Repository navigation
Optimization 12h R36 pgo bounded 2026 11 04
odashi edited this page Nov 16, 2026
·
1 revision
R28ではPGOによりVoiceへ過剰に展開されたコードが位相変調を遅くした。23ケースで訓練した同じプロファイルへ、通常・hint・hotの閾値225を指定して再ビルドする。基点b82bbb1。
採用しない。32ケースは1.55〜34.20%有意に短縮したが、位相変調5ケースが3.16〜12.47%有意に悪化した。Voiceの機械語サイズは27,632バイトのままで、指定した閾値では目的の展開を制限できなかった。出力fingerprintは全ケース一致した。
全実装・ケースをブロック内で無作為に実行し、各実行は最低10 msかつシナリオ1周のburn-in、ブロック間は5秒。48 kHz・4秒分生成、準備2秒分。Intel Core i9-14900K CPU 0、Rust 1.99.1、標準設定はopt-level=3・codegen-units=16(コンパイラ比較の変更は上記とmetadataへ記載)。対応差の両側t検定、比較ごとの全ケースへHolm補正α=0.05。差未検出は同等性の証明ではない。
37ケース、20ブロック、音声バッファ256サンプル、seed=120445。単位ns/frame、±は標準偏差、CIはケース単位95%。
logs/assets/optimization-12h-2026-11-04/R36-pgo-bounded/paired/performance.png
| Case | Blocks | Before mean ± SD | After mean ± SD | Difference mean ± SD | Difference 95% CI | t (df) | p | Holm p | Audio identical |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| sine-mono | 20 | 22.713 ± 0.459 | 21.640 ± 1.792 | -1.073 ± 1.892 | -1.958 … -0.187 | -2.536 (19) | 0.02015 | 0.02015 | True |
| saw-bass | 20 | 44.015 ± 0.326 | 40.289 ± 0.270 | -3.725 ± 0.382 | -3.904 … -3.547 | -43.61 (19) | 1.639e-20 | 4.589e-19 | True |
| triangle-pluck | 20 | 77.724 ± 0.777 | 71.806 ± 0.382 | -5.918 ± 0.814 | -6.299 … -5.537 | -32.53 (19) | 4.006e-18 | 6.009e-17 | True |
| square-lead | 20 | 45.156 ± 0.352 | 39.782 ± 0.302 | -5.374 ± 0.400 | -5.561 … -5.187 | -60.03 (19) | 3.944e-23 | 1.262e-21 | True |
| saw-chords | 20 | 256.626 ± 1.858 | 234.960 ± 1.188 | -21.666 ± 2.295 | -22.740 … -20.592 | -42.23 (19) | 2.999e-20 | 7.797e-19 | True |
| slow-pad | 20 | 353.788 ± 2.208 | 331.404 ± 1.535 | -22.384 ± 2.530 | -23.569 … -21.200 | -39.56 (19) | 1.022e-19 | 2.044e-18 | True |
| three-osc-keys | 20 | 241.323 ± 1.657 | 227.285 ± 1.418 | -14.038 ± 1.910 | -14.932 … -13.144 | -32.86 (19) | 3.304e-18 | 5.287e-17 | True |
| phase-mod-bell | 20 | 148.734 ± 0.440 | 163.012 ± 1.616 | 14.278 ± 1.774 | 13.448 … 15.108 | 35.99 (19) | 6.017e-19 | 1.083e-17 | True |
| soft-bass | 20 | 69.936 ± 0.316 | 65.185 ± 0.287 | -4.751 ± 0.498 | -4.984 … -4.518 | -42.66 (19) | 2.479e-20 | 6.694e-19 | True |
| hard-lead | 20 | 57.617 ± 0.264 | 50.186 ± 0.238 | -7.431 ± 0.404 | -7.620 … -7.242 | -82.29 (19) | 1.006e-25 | 3.522e-24 | True |
| idle-pad | 20 | 2.536 ± 0.127 | 1.669 ± 0.040 | -0.867 ± 0.137 | -0.931 … -0.803 | -28.34 (19) | 5.235e-17 | 5.077e-16 | True |
| auto-cutoff | 20 | 270.944 ± 2.166 | 248.543 ± 0.621 | -22.401 ± 2.003 | -23.338 … -21.463 | -50.01 (19) | 1.241e-21 | 3.602e-20 | True |
| auto-resonance | 20 | 293.929 ± 1.624 | 275.415 ± 1.193 | -18.514 ± 1.965 | -19.433 … -17.594 | -42.14 (19) | 3.114e-20 | 7.797e-19 | True |
| auto-drive | 20 | 514.248 ± 1.506 | 488.053 ± 22.951 | -26.195 ± 23.344 | -37.121 … -15.270 | -5.018 (19) | 7.63e-05 | 0.0002289 | True |
| auto-mix | 20 | 516.195 ± 4.712 | 483.228 ± 2.576 | -32.968 ± 5.162 | -35.384 … -30.552 | -28.56 (19) | 4.523e-17 | 4.975e-16 | True |
| auto-pan | 20 | 297.642 ± 3.010 | 279.132 ± 13.630 | -18.510 ± 13.911 | -25.021 … -12.000 | -5.951 (19) | 9.974e-06 | 4.987e-05 | True |
