-24.657, -18.565] -16.049 6.2627e-08 6.2627e-07
auto-phase-mod 199.928 ± 2.318 193.990 ± 2.227 -5.937 ± 1.659 [-7.124, -4.751] -11.319 1.2643e-06 1.0114e-05

F3 constant selection vs F3 refined

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61049。生データ: sse2-constant-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 30.791 ± 0.274 30.836 ± 0.110 0.045 ± 0.278 [-0.153, 0.244] 0.514 0.61937 1
saw-bass 56.188 ± 0.208 53.416 ± 0.117 -2.772 ± 0.178 [-2.900, -2.644] -49.128 3.008e-12 5.4144e-11
triangle-pluck 104.029 ± 0.343 102.451 ± 0.384 -1.578 ± 0.663 [-2.052, -1.103] -7.521 3.6128e-05 0.00028902
square-lead 56.622 ± 0.128 53.552 ± 0.184 -3.070 ± 0.253 [-3.251, -2.889] -38.353 2.7662e-11 4.7025e-10
saw-chords 337.619 ± 0.694 318.457 ± 1.158 -19.162 ± 1.656 [-20.347, -17.977] -36.583 4.2212e-11 6.7539e-10
slow-pad 441.998 ± 3.515 421.831 ± 1.660 -20.168 ± 4.022 [-23.045, -17.291] -15.859 6.9506e-08 8.3408e-07
three-osc-keys 281.691 ± 0.544 277.148 ± 1.117 -4.543 ± 1.245 [-5.434, -3.653] -11.537 1.0756e-06 1.1831e-05
phase-mod-bell 164.865 ± 0.627 166.180 ± 1.450 1.315 ± 1.789 [0.036, 2.595] 2.325 0.045108 0.22554
soft-bass 86.809 ± 0.106 83.671 ± 0.077 -3.138 ± 0.093 [-3.204, -3.072] -107.266 2.6997e-15 5.1295e-14
hard-lead 72.123 ± 3.879 67.950 ± 0.130 -4.173 ± 3.913 [-6.973, -1.374] -3.373 0.0082242 0.049345
idle-pad 125.785 ± 0.978 123.729 ± 0.875 -2.056 ± 1.424 [-3.075, -1.037] -4.565 0.0013566 0.0094964
auto-cutoff 352.203 ± 0.856 339.392 ± 18.305 -12.811 ± 18.263 [-25.876, 0.254] -2.218 0.053717 0.22554
auto-resonance 401.565 ± 1.422 378.984 ± 1.993 -22.581 ± 2.931 [-24.678, -20.485] -24.362 1.5841e-09 2.2178e-08
auto-drive 601.566 ± 2.213 576.800 ± 0.868 -24.765 ± 2.171 [-26.318, -23.213] -36.081 4.7769e-11 7.1654e-10
auto-mix 601.658 ± 2.860 586.710 ± 30.500 -14.948 ± 30.738 [-36.937, 7.041] -1.538 0.15847 0.47541
auto-pan 383.808 ± 4.613 364.376 ± 3.828 -19.432 ± 7.120 [-24.525, -14.338] -8.630 1.202e-05 0.00010818
auto-volume 363.943 ± 0.585 347.241 ± 3.310 -16.702 ± 3.044 [-18.879, -14.524] -17.352 3.1657e-08 4.1154e-07
auto-width 377.732 ± 5.633 357.048 ± 2.713 -20.684 ± 6.092 [-25.042, -16.326] -10.736 1.9753e-06 1.9753e-05
auto-phase-mod 196.932 ± 1.816 197.287 ± 1.833 0.355 ± 2.425 [-1.380, 2.090] 0.463 0.65459 1

F6: cached validation vs refined F3

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61050。生データ: filter-validation-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 30.951 ± 0.325 30.717 ± 0.074 -0.234 ± 0.319 [-0.462, -0.006] -2.321 0.045404 0.36323
saw-bass 56.253 ± 0.157 56.031 ± 0.056 -0.222 ± 0.172 [-0.346, -0.099] -4.078 0.0027671 0.035972
triangle-pluck 104.099 ± 0.310 102.092 ± 0.246 -2.007 ± 0.346 [-2.254, -1.759] -18.336 1.9509e-08 3.5117e-07
square-lead 57.379 ± 2.232 57.797 ± 3.994 0.418 ± 1.791 [-0.863, 1.699] 0.738 0.4792 1
saw-chords 338.017 ± 0.846 334.230 ± 0.937 -3.787 ± 1.212 [-4.654, -2.920] -9.885 3.9386e-06 6.6957e-05
slow-pad 442.408 ± 3.008 438.574 ± 1.609 -3.834 ± 3.605 [-6.413, -1.255] -3.363 0.0083438 0.10013
three-osc-keys 282.743 ± 3.112 280.667 ± 2.474 -2.076 ± 3.950 [-4.902, 0.750] -1.662 0.13091 0.91639
phase-mod-bell 165.212 ± 1.021 165.564 ± 0.791 0.352 ± 1.235 [-0.532, 1.235] 0.900 0.39155 1
soft-bass 86.853 ± 0.233 86.920 ± 0.726 0.067 ± 0.540 [-0.319, 0.453] 0.394 0.70299 1
hard-lead 71.013 ± 0.228 71.941 ± 3.009 0.928 ± 2.930 [-1.168, 3.025] 1.002 0.34254 1
idle-pad 126.444 ± 1.089 140.497 ± 0.331 14.053 ± 1.243 [13.163, 14.942] 35.738 5.2021e-11 9.884e-10
auto-cutoff 352.718 ± 2.539 350.403 ± 6.651 -2.315 ± 7.225 [-7.484, 2.854] -1.013 0.33745 1
auto-resonance 401.620 ± 1.871 406.226 ± 2.265 4.606 ± 3.252 [2.279, 6.932] 4.479 0.0015355 0.021497
auto-drive 601.749 ± 2.248 598.803 ± 2.101 -2.947 ± 3.505 [-5.454, -0.439] -2.658 0.026111 0.26111
auto-mix 602.857 ± 4.858 597.618 ± 1.335 -5.239 ± 5.307 [-9.035, -1.443] -3.122 0.01228 0.13508
auto-pan 382.443 ± 1.883 378.259 ± 1.222 -4.184 ± 1.936 [-5.569, -2.800] -6.835 7.5999e-05 0.00114
auto-volume 364.272 ± 0.593 361.340 ± 1.227 -2.932 ± 1.173 [-3.771, -2.093] -7.903 2.4385e-05 0.00039016
auto-width 378.251 ± 6.547 372.502 ± 2.019 -5.749 ± 7.117 [-10.840, -0.657] -2.554 0.030981 0.27883
auto-phase-mod 196.242 ± 1.688 195.672 ± 1.398 -0.570 ± 2.080 [-2.058, 0.917] -0.867 0.40832 1

F7: cached 1/Q vs refined F3

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61051。生データ: filter-q-cache-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 30.723 ± 0.077 30.832 ± 0.385 0.109 ± 0.403 [-0.179, 0.398] 0.857 0.41347 1
saw-bass 56.286 ± 0.317 56.538 ± 0.249 0.252 ± 0.393 [-0.029, 0.533] 2.025 0.07353 1
triangle-pluck 104.321 ± 0.335 104.296 ± 0.513 -0.024 ± 0.627 [-0.473, 0.424] -0.123 0.90503 1
square-lead 56.782 ± 0.379 56.623 ± 0.351 -0.159 ± 0.506 [-0.521, 0.203] -0.995 0.34583 1
saw-chords 341.073 ± 3.987 337.584 ± 1.553 -3.489 ± 4.440 [-6.665, -0.313] -2.485 0.034707 0.59003
slow-pad 442.117 ± 4.156 440.887 ± 0.944 -1.230 ± 4.031 [-4.113, 1.654] -0.965 0.35991 1
three-osc-keys 281.961 ± 1.467 282.135 ± 0.783 0.174 ± 1.303 [-0.758, 1.106] 0.423 0.68237 1
phase-mod-bell 165.716 ± 2.091 165.588 ± 0.477 -0.128 ± 1.918 [-1.500, 1.244] -0.211 0.83789 1
soft-bass 87.012 ± 0.356 87.058 ± 0.326 0.046 ± 0.356 [-0.209, 0.300] 0.407 0.69323 1
hard-lead 70.995 ± 0.223 70.967 ± 0.140 -0.028 ± 0.129 [-0.121, 0.064] -0.688 0.50902 1
idle-pad 126.529 ± 0.997 128.096 ± 2.884 1.567 ± 2.554 [-0.261, 3.394] 1.940 0.084361 1
auto-cutoff 352.070 ± 1.217 351.299 ± 0.810 -0.771 ± 1.118 [-1.571, 0.029] -2.179 0.057263 0.9162
auto-resonance 403.051 ± 1.556 401.713 ± 3.824 -1.338 ± 4.915 [-4.854, 2.178] -0.861 0.41167 1
auto-drive 600.947 ± 0.500 605.151 ± 4.793 4.205 ± 4.621 [0.899, 7.510] 2.877 0.018265 0.32877
auto-mix 600.970 ± 0.459 603.238 ± 0.855 2.268 ± 0.878 [1.640, 2.896] 8.171 1.8693e-05 0.00035517
auto-pan 381.373 ± 2.582 382.523 ± 2.489 1.150 ± 3.462 [-1.327, 3.626] 1.050 0.321 1
auto-volume 364.992 ± 3.189 364.164 ± 0.602 -0.829 ± 3.122 [-3.062, 1.404] -0.839 0.42295 1
auto-width 375.199 ± 2.238 374.998 ± 0.975 -0.201 ± 1.910 [-1.567, 1.166] -0.332 0.74749 1
auto-phase-mod 195.742 ± 0.978 196.273 ± 1.142 0.531 ± 1.455 [-0.510, 1.572] 1.154 0.27811 1

F8 initial: rational coefficients vs constant-selection F3

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61052。生データ: filter-rational-direct-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 30.945 ± 0.288 30.867 ± 0.190 -0.078 ± 0.386 [-0.354, 0.197] -0.643 0.53633 1
saw-bass 53.333 ± 0.247 49.652 ± 0.269 -3.681 ± 0.396 [-3.964, -3.398] -29.411 2.9644e-10 3.8537e-09
triangle-pluck 102.410 ± 0.402 99.069 ± 0.344 -3.342 ± 0.356 [-3.596, -3.087] -29.670 2.7414e-10 3.8379e-09
square-lead 53.504 ± 0.108 49.647 ± 0.055 -3.856 ± 0.121 [-3.943, -3.770] -100.819 4.7142e-15 8.957e-14
saw-chords 321.251 ± 3.940 299.641 ± 1.040 -21.610 ± 4.011 [-24.479, -18.741] -17.039 3.7115e-08 3.0967e-07
slow-pad 424.644 ± 5.602 383.867 ± 0.826 -40.776 ± 5.307 [-44.573, -36.980] -24.296 1.6223e-09 1.7845e-08
three-osc-keys 280.311 ± 4.414 270.360 ± 1.745 -9.950 ± 4.313 [-13.036, -6.865] -7.295 4.5889e-05 0.00027533
phase-mod-bell 165.995 ± 1.117 165.199 ± 0.828 -0.796 ± 1.604 [-1.943, 0.352] -1.569 0.15112 0.60448
soft-bass 83.683 ± 0.125 80.079 ± 0.091 -3.604 ± 0.158 [-3.718, -3.491] -72.030 9.6868e-14 1.6468e-12
hard-lead 67.873 ± 0.106 63.901 ± 0.074 -3.972 ± 0.136 [-4.069, -3.875] -92.565 1.0162e-14 1.8292e-13
idle-pad 123.488 ± 0.964 123.730 ± 1.187 0.242 ± 1.819 [-1.059, 1.544] 0.421 0.68345 1
auto-cutoff 334.494 ± 5.228 314.163 ± 6.035 -20.331 ± 1.023 [-21.063, -19.599] -62.822 3.3101e-13 5.2962e-12
auto-resonance 379.131 ± 1.491 353.380 ± 4.521 -25.751 ± 4.989 [-29.320, -22.182] -16.322 5.406e-08 3.7842e-07
auto-drive 577.635 ± 2.778 548.804 ± 2.936 -28.830 ± 4.420 [-31.992, -25.668] -20.624 6.9219e-09 6.9219e-08
auto-mix 578.609 ± 3.495 548.273 ± 0.896 -30.336 ± 3.799 [-33.053, -27.618] -25.250 1.1526e-09 1.3831e-08
auto-pan 362.826 ± 2.459 347.374 ± 6.869 -15.452 ± 7.849 [-21.067, -9.837] -6.225 0.00015409 0.00077046
auto-volume 345.874 ± 2.040 327.399 ± 3.009 -18.475 ± 1.823 [-19.779, -17.170] -32.041 1.3804e-10 2.0706e-09
auto-width 357.146 ± 2.150 339.269 ± 2.072 -17.877 ± 3.289 [-20.230, -15.524] -17.187 3.4408e-08 3.0967e-07
auto-phase-mod 197.824 ± 2.359 197.353 ± 1.295 -0.471 ± 2.728 [-2.422, 1.481] -0.546 0.59863 1

F9: stereo component vs constant-selection F3

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61053。生データ: filter-stereo-component-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 31.263 ± 0.663 30.817 ± 0.191 -0.447 ± 0.598 [-0.875, -0.019] -2.361 0.042541 0.63811
saw-bass 53.435 ± 0.319 53.269 ± 0.383 -0.166 ± 0.363 [-0.425, 0.093] -1.447 0.1818 1
triangle-pluck 103.050 ± 0.985 103.917 ± 0.692 0.867 ± 0.503 [0.507, 1.227] 5.447 0.00040706 0.0073271
square-lead 53.755 ± 0.456 54.372 ± 2.473 0.617 ± 2.278 [-1.012, 2.247] 0.857 0.41363 1
saw-chords 319.724 ± 1.993 321.668 ± 3.786 1.944 ± 3.361 [-0.461, 4.348] 1.829 0.1007 1
slow-pad 424.574 ± 4.513 425.013 ± 2.434 0.439 ± 3.803 [-2.281, 3.159] 0.365 0.72359 1
three-osc-keys 279.330 ± 2.144 282.137 ± 3.605 2.807 ± 4.212 [-0.206, 5.820] 2.108 0.064301 0.90021
phase-mod-bell 165.844 ± 1.448 165.604 ± 1.184 -0.240 ± 1.133 [-1.051, 0.570] -0.670 0.5195 1
soft-bass 83.939 ± 0.432 84.656 ± 1.871 0.716 ± 1.923 [-0.660, 2.092] 1.178 0.26911 1
hard-lead 68.555 ± 1.328 68.198 ± 0.537 -0.357 ± 1.345 [-1.320, 0.605] -0.840 0.42273 1
idle-pad 123.371 ± 1.171 145.657 ± 1.337 22.286 ± 1.231 [21.405, 23.166] 57.249 7.6227e-13 1.4483e-11
auto-cutoff 334.101 ± 2.210 333.360 ± 1.962 -0.741 ± 1.127 [-1.547, 0.065] -2.079 0.067409 0.90021
auto-resonance 378.675 ± 2.509 382.145 ± 5.668 3.470 ± 5.694 [-0.603, 7.543] 1.927 0.086073 1
auto-drive 578.711 ± 3.085 577.459 ± 3.009 -1.251 ± 1.138 [-2.065, -0.437] -3.477 0.006972 0.11852
auto-mix 578.210 ± 3.178 577.827 ± 3.000 -0.383 ± 1.020 [-1.113, 0.346] -1.189 0.26502 1
auto-pan 364.251 ± 3.192 365.943 ± 5.893 1.692 ± 5.061 [-1.928, 5.313] 1.057 0.31789 1
auto-volume 347.577 ± 2.827 346.815 ± 2.127 -0.763 ± 2.793 [-2.761, 1.235] -0.864 0.41028 1
auto-width 357.659 ± 2.308 356.736 ± 1.555 -0.923 ± 1.567 [-2.044, 0.198] -1.863 0.095348 1
auto-phase-mod 197.764 ± 0.816 196.216 ± 2.088 -1.548 ± 1.983 [-2.967, -0.129] -2.469 0.035655 0.57049

F10: rate factor vs constant-selection F3

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61054。生データ: filter-rate-cache-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 30.953 ± 0.142 30.871 ± 0.314 -0.082 ± 0.249 [-0.260, 0.096] -1.042 0.32468 1
saw-bass 53.576 ± 0.438 52.741 ± 0.564 -0.834 ± 0.394 [-1.116, -0.553] -6.695 8.9062e-05 0.0016922
triangle-pluck 102.645 ± 0.594 102.511 ± 0.764 -0.135 ± 0.699 [-0.634, 0.365] -0.609 0.55778 1
square-lead 54.525 ± 2.846 53.827 ± 0.619 -0.698 ± 3.049 [-2.880, 1.483] -0.724 0.48743 1
saw-chords 320.143 ± 3.050 323.134 ± 4.707 2.991 ± 4.995 [-0.582, 6.564] 1.894 0.090817 1
slow-pad 421.627 ± 2.717 418.875 ± 0.948 -2.752 ± 2.737 [-4.710, -0.794] -3.180 0.011185 0.16777
three-osc-keys 278.168 ± 1.873 279.898 ± 2.995 1.730 ± 2.631 [-0.152, 3.612] 2.079 0.067359 0.94303
phase-mod-bell 165.982 ± 1.339 165.351 ± 0.856 -0.631 ± 1.440 [-1.661, 0.399] -1.385 0.1993 1
soft-bass 83.753 ± 0.148 83.317 ± 0.427 -0.435 ± 0.348 [-0.684, -0.186] -3.954 0.0033335 0.053337
hard-lead 68.447 ± 1.114 67.981 ± 0.251 -0.466 ± 0.998 [-1.180, 0.248] -1.476 0.17398 1
idle-pad 125.545 ± 3.506 125.638 ± 4.123 0.092 ± 6.200 [-4.343, 4.527] 0.047 0.96346 1
auto-cutoff 334.194 ± 2.274 334.940 ± 0.718 0.746 ± 2.186 [-0.818, 2.310] 1.080 0.30841 1
auto-resonance 379.603 ± 2.381 380.223 ± 2.658 0.620 ± 4.002 [-2.243, 3.483] 0.490 0.63602 1
auto-drive 577.796 ± 3.323 581.725 ± 3.869 3.929 ± 2.468 [2.164, 5.694] 5.035 0.00070444 0.01268
auto-mix 579.552 ± 5.432 579.593 ± 0.626 0.042 ± 5.124 [-3.624, 3.707] 0.026 0.97993 1
auto-pan 364.148 ± 3.462 366.789 ± 5.386 2.642 ± 7.101 [-2.438, 7.722] 1.176 0.26965 1
auto-volume 347.612 ± 3.572 348.212 ± 1.726 0.600 ± 4.254 [-2.444, 3.643] 0.446 0.66637 1
auto-width 357.272 ± 1.470 358.469 ± 0.911 1.197 ± 0.918 [0.540, 1.854] 4.121 0.0025943 0.044102
auto-phase-mod 197.850 ± 1.924 196.686 ± 1.468 -1.163 ± 2.172 [-2.717, 0.390] -1.694 0.12446 1

