Cookies are not set during redirect

[jackhftang]

I am testing RestSharp with opera cookies test suite . It seems RestSharp do not handle set-cookie during redirection, and hence all subsequent tests fail.

let client = new RestClient()
client.CookieContainer <- new System.Net.CookieContainer ()
let req = new RestRequest("http://testsuites.opera.com/cookies/001.php", Method.GET)
let res = client.Execute(req) 
if res.ErrorException <> null then
  printfn "%A" res.ErrorException
else 
  printfn "%s" res.Content

[sherpc]

At this time bug is still present. Maybe it's a feature?

[hallem]

It's not a feature, it's a bug. I have just not gotten to it yet.

[kjellski]

+1 for this fix, don't know how, any advice on how to help here?

[pashidlos]

same for me :(

[RodrigoGroener]

+1

[ashw1984]

+1

[tuxuser]

Same issue for me, only a single cookie gets parsed.

Here is some more detailed info:

RestClient client = new RestClient("https://login.live.com");
RestRequest req = new RestRequest("oauth20_authorize.srf", Method.GET);

req.AddQueryParameter("response_type", "token");
req.AddQueryParameter("scope", "service::user.auth.xboxlive.com::MBI_SSL");
req.AddQueryParameter("redirect_uri", "https://login.live.com/oauth20_desktop.srf");
req.AddQueryParameter("client_id", "0000000048093EE3");
req.AddQueryParameter("display", "touch");
req.AddQueryParameter("locale", "en");

client.FollowRedirects = false;
IRestResponse resp = client.Execute(req);

Debug.Assert(resp.Cookies.Count > 1, "Cookie parsing incomplete");

Returned cookie string
Set-Cookie=MSPRequ=lt=<OBFUSCATED>&co=1&id=N; secure= ;path=/;HTTPOnly=;version=1, uaid=<OBFUSCATED>; domain=login.live.com;secure= ;path=/;HTTPOnly= ;version=1, MSPOK=$uuid-<OBFUSCATED>; domain=login.live.com;secure= ;path=/;HTTPOnly= ;version=1

Expected parsed cookies
MSPOK, uaid, MSPRequ

Actually parsed cookies
MSPRequ

UPDATE: Looks like the issue is NOT RestSharp but rather the underlying System.Net.Http - > https://github.com/dotnet/corefx/issues/29651

[alexeyzimarev]

It is, unfortunately, how HttpWebRequest works.

[alexeyzimarev]

@tuxuser if you set FollowRedirects to false, you will never get to the actual endpoint, so that won't work anyway.

[alexeyzimarev]

I added a branch that porentiall can fix the issue, although, to be honest, I think we just need to wait until it is fixed in the .NET Framework. If anyone is willing to test it - please do
https://github.com/restsharp/RestSharp/tree/fix/cookies-redirect

The Opera test suite is no longer available and I have no resources that I know that can help me testing this issue. I am closing it for now.

[jotzhao]

how about the issue ? this problem occured on v110.2.0