Skip to content

Conversation

@Shahab96
Copy link
Collaborator

@Shahab96 Shahab96 commented Nov 13, 2025

Summary

This PR adds comprehensive documentation, reorganizes examples, and establishes a project roadmap to guide development toward v1.0. These additions provide critical architectural understanding, prevent common misconfigurations, and create a foundation for community discussion.

Changes

📚 Documentation (docs/)

  • architecture-decisions.md (469 lines)

    • Documents RustFS unified cluster architecture
    • Explains erasure coding behavior and data distribution
    • Clarifies valid vs invalid multi-pool use cases
    • Warns about storage class mixing pitfalls
  • multi-pool-use-cases.md (430 lines)

    • Comprehensive guide for multi-pool scenarios
    • Valid use cases: capacity expansion, geographic distribution, spot instances, hardware migration
    • Anti-patterns to avoid with detailed explanations
    • Real-world examples and best practices
  • DEVELOPMENT-NOTES.md (224 lines)

    • Development workflow and build commands
    • Testing procedures and contribution guidelines
    • Code organization and architecture overview

📋 Examples Reorganization

Moved examples from deploy/rustfs-operator/examples/ to project root examples/ for better visibility.

New Examples Added:

  • cluster-expansion-tenant.yaml - Capacity expansion and hardware migration
  • geographic-pools-tenant.yaml - Multi-region deployment with topology constraints
  • hardware-pools-tenant.yaml - Heterogeneous disk sizes (same storage class)
  • spot-instance-tenant.yaml - Cost optimization using spot instances
  • production-ha-tenant.yaml - Production HA with topology spread constraints
  • README.md - Comprehensive usage guide with kubectl verification commands

Enhanced Existing Examples:

  • simple-tenant.yaml - Added scheduling field documentation
  • minimal-dev-tenant.yaml - Corrected port references
  • custom-rbac