F8 safe: rational coefficients vs constant-selection F3

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61056。生データ: filter-rational-safe-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 31.603 ± 2.162 30.934 ± 0.175 -0.668 ± 2.154 [-2.209, 0.872] -0.981 0.352 0.97598
saw-bass 53.529 ± 0.335 51.074 ± 0.142 -2.455 ± 0.260 [-2.641, -2.269] -29.854 2.5943e-10 4.4104e-09
triangle-pluck 102.663 ± 0.528 100.598 ± 0.218 -2.065 ± 0.594 [-2.490, -1.640] -10.993 1.6182e-06 2.1037e-05
square-lead 53.601 ± 0.272 51.282 ± 0.385 -2.318 ± 0.166 [-2.437, -2.200] -44.268 7.6541e-12 1.4543e-10
saw-chords 320.298 ± 2.394 308.990 ± 3.640 -11.308 ± 4.635 [-14.623, -7.992] -7.715 2.9545e-05 0.00029545
slow-pad 422.919 ± 4.011 394.367 ± 2.943 -28.552 ± 5.219 [-32.285, -24.818] -17.300 3.2495e-08 5.1993e-07
three-osc-keys 278.672 ± 2.709 274.931 ± 0.907 -3.741 ± 2.558 [-5.571, -1.911] -4.625 0.0012458 0.0087205
phase-mod-bell 166.040 ± 1.103 165.223 ± 1.508 -0.817 ± 1.937 [-2.203, 0.569] -1.334 0.21509 0.86037
soft-bass 85.239 ± 3.203 81.552 ± 0.250 -3.687 ± 3.067 [-5.881, -1.493] -3.802 0.0042071 0.025243
hard-lead 68.084 ± 0.264 65.745 ± 0.167 -2.339 ± 0.174 [-2.463, -2.214] -42.410 1.124e-11 2.0233e-10
idle-pad 123.771 ± 1.382 124.362 ± 1.689 0.592 ± 1.798 [-0.695, 1.878] 1.040 0.32533 0.97598
auto-cutoff 334.111 ± 2.441 323.685 ± 3.343 -10.426 ± 3.617 [-13.014, -7.839] -9.115 7.6953e-06 8.4648e-05
auto-resonance 379.946 ± 1.806 372.775 ± 28.372 -7.170 ± 28.858 [-27.814, 13.473] -0.786 0.45221 0.97598
auto-drive 579.351 ± 3.141 559.145 ± 2.383 -20.206 ± 4.595 [-23.493, -16.919] -13.905 2.1746e-07 3.0444e-06
auto-mix 580.576 ± 5.004 557.994 ± 2.093 -22.582 ± 4.954 [-26.126, -19.038] -14.414 1.5941e-07 2.3911e-06
auto-pan 364.201 ± 3.055 355.188 ± 2.081 -9.013 ± 3.910 [-11.810, -6.216] -7.290 4.6128e-05 0.00041515
auto-volume 347.029 ± 2.698 335.713 ± 0.919 -11.315 ± 3.290 [-13.669, -8.962] -10.877 1.77e-06 2.124e-05
auto-width 361.653 ± 6.722 347.239 ± 0.973 -14.414 ± 6.691 [-19.200, -9.627] -6.812 7.7952e-05 0.00062362
auto-phase-mod 198.814 ± 1.948 196.938 ± 1.552 -1.877 ± 2.552 [-3.702, -0.051] -2.325 0.045086 0.22543

F8 bounded: exact tan vs constant-selection F3

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61057。生データ: filter-bounded-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 31.251 ± 0.432 31.363 ± 0.530 0.113 ± 0.615 [-0.327, 0.552] 0.579 0.57667 1
saw-bass 54.114 ± 0.695 51.225 ± 0.556 -2.888 ± 0.693 [-3.384, -2.392] -13.179 3.4529e-07 6.2152e-06
triangle-pluck 103.716 ± 1.068 105.167 ± 1.240 1.452 ± 1.396 [0.453, 2.450] 3.288 0.0094057 0.075245
square-lead 54.256 ± 0.470 52.538 ± 0.629 -1.717 ± 0.623 [-2.163, -1.272] -8.722 1.1024e-05 0.00016536
saw-chords 322.092 ± 2.929 316.085 ± 2.671 -6.007 ± 2.673 [-7.919, -4.095] -7.106 5.6294e-05 0.00073183
slow-pad 425.748 ± 3.913 414.476 ± 2.895 -11.272 ± 3.883 [-14.050, -8.494] -9.179 7.2634e-06 0.00011621
three-osc-keys 279.771 ± 2.422 281.406 ± 2.452 1.635 ± 1.754 [0.381, 2.890] 2.949 0.016253 0.11377
phase-mod-bell 166.722 ± 1.220 167.031 ± 2.160 0.309 ± 1.670 [-0.886, 1.503] 0.585 0.57318 1
soft-bass 84.378 ± 0.822 81.917 ± 0.854 -2.461 ± 0.980 [-3.162, -1.760] -7.944 2.3417e-05 0.00032784
hard-lead 69.315 ± 1.834 67.349 ± 0.794 -1.966 ± 2.157 [-3.509, -0.423] -2.883 0.018103 0.11377
idle-pad 126.252 ± 1.896 125.666 ± 2.676 -0.586 ± 3.280 [-2.933, 1.761] -0.565 0.58592 1
auto-cutoff 336.941 ± 5.421 330.477 ± 2.770 -6.464 ± 4.035 [-9.351, -3.578] -5.066 0.00067553 0.0074308
auto-resonance 383.248 ± 5.345 374.313 ± 3.843 -8.935 ± 4.991 [-12.505, -5.365] -5.661 0.00030912 0.0037094
auto-drive 581.898 ± 5.692 566.703 ± 5.566 -15.195 ± 4.872 [-18.680, -11.710] -9.864 4.0108e-06 6.8184e-05
auto-mix 584.187 ± 6.474 569.654 ± 5.317 -14.534 ± 2.686 [-16.455, -12.612] -17.113 3.5741e-08 6.7907e-07
auto-pan 369.710 ± 7.208 362.512 ± 4.041 -7.199 ± 8.498 [-13.278, -1.119] -2.679 0.025259 0.1263
auto-volume 351.517 ± 5.167 342.187 ± 2.690 -9.330 ± 6.169 [-13.743, -4.917] -4.783 0.00099722 0.0099722
auto-width 362.012 ± 6.589 355.263 ± 3.336 -6.749 ± 5.993 [-11.036, -2.462] -3.561 0.006106 0.054954
auto-phase-mod 201.071 ± 5.399 198.406 ± 2.236 -2.665 ± 4.746 [-6.060, 0.730] -1.776 0.10949 0.43796

F6 unified: validation vs F9

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61055。生データ: filter-validation-unified-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 30.907 ± 0.166 30.881 ± 0.193 -0.026 ± 0.257 [-0.209, 0.158] -0.315 0.75992 1
saw-bass 53.861 ± 2.230 54.408 ± 0.500 0.547 ± 1.900 [-0.813, 1.906] 0.910 0.38674 1
triangle-pluck 104.396 ± 1.695 104.566 ± 0.554 0.170 ± 1.985 [-1.250, 1.590] 0.270 0.79296 1
square-lead 53.676 ± 0.476 53.941 ± 0.279 0.266 ± 0.529 [-0.113, 0.644] 1.588 0.14676 1
saw-chords 319.578 ± 0.448 337.123 ± 3.672 17.545 ± 3.577 [14.986, 20.104] 15.510 8.4335e-08 1.3494e-06
slow-pad 428.959 ± 12.470 434.950 ± 0.811 5.991 ± 12.877 [-3.220, 15.203] 1.471 0.17528 1
three-osc-keys 280.401 ± 2.710 282.563 ± 1.306 2.163 ± 1.985 [0.743, 3.583] 3.445 0.0073293 0.073293
phase-mod-bell 165.310 ± 1.220 164.422 ± 0.743 -0.888 ± 1.495 [-1.957, 0.181] -1.878 0.093058 0.74447
soft-bass 83.822 ± 0.116 85.071 ± 0.360 1.249 ± 0.348 [1.000, 1.498] 11.347 1.2386e-06 1.8005e-05
hard-lead 68.180 ± 0.495 68.343 ± 0.093 0.163 ± 0.489 [-0.187, 0.513] 1.054 0.31952 1
idle-pad 145.892 ± 1.109 120.541 ± 0.996 -25.351 ± 1.675 [-26.549, -24.152] -47.862 3.8018e-12 7.2233e-11
auto-cutoff 336.625 ± 12.489 346.633 ± 1.448 10.009 ± 11.143 [2.037, 17.980] 2.840 0.019392 0.17453
auto-resonance 380.151 ± 2.394 385.854 ± 1.872 5.703 ± 3.265 [3.367, 8.038] 5.522 0.00036939 0.0040633
auto-drive 577.537 ± 2.276 600.450 ± 2.617 22.914 ± 3.764 [20.221, 25.607] 19.248 1.2726e-08 2.2907e-07
auto-mix 577.165 ± 1.027 601.363 ± 3.740 24.198 ± 4.009 [21.330, 27.066] 19.087 1.3706e-08 2.33e-07
auto-pan 365.145 ± 3.574 380.146 ± 6.392 15.001 ± 6.792 [10.143, 19.860] 6.985 6.4316e-05 0.00077179
auto-volume 345.643 ± 1.457 361.819 ± 4.085 16.175 ± 4.491 [12.962, 19.388] 11.389 1.2003e-06 1.8005e-05
auto-width 358.960 ± 4.132 371.728 ± 2.351 12.767 ± 5.488 [8.841, 16.693] 7.357 4.2964e-05 0.00055853
auto-phase-mod 196.714 ± 1.997 196.592 ± 2.495 -0.122 ± 2.980 [-2.254, 2.009] -0.130 0.89964 1

E3: cutoff recurrence vs combined 21db175

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61058。生データ: cutoff-root-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 22.948 ± 0.124 23.743 ± 0.289 0.795 ± 0.328 [0.561, 1.030] 7.666 3.1074e-05 0.00031074
saw-bass 45.067 ± 0.077 44.501 ± 0.170 -0.566 ± 0.167 [-0.685, -0.447] -10.739 1.971e-06 2.7594e-05
triangle-pluck 78.334 ± 0.219 81.069 ± 0.449 2.734 ± 0.507 [2.372, 3.097] 17.064 3.6647e-08 6.23e-07
square-lead 46.085 ± 0.079 47.153 ± 2.294 1.068 ± 2.302 [-0.579, 2.715] 1.467 0.17634 0.52902
saw-chords 264.881 ± 0.718 272.040 ± 1.488 7.160 ± 1.574 [6.033, 8.286] 14.381 1.6263e-07 2.602e-06
slow-pad 360.409 ± 0.421 365.713 ± 1.357 5.304 ± 1.451 [4.266, 6.342] 11.558 1.0596e-06 1.5894e-05
three-osc-keys 245.763 ± 1.709 250.215 ± 1.244 4.452 ± 2.253 [2.840, 6.063] 6.249 0.00014978 0.001348
phase-mod-bell 150.391 ± 0.372 153.740 ± 4.692 3.349 ± 4.773 [-0.065, 6.763] 2.219 0.053669 0.26835
soft-bass 71.228 ± 0.258 69.629 ± 0.154 -1.599 ± 0.286 [-1.804, -1.394] -17.678 2.6884e-08 5.108e-07
hard-lead 58.319 ± 0.204 58.549 ± 0.126 0.230 ± 0.270 [0.037, 0.423] 2.696 0.024573 0.14744
idle-pad 2.581 ± 0.146 2.574 ± 0.161 -0.007 ± 0.241 [-0.179, 0.165] -0.093 0.92767 0.94026
auto-cutoff 282.544 ± 13.926 285.903 ± 1.440 3.360 ± 14.091 [-6.720, 13.439] 0.754 0.47013 0.94026
auto-resonance 302.694 ± 2.856 308.289 ± 0.497 5.595 ± 2.995 [3.453, 7.738] 5.907 0.00022702 0.0018162
auto-drive 518.723 ± 0.974 521.866 ± 1.586 3.142 ± 2.119 [1.626, 4.658] 4.689 0.0011381 0.0079669
auto-mix 519.231 ± 1.460 521.304 ± 1.090 2.073 ± 0.697 [1.575, 2.571] 9.410 5.9197e-06 7.6956e-05
auto-pan 305.945 ± 1.021 312.778 ± 0.704 6.833 ± 1.247 [5.941, 7.725] 17.328 3.2044e-08 5.7679e-07
auto-volume 293.472 ± 0.980 300.927 ± 2.753 7.456 ± 2.820 [5.438, 9.473] 8.359 1.5558e-05 0.0001867
auto-width 299.744 ± 2.419 306.279 ± 1.138 6.535 ± 2.543 [4.715, 8.354] 8.125 1.9557e-05 0.00021512
auto-phase-mod 174.745 ± 2.760 176.231 ± 0.758 1.486 ± 2.407 [-0.236, 3.208] 1.952 0.082685 0.33074

E5: reciprocal scaling vs combined 21db175

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61059。生データ: cutoff-scale-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 22.992 ± 0.209 22.913 ± 0.119 -0.080 ± 0.258 [-0.264, 0.105] -0.974 0.35541 1
saw-bass 45.136 ± 0.291 45.330 ± 0.299 0.195 ± 0.054 [0.156, 0.233] 11.331 1.2531e-06 2.381e-05
triangle-pluck 78.171 ± 0.291 78.493 ± 1.001 0.321 ± 0.928 [-0.342, 0.985] 1.096 0.30165 1
square-lead 46.174 ± 0.144 46.161 ± 0.094 -0.014 ± 0.196 [-0.154, 0.127] -0.218 0.83194 1
saw-chords 265.650 ± 1.331 265.331 ± 0.498 -0.319 ± 1.420 [-1.335, 0.696] -0.711 0.49492 1
slow-pad 361.978 ± 2.599 362.367 ± 2.267 0.389 ± 3.346 [-2.005, 2.783] 0.368 0.72161 1
three-osc-keys 244.729 ± 0.694 243.797 ± 0.792 -0.932 ± 1.291 [-1.856, -0.009] -2.285 0.048192 0.72287
phase-mod-bell 150.684 ± 0.710 149.673 ± 0.264 -1.011 ± 0.720 [-1.526, -0.496] -4.441 0.0016218 0.02757
soft-bass 71.174 ± 0.184 71.487 ± 0.153 0.313 ± 0.264 [0.124, 0.502] 3.742 0.0046148 0.073836
hard-lead 58.397 ± 0.177 58.399 ± 0.409 0.003 ± 0.475 [-0.337, 0.343] 0.018 0.98632 1
idle-pad 3.447 ± 2.518 2.608 ± 0.144 -0.839 ± 2.592 [-2.693, 1.015] -1.024 0.33245 1
auto-cutoff 278.588 ± 1.234 279.300 ± 2.096 0.712 ± 2.379 [-0.989, 2.414] 0.947 0.36851 1
auto-resonance 301.819 ± 0.435 302.161 ± 0.567 0.342 ± 0.875 [-0.284, 0.968] 1.237 0.24745 1
auto-drive 518.414 ± 0.579 520.740 ± 0.932 2.326 ± 0.863 [1.708, 2.943] 8.519 1.3348e-05 0.00024027
auto-mix 519.443 ± 2.151 520.406 ± 1.179 0.963 ± 2.875 [-1.094, 3.020] 1.059 0.31711 1
auto-pan 306.260 ± 1.075 306.577 ± 1.840 0.316 ± 2.073 [-1.167, 1.799] 0.482 0.64105 1
auto-volume 293.728 ± 2.077 294.160 ± 1.451 0.432 ± 2.713 [-1.509, 2.373] 0.503 0.62673 1
auto-width 300.749 ± 4.854 300.019 ± 1.669 -0.730 ± 5.265 [-4.497, 3.036] -0.439 0.67125 1
auto-phase-mod 173.945 ± 0.891 174.480 ± 0.352 0.535 ± 0.989 [-0.172, 1.243] 1.711 0.12122 1