| auto-volume | 20 | 285.016 ± 1.827 | 265.507 ± 1.046 | -19.509 ± 2.102 | -20.493 … -18.525 | -41.5 (19) | 4.162e-20 | 9.572e-19 | True |
| auto-width | 20 | 292.034 ± 4.685 | 268.234 ± 0.838 | -23.800 ± 4.841 | -26.066 … -21.535 | -21.99 (19) | 5.658e-15 | 3.961e-14 | True |
| auto-phase-mod | 20 | 172.688 ± 1.143 | 187.631 ± 1.038 | 14.943 ± 1.637 | 14.177 … 15.709 | 40.83 (19) | 5.645e-20 | 1.186e-18 | True |
| extra-auto-detune | 20 | 575.607 ± 4.844 | 479.954 ± 2.294 | -95.653 ± 4.324 | -97.677 … -93.629 | -98.92 (19) | 3.069e-27 | 1.105e-25 | True |
| extra-auto-amp-sustain | 20 | 426.296 ± 2.400 | 363.283 ± 0.892 | -63.013 ± 2.330 | -64.103 … -61.922 | -121 (19) | 6.75e-29 | 2.498e-27 | True |
| extra-auto-osc-volume | 20 | 321.205 ± 1.453 | 301.576 ± 2.528 | -19.629 ± 3.014 | -21.039 … -18.218 | -29.12 (19) | 3.143e-17 | 3.772e-16 | True |
| extra-auto-osc-tune | 20 | 332.970 ± 2.078 | 312.372 ± 2.213 | -20.598 ± 2.996 | -22.000 … -19.196 | -30.75 (19) | 1.141e-17 | 1.483e-16 | True |
| holdout-noise-percussion | 20 | 60.903 ± 1.965 | 58.268 ± 1.123 | -2.635 ± 2.087 | -3.611 … -1.658 | -5.647 (19) | 1.913e-05 | 7.65e-05 | True |
| holdout-bright-pad | 20 | 361.737 ± 2.225 | 337.151 ± 1.251 | -24.586 ± 2.621 | -25.812 … -23.359 | -41.94 (19) | 3.404e-20 | 8.17e-19 | True |
| holdout-bandpass-pluck | 20 | 157.436 ± 3.120 | 154.993 ± 1.690 | -2.443 ± 3.656 | -4.154 … -0.732 | -2.988 (19) | 0.007554 | 0.01511 | True |
| holdout-highpass-chords | 20 | 286.838 ± 1.265 | 274.266 ± 1.646 | -12.572 ± 2.146 | -13.576 … -11.567 | -26.2 (19) | 2.24e-16 | 1.792e-15 | True |
| holdout-soft-stereo | 20 | 425.902 ± 2.499 | 393.037 ± 0.853 | -32.865 ± 2.770 | -34.162 … -31.569 | -53.07 (19) | 4.042e-22 | 1.253e-20 | True |
| holdout-hard-stereo | 20 | 353.231 ± 0.757 | 337.087 ± 1.688 | -16.144 ± 1.745 | -16.960 … -15.327 | -41.38 (19) | 4.388e-20 | 9.653e-19 | True |
| holdout-square-mod | 20 | 127.176 ± 0.496 | 131.201 ± 1.030 | 4.024 ± 1.313 | 3.410 … 4.639 | 13.71 (19) | 2.655e-11 | 1.593e-10 | True |
| holdout-triangle-mod | 20 | 188.146 ± 0.725 | 201.265 ± 1.718 | 13.119 ± 1.824 | 12.265 … 13.972 | 32.17 (19) | 4.926e-18 | 6.896e-17 | True |
| holdout-cutoff-envelope | 20 | 383.805 ± 2.317 | 339.621 ± 5.621 | -44.185 ± 5.899 | -46.945 … -41.424 | -33.5 (19) | 2.314e-18 | 3.933e-17 | True |
| holdout-resonance-bandpass | 20 | 252.727 ± 1.934 | 238.077 ± 1.584 | -14.650 ± 2.308 | -15.731 … -13.570 | -28.38 (19) | 5.077e-17 | 5.077e-16 | True |
| holdout-drive-stereo | 20 | 516.407 ± 3.184 | 483.444 ± 1.386 | -32.963 ± 2.943 | -34.340 … -31.585 | -50.09 (19) | 1.201e-21 | 3.602e-20 | True |
| holdout-detune | 20 | 544.188 ± 3.937 | 459.744 ± 3.421 | -84.444 ± 5.637 | -87.082 … -81.806 | -67 (19) | 4.936e-24 | 1.629e-22 | True |
| holdout-mod-depth | 20 | 532.981 ± 3.531 | 599.454 ± 3.020 | 66.474 ± 4.393 | 64.418 … 68.530 | 67.67 (19) | 4.085e-24 | 1.389e-22 | True |
| holdout-osc-tune | 20 | 389.197 ± 2.393 | 366.336 ± 1.952 | -22.861 ± 2.791 | -24.167 … -21.555 | -36.64 (19) | 4.317e-19 | 8.203e-18 | True |
ソースパッチは固定基準27ecc45との差分。ビルド・測定条件はmetadataとJSONに記録する。