E5: degree-10 polynomial vs combined 21db175

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61060。生データ: cutoff-poly-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 22.928 ± 0.034 23.620 ± 0.134 0.692 ± 0.147 [0.587, 0.797] 14.936 1.1708e-07 2.1074e-06
saw-bass 45.772 ± 2.307 45.209 ± 0.079 -0.563 ± 2.308 [-2.214, 1.088] -0.771 0.46033 1
triangle-pluck 78.157 ± 0.234 78.914 ± 0.490 0.756 ± 0.579 [0.343, 1.170] 4.135 0.0025423 0.040677
square-lead 46.049 ± 0.088 46.230 ± 0.062 0.182 ± 0.108 [0.104, 0.259] 5.313 0.00048546 0.0082528
saw-chords 264.305 ± 0.556 264.886 ± 0.503 0.580 ± 0.470 [0.244, 0.917] 3.903 0.0036023 0.054035
slow-pad 360.114 ± 0.438 361.495 ± 4.102 1.382 ± 4.354 [-1.733, 4.497] 1.003 0.34192 1
three-osc-keys 244.596 ± 0.654 244.590 ± 0.707 -0.006 ± 0.825 [-0.596, 0.584] -0.022 0.98286 1
phase-mod-bell 150.761 ± 0.913 150.898 ± 0.359 0.138 ± 0.667 [-0.340, 0.615] 0.652 0.53048 1
soft-bass 71.132 ± 0.107 70.980 ± 0.076 -0.152 ± 0.143 [-0.254, -0.050] -3.362 0.0083679 0.10878
hard-lead 58.314 ± 0.107 58.526 ± 0.118 0.212 ± 0.176 [0.087, 0.338] 3.824 0.0040659 0.056923
idle-pad 2.647 ± 0.177 2.600 ± 0.160 -0.047 ± 0.232 [-0.213, 0.119] -0.640 0.5381 1
auto-cutoff 278.648 ± 1.326 278.967 ± 1.462 0.319 ± 2.132 [-1.207, 1.844] 0.473 0.64753 1
auto-resonance 302.732 ± 2.669 301.958 ± 0.451 -0.774 ± 2.669 [-2.683, 1.135] -0.917 0.38295 1
auto-drive 518.674 ± 0.734 519.962 ± 1.524 1.288 ± 1.841 [-0.029, 2.605] 2.212 0.054244 0.65092
auto-mix 518.541 ± 0.778 519.497 ± 1.207 0.956 ± 1.546 [-0.151, 2.062] 1.954 0.082427 0.9067
auto-pan 306.125 ± 2.981 305.766 ± 1.395 -0.360 ± 3.737 [-3.033, 2.313] -0.304 0.76777 1
auto-volume 293.908 ± 1.541 293.542 ± 0.345 -0.366 ± 1.471 [-1.418, 0.687] -0.786 0.45212 1
auto-width 298.995 ± 1.286 299.808 ± 0.953 0.813 ± 1.529 [-0.281, 1.907] 1.682 0.1269 1
auto-phase-mod 173.944 ± 0.606 176.787 ± 0.471 2.844 ± 0.511 [2.478, 3.209] 17.595 2.8021e-08 5.3241e-07

E5 initial: Hermite table vs combined 21db175

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61061。生データ: cutoff-table-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 23.144 ± 0.239 23.891 ± 0.321 0.747 ± 0.267 [0.556, 0.938] 8.833 9.9514e-06 0.00017913
saw-bass 45.328 ± 0.554 45.057 ± 0.417 -0.271 ± 0.349 [-0.521, -0.022] -2.460 0.036148 0.36653
triangle-pluck 78.659 ± 0.586 79.273 ± 0.834 0.614 ± 0.602 [0.183, 1.044] 3.225 0.010403 0.14564
square-lead 46.404 ± 0.559 46.622 ± 0.557 0.218 ± 0.224 [0.058, 0.378] 3.080 0.013132 0.17072
saw-chords 266.397 ± 2.275 266.019 ± 2.583 -0.378 ± 1.083 [-1.152, 0.396] -1.104 0.29819 1
slow-pad 362.157 ± 3.183 361.198 ± 2.759 -0.959 ± 1.364 [-1.934, 0.017] -2.223 0.053269 0.47942
three-osc-keys 250.943 ± 16.243 245.920 ± 2.188 -5.023 ± 15.035 [-15.779, 5.732] -1.057 0.31823 1
phase-mod-bell 151.165 ± 1.339 151.690 ± 1.465 0.525 ± 0.619 [0.082, 0.967] 2.682 0.025126 0.30151
soft-bass 71.552 ± 0.691 71.083 ± 0.674 -0.470 ± 0.258 [-0.654, -0.285] -5.752 0.00027577 0.0046881
hard-lead 58.655 ± 0.605 59.029 ± 0.746 0.374 ± 0.206 [0.227, 0.522] 5.733 0.00028228 0.0046881
idle-pad 2.628 ± 0.174 2.615 ± 0.149 -0.012 ± 0.253 [-0.193, 0.168] -0.155 0.88009 1
auto-cutoff 279.348 ± 2.186 280.108 ± 2.562 0.760 ± 1.602 [-0.386, 1.906] 1.500 0.16783 1
auto-resonance 303.336 ± 2.809 304.058 ± 3.699 0.722 ± 1.480 [-0.336, 1.781] 1.543 0.15716 1
auto-drive 522.045 ± 4.947 521.628 ± 5.274 -0.417 ± 3.048 [-2.597, 1.763] -0.433 0.67527 1
auto-mix 521.316 ± 4.365 522.193 ± 4.596 0.878 ± 2.473 [-0.891, 2.646] 1.122 0.29082 1
auto-pan 306.851 ± 2.969 308.090 ± 2.954 1.239 ± 0.944 [0.564, 1.914] 4.152 0.0024778 0.037167
auto-volume 294.915 ± 2.605 294.664 ± 2.656 -0.251 ± 1.975 [-1.663, 1.162] -0.401 0.69748 1
auto-width 300.531 ± 2.895 302.349 ± 3.268 1.818 ± 2.291 [0.179, 3.457] 2.510 0.033321 0.36653
auto-phase-mod 174.549 ± 1.597 178.114 ± 2.446 3.565 ± 1.043 [2.819, 4.311] 10.811 1.8632e-06 3.5401e-05

E6 initial: deferred events vs combined 21db175

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61062。生データ: envelope-events-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 23.056 ± 0.215 22.658 ± 0.205 -0.398 ± 0.258 [-0.583, -0.214] -4.886 0.00086379 0.0060465
saw-bass 45.010 ± 0.066 44.550 ± 0.198 -0.460 ± 0.156 [-0.571, -0.348] -9.319 6.4165e-06 7.6998e-05
triangle-pluck 78.279 ± 0.238 75.163 ± 0.291 -3.116 ± 0.403 [-3.404, -2.828] -24.478 1.5182e-09 2.8847e-08
square-lead 46.104 ± 0.071 45.557 ± 0.080 -0.547 ± 0.118 [-0.632, -0.462] -14.622 1.4076e-07 2.393e-06
saw-chords 265.194 ± 2.366 258.583 ± 0.806 -6.612 ± 2.726 [-8.562, -4.662] -7.670 3.0948e-05 0.00027853
slow-pad 361.820 ± 3.301 355.115 ± 3.238 -6.705 ± 5.058 [-10.323, -3.087] -4.192 0.002334 0.01167
three-osc-keys 245.948 ± 2.616 238.333 ± 2.219 -7.616 ± 1.904 [-8.978, -6.253] -12.648 4.9146e-07 6.389e-06
phase-mod-bell 150.815 ± 1.754 147.288 ± 0.686 -3.527 ± 1.886 [-4.876, -2.178] -5.914 0.0002251 0.0018008
soft-bass 71.141 ± 0.178 70.159 ± 0.055 -0.982 ± 0.176 [-1.108, -0.857] -17.687 2.676e-08 4.8168e-07
hard-lead 58.931 ± 2.037 57.709 ± 0.097 -1.222 ± 2.029 [-2.673, 0.229] -1.905 0.089206 0.17841
idle-pad 2.615 ± 0.175 2.559 ± 0.141 -0.056 ± 0.206 [-0.203, 0.091] -0.859 0.41242 0.41242
auto-cutoff 280.291 ± 5.185 271.612 ± 1.965 -8.679 ± 5.838 [-12.855, -4.503] -4.702 0.0011178 0.0067067
auto-resonance 302.393 ± 0.377 296.037 ± 1.724 -6.357 ± 1.488 [-7.421, -5.292] -13.509 2.7905e-07 4.4648e-06
auto-drive 519.303 ± 1.636 510.888 ± 0.983 -8.415 ± 1.998 [-9.844, -6.986] -13.319 3.1521e-07 4.7282e-06
auto-mix 519.091 ± 2.325 510.811 ± 1.668 -8.281 ± 2.969 [-10.405, -6.157] -8.820 1.0067e-05 0.00010067
auto-pan 307.245 ± 4.627 301.138 ± 3.577 -6.107 ± 6.174 [-10.524, -1.691] -3.128 0.012158 0.044259
auto-volume 293.085 ± 0.758 287.148 ± 1.178 -5.938 ± 1.444 [-6.970, -4.905] -13.004 3.8736e-07 5.423e-06
auto-width 301.143 ± 2.654 293.185 ± 1.073 -7.958 ± 2.759 [-9.932, -5.984] -9.120 7.6617e-06 8.4279e-05
auto-phase-mod 177.369 ± 6.890 170.662 ± 0.408 -6.707 ± 6.656 [-11.468, -1.946] -3.187 0.011065 0.044259

E8: absolute stage vs boundary-corrected 368a2a4

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61064。生データ: envelope-segment-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 22.905 ± 0.078 24.012 ± 0.119 1.107 ± 0.163 [0.990, 1.223] 21.435 4.9229e-09 9.3534e-08
saw-bass 45.126 ± 0.712 46.732 ± 0.212 1.607 ± 0.680 [1.120, 2.093] 7.467 3.825e-05 0.00049726
triangle-pluck 78.207 ± 0.326 81.224 ± 0.182 3.017 ± 0.380 [2.745, 3.289] 25.109 1.2114e-09 2.4227e-08
square-lead 46.101 ± 0.173 46.641 ± 0.108 0.540 ± 0.164 [0.423, 0.658] 10.415 2.5486e-06 3.8228e-05
saw-chords 264.395 ± 0.540 267.391 ± 0.626 2.996 ± 0.676 [2.513, 3.479] 14.024 2.0206e-07 3.5507e-06
slow-pad 360.093 ± 0.573 366.182 ± 0.676 6.089 ± 0.586 [5.669, 6.508] 32.838 1.1085e-10 2.5497e-09
three-osc-keys 244.763 ± 0.558 250.484 ± 0.547 5.722 ± 0.700 [5.221, 6.223] 25.837 9.3954e-10 1.973e-08
phase-mod-bell 149.731 ± 0.433 154.648 ± 0.526 4.917 ± 0.563 [4.514, 5.320] 27.623 5.1837e-10 1.1404e-08
soft-bass 71.001 ± 0.144 70.972 ± 0.079 -0.029 ± 0.142 [-0.131, 0.072] -0.652 0.53091 1
hard-lead 59.718 ± 4.757 58.024 ± 0.081 -1.694 ± 4.790 [-5.121, 1.733] -1.118 0.29235 1
idle-pad 2.456 ± 0.059 2.623 ± 0.164 0.167 ± 0.185 [0.034, 0.299] 2.844 0.01929 0.17361
auto-cutoff 279.417 ± 1.712 281.863 ± 1.916 2.446 ± 2.902 [0.370, 4.522] 2.666 0.025795 0.20636
auto-resonance 303.004 ± 2.461 304.970 ± 0.912 1.966 ± 2.659 [0.064, 3.868] 2.339 0.044104 0.29336
auto-drive 519.131 ± 4.821 520.317 ± 2.756 1.186 ± 5.926 [-3.053, 5.426] 0.633 0.54241 1
auto-mix 517.314 ± 0.588 518.808 ± 0.622 1.494 ± 0.919 [0.837, 2.151] 5.141 0.00061055 0.0061055
auto-pan 307.044 ± 3.057 309.427 ± 1.117 2.383 ± 3.179 [0.108, 4.657] 2.370 0.041908 0.29336
auto-volume 293.219 ± 0.624 296.232 ± 0.802 3.013 ± 0.829 [2.420, 3.606] 11.497 1.1083e-06 1.7732e-05
auto-width 299.429 ± 0.884 303.260 ± 1.003 3.831 ± 0.861 [3.215, 4.447] 14.063 1.9726e-07 3.5507e-06
auto-phase-mod 174.921 ± 0.672 180.312 ± 1.631 5.392 ± 1.779 [4.119, 6.664] 9.585 5.0858e-06 7.1201e-05
extra-auto-detune 608.499 ± 1.152 612.170 ± 1.143 3.671 ± 2.003 [2.238, 5.104] 5.794 0.00026128 0.0031354
extra-auto-amp-sustain 431.810 ± 4.708 432.228 ± 1.445 0.418 ± 5.295 [-3.370, 4.206] 0.250 0.80837 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 325.738 ± 5.260 325.129 ± 0.508 -0.608 ± 5.092 [-4.251, 3.034] -0.378 0.71436 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 334.092 ± 1.132 336.810 ± 1.046 2.718 ± 1.492 [1.651, 3.785] 5.762 0.00027227 0.0031354

F8 bounded: exact tan added to combined 21db175

20ブロック、自由度19、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61063。生データ: filter-bounded-root-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 23.260 ± 0.688 23.474 ± 0.825 0.215 ± 1.086 [-0.294, 0.723] 0.883 0.38802 0.77604
saw-bass 45.148 ± 0.321 42.877 ± 0.334 -2.271 ± 0.406 [-2.461, -2.080] -24.998 5.3347e-16 9.0691e-15
triangle-pluck 78.635 ± 0.677 77.191 ± 0.350 -1.443 ± 0.605 [-1.726, -1.160] -10.677 1.814e-09 1.4512e-08
square-lead 46.320 ± 0.289 43.869 ± 0.354 -2.452 ± 0.282 [-2.584, -2.320] -38.884 1.4134e-19 2.8269e-18
saw-chords 264.905 ± 1.215 254.413 ± 1.343 -10.492 ± 0.975 [-10.949, -10.036] -48.106 2.5766e-21 5.9262e-20
slow-pad 362.120 ± 2.054 347.398 ± 1.792 -14.722 ± 2.005 [-15.661, -13.784] -32.845 3.3371e-18 6.3406e-17
three-osc-keys 245.853 ± 1.923 242.768 ± 2.275 -3.085 ± 3.003 [-4.491, -1.680] -4.594 0.00019809 0.0011885
phase-mod-bell 150.707 ± 0.892 151.540 ± 0.630 0.833 ± 0.899 [0.413, 1.254] 4.146 0.00054834 0.0027417
soft-bass 71.391 ± 0.396 68.898 ± 0.366 -2.493 ± 0.455 [-2.706, -2.279] -24.482 7.8397e-16 1.2543e-14
hard-lead 58.612 ± 0.316 56.081 ± 0.306 -2.531 ± 0.415 [-2.725, -2.337] -27.280 1.0587e-16 1.9057e-15
idle-pad 2.624 ± 0.158 2.525 ± 0.134 -0.099 ± 0.216 [-0.200, 0.002] -2.052 0.054159 0.21664
auto-cutoff 279.718 ± 1.622 268.210 ± 1.730 -11.508 ± 2.106 [-12.494, -10.523] -24.437 8.109e-16 1.2543e-14
auto-resonance 303.094 ± 1.527 289.318 ± 1.610 -13.776 ± 1.549 [-14.501, -13.051] -39.772 9.2488e-20 1.9423e-18
auto-drive 519.368 ± 2.723 498.601 ± 2.098 -20.767 ± 2.223 [-21.807, -19.727] -41.785 3.6567e-20 8.0447e-19
auto-mix 519.916 ± 2.568 499.402 ± 5.421 -20.514 ± 5.781 [-23.219, -17.808] -15.869 2.0354e-12 2.0354e-11
auto-pan 306.676 ± 1.820 296.926 ± 2.317 -9.750 ± 2.648 [-10.989, -8.510] -16.464 1.058e-12 1.2696e-11
auto-volume 294.532 ± 1.532 283.685 ± 2.620 -10.847 ± 2.543 [-12.037, -9.657] -19.075 7.5208e-14 9.7771e-13
auto-width 301.322 ± 2.990 291.290 ± 1.785 -10.032 ± 2.088 [-11.009, -9.055] -21.492 8.5779e-15 1.2009e-13
auto-phase-mod 176.219 ± 1.112 175.900 ± 0.843 -0.319 ± 1.224 [-0.892, 0.254] -1.167 0.25784 0.77351
extra-auto-detune 610.740 ± 4.447 611.333 ± 3.939 0.593 ± 5.085 [-1.787, 2.972] 0.521 0.60826 0.77604
extra-auto-amp-sustain 432.291 ± 2.694 421.071 ± 2.525 -11.220 ± 3.099 [-12.670, -9.769] -16.189 1.4277e-12 1.5705e-11
extra-auto-osc-volume 322.992 ± 1.435 314.077 ± 3.639 -8.915 ± 3.443 [-10.526, -7.304] -11.581 4.7109e-10 4.2398e-09
extra-auto-osc-tune 335.190 ± 2.294 325.413 ± 3.932 -9.777 ± 4.156 [-11.722, -7.832] -10.519 2.3139e-09 1.6198e-08

E7: setting delivery vs combined 21db175

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61065。生データ: filter-config-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 22.931 ± 0.147 23.093 ± 0.099 0.162 ± 0.166 [0.043, 0.281] 3.081 0.013127 0.065635
saw-bass 45.015 ± 0.207 59.550 ± 0.190 14.535 ± 0.268 [14.343, 14.727] 171.459 3.9709e-17 8.7359e-16
triangle-pluck 78.246 ± 0.505 73.536 ± 0.363 -4.710 ± 0.743 [-5.241, -4.178] -20.047 8.8921e-09 1.3338e-07
square-lead 46.121 ± 0.097 45.266 ± 0.173 -0.855 ± 0.151 [-0.963, -0.747] -17.863 2.4534e-08 3.1894e-07
saw-chords 264.512 ± 0.502 253.640 ± 0.758 -10.872 ± 0.900 [-11.516, -10.228] -38.182 2.8785e-11 5.1813e-10
slow-pad 361.556 ± 2.525 386.943 ± 0.409 25.387 ± 2.607 [23.522, 27.252] 30.795 1.9666e-10 3.2135e-09
three-osc-keys 244.645 ± 1.065 235.009 ± 0.755 -9.636 ± 0.756 [-10.177, -9.096] -40.317 1.7686e-11 3.3603e-10
phase-mod-bell 150.110 ± 0.148 150.676 ± 1.365 0.566 ± 1.394 [-0.431, 1.563] 1.285 0.231 0.46199
soft-bass 71.131 ± 0.246 86.262 ± 0.183 15.131 ± 0.277 [14.933, 15.329] 172.787 3.7045e-17 8.5204e-16
hard-lead 58.994 ± 1.976 57.440 ± 0.273 -1.554 ± 2.057 [-3.025, -0.083] -2.390 0.040582 0.16233
idle-pad 2.542 ± 0.145 2.657 ± 0.138 0.115 ± 0.192 [-0.023, 0.253] 1.891 0.091209 0.27363
auto-cutoff 278.575 ± 1.084 269.785 ± 5.430 -8.790 ± 5.644 [-12.828, -4.753] -4.925 0.00081909 0.0057337
auto-resonance 304.359 ± 5.410 400.336 ± 19.548 95.977 ± 21.124 [80.865, 111.088] 14.368 1.6387e-07 1.6387e-06
auto-drive 518.263 ± 0.612 507.951 ± 0.534 -10.311 ± 0.561 [-10.713, -9.910] -58.131 6.6448e-13 1.3954e-11
auto-mix 517.897 ± 1.288 507.852 ± 1.159 -10.046 ± 1.679 [-11.247, -8.844] -18.917 1.4826e-08 2.0756e-07
auto-pan 305.879 ± 1.465 295.750 ± 1.157 -10.129 ± 1.984 [-11.549, -8.710] -16.143 5.953e-08 6.5483e-07
auto-volume 293.398 ± 0.793 281.983 ± 0.596 -11.415 ± 1.167 [-12.250, -10.580] -30.932 1.8903e-10 3.2135e-09
auto-width 300.485 ± 3.161 290.545 ± 5.173 -9.940 ± 6.534 [-14.614, -5.266] -4.811 0.00095924 0.0057554
auto-phase-mod 175.587 ± 1.414 176.143 ± 1.656 0.556 ± 2.366 [-1.136, 2.249] 0.743 0.47615 0.47615
extra-auto-detune 612.365 ± 6.503 600.002 ± 2.075 -12.363 ± 6.192 [-16.793, -7.934] -6.314 0.0001387 0.0011096
extra-auto-amp-sustain 431.527 ± 1.706 422.962 ± 3.817 -8.565 ± 2.496 [-10.350, -6.779] -10.852 1.804e-06 1.6236e-05
extra-auto-osc-volume 322.373 ± 1.081 313.292 ± 1.080 -9.081 ± 1.739 [-10.325, -7.837] -16.512 4.8854e-08 5.8625e-07
extra-auto-osc-tune 333.632 ± 0.498 324.261 ± 0.504 -9.371 ± 0.658 [-9.842, -8.900] -45.029 6.5698e-12 1.314e-10

E8: signed cast vs absolute-stage 762a59f

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61066。生データ: envelope-cast-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 24.350 ± 0.729 25.915 ± 0.178 1.565 ± 0.634 [1.112, 2.019] 7.804 2.6964e-05 0.00024268
saw-bass 46.799 ± 0.272 62.755 ± 1.209 15.956 ± 1.321 [15.011, 16.901] 38.208 2.8612e-11 6.0086e-10
triangle-pluck 81.985 ± 1.731 81.542 ± 0.745 -0.443 ± 2.176 [-1.999, 1.114] -0.644 0.53588 1
square-lead 46.812 ± 0.196 52.711 ± 0.345 5.900 ± 0.435 [5.589, 6.211] 42.918 1.0104e-11 2.2228e-10
saw-chords 268.292 ± 1.463 275.634 ± 0.644 7.342 ± 1.501 [6.268, 8.416] 15.470 8.6247e-08 1.4559e-06
slow-pad 366.940 ± 2.013 402.078 ± 2.403 35.138 ± 0.672 [34.657, 35.618] 165.373 5.4967e-17 1.2642e-15
three-osc-keys 251.115 ± 1.029 250.871 ± 1.445 -0.244 ± 0.945 [-0.921, 0.432] -0.817 0.4348 1
phase-mod-bell 155.607 ± 2.723 155.985 ± 3.719 0.378 ± 1.339 [-0.580, 1.336] 0.892 0.39542 1
soft-bass 71.405 ± 0.492 73.912 ± 0.487 2.506 ± 0.795 [1.938, 3.075] 9.972 3.6639e-06 4.0303e-05
hard-lead 58.168 ± 0.129 63.531 ± 0.613 5.364 ± 0.600 [4.934, 5.793] 28.262 4.2285e-10 8.457e-09
idle-pad 2.635 ± 0.124 2.626 ± 0.161 -0.008 ± 0.152 [-0.118, 0.101] -0.175 0.86526 1
auto-cutoff 281.871 ± 1.871 291.177 ± 2.390 9.306 ± 2.252 [7.694, 10.917] 13.065 3.7212e-07 4.8376e-06
auto-resonance 305.929 ± 2.017 313.298 ± 1.893 7.368 ± 1.682 [6.165, 8.572] 13.852 2.2482e-07 3.1474e-06
auto-drive 521.669 ± 3.238 523.009 ± 4.507 1.340 ± 5.010 [-2.244, 4.924] 0.846 0.41951 1
auto-mix 519.613 ± 0.957 519.716 ± 0.471 0.103 ± 1.284 [-0.816, 1.021] 0.253 0.80624 1
auto-pan 308.438 ± 0.918 317.837 ± 1.005 9.400 ± 1.487 [8.336, 10.463] 19.988 9.129e-09 1.7345e-07
auto-volume 296.529 ± 1.994 304.911 ± 0.417 8.382 ± 2.180 [6.822, 9.942] 12.157 6.8927e-07 8.2713e-06
auto-width 303.144 ± 1.280 311.574 ± 1.245 8.430 ± 1.511 [7.349, 9.511] 17.638 2.7426e-08 4.9367e-07
auto-phase-mod 179.903 ± 0.959 179.733 ± 1.453 -0.170 ± 1.767 [-1.434, 1.094] -0.304 0.76775 1
extra-auto-detune 613.565 ± 2.080 620.525 ± 2.286 6.960 ± 3.396 [4.531, 9.390] 6.481 0.00011391 0.00091131
extra-auto-amp-sustain 432.252 ± 1.832 443.410 ± 3.808 11.158 ± 4.036 [8.271, 14.045] 8.742 1.0826e-05 0.00010826
extra-auto-osc-volume 325.407 ± 1.745 334.253 ± 0.556 8.846 ± 1.807 [7.554, 10.139] 15.483 8.5644e-08 1.4559e-06
extra-auto-osc-tune 338.687 ± 2.443 346.774 ± 0.996 8.087 ± 1.675 [6.889, 9.285] 15.272 9.6503e-08 1.4559e-06

E8: inline update vs absolute-stage 762a59f

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61067。生データ: envelope-inline-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 24.136 ± 0.187 23.694 ± 0.057 -0.443 ± 0.191 [-0.579, -0.306] -7.328 4.4296e-05 0.00088592
saw-bass 46.811 ± 0.316 46.552 ± 0.168 -0.259 ± 0.247 [-0.435, -0.082] -3.313 0.0090341 0.15358
triangle-pluck 81.565 ± 0.681 80.270 ± 1.564 -1.296 ± 1.836 [-2.609, 0.018] -2.232 0.052539 0.42998
square-lead 46.879 ± 0.374 46.558 ± 0.190 -0.321 ± 0.340 [-0.564, -0.078] -2.985 0.015323 0.21452
saw-chords 267.909 ± 2.337 266.190 ± 1.761 -1.718 ± 2.308 [-3.369, -0.067] -2.354 0.042998 0.42998
slow-pad 367.006 ± 2.080 366.091 ± 3.807 -0.915 ± 4.779 [-4.333, 2.503] -0.606 0.5598 1
three-osc-keys 251.058 ± 0.975 244.411 ± 0.972 -6.647 ± 1.491 [-7.713, -5.581] -14.100 1.928e-07 4.2417e-06
phase-mod-bell 155.013 ± 0.633 151.935 ± 0.484 -3.078 ± 0.603 [-3.510, -2.647] -16.149 5.9343e-08 1.3649e-06
soft-bass 71.264 ± 0.504 71.910 ± 2.169 0.647 ± 2.255 [-0.966, 2.260] 0.907 0.38803 1
hard-lead 58.063 ± 0.100 58.287 ± 0.162 0.224 ± 0.134 [0.129, 0.320] 5.308 0.00048864 0.0092841
idle-pad 2.575 ± 0.194 2.555 ± 0.171 -0.020 ± 0.248 [-0.197, 0.158] -0.250 0.80817 1
auto-cutoff 282.069 ± 1.426 280.140 ± 2.037 -1.928 ± 2.482 [-3.704, -0.152] -2.456 0.036395 0.40034
auto-resonance 305.097 ± 0.941 303.382 ± 1.844 -1.716 ± 1.748 [-2.966, -0.465] -3.103 0.012662 0.2026
auto-drive 520.838 ± 2.772 519.232 ± 1.685 -1.606 ± 2.913 [-3.690, 0.477] -1.744 0.11516 0.76614
auto-mix 519.207 ± 0.649 518.958 ± 2.061 -0.248 ± 1.972 [-1.659, 1.162] -0.398 0.69978 1
auto-pan 309.682 ± 2.642 307.408 ± 0.929 -2.275 ± 2.613 [-4.144, -0.405] -2.753 0.022381 0.29095
auto-volume 296.675 ± 0.652 295.407 ± 1.981 -1.269 ± 2.439 [-3.014, 0.476] -1.645 0.13445 0.76614
auto-width 303.903 ± 1.489 301.143 ± 1.566 -2.760 ± 2.337 [-4.432, -1.088] -3.734 0.0046706 0.08407
auto-phase-mod 179.409 ± 0.471 176.425 ± 0.538 -2.984 ± 0.857 [-3.597, -2.371] -11.013 1.5939e-06 3.3472e-05
extra-auto-detune 615.622 ± 8.518 610.745 ± 1.811 -4.877 ± 8.682 [-11.088, 1.335] -1.776 0.10945 0.76614
extra-auto-amp-sustain 431.663 ± 0.900 430.203 ± 1.685 -1.460 ± 1.720 [-2.691, -0.230] -2.684 0.025023 0.30028
extra-auto-osc-volume 325.137 ± 1.177 324.074 ± 1.094 -1.063 ± 1.467 [-2.112, -0.013] -2.290 0.047746 0.42998
extra-auto-osc-tune 337.694 ± 1.878 335.358 ± 1.054 -2.336 ± 2.380 [-4.039, -0.633] -3.103 0.012664 0.2026

F11: bypass reset vs combined 21db175

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61068。生データ: filter-bypass-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 22.932 ± 0.095 23.000 ± 0.285 0.068 ± 0.222 [-0.091, 0.227] 0.971 0.35706 1
saw-bass 45.582 ± 1.107 45.169 ± 0.180 -0.413 ± 1.190 [-1.264, 0.438] -1.098 0.30086 1
triangle-pluck 78.880 ± 2.000 78.259 ± 0.546 -0.622 ± 2.105 [-2.128, 0.884] -0.934 0.3747 1
square-lead 46.271 ± 0.552 46.136 ± 0.189 -0.135 ± 0.591 [-0.558, 0.288] -0.724 0.48758 1
saw-chords 265.154 ± 1.072 264.539 ± 0.861 -0.615 ± 0.799 [-1.187, -0.044] -2.435 0.037699 0.56549
slow-pad 360.563 ± 1.762 361.208 ± 1.179 0.644 ± 2.117 [-0.870, 2.159] 0.963 0.36091 1
three-osc-keys 244.752 ± 0.681 244.089 ± 0.871 -0.663 ± 1.022 [-1.394, 0.068] -2.051 0.070502 0.98703
phase-mod-bell 150.251 ± 0.252 148.344 ± 0.540 -1.907 ± 0.470 [-2.244, -1.571] -12.821 4.3736e-07 8.3098e-06
soft-bass 71.145 ± 0.177 71.219 ± 0.265 0.074 ± 0.195 [-0.066, 0.213] 1.195 0.26272 1
hard-lead 58.296 ± 0.242 58.292 ± 0.113 -0.004 ± 0.252 [-0.185, 0.176] -0.055 0.95772 1
idle-pad 2.530 ± 0.158 2.616 ± 0.173 0.086 ± 0.248 [-0.092, 0.263] 1.093 0.3028 1
auto-cutoff 278.213 ± 0.966 278.395 ± 1.051 0.182 ± 1.517 [-0.903, 1.267] 0.380 0.71297 1
auto-resonance 302.436 ± 1.215 301.548 ± 1.476 -0.888 ± 1.827 [-2.195, 0.419] -1.537 0.15866 1
auto-drive 519.481 ± 1.975 521.968 ± 1.667 2.487 ± 1.999 [1.057, 3.918] 3.934 0.0034382 0.061888
auto-mix 518.626 ± 1.539 521.476 ± 2.795 2.850 ± 3.049 [0.669, 5.031] 2.956 0.016072 0.27322
auto-pan 306.965 ± 4.832 305.509 ± 1.187 -1.456 ± 5.061 [-5.076, 2.165] -0.910 0.38677 1
auto-volume 293.263 ± 0.509 293.633 ± 0.552 0.371 ± 0.645 [-0.091, 0.832] 1.817 0.1026 1
auto-width 299.596 ± 1.117 299.283 ± 0.819 -0.313 ± 1.131 [-1.122, 0.497] -0.874 0.40475 1
auto-phase-mod 174.203 ± 1.420 172.898 ± 0.855 -1.305 ± 1.637 [-2.476, -0.134] -2.521 0.032727 0.52363

E9: scalar path control vs E8 c11dcc2

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61069。生データ: cutoff-envelope-bulk-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 21.304 ± 0.121 21.220 ± 0.102 -0.083 ± 0.180 [-0.212, 0.045] -1.464 0.17719 1
saw-bass 43.991 ± 0.949 43.758 ± 0.135 -0.233 ± 1.018 [-0.960, 0.495] -0.723 0.48809 1
triangle-pluck 64.014 ± 0.144 65.352 ± 2.572 1.338 ± 2.555 [-0.490, 3.166] 1.656 0.13206 1
square-lead 44.597 ± 1.581 44.098 ± 0.097 -0.499 ± 1.596 [-1.641, 0.643] -0.988 0.34877 1
saw-chords 232.279 ± 1.935 232.596 ± 0.900 0.316 ± 1.665 [-0.875, 1.507] 0.600 0.56308 1
slow-pad 334.206 ± 0.401 334.612 ± 1.119 0.406 ± 1.050 [-0.345, 1.158] 1.223 0.25233 1
three-osc-keys 209.951 ± 0.567 209.708 ± 1.015 -0.243 ± 1.121 [-1.045, 0.559] -0.686 0.51014 1
phase-mod-bell 135.168 ± 0.283 135.070 ± 0.311 -0.098 ± 0.485 [-0.445, 0.249] -0.638 0.53949 1
soft-bass 67.788 ± 0.187 67.751 ± 0.121 -0.038 ± 0.143 [-0.140, 0.065] -0.834 0.42603 1
hard-lead 54.970 ± 0.112 55.028 ± 0.219 0.058 ± 0.269 [-0.134, 0.250] 0.682 0.51236 1
idle-pad 2.559 ± 0.165 2.484 ± 0.132 -0.076 ± 0.235 [-0.244, 0.092] -1.018 0.33508 1
auto-cutoff 243.402 ± 0.744 245.453 ± 3.077 2.051 ± 3.442 [-0.411, 4.514] 1.884 0.092149 1
auto-resonance 264.103 ± 1.834 264.365 ± 2.789 0.261 ± 3.823 [-2.473, 2.996] 0.216 0.83366 1
auto-drive 483.778 ± 2.799 483.205 ± 0.700 -0.572 ± 2.757 [-2.544, 1.400] -0.657 0.52792 1
auto-mix 481.868 ± 0.626 481.926 ± 0.592 0.058 ± 0.863 [-0.560, 0.675] 0.212 0.83715 1
auto-pan 273.537 ± 1.904 272.949 ± 0.752 -0.587 ± 2.197 [-2.158, 0.984] -0.845 0.4199 1
auto-volume 259.829 ± 0.788 260.475 ± 2.778 0.646 ± 2.379 [-1.056, 2.348] 0.859 0.41278 1
auto-width 267.065 ± 0.820 268.401 ± 2.091 1.336 ± 2.268 [-0.287, 2.959] 1.862 0.095475 1
auto-phase-mod 159.925 ± 0.978 160.687 ± 2.473 0.762 ± 2.906 [-1.317, 2.841] 0.829 0.4284 1
extra-auto-detune 534.984 ± 3.248 534.137 ± 1.080 -0.847 ± 3.865 [-3.612, 1.918] -0.693 0.50585 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 396.635 ± 0.892 396.685 ± 0.814 0.049 ± 1.330 [-0.902, 1.000] 0.117 0.90959 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 294.091 ± 0.903 293.580 ± 0.339 -0.511 ± 1.000 [-1.226, 0.204] -1.617 0.14044 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 303.269 ± 0.370 303.061 ± 0.947 -0.208 ± 0.950 [-0.888, 0.472] -0.693 0.50597 1

E9: series advance vs E8 c11dcc2

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61071。生データ: cutoff-envelope-bulk-series-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 16.488 ± 0.321 14.582 ± 0.200 -1.905 ± 0.412 [-2.200, -1.610] -14.609 1.4188e-07 2.9794e-06
saw-bass 35.331 ± 0.178 35.516 ± 0.288 0.185 ± 0.347 [-0.063, 0.433] 1.685 0.12622 1
triangle-pluck 56.081 ± 0.377 54.749 ± 0.321 -1.332 ± 0.139 [-1.431, -1.233] -30.416 2.1968e-10 4.9355e-09
square-lead 33.883 ± 0.297 32.963 ± 0.041 -0.920 ± 0.264 [-1.109, -0.732] -11.028 1.5753e-06 3.1505e-05
saw-chords 188.076 ± 0.269 183.744 ± 0.303 -4.332 ± 0.449 [-4.654, -4.011] -30.496 2.1459e-10 4.9355e-09
slow-pad 282.716 ± 1.354 283.033 ± 0.471 0.317 ± 1.614 [-0.838, 1.472] 0.621 0.54974 1
three-osc-keys 186.162 ± 1.236 181.071 ± 0.511 -5.091 ± 1.483 [-6.152, -4.031] -10.858 1.7958e-06 3.412e-05
phase-mod-bell 112.898 ± 0.210 108.517 ± 2.035 -4.380 ± 1.976 [-5.794, -2.967] -7.010 6.2522e-05 0.0010629
soft-bass 44.800 ± 0.240 45.007 ± 0.229 0.208 ± 0.128 [0.116, 0.300] 5.116 0.00063139 0.0094709
hard-lead 39.640 ± 0.433 38.899 ± 0.238 -0.741 ± 0.516 [-1.110, -0.372] -4.544 0.0013978 0.019569
idle-pad 0.966 ± 0.005 0.966 ± 0.006 -0.000 ± 0.005 [-0.004, 0.004] -0.069 0.94634 1
auto-cutoff 243.491 ± 1.495 245.172 ± 3.879 1.681 ± 4.184 [-1.312, 4.674] 1.270 0.23586 1
auto-resonance 262.532 ± 1.599 263.355 ± 1.441 0.823 ± 2.351 [-0.859, 2.505] 1.107 0.29711 1
auto-drive 488.284 ± 2.208 482.254 ± 0.824 -6.030 ± 2.414 [-7.757, -4.303] -7.899 2.4503e-05 0.00044105
auto-mix 486.149 ± 0.374 481.947 ± 2.069 -4.202 ± 2.024 [-5.650, -2.754] -6.565 0.00010334 0.0016534
auto-pan 273.033 ± 2.821 275.714 ± 5.457 2.681 ± 5.436 [-1.207, 6.570] 1.560 0.15323 1
auto-volume 258.793 ± 0.370 259.354 ± 0.544 0.561 ± 0.677 [0.077, 1.046] 2.620 0.02779 0.30569
auto-width 266.828 ± 2.416 266.238 ± 0.319 -0.589 ± 2.598 [-2.447, 1.269] -0.717 0.49149 1
auto-phase-mod 163.061 ± 1.301 160.503 ± 1.039 -2.558 ± 2.012 [-3.998, -1.119] -4.021 0.0030156 0.039203
extra-auto-detune 537.254 ± 2.357 538.704 ± 7.248 1.449 ± 8.509 [-4.638, 7.537] 0.539 0.60319 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 397.407 ± 1.224 397.908 ± 1.584 0.501 ± 1.368 [-0.477, 1.480] 1.159 0.27637 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 293.616 ± 1.109 294.671 ± 0.861 1.055 ± 1.593 [-0.084, 2.194] 2.095 0.065666 0.65666
extra-auto-osc-tune 303.485 ± 0.752 304.823 ± 1.458 1.338 ± 1.363 [0.363, 2.314] 3.104 0.012639 0.15166

F11: bypass reset vs root 0f73c89

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 61070。生データ: filter-bypass-root-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 16.323 ± 0.124 14.261 ± 0.129 -2.062 ± 0.186 [-2.195, -1.929] -35.088 6.1305e-11 1.1035e-09
saw-bass 35.366 ± 0.159 35.415 ± 0.313 0.049 ± 0.169 [-0.072, 0.170] 0.920 0.38148 1
triangle-pluck 56.084 ± 0.335 56.154 ± 0.306 0.070 ± 0.319 [-0.158, 0.298] 0.693 0.50592 1
square-lead 33.784 ± 0.080 34.116 ± 0.576 0.332 ± 0.590 [-0.090, 0.754] 1.781 0.10863 1
saw-chords 188.310 ± 0.556 188.239 ± 0.276 -0.071 ± 0.436 [-0.382, 0.241] -0.512 0.62099 1
slow-pad 283.121 ± 2.339 282.250 ± 0.433 -0.871 ± 2.391 [-2.582, 0.839] -1.152 0.27895 1
three-osc-keys 185.940 ± 1.369 185.449 ± 0.326 -0.491 ± 1.422 [-1.508, 0.526] -1.092 0.30311 1
phase-mod-bell 112.965 ± 0.350 106.131 ± 0.144 -6.834 ± 0.401 [-7.121, -6.547] -53.869 1.3163e-12 2.501e-11
soft-bass 44.833 ± 0.246 44.925 ± 0.256 0.092 ± 0.345 [-0.155, 0.338] 0.842 0.42135 1
hard-lead 39.480 ± 0.107 40.062 ± 1.282 0.583 ± 1.278 [-0.331, 1.497] 1.443 0.18297 1
idle-pad 0.968 ± 0.010 0.966 ± 0.011 -0.002 ± 0.014 [-0.013, 0.008] -0.518 0.61712 1
auto-cutoff 243.129 ± 0.735 243.533 ± 0.899 0.403 ± 1.353 [-0.564, 1.371] 0.943 0.37025 1
auto-resonance 262.454 ± 0.550 263.579 ± 2.036 1.126 ± 2.054 [-0.343, 2.595] 1.733 0.11709 1
auto-drive 484.420 ± 2.012 483.949 ± 0.489 -0.470 ± 2.226 [-2.063, 1.122] -0.668 0.52071 1
auto-mix 483.407 ± 2.626 482.623 ± 0.378 -0.784 ± 2.567 [-2.620, 1.052] -0.966 0.35934 1
auto-pan 272.739 ± 0.894 272.938 ± 1.353 0.198 ± 1.762 [-1.062, 1.459] 0.356 0.72997 1
auto-volume 259.111 ± 0.559 259.309 ± 0.434 0.198 ± 0.675 [-0.285, 0.681] 0.927 0.37803 1
auto-width 266.269 ± 1.354 267.046 ± 3.109 0.776 ± 3.502 [-1.729, 3.282] 0.701 0.50103 1
auto-phase-mod 161.953 ± 1.069 155.925 ± 0.821 -6.028 ± 1.549 [-7.136, -4.920] -12.306 6.2107e-07 1.0558e-05

F12: fixed-filter series vs 0699d82

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61072。生データ: filter-series-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 16.408 ± 0.329 13.286 ± 0.152 -3.122 ± 0.329 [-3.357, -2.887] -30.013 2.474e-10 4.4532e-09
saw-bass 35.397 ± 0.205 35.431 ± 0.263 0.034 ± 0.181 [-0.095, 0.164] 0.601 0.56241 1
triangle-pluck 56.141 ± 0.348 64.927 ± 0.389 8.786 ± 0.247 [8.609, 8.963] 112.488 1.7605e-15 4.0492e-14
square-lead 33.845 ± 0.237 30.006 ± 0.307 -3.839 ± 0.405 [-4.129, -3.549] -29.947 2.5231e-10 4.4532e-09
saw-chords 188.199 ± 0.519 192.052 ± 0.270 3.853 ± 0.558 [3.453, 4.252] 21.827 4.1942e-09 6.2914e-08
slow-pad 282.247 ± 0.675 282.122 ± 0.858 -0.124 ± 1.109 [-0.917, 0.669] -0.354 0.73138 1
three-osc-keys 185.404 ± 0.326 197.462 ± 0.517 12.059 ± 0.653 [11.592, 12.526] 58.433 6.3429e-13 1.332e-11
phase-mod-bell 113.001 ± 0.386 104.323 ± 0.336 -8.677 ± 0.430 [-8.985, -8.370] -63.783 2.888e-13 6.3537e-12
soft-bass 44.931 ± 0.390 45.046 ± 0.418 0.116 ± 0.456 [-0.211, 0.442] 0.802 0.44307 1
hard-lead 39.623 ± 0.389 35.545 ± 0.076 -4.079 ± 0.410 [-4.372, -3.786] -31.477 1.6175e-10 3.0732e-09
idle-pad 0.966 ± 0.005 0.966 ± 0.008 -0.000 ± 0.010 [-0.007, 0.007] -0.025 0.98055 1
auto-cutoff 244.040 ± 1.653 243.407 ± 0.840 -0.633 ± 1.803 [-1.923, 0.658] -1.109 0.29613 1
auto-resonance 262.225 ± 0.573 262.150 ± 0.523 -0.074 ± 0.889 [-0.711, 0.562] -0.265 0.79728 1
auto-drive 487.426 ± 0.447 481.934 ± 0.764 -5.492 ± 0.689 [-5.985, -4.999] -25.190 1.177e-09 1.8831e-08
auto-mix 486.184 ± 0.427 480.373 ± 0.550 -5.811 ± 0.444 [-6.129, -5.494] -41.413 1.3912e-11 2.7823e-10
auto-pan 273.351 ± 2.251 273.502 ± 3.261 0.151 ± 3.889 [-2.632, 2.933] 0.122 0.90525 1
auto-volume 258.926 ± 0.526 258.508 ± 0.583 -0.418 ± 0.863 [-1.035, 0.200] -1.529 0.1605 1
auto-width 265.632 ± 0.778 266.022 ± 2.514 0.389 ± 2.548 [-1.434, 2.212] 0.483 0.64074 1
auto-phase-mod 161.834 ± 0.498 159.460 ± 1.060 -2.374 ± 1.269 [-3.281, -1.466] -5.917 0.00022423 0.0031392
extra-auto-detune 535.975 ± 1.295 534.813 ± 1.327 -1.162 ± 1.932 [-2.544, 0.220] -1.902 0.089596 0.89596
extra-auto-amp-sustain 398.052 ± 1.749 396.428 ± 2.016 -1.625 ± 2.313 [-3.279, 0.029] -2.222 0.053403 0.58743
extra-auto-osc-volume 293.464 ± 0.793 292.227 ± 0.611 -1.237 ± 1.154 [-2.063, -0.411] -3.389 0.0080123 0.096147
extra-auto-osc-tune 303.675 ± 1.519 301.328 ± 0.722 -2.346 ± 1.618 [-3.504, -1.189] -4.585 0.0013187 0.017143

F13: skip bypassed filter vs ba2b8f2

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61073。生データ: filter-none-series-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.243 ± 0.117 13.124 ± 0.385 -0.120 ± 0.387 [-0.397, 0.157] -0.980 0.35281 1
saw-bass 35.434 ± 0.282 35.571 ± 0.309 0.137 ± 0.089 [0.074, 0.200] 4.892 0.00085762 0.018868
triangle-pluck 56.101 ± 0.402 56.034 ± 0.569 -0.067 ± 0.247 [-0.243, 0.110] -0.858 0.41291 1
square-lead 33.916 ± 0.276 33.790 ± 0.153 -0.126 ± 0.310 [-0.348, 0.096] -1.286 0.23047 1
saw-chords 188.489 ± 0.640 187.874 ± 0.576 -0.615 ± 0.510 [-0.980, -0.250] -3.815 0.0041238 0.082476
slow-pad 282.836 ± 1.171 282.126 ± 0.819 -0.710 ± 1.246 [-1.602, 0.182] -1.801 0.10516 1
three-osc-keys 185.383 ± 1.150 184.982 ± 0.223 -0.401 ± 1.156 [-1.228, 0.427] -1.095 0.3018 1
phase-mod-bell 85.814 ± 0.233 83.637 ± 0.238 -2.177 ± 0.149 [-2.284, -2.071] -46.218 5.2012e-12 1.1963e-10
soft-bass 44.828 ± 0.299 45.053 ± 0.381 0.225 ± 0.482 [-0.120, 0.570] 1.474 0.17464 1
hard-lead 39.200 ± 0.251 39.047 ± 0.095 -0.153 ± 0.229 [-0.317, 0.011] -2.111 0.06392 1
idle-pad 0.970 ± 0.008 0.966 ± 0.004 -0.004 ± 0.009 [-0.010, 0.003] -1.235 0.248 1
auto-cutoff 242.957 ± 0.484 244.167 ± 1.603 1.211 ± 1.507 [0.133, 2.288] 2.541 0.031658 0.6015
auto-resonance 261.941 ± 0.807 262.952 ± 2.545 1.011 ± 2.623 [-0.865, 2.887] 1.219 0.25393 1
auto-drive 481.801 ± 2.219 481.136 ± 0.568 -0.665 ± 2.048 [-2.130, 0.799] -1.028 0.33092 1
auto-mix 479.897 ± 0.680 479.946 ± 0.480 0.048 ± 0.654 [-0.420, 0.516] 0.234 0.82038 1
auto-pan 272.177 ± 0.739 271.938 ± 1.097 -0.239 ± 1.286 [-1.159, 0.680] -0.589 0.57049 1
auto-volume 259.094 ± 0.845 259.839 ± 3.390 0.745 ± 3.950 [-2.081, 3.570] 0.596 0.56583 1
auto-width 266.227 ± 2.645 266.019 ± 2.675 -0.208 ± 4.361 [-3.328, 2.912] -0.151 0.8835 1
auto-phase-mod 156.301 ± 0.809 156.401 ± 1.119 0.100 ± 1.454 [-0.940, 1.140] 0.217 0.83279 1
extra-auto-detune 536.580 ± 4.872 535.254 ± 3.440 -1.326 ± 5.540 [-5.289, 2.637] -0.757 0.4685 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 401.390 ± 7.551 397.179 ± 1.965 -4.211 ± 7.070 [-9.269, 0.847] -1.883 0.092329 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 294.743 ± 1.359 294.104 ± 2.377 -0.639 ± 2.829 [-2.663, 1.385] -0.714 0.4932 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 304.043 ± 1.177 302.938 ± 0.839 -1.106 ± 0.879 [-1.735, -0.476] -3.975 0.0032289 0.067807

F13: PM-only bypass vs ba2b8f2

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61074。生データ: filter-none-pm-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.225 ± 0.109 13.314 ± 0.104 0.089 ± 0.151 [-0.019, 0.197] 1.872 0.093938 1
saw-bass 35.434 ± 0.171 35.457 ± 0.190 0.023 ± 0.187 [-0.111, 0.157] 0.384 0.71007 1
triangle-pluck 56.127 ± 0.279 55.996 ± 0.226 -0.130 ± 0.297 [-0.343, 0.082] -1.386 0.19904 1
square-lead 33.880 ± 0.144 33.973 ± 0.195 0.094 ± 0.128 [0.002, 0.185] 2.318 0.045613 1
saw-chords 188.914 ± 1.103 188.928 ± 1.042 0.014 ± 1.329 [-0.936, 0.964] 0.033 0.97418 1
slow-pad 282.818 ± 1.212 281.951 ± 0.549 -0.867 ± 1.255 [-1.764, 0.031] -2.184 0.056846 1
three-osc-keys 185.491 ± 0.466 185.257 ± 0.425 -0.234 ± 0.416 [-0.532, 0.064] -1.779 0.10901 1
phase-mod-bell 85.925 ± 0.437 84.248 ± 0.883 -1.677 ± 0.963 [-2.366, -0.989] -5.511 0.00037494 0.0086237
soft-bass 44.883 ± 0.285 44.819 ± 0.278 -0.064 ± 0.393 [-0.345, 0.217] -0.518 0.61681 1
hard-lead 39.334 ± 0.484 39.404 ± 0.473 0.070 ± 0.385 [-0.205, 0.345] 0.576 0.57874 1
idle-pad 0.968 ± 0.004 0.966 ± 0.004 -0.001 ± 0.006 [-0.006, 0.003] -0.661 0.52529 1
auto-cutoff 243.487 ± 0.860 244.367 ± 1.528 0.880 ± 1.690 [-0.329, 2.089] 1.647 0.13396 1
auto-resonance 262.714 ± 1.268 262.754 ± 1.527 0.041 ± 1.923 [-1.335, 1.416] 0.067 0.94802 1
auto-drive 481.370 ± 0.875 483.040 ± 2.510 1.670 ± 2.580 [-0.176, 3.516] 2.047 0.071012 1
auto-mix 480.201 ± 0.716 482.236 ± 4.948 2.036 ± 5.234 [-1.708, 5.780] 1.230 0.24982 1
auto-pan 273.101 ± 2.739 273.318 ± 1.587 0.217 ± 3.279 [-2.129, 2.563] 0.210 0.83868 1
auto-volume 259.764 ± 3.205 259.463 ± 1.580 -0.302 ± 3.591 [-2.870, 2.267] -0.266 0.79655 1
auto-width 266.696 ± 2.072 267.508 ± 2.785 0.812 ± 3.426 [-1.639, 3.263] 0.750 0.47268 1
auto-phase-mod 156.748 ± 0.984 156.690 ± 1.165 -0.058 ± 1.669 [-1.251, 1.136] -0.109 0.91536 1
extra-auto-detune 534.289 ± 1.880 535.603 ± 1.920 1.314 ± 1.918 [-0.058, 2.686] 2.167 0.058426 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 397.845 ± 1.177 398.337 ± 4.113 0.492 ± 4.114 [-2.450, 3.435] 0.379 0.71382 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 294.974 ± 1.962 293.514 ± 0.948 -1.460 ± 2.384 [-3.166, 0.246] -1.937 0.084779 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 304.045 ± 0.800 305.918 ± 4.426 1.873 ± 4.349 [-1.238, 4.984] 1.362 0.20637 1

F14: finite frequencies vs ba2b8f2

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61075。生データ: filter-finite-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.899 ± 1.975 13.680 ± 0.116 -0.218 ± 1.972 [-1.629, 1.192] -0.350 0.73434 1
saw-bass 35.492 ± 0.332 35.061 ± 0.078 -0.432 ± 0.329 [-0.667, -0.196] -4.142 0.0025151 0.050302
triangle-pluck 56.096 ± 0.366 55.974 ± 0.490 -0.122 ± 0.515 [-0.491, 0.247] -0.748 0.47335 1
square-lead 33.929 ± 0.310 33.908 ± 0.244 -0.021 ± 0.120 [-0.107, 0.065] -0.544 0.59961 1
saw-chords 188.472 ± 1.068 188.650 ± 2.366 0.179 ± 2.707 [-1.758, 2.115] 0.209 0.83941 1
slow-pad 283.044 ± 1.160 281.978 ± 0.889 -1.066 ± 1.245 [-1.957, -0.176] -2.709 0.024048 0.40882
three-osc-keys 185.527 ± 0.724 185.192 ± 0.410 -0.335 ± 0.740 [-0.864, 0.194] -1.433 0.18574 1
phase-mod-bell 86.286 ± 0.726 85.710 ± 0.297 -0.576 ± 0.848 [-1.182, 0.030] -2.149 0.060142 0.90213
soft-bass 44.972 ± 0.372 44.635 ± 0.268 -0.338 ± 0.330 [-0.574, -0.102] -3.235 0.010248 0.19471
hard-lead 39.208 ± 0.208 39.233 ± 0.340 0.025 ± 0.310 [-0.197, 0.247] 0.254 0.80557 1
idle-pad 0.969 ± 0.005 0.969 ± 0.009 -0.001 ± 0.011 [-0.008, 0.007] -0.165 0.87278 1
auto-cutoff 243.119 ± 0.969 246.326 ± 0.941 3.207 ± 0.941 [2.534, 3.881] 10.773 1.9193e-06 4.4144e-05
auto-resonance 261.942 ± 0.731 263.262 ± 2.347 1.320 ± 1.884 [-0.028, 2.668] 2.215 0.054001 0.86401
auto-drive 481.880 ± 1.226 482.995 ± 1.466 1.115 ± 1.650 [-0.065, 2.295] 2.138 0.061246 0.90213
auto-mix 482.262 ± 3.287 482.962 ± 5.365 0.700 ± 7.042 [-4.337, 5.737] 0.314 0.76042 1
auto-pan 272.438 ± 1.082 274.661 ± 1.089 2.222 ± 1.291 [1.299, 3.146] 5.444 0.00040909 0.0085908
auto-volume 258.590 ± 0.759 261.430 ± 1.321 2.840 ± 1.303 [1.907, 3.772] 6.890 7.1484e-05 0.0015726
auto-width 266.390 ± 2.154 269.171 ± 2.345 2.782 ± 2.863 [0.734, 4.830] 3.072 0.013301 0.23942
auto-phase-mod 156.362 ± 0.611 155.796 ± 0.947 -0.566 ± 1.365 [-1.543, 0.411] -1.310 0.22258 1
extra-auto-detune 535.332 ± 2.670 535.463 ± 1.587 0.131 ± 2.606 [-1.733, 1.996] 0.159 0.87708 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 397.616 ± 1.475 398.037 ± 1.229 0.422 ± 1.817 [-0.878, 1.721] 0.734 0.48165 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 293.968 ± 1.083 294.438 ± 1.771 0.470 ± 2.134 [-1.057, 1.997] 0.697 0.50352 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 303.850 ± 0.695 303.544 ± 2.066 -0.306 ± 2.464 [-2.069, 1.456] -0.393 0.70359 1

E10: envelope series vs ba2b8f2

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61076。生データ: envelope-series-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.210 ± 0.070 14.533 ± 0.070 1.323 ± 0.106 [1.247, 1.398] 39.622 2.0669e-11 4.7538e-10
saw-bass 35.469 ± 0.328 35.586 ± 0.177 0.117 ± 0.425 [-0.187, 0.420] 0.868 0.4079 1
triangle-pluck 56.033 ± 0.189 56.284 ± 0.289 0.251 ± 0.419 [-0.048, 0.551] 1.897 0.090295 1
square-lead 33.941 ± 0.296 33.906 ± 0.142 -0.036 ± 0.327 [-0.269, 0.198] -0.345 0.73814 1
saw-chords 189.062 ± 1.569 188.373 ± 0.274 -0.689 ± 1.624 [-1.851, 0.473] -1.341 0.21282 1
slow-pad 283.257 ± 1.328 283.111 ± 0.678 -0.146 ± 1.411 [-1.155, 0.863] -0.327 0.7511 1
three-osc-keys 185.884 ± 2.162 185.656 ± 0.610 -0.228 ± 2.330 [-1.895, 1.439] -0.309 0.76405 1
phase-mod-bell 86.160 ± 0.424 88.287 ± 0.772 2.127 ± 1.046 [1.379, 2.875] 6.431 0.00012077 0.002657
soft-bass 44.778 ± 0.063 45.035 ± 0.227 0.257 ± 0.249 [0.079, 0.435] 3.264 0.0097751 0.1955
hard-lead 39.145 ± 0.149 39.172 ± 0.126 0.028 ± 0.194 [-0.111, 0.167] 0.448 0.66462 1
idle-pad 0.970 ± 0.008 0.967 ± 0.007 -0.003 ± 0.011 [-0.011, 0.004] -1.004 0.3418 1
auto-cutoff 243.229 ± 0.552 243.877 ± 1.784 0.648 ± 1.395 [-0.350, 1.645] 1.468 0.17616 1
auto-resonance 262.700 ± 0.976 264.604 ± 4.999 1.904 ± 4.767 [-1.506, 5.314] 1.263 0.23822 1
auto-drive 483.679 ± 5.868 484.784 ± 4.881 1.105 ± 4.907 [-2.405, 4.615] 0.712 0.49455 1
auto-mix 480.559 ± 0.451 481.576 ± 0.909 1.017 ± 0.972 [0.322, 1.713] 3.309 0.0090969 0.19104
auto-pan 272.439 ± 1.677 273.489 ± 2.714 1.050 ± 3.429 [-1.403, 3.503] 0.968 0.35815 1
auto-volume 258.929 ± 0.961 259.535 ± 1.169 0.607 ± 1.686 [-0.600, 1.813] 1.138 0.28457 1
auto-width 265.752 ± 1.075 266.883 ± 1.845 1.131 ± 2.399 [-0.585, 2.847] 1.491 0.17018 1
auto-phase-mod 157.422 ± 2.262 155.235 ± 0.774 -2.187 ± 2.385 [-3.893, -0.481] -2.900 0.017583 0.33407
extra-auto-detune 537.226 ± 3.407 537.713 ± 2.962 0.487 ± 4.109 [-2.453, 3.426] 0.374 0.71676 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 397.884 ± 1.366 397.639 ± 1.454 -0.245 ± 1.932 [-1.627, 1.137] -0.401 0.69758 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 294.644 ± 2.104 293.949 ± 0.891 -0.695 ± 2.433 [-2.436, 1.046] -0.903 0.38983 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 304.257 ± 1.285 303.929 ± 0.848 -0.329 ± 1.881 [-1.674, 1.017] -0.553 0.59376 1

R29: envelope reuse vs 0faf609

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61077。生データ: envelope-reuse-latest-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.174 ± 0.174 13.170 ± 0.146 -0.004 ± 0.192 [-0.142, 0.134] -0.066 0.94883 1
saw-bass 35.660 ± 0.467 36.797 ± 3.677 1.137 ± 3.667 [-1.486, 3.760] 0.980 0.3525 1
triangle-pluck 56.220 ± 0.750 56.154 ± 0.739 -0.067 ± 0.727 [-0.586, 0.453] -0.290 0.77854 1
square-lead 34.112 ± 0.442 33.893 ± 0.381 -0.219 ± 0.497 [-0.575, 0.137] -1.390 0.19781 1
saw-chords 190.460 ± 6.077 189.349 ± 1.803 -1.111 ± 5.566 [-5.093, 2.870] -0.631 0.54348 1
slow-pad 282.321 ± 1.854 282.476 ± 1.825 0.155 ± 0.493 [-0.197, 0.508] 0.997 0.34466 1
three-osc-keys 185.697 ± 1.330 186.757 ± 2.521 1.060 ± 2.760 [-0.914, 3.034] 1.215 0.25544 1
phase-mod-bell 83.737 ± 0.516 84.139 ± 0.893 0.402 ± 0.886 [-0.232, 1.036] 1.435 0.18506 1
soft-bass 43.297 ± 0.504 43.601 ± 0.689 0.303 ± 0.468 [-0.032, 0.638] 2.048 0.070898 1
hard-lead 36.190 ± 0.464 36.144 ± 0.449 -0.047 ± 0.598 [-0.474, 0.381] -0.247 0.81039 1
idle-pad 0.975 ± 0.034 0.971 ± 0.014 -0.004 ± 0.039 [-0.032, 0.024] -0.292 0.7771 1
auto-cutoff 221.694 ± 2.117 221.633 ± 1.751 -0.061 ± 2.155 [-1.603, 1.480] -0.090 0.93015 1
auto-resonance 239.421 ± 1.514 238.993 ± 0.973 -0.428 ± 1.501 [-1.501, 0.646] -0.901 0.391 1
auto-drive 461.735 ± 3.056 460.736 ± 1.468 -0.999 ± 2.602 [-2.861, 0.862] -1.214 0.25555 1
auto-mix 460.952 ± 3.308 459.968 ± 2.992 -0.984 ± 1.436 [-2.012, 0.043] -2.168 0.058349 1
auto-pan 252.027 ± 4.115 250.331 ± 1.612 -1.695 ± 4.447 [-4.876, 1.486] -1.206 0.25872 1
auto-volume 235.901 ± 1.590 236.106 ± 1.404 0.205 ± 0.536 [-0.178, 0.589] 1.212 0.2565 1
auto-width 243.250 ± 1.738 243.608 ± 4.129 0.358 ± 4.173 [-2.627, 3.343] 0.271 0.79231 1
auto-phase-mod 152.519 ± 0.926 150.972 ± 0.661 -1.547 ± 1.000 [-2.262, -0.831] -4.891 0.00085779 0.018014
extra-auto-detune 510.179 ± 6.263 495.311 ± 5.148 -14.868 ± 3.754 [-17.554, -12.182] -12.523 5.3486e-07 1.2302e-05
extra-auto-amp-sustain 376.288 ± 1.564 363.254 ± 6.212 -13.033 ± 6.044 [-17.357, -8.710] -6.819 7.7358e-05 0.0017019
extra-auto-osc-volume 265.464 ± 1.479 264.481 ± 2.106 -0.983 ± 0.990 [-1.691, -0.274] -3.139 0.011956 0.23912
extra-auto-osc-tune 294.777 ± 2.148 293.212 ± 2.128 -1.565 ± 3.068 [-3.760, 0.629] -1.613 0.14111 1

R24: used-table preparation vs 8c9754d

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61078。生データ: lazy-bands-latest-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.359 ± 0.249 14.068 ± 0.359 0.709 ± 0.215 [0.555, 0.863] 10.427 2.5246e-06 5.5541e-05
saw-bass 36.226 ± 0.676 36.061 ± 0.850 -0.165 ± 0.761 [-0.710, 0.380] -0.684 0.51108 1
triangle-pluck 56.986 ± 0.910 57.380 ± 0.870 0.394 ± 0.845 [-0.210, 0.998] 1.475 0.17441 1
square-lead 34.491 ± 0.847 34.376 ± 0.595 -0.115 ± 0.550 [-0.508, 0.278] -0.663 0.52408 1
saw-chords 190.185 ± 2.223 189.774 ± 2.090 -0.411 ± 0.416 [-0.708, -0.114] -3.126 0.012205 0.24409
slow-pad 285.181 ± 2.977 285.482 ± 4.220 0.301 ± 3.651 [-2.310, 2.913] 0.261 0.79986 1
three-osc-keys 187.061 ± 2.061 187.602 ± 1.983 0.541 ± 1.007 [-0.179, 1.261] 1.700 0.12327 1
phase-mod-bell 84.170 ± 1.077 83.960 ± 1.313 -0.210 ± 1.297 [-1.138, 0.718] -0.512 0.62103 1
soft-bass 44.130 ± 0.975 44.205 ± 0.786 0.075 ± 0.749 [-0.461, 0.611] 0.317 0.75858 1
hard-lead 36.615 ± 0.747 36.688 ± 0.873 0.073 ± 0.460 [-0.256, 0.402] 0.504 0.62639 1
idle-pad 0.975 ± 0.011 0.978 ± 0.015 0.003 ± 0.010 [-0.004, 0.010] 0.966 0.35908 1
auto-cutoff 222.611 ± 2.249 224.613 ± 3.268 2.002 ± 3.673 [-0.625, 4.629] 1.724 0.11884 1
auto-resonance 241.149 ± 3.961 241.755 ± 2.290 0.606 ± 2.853 [-1.435, 2.646] 0.671 0.51888 1
auto-drive 464.861 ± 3.809 465.013 ± 4.723 0.152 ± 2.735 [-1.805, 2.108] 0.176 0.86457 1
auto-mix 463.843 ± 3.628 464.320 ± 3.956 0.477 ± 2.050 [-0.989, 1.944] 0.736 0.48033 1
auto-pan 253.118 ± 2.495 252.841 ± 2.585 -0.277 ± 2.335 [-1.948, 1.393] -0.376 0.71594 1
auto-volume 237.662 ± 2.250 238.211 ± 2.181 0.549 ± 0.726 [0.030, 1.069] 2.392 0.0404 0.7676
auto-width 245.476 ± 3.855 245.092 ± 2.649 -0.384 ± 5.228 [-4.124, 3.356] -0.232 0.82155 1
auto-phase-mod 152.077 ± 1.318 152.482 ± 2.241 0.405 ± 1.865 [-0.929, 1.739] 0.686 0.50988 1
extra-auto-detune 500.179 ± 5.441 420.666 ± 6.391 -79.512 ± 5.456 [-83.415, -75.609] -46.085 5.3375e-12 1.2276e-10
extra-auto-amp-sustain 365.525 ± 5.488 365.711 ± 3.439 0.186 ± 2.735 [-1.770, 2.143] 0.215 0.83427 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 266.860 ± 2.456 267.450 ± 2.788 0.590 ± 1.944 [-0.801, 1.981] 0.960 0.36218 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 295.525 ± 3.032 290.563 ± 5.418 -4.961 ± 4.459 [-8.151, -1.772] -3.519 0.006529 0.13711

Cold frequency remainder helper vs 8c9754d

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61079。生データ: frequency-remainder-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.018 ± 0.081 13.469 ± 0.202 0.452 ± 0.262 [0.264, 0.639] 5.457 0.00040224 0.0088492
saw-bass 35.346 ± 0.300 35.286 ± 0.042 -0.060 ± 0.296 [-0.272, 0.151] -0.644 0.53567 1
triangle-pluck 55.850 ± 0.145 55.826 ± 0.258 -0.023 ± 0.319 [-0.252, 0.205] -0.231 0.82219 1
square-lead 33.784 ± 0.324 33.684 ± 0.277 -0.100 ± 0.106 [-0.176, -0.024] -2.984 0.015342 0.32219
saw-chords 188.085 ± 0.497 188.063 ± 0.943 -0.021 ± 1.087 [-0.799, 0.756] -0.062 0.95158 1
slow-pad 281.951 ± 0.787 282.344 ± 1.774 0.393 ± 2.032 [-1.060, 1.846] 0.612 0.55571 1
three-osc-keys 185.187 ± 0.726 184.711 ± 0.230 -0.477 ± 0.810 [-1.056, 0.103] -1.861 0.095697 1
phase-mod-bell 83.042 ± 0.466 83.175 ± 1.101 0.133 ± 1.342 [-0.827, 1.093] 0.314 0.76058 1
soft-bass 43.095 ± 0.356 43.248 ± 0.350 0.153 ± 0.587 [-0.267, 0.572] 0.822 0.43216 1
hard-lead 35.914 ± 0.179 35.844 ± 0.073 -0.070 ± 0.201 [-0.213, 0.074] -1.095 0.302 1
idle-pad 0.971 ± 0.013 0.963 ± 0.003 -0.008 ± 0.013 [-0.017, 0.002] -1.852 0.096978 1
auto-cutoff 221.313 ± 3.076 220.520 ± 0.682 -0.793 ± 3.111 [-3.019, 1.433] -0.806 0.4412 1
auto-resonance 238.723 ± 1.148 239.172 ± 1.751 0.449 ± 2.124 [-1.070, 1.968] 0.669 0.52058 1
auto-drive 460.281 ± 0.585 461.255 ± 2.221 0.974 ± 2.326 [-0.690, 2.638] 1.324 0.21812 1
auto-mix 459.194 ± 1.035 458.569 ± 0.518 -0.625 ± 1.317 [-1.568, 0.317] -1.500 0.16772 1
auto-pan 249.803 ± 0.739 250.348 ± 1.759 0.545 ± 1.854 [-0.781, 1.871] 0.930 0.37683 1
auto-volume 235.370 ± 0.563 235.436 ± 0.554 0.066 ± 0.820 [-0.520, 0.653] 0.255 0.80461 1
auto-width 240.788 ± 0.372 241.810 ± 2.013 1.021 ± 2.150 [-0.517, 2.559] 1.502 0.16732 1
auto-phase-mod 150.456 ± 0.455 150.238 ± 0.948 -0.218 ± 1.056 [-0.973, 0.537] -0.653 0.53027 1
extra-auto-detune 493.345 ± 3.541 483.888 ± 3.437 -9.457 ± 4.087 [-12.381, -6.533] -7.317 4.4825e-05 0.001031
extra-auto-amp-sustain 362.356 ± 2.878 363.668 ± 7.455 1.312 ± 8.776 [-4.966, 7.590] 0.473 0.64761 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 264.111 ± 2.042 263.498 ± 0.684 -0.613 ± 1.949 [-2.007, 0.781] -0.994 0.34601 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 292.686 ± 1.810 292.334 ± 0.582 -0.352 ± 1.870 [-1.690, 0.986] -0.595 0.56664 1

Sustain-only deferred refresh vs 8c9754d

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61080。生データ: envelope-sustain-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.068 ± 0.172 13.598 ± 0.086 0.530 ± 0.178 [0.403, 0.657] 9.416 5.8918e-06 0.00012962
saw-bass 35.539 ± 0.431 35.481 ± 0.256 -0.057 ± 0.411 [-0.351, 0.237] -0.442 0.669 1
triangle-pluck 56.966 ± 1.276 56.750 ± 0.657 -0.216 ± 1.371 [-1.197, 0.765] -0.498 0.63068 1
square-lead 34.115 ± 0.381 34.032 ± 0.508 -0.083 ± 0.322 [-0.314, 0.147] -0.816 0.4356 1
saw-chords 189.178 ± 1.007 188.553 ± 0.794 -0.625 ± 1.039 [-1.368, 0.118] -1.903 0.089446 1
slow-pad 282.515 ± 0.962 282.198 ± 0.663 -0.317 ± 1.331 [-1.270, 0.635] -0.754 0.47015 1
three-osc-keys 185.686 ± 0.659 185.619 ± 1.052 -0.067 ± 1.149 [-0.889, 0.755] -0.185 0.85751 1
phase-mod-bell 83.227 ± 0.759 83.161 ± 0.599 -0.065 ± 1.004 [-0.784, 0.653] -0.206 0.84119 1
soft-bass 43.279 ± 0.323 43.532 ± 0.375 0.253 ± 0.288 [0.047, 0.459] 2.774 0.021597 0.41035
hard-lead 36.344 ± 0.555 36.141 ± 0.486 -0.202 ± 0.443 [-0.520, 0.115] -1.444 0.1826 1
idle-pad 0.969 ± 0.008 0.969 ± 0.014 0.000 ± 0.015 [-0.011, 0.011] 0.032 0.97493 1
auto-cutoff 221.377 ± 1.296 221.279 ± 1.775 -0.098 ± 1.677 [-1.298, 1.102] -0.185 0.85732 1
auto-resonance 239.312 ± 0.935 239.438 ± 1.277 0.127 ± 1.331 [-0.825, 1.078] 0.301 0.77043 1
auto-drive 461.210 ± 1.512 463.356 ± 3.436 2.145 ± 4.314 [-0.940, 5.231] 1.573 0.15024 1
auto-mix 459.130 ± 0.745 461.236 ± 2.276 2.106 ± 2.346 [0.428, 3.785] 2.839 0.019447 0.38895
auto-pan 250.804 ± 0.708 251.936 ± 4.643 1.132 ± 4.270 [-1.923, 4.187] 0.838 0.42363 1
auto-volume 235.534 ± 0.674 235.872 ± 0.556 0.338 ± 0.706 [-0.167, 0.843] 1.514 0.16427 1
auto-width 241.892 ± 0.984 241.633 ± 1.548 -0.259 ± 1.530 [-1.353, 0.836] -0.535 0.60593 1
auto-phase-mod 150.777 ± 0.644 151.103 ± 0.726 0.326 ± 0.346 [0.079, 0.574] 2.982 0.015393 0.32326
extra-auto-detune 493.588 ± 5.720 502.543 ± 10.004 8.956 ± 13.279 [-0.543, 18.455] 2.133 0.061747 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 362.068 ± 3.079 397.474 ± 2.863 35.406 ± 4.889 [31.908, 38.903] 22.901 2.7409e-09 6.3042e-08
extra-auto-osc-volume 264.287 ± 0.650 264.010 ± 1.205 -0.278 ± 0.993 [-0.988, 0.433] -0.884 0.39994 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 294.018 ± 2.037 294.460 ± 3.623 0.442 ± 4.201 [-2.563, 3.448] 0.333 0.74686 1

Unify all Voice sample series vs 8c9754d

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61081。生データ: pipeline-all-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.030 ± 0.071 13.891 ± 0.104 0.861 ± 0.110 [0.782, 0.939] 24.819 1.343e-09 2.686e-08
saw-bass 35.318 ± 0.242 35.222 ± 1.646 -0.096 ± 1.702 [-1.314, 1.121] -0.179 0.8619 1
triangle-pluck 56.041 ± 0.344 64.436 ± 0.370 8.394 ± 0.487 [8.046, 8.743] 54.549 1.176e-12 2.4696e-11
square-lead 33.703 ± 0.048 30.414 ± 0.116 -3.289 ± 0.132 [-3.384, -3.195] -78.626 4.4077e-14 9.6969e-13
saw-chords 188.197 ± 0.337 189.724 ± 1.104 1.526 ± 1.257 [0.627, 2.426] 3.840 0.0039692 0.067477
slow-pad 281.769 ± 0.900 280.575 ± 0.507 -1.194 ± 0.756 [-1.735, -0.653] -4.992 0.00074712 0.013448
three-osc-keys 185.228 ± 0.682 186.479 ± 2.082 1.251 ± 2.233 [-0.346, 2.849] 1.772 0.11013 1
phase-mod-bell 82.926 ± 0.681 82.526 ± 0.124 -0.400 ± 0.626 [-0.848, 0.047] -2.023 0.073767 1
soft-bass 42.951 ± 0.078 42.486 ± 0.057 -0.466 ± 0.104 [-0.540, -0.391] -14.162 1.8566e-07 3.5275e-06
hard-lead 35.908 ± 0.066 32.475 ± 0.061 -3.432 ± 0.053 [-3.470, -3.394] -203.570 8.4736e-18 1.9489e-16
idle-pad 0.970 ± 0.010 1.014 ± 0.140 0.044 ± 0.132 [-0.050, 0.138] 1.060 0.31689 1
auto-cutoff 220.489 ± 0.457 220.871 ± 0.891 0.382 ± 1.141 [-0.434, 1.198] 1.058 0.31746 1
auto-resonance 253.245 ± 47.334 238.051 ± 0.435 -15.195 ± 47.518 [-49.187, 18.797] -1.011 0.33833 1
auto-drive 460.667 ± 1.409 459.888 ± 1.763 -0.780 ± 2.277 [-2.409, 0.849] -1.083 0.30691 1
auto-mix 458.722 ± 0.810 459.388 ± 1.585 0.666 ± 2.138 [-0.864, 2.195] 0.985 0.35046 1
auto-pan 249.519 ± 0.644 249.203 ± 0.771 -0.316 ± 1.096 [-1.099, 0.468] -0.912 0.38578 1
auto-volume 235.283 ± 0.521 235.332 ± 0.339 0.049 ± 0.621 [-0.396, 0.493] 0.248 0.8096 1
auto-width 241.400 ± 0.894 243.172 ± 4.716 1.772 ± 4.529 [-1.468, 5.012] 1.237 0.24727 1
auto-phase-mod 150.502 ± 1.198 151.379 ± 0.742 0.877 ± 1.455 [-0.164, 1.918] 1.907 0.088939 1
extra-auto-detune 494.057 ± 3.870 492.333 ± 3.892 -1.724 ± 6.423 [-6.318, 2.870] -0.849 0.41797 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 360.935 ± 3.403 360.150 ± 3.316 -0.785 ± 4.199 [-3.789, 2.219] -0.591 0.56896 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 264.345 ± 1.932 264.268 ± 2.602 -0.076 ± 1.687 [-1.283, 1.130] -0.143 0.88951 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 292.944 ± 1.160 293.084 ± 2.008 0.140 ± 2.674 [-1.773, 2.053] 0.165 0.87258 1

PM or effective Unison > 1 pipeline vs 693ab23

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61082。生データ: pipeline-unison-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.460 ± 0.071 13.108 ± 0.038 -0.352 ± 0.087 [-0.414, -0.290] -12.823 4.3674e-07 9.1716e-06
saw-bass 35.299 ± 0.049 35.384 ± 0.104 0.085 ± 0.076 [0.031, 0.139] 3.547 0.0062435 0.11238
triangle-pluck 55.911 ± 0.333 55.997 ± 0.764 0.086 ± 0.922 [-0.573, 0.745] 0.295 0.77438 1
square-lead 33.612 ± 0.055 30.363 ± 0.106 -3.250 ± 0.096 [-3.318, -3.181] -107.484 2.6509e-15 6.097e-14
saw-chords 187.642 ± 0.373 190.293 ± 0.893 2.651 ± 1.127 [1.845, 3.458] 7.438 3.9421e-05 0.00078841
slow-pad 281.404 ± 0.582 281.649 ± 1.187 0.245 ± 1.263 [-0.658, 1.148] 0.614 0.55466 1
three-osc-keys 185.018 ± 0.828 185.032 ± 0.882 0.013 ± 0.328 [-0.221, 0.248] 0.129 0.90038 1
phase-mod-bell 82.666 ± 0.222 82.696 ± 0.545 0.030 ± 0.436 [-0.282, 0.342] 0.217 0.83285 1
soft-bass 43.236 ± 0.223 43.149 ± 0.078 -0.088 ± 0.264 [-0.277, 0.101] -1.051 0.32087 1
hard-lead 35.937 ± 0.264 32.466 ± 0.113 -3.471 ± 0.204 [-3.617, -3.324] -53.702 1.3534e-12 2.9774e-11
idle-pad 0.964 ± 0.003 0.965 ± 0.006 0.001 ± 0.005 [-0.003, 0.005] 0.767 0.46261 1
auto-cutoff 220.815 ± 1.220 221.376 ± 2.596 0.561 ± 3.326 [-1.818, 2.941] 0.534 0.60643 1
auto-resonance 239.258 ± 0.998 238.986 ± 0.699 -0.271 ± 1.216 [-1.141, 0.598] -0.706 0.49817 1
auto-drive 461.862 ± 3.520 460.138 ± 0.390 -1.724 ± 3.375 [-4.138, 0.690] -1.615 0.14066 1
auto-mix 458.849 ± 0.692 460.899 ± 4.390 2.050 ± 4.809 [-1.390, 5.490] 1.348 0.21061 1
auto-pan 251.358 ± 3.489 250.196 ± 1.446 -1.163 ± 4.094 [-4.092, 1.766] -0.898 0.39263 1
auto-volume 236.123 ± 0.968 235.696 ± 0.759 -0.427 ± 1.378 [-1.413, 0.559] -0.980 0.35288 1
auto-width 241.731 ± 0.917 241.155 ± 0.613 -0.576 ± 1.120 [-1.377, 0.225] -1.626 0.13835 1
auto-phase-mod 150.581 ± 0.351 151.138 ± 0.525 0.558 ± 0.354 [0.305, 0.811] 4.988 0.0007514 0.014277
extra-auto-detune 494.939 ± 4.445 495.557 ± 3.649 0.618 ± 6.235 [-3.842, 5.078] 0.314 0.76098 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 360.450 ± 6.421 361.862 ± 2.609 1.413 ± 6.251 [-3.059, 5.884] 0.715 0.49286 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 263.375 ± 0.321 264.051 ± 1.300 0.676 ± 1.381 [-0.311, 1.664] 1.549 0.15585 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 293.002 ± 0.551 292.602 ± 0.463 -0.399 ± 0.713 [-0.910, 0.111] -1.771 0.11038 1

Unison factorial: PM or effective Unison > 1 pipeline vs 693ab23

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正48ケース。Seed: 61083。生データ: pipeline-unison-matrix-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
unison-sine-u2-p1-none 14.880 ± 0.225 16.523 ± 0.136 1.643 ± 0.233 [1.476, 1.810] 22.257 3.5293e-09 1.0235e-07
unison-sine-u2-p1-lp2 25.008 ± 0.062 25.400 ± 0.050 0.392 ± 0.068 [0.343, 0.440] 18.289 1.9951e-08 4.4798e-07
unison-sine-u2-p4-none 51.635 ± 1.698 57.301 ± 0.272 5.666 ± 1.805 [4.375, 6.958] 9.926 3.8067e-06 5.3294e-05
unison-sine-u2-p4-lp2 90.604 ± 0.156 92.955 ± 0.472 2.351 ± 0.510 [1.987, 2.716] 14.591 1.4335e-07 2.867e-06
unison-sine-u3-p1-none 16.871 ± 0.125 18.898 ± 0.052 2.027 ± 0.151 [1.919, 2.135] 42.337 1.1416e-11 4.9089e-10
unison-sine-u3-p1-lp2 26.949 ± 0.040 28.140 ± 0.203 1.190 ± 0.215 [1.037, 1.344] 17.535 2.8871e-08 6.0629e-07
unison-sine-u3-p4-none 58.675 ± 0.383 66.082 ± 0.211 7.406 ± 0.489 [7.056, 7.756] 47.891 3.781e-12 1.6637e-10
unison-sine-u3-p4-lp2 98.118 ± 1.461 102.689 ± 0.448 4.571 ± 1.118 [3.772, 5.371] 12.932 4.0621e-07 6.4994e-06
unison-sine-u7-p1-none 27.314 ± 0.173 28.608 ± 0.044 1.294 ± 0.169 [1.173, 1.414] 24.252 1.6489e-09 5.1115e-08
unison-sine-u7-p1-lp2 35.754 ± 0.030 37.736 ± 0.064 1.982 ± 0.079 [1.926, 2.038] 79.613 3.94e-14 1.8124e-12
unison-sine-u7-p4-none 97.753 ± 0.498 101.920 ± 0.124 4.168 ± 0.512 [3.801, 4.534] 25.724 9.7683e-10 3.3212e-08
unison-sine-u7-p4-lp2 129.721 ± 0.936 138.491 ± 0.277 8.770 ± 1.056 [8.014, 9.526] 26.251 8.1576e-10 2.8552e-08
unison-triangle-u2-p1-none 20.321 ± 0.111 21.401 ± 0.060 1.080 ± 0.105 [1.005, 1.155] 32.627 1.1742e-10 4.3446e-09
unison-triangle-u2-p1-lp2 33.675 ± 0.252 30.478 ± 0.113 -3.198 ± 0.248 [-3.375, -3.021] -40.819 1.5832e-11 6.6495e-10
unison-triangle-u2-p4-none 77.798 ± 3.418 80.596 ± 2.087 2.798 ± 4.343 [-0.309, 5.904] 2.037 0.072085 0.5046
unison-triangle-u2-p4-lp2 125.629 ± 0.345 115.874 ± 0.119 -9.756 ± 0.367 [-10.018, -9.493] -84.109 2.4045e-14 1.1542e-12
unison-triangle-u3-p1-none 23.510 ± 0.233 24.312 ± 0.410 0.802 ± 0.425 [0.498, 1.106] 5.961 0.00021251 0.0023376
unison-triangle-u3-p1-lp2 35.426 ± 0.117 33.368 ± 0.096 -2.058 ± 0.193 [-2.196, -1.920] -33.684 8.832e-11 3.3562e-09
unison-triangle-u3-p4-none 93.959 ± 0.595 95.494 ± 0.382 1.535 ± 0.844 [0.931, 2.139] 5.750 0.00027638 0.0027638
unison-triangle-u3-p4-lp2 134.800 ± 0.205 131.980 ± 0.348 -2.820 ± 0.401 [-3.107, -2.534] -22.254 3.5332e-09 1.0235e-07
unison-triangle-u7-p1-none 37.285 ± 0.070 38.677 ± 0.218 1.391 ± 0.210 [1.241, 1.542] 20.924 6.0934e-09 1.6452e-07
unison-triangle-u7-p1-lp2 47.799 ± 0.051 47.769 ± 0.137 -0.031 ± 0.172 [-0.154, 0.092] -0.568 0.58423 1
unison-triangle-u7-p4-none 157.841 ± 0.211 161.929 ± 0.340 4.089 ± 0.343 [3.843, 4.334] 37.718 3.2114e-11 1.3167e-09
unison-triangle-u7-p4-lp2 195.307 ± 0.251 198.995 ± 1.045 3.688 ± 0.868 [3.067, 4.309] 13.430 2.9347e-07 4.989e-06
unison-square-u2-p1-none 20.321 ± 0.086 21.417 ± 0.059 1.097 ± 0.093 [1.030, 1.163] 37.485 3.3947e-11 1.3579e-09
unison-square-u2-p1-lp2 34.755 ± 3.691 30.454 ± 0.073 -4.301 ± 3.712 [-6.956, -1.646] -3.664 0.0052018 0.046816
unison-square-u2-p4-none 76.293 ± 0.295 80.141 ± 0.454 3.849 ± 0.534 [3.467, 4.231] 22.791 2.8608e-09 8.5825e-08
unison-square-u2-p4-lp2 125.566 ± 0.281 116.549 ± 1.471 -9.017 ± 1.534 [-10.114, -7.920] -18.593 1.7261e-08 4.1427e-07
unison-square-u3-p1-none 23.645 ± 0.223 24.197 ± 0.167 0.552 ± 0.286 [0.347, 0.756] 6.101 0.00017902 0.0021482
unison-square-u3-p1-lp2 35.371 ± 0.082 33.472 ± 0.267 -1.899 ± 0.289 [-2.106, -1.692] -20.781 6.4755e-09 1.6836e-07
unison-square-u3-p4-none 95.203 ± 3.640 95.734 ± 0.415 0.531 ± 3.716 [-2.127, 3.189] 0.452 0.66204 1
unison-square-u3-p4-lp2 134.833 ± 0.190 131.866 ± 0.294 -2.966 ± 0.369 [-3.230, -2.702] -25.412 1.0887e-09 3.4838e-08
unison-square-u7-p1-none 37.240 ± 0.031 38.575 ± 0.051 1.335 ± 0.052 [1.298, 1.373] 80.807 3.4467e-14 1.6199e-12
unison-square-u7-p1-lp2 47.884 ± 0.273 47.741 ± 0.120 -0.143 ± 0.260 [-0.329, 0.043] -1.740 0.11586 0.69515
unison-square-u7-p4-none 157.865 ± 0.422 162.066 ± 0.501 4.201 ± 0.518 [3.831, 4.571] 25.657 9.9962e-10 3.3212e-08
unison-square-u7-p4-lp2 195.108 ± 0.516 198.600 ± 0.258 3.492 ± 0.602 [3.061, 3.923] 18.339 1.9477e-08 4.4798e-07
unison-saw-u2-p1-none 20.287 ± 0.054 21.262 ± 0.123 0.975 ± 0.151 [0.867, 1.083] 20.461 7.4244e-09 1.8561e-07
unison-saw-u2-p1-lp2 33.718 ± 0.314 30.391 ± 0.128 -3.327 ± 0.325 [-3.560, -3.095] -32.404 1.2482e-10 4.4935e-09
unison-saw-u2-p4-none 80.245 ± 12.221 78.769 ± 0.449 -1.475 ± 12.390 [-10.339, 7.388] -0.377 0.71526 1
unison-saw-u2-p4-lp2 125.219 ± 0.443 114.478 ± 0.732 -10.741 ± 0.941 [-11.413, -10.068] -36.112 4.7405e-11 1.8488e-09
unison-saw-u3-p1-none 23.538 ± 0.222 23.617 ± 0.095 0.079 ± 0.186 [-0.054, 0.212] 1.346 0.21127 0.90094
unison-saw-u3-p1-lp2 35.535 ± 0.477 33.026 ± 0.406 -2.509 ± 0.657 [-2.979, -2.039] -12.083 7.2621e-07 1.0893e-05
unison-saw-u3-p4-none 92.677 ± 0.984 92.157 ± 0.317 -0.520 ± 1.132 [-1.330, 0.290] -1.453 0.18019 0.90094
unison-saw-u3-p4-lp2 133.506 ± 0.181 128.922 ± 0.345 -4.583 ± 0.284 [-4.787, -4.380] -51.000 2.1507e-12 9.6783e-11
unison-saw-u7-p1-none 36.506 ± 0.209 37.265 ± 0.277 0.759 ± 0.364 [0.499, 1.019] 6.600 9.9237e-05 0.0012901
unison-saw-u7-p1-lp2 46.687 ± 0.105 46.481 ± 0.251 -0.206 ± 0.245 [-0.382, -0.031] -2.657 0.026157 0.20925
unison-saw-u7-p4-none 152.542 ± 0.270 155.721 ± 0.653 3.179 ± 0.739 [2.651, 3.707] 13.612 2.6142e-07 4.7056e-06
unison-saw-u7-p4-lp2 189.585 ± 0.113 191.771 ± 0.448 2.187 ± 0.490 [1.836, 2.537] 14.114 1.9123e-07 3.6333e-06

16-frame outer chunks vs ff680ff

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61084。生データ: chunk16-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 14.495 ± 3.038 13.591 ± 0.093 -0.904 ± 3.029 [-3.070, 1.263] -0.944 0.36993 1
saw-bass 35.720 ± 1.245 35.407 ± 0.213 -0.313 ± 1.257 [-1.213, 0.586] -0.787 0.45128 1
triangle-pluck 55.900 ± 0.182 55.774 ± 0.250 -0.126 ± 0.319 [-0.354, 0.102] -1.247 0.2438 1
square-lead 33.697 ± 0.079 33.747 ± 0.112 0.050 ± 0.139 [-0.049, 0.150] 1.142 0.28273 1
saw-chords 187.772 ± 0.427 189.248 ± 0.393 1.477 ± 0.336 [1.236, 1.718] 13.882 2.2064e-07 5.0748e-06
slow-pad 283.283 ± 5.204 283.732 ± 0.375 0.449 ± 5.409 [-3.421, 4.318] 0.262 0.79891 1
three-osc-keys 185.195 ± 0.896 184.925 ± 0.521 -0.270 ± 0.976 [-0.968, 0.428] -0.874 0.40506 1
phase-mod-bell 82.861 ± 0.313 89.289 ± 2.204 6.428 ± 2.265 [4.808, 8.048] 8.975 8.7361e-06 0.00019219
soft-bass 43.257 ± 0.380 43.588 ± 0.127 0.331 ± 0.328 [0.096, 0.565] 3.186 0.011085 0.2217
hard-lead 35.955 ± 0.269 36.283 ± 0.488 0.328 ± 0.252 [0.148, 0.508] 4.118 0.0026067 0.05474
idle-pad 0.968 ± 0.012 0.971 ± 0.012 0.003 ± 0.020 [-0.012, 0.017] 0.412 0.68988 1
auto-cutoff 220.997 ± 1.356 220.033 ± 0.365 -0.964 ± 1.342 [-1.924, -0.004] -2.272 0.049223 0.88601
auto-resonance 239.813 ± 1.441 239.327 ± 1.518 -0.486 ± 2.427 [-2.223, 1.250] -0.634 0.54197 1
auto-drive 461.261 ± 1.209 460.135 ± 1.000 -1.126 ± 1.325 [-2.074, -0.178] -2.687 0.024922 0.47353
auto-mix 459.827 ± 1.657 459.764 ± 1.911 -0.062 ± 2.299 [-1.706, 1.582] -0.085 0.93378 1
auto-pan 251.082 ± 2.592 249.883 ± 0.897 -1.199 ± 2.805 [-3.206, 0.808] -1.352 0.20946 1
auto-volume 235.730 ± 0.684 235.541 ± 0.673 -0.189 ± 1.101 [-0.976, 0.598] -0.543 0.6003 1
auto-width 241.485 ± 0.580 241.702 ± 1.997 0.217 ± 1.998 [-1.212, 1.646] 0.343 0.73934 1
auto-phase-mod 150.682 ± 0.322 150.853 ± 0.522 0.171 ± 0.664 [-0.304, 0.646] 0.813 0.43743 1
extra-auto-detune 494.689 ± 4.569 495.844 ± 5.352 1.155 ± 8.035 [-4.593, 6.902] 0.455 0.66023 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 361.261 ± 3.873 361.576 ± 2.883 0.315 ± 5.857 [-3.875, 4.505] 0.170 0.86872 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 264.649 ± 2.645 266.006 ± 7.059 1.357 ± 7.745 [-4.183, 6.898] 0.554 0.59291 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 294.512 ± 2.809 292.469 ± 1.163 -2.042 ± 3.170 [-4.310, 0.225] -2.038 0.07203 1

64-frame outer chunks vs ff680ff

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61085。生データ: chunk64-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.457 ± 0.147 13.568 ± 0.318 0.112 ± 0.324 [-0.120, 0.343] 1.091 0.30343 1
saw-bass 35.356 ± 0.097 35.249 ± 0.183 -0.107 ± 0.161 [-0.222, 0.008] -2.100 0.06509 1
triangle-pluck 55.956 ± 0.442 55.894 ± 0.419 -0.063 ± 0.656 [-0.532, 0.406] -0.302 0.7692 1
square-lead 33.735 ± 0.265 33.487 ± 0.144 -0.248 ± 0.326 [-0.481, -0.015] -2.404 0.039618 0.71312
saw-chords 187.572 ± 0.180 186.584 ± 0.543 -0.988 ± 0.468 [-1.323, -0.654] -6.679 9.0727e-05 0.0019053
slow-pad 282.010 ± 1.172 279.244 ± 0.651 -2.766 ± 0.829 [-3.359, -2.173] -10.547 2.2925e-06 5.2728e-05
three-osc-keys 185.137 ± 0.720 185.225 ± 1.957 0.088 ± 1.494 [-0.981, 1.157] 0.186 0.85686 1
phase-mod-bell 83.117 ± 0.567 82.589 ± 0.783 -0.529 ± 1.064 [-1.290, 0.232] -1.572 0.1504 1
soft-bass 43.189 ± 0.221 42.952 ± 0.203 -0.237 ± 0.273 [-0.433, -0.042] -2.748 0.022541 0.42828
hard-lead 35.940 ± 0.187 35.698 ± 0.147 -0.242 ± 0.223 [-0.401, -0.082] -3.432 0.0074903 0.14981
idle-pad 0.967 ± 0.005 0.933 ± 0.015 -0.034 ± 0.013 [-0.043, -0.024] -8.194 1.8272e-05 0.00040199
auto-cutoff 221.160 ± 1.347 220.518 ± 1.305 -0.643 ± 2.227 [-2.236, 0.951] -0.912 0.38537 1
auto-resonance 239.540 ± 0.807 240.885 ± 5.537 1.345 ± 5.875 [-2.858, 5.548] 0.724 0.48743 1
auto-drive 460.675 ± 0.415 461.398 ± 2.781 0.723 ± 2.923 [-1.367, 2.814] 0.782 0.45402 1
auto-mix 459.949 ± 2.101 459.594 ± 0.637 -0.354 ± 2.275 [-1.982, 1.273] -0.492 0.63416 1
auto-pan 250.017 ± 0.520 250.779 ± 2.452 0.762 ± 2.488 [-1.018, 2.542] 0.969 0.35809 1
auto-volume 235.642 ± 0.706 236.589 ± 3.064 0.947 ± 3.090 [-1.263, 3.158] 0.969 0.35769 1
auto-width 242.614 ± 2.356 241.975 ± 2.457 -0.638 ± 3.628 [-3.234, 1.957] -0.556 0.59149 1
auto-phase-mod 150.403 ± 0.456 150.492 ± 0.667 0.089 ± 0.990 [-0.620, 0.797] 0.283 0.78365 1
extra-auto-detune 493.680 ± 4.460 497.131 ± 6.170 3.451 ± 8.861 [-2.888, 9.790] 1.231 0.24935 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 360.559 ± 4.219 360.984 ± 3.063 0.424 ± 5.002 [-3.154, 4.003] 0.268 0.79452 1
extra-auto-osc-volume 263.899 ± 1.172 264.087 ± 2.546 0.188 ± 1.952 [-1.208, 1.585] 0.305 0.76724 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 295.762 ± 4.548 293.708 ± 2.957 -2.053 ± 5.257 [-5.814, 1.707] -1.235 0.24803 1

64-frame outer chunks: independent 20-block confirmation vs ff680ff

20ブロック、自由度19、Holm補正23ケース。Seed: 61086。生データ: chunk64-confirmation-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 13.470 ± 0.118 13.485 ± 0.252 0.014 ± 0.298 [-0.125, 0.154] 0.217 0.8307 1
saw-bass 35.341 ± 0.199 35.675 ± 1.632 0.334 ± 1.661 [-0.444, 1.111] 0.899 0.38004 1
triangle-pluck 55.944 ± 0.400 55.836 ± 0.273 -0.108 ± 0.539 [-0.360, 0.144] -0.899 0.38008 1
square-lead 33.728 ± 0.246 33.493 ± 0.248 -0.235 ± 0.359 [-0.403, -0.067] -2.921 0.0087569 0.15762
saw-chords 188.030 ± 0.687 186.575 ± 1.479 -1.455 ± 1.597 [-2.202, -0.707] -4.072 0.00064929 0.013635
slow-pad 281.387 ± 0.554 279.114 ± 0.997 -2.273 ± 0.822 [-2.658, -1.889] -12.374 1.5403e-10 3.5428e-09
three-osc-keys 188.208 ± 12.693 185.085 ± 1.382 -3.123 ± 12.660 [-9.048, 2.802] -1.103 0.28368 1
phase-mod-bell 82.765 ± 0.258 82.528 ± 0.708 -0.236 ± 0.628 [-0.530, 0.057] -1.684 0.10853 1
soft-bass 43.264 ± 0.322 42.998 ± 0.404 -0.266 ± 0.444 [-0.474, -0.058] -2.675 0.01497 0.23953
hard-lead 35.965 ± 0.277 35.728 ± 0.163 -0.237 ± 0.300 [-0.377, -0.096] -3.525 0.0022633 0.045267
idle-pad 0.970 ± 0.011 0.936 ± 0.019 -0.034 ± 0.024 [-0.046, -0.023] -6.307 4.7044e-06 0.0001035
auto-cutoff 220.854 ± 1.066 221.115 ± 2.061 0.261 ± 2.259 [-0.797, 1.318] 0.516 0.61188 1
auto-resonance 239.666 ± 1.150 239.030 ± 0.683 -0.636 ± 1.005 [-1.107, -0.166] -2.831 0.010688 0.18169
auto-drive 460.807 ± 0.904 461.043 ± 1.482 0.237 ± 1.348 [-0.394, 0.868] 0.785 0.4424 1
auto-mix 460.425 ± 3.829 460.550 ± 3.735 0.125 ± 4.367 [-1.919, 2.169] 0.128 0.89951 1
auto-pan 250.617 ± 1.497 249.919 ± 1.380 -0.698 ± 1.959 [-1.615, 0.219] -1.594 0.12752 1
auto-volume 236.185 ± 1.538 235.182 ± 0.510 -1.003 ± 1.517 [-1.713, -0.293] -2.958 0.0080717 0.15336
auto-width 241.596 ± 1.033 241.528 ± 1.241 -0.068 ± 1.439 [-0.742, 0.605] -0.212 0.8342 1
auto-phase-mod 150.917 ± 0.776 150.789 ± 1.171 -0.128 ± 1.509 [-0.834, 0.578] -0.380 0.7083 1
extra-auto-detune 495.703 ± 5.863 494.997 ± 4.004 -0.706 ± 6.964 [-3.965, 2.553] -0.454 0.65528 1
extra-auto-amp-sustain 363.001 ± 3.894 360.847 ± 3.118 -2.154 ± 4.089 [-4.067, -0.240] -2.356 0.02938 0.4407
extra-auto-osc-volume 263.826 ± 0.685 264.042 ± 2.335 0.215 ± 2.418 [-0.916, 1.347] 0.398 0.69497 1
extra-auto-osc-tune 294.213 ± 3.040 293.982 ± 2.161 -0.231 ± 3.454 [-1.848, 1.385] -0.300 0.76772 1

64-frame chunks: Windows VST3 initial 10 blocks

10ブロック、自由度9、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 120479。生データ: chunk64-windows-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 16.535 ± 5.999 15.219 ± 0.403 -1.316 ± 6.080 [-5.665, 3.034] -0.684 0.51098 1
saw-bass 67.091 ± 6.145 65.181 ± 0.520 -1.910 ± 6.051 [-6.238, 2.419] -0.998 0.34433 1
triangle-pluck 66.911 ± 28.067 64.123 ± 21.498 -2.788 ± 36.902 [-29.187, 23.610] -0.239 0.81649 1
square-lead 34.948 ± 1.417 39.704 ± 15.625 4.757 ± 15.648 [-6.437, 15.951] 0.961 0.36153 1
saw-chords 187.917 ± 1.054 186.292 ± 1.722 -1.624 ± 1.926 [-3.002, -0.247] -2.667 0.025753 0.41205
slow-pad 321.711 ± 0.500 320.131 ± 0.629 -1.579 ± 0.830 [-2.173, -0.986] -6.016 0.0001985 0.0035731
three-osc-keys 185.185 ± 2.369 185.419 ± 2.725 0.234 ± 3.725 [-2.430, 2.899] 0.199 0.84673 1
phase-mod-bell 96.443 ± 0.668 95.721 ± 0.647 -0.722 ± 1.047 [-1.471, 0.027] -2.180 0.057213 0.85819
soft-bass 73.572 ± 0.506 73.500 ± 0.607 -0.072 ± 0.855 [-0.683, 0.540] -0.265 0.79695 1
hard-lead 37.291 ± 0.543 37.226 ± 0.758 -0.065 ± 1.031 [-0.803, 0.672] -0.201 0.84542 1
idle-pad 2.249 ± 0.121 2.188 ± 0.168 -0.062 ± 0.205 [-0.208, 0.085] -0.951 0.3666 1
auto-cutoff 228.246 ± 3.255 228.658 ± 0.688 0.412 ± 3.535 [-2.117, 2.941] 0.368 0.72113 1
auto-resonance 247.730 ± 1.593 249.122 ± 1.637 1.392 ± 2.307 [-0.259, 3.042] 1.908 0.088787 1
auto-drive 486.866 ± 0.807 492.877 ± 1.377 6.011 ± 1.696 [4.798, 7.224] 11.209 1.3732e-06 2.6091e-05
auto-mix 488.513 ± 2.960 493.151 ± 2.607 4.638 ± 3.219 [2.336, 6.941] 4.556 0.0013733 0.023346
auto-pan 255.528 ± 0.649 255.984 ± 0.921 0.455 ± 1.110 [-0.338, 1.249] 1.298 0.22662 1
auto-volume 261.106 ± 28.368 248.671 ± 0.891 -12.435 ± 28.615 [-32.905, 8.036] -1.374 0.20264 1
auto-width 252.374 ± 3.163 251.899 ± 1.237 -0.474 ± 3.807 [-3.198, 2.249] -0.394 0.70276 1
auto-phase-mod 185.791 ± 26.706 177.330 ± 0.424 -8.461 ± 26.593 [-27.484, 10.562] -1.006 0.34064 1

64-frame chunks: Windows VST3 quiet 20 blocks

20ブロック、自由度19、Holm補正19ケース。Seed: 120480。生データ: chunk64-windows-confirmation-paired.json。

ケース 前 平均±SD 後 平均±SD 差 平均±SD 差95%CI t p 両側 p Holm
sine-mono 14.509 ± 0.358 14.999 ± 0.275 0.490 ± 0.485 [0.263, 0.717] 4.519 0.00023494 0.004229
saw-bass 67.947 ± 14.240 64.584 ± 0.621 -3.363 ± 14.320 [-10.065, 3.339] -1.050 0.30677 1
triangle-pluck 61.113 ± 14.877 60.049 ± 13.220 -1.064 ± 20.504 [-10.660, 8.533] -0.232 0.81902 1
square-lead 36.396 ± 9.547 34.990 ± 3.926 -1.406 ± 10.622 [-6.377, 3.565] -0.592 0.56088 1
saw-chords 186.785 ± 1.186 190.259 ± 24.646 3.474 ± 24.533 [-8.007, 14.956] 0.633 0.53405 1
slow-pad 320.146 ± 0.724 327.429 ± 26.766 7.283 ± 26.948 [-5.329, 19.895] 1.209 0.2416 1
three-osc-keys 184.096 ± 0.722 194.014 ± 44.809 9.918 ± 44.935 [-11.112, 30.949] 0.987 0.33599 1
phase-mod-bell 106.913 ± 33.089 95.838 ± 2.232 -11.075 ± 32.528 [-26.298, 4.149] -1.523 0.14433 1
soft-bass 73.002 ± 0.426 72.861 ± 0.462 -0.142 ± 0.543 [-0.396, 0.113] -1.166 0.25815 1
hard-lead 38.828 ± 9.547 36.654 ± 0.617 -2.174 ± 9.690 [-6.709, 2.362] -1.003 0.32841 1
idle-pad 2.105 ± 0.043 2.358 ± 1.250 0.254 ± 1.232 [-0.323, 0.830] 0.921 0.3688 1
auto-cutoff 226.702 ± 1.197 231.503 ± 19.133 4.801 ± 19.401 [-4.279, 13.881] 1.107 0.28221 1
auto-resonance 246.341 ± 1.194 247.113 ± 0.422 0.772 ± 1.300 [0.164, 1.380] 2.656 0.015608 0.26534
auto-drive 485.708 ± 0.894 495.512 ± 18.852 9.804 ± 18.843 [0.986, 18.623] 2.327 0.03118 0.49887
auto-mix 485.992 ± 2.843 491.073 ± 0.625 5.081 ± 3.128 [3.617, 6.545] 7.264 6.8187e-07 1.2955e-05
auto-pan 260.405 ± 24.202 255.942 ± 2.232 -4.463 ± 24.580 [-15.966, 7.041] -0.812 0.42685 1
auto-volume 248.164 ± 4.160 256.545 ± 26.125 8.382 ± 26.477 [-4.010, 20.773] 1.416 0.17304 1
auto-width 250.514 ± 1.219 256.544 ± 20.995 6.030 ± 20.997 [-3.797, 15.857] 1.284 0.21447 1
auto-phase-mod 176.465 ± 1.961 178.577 ± 9.135 2.112 ± 9.500 [-2.334, 6.558] 0.994 0.33268 1

Clone this wiki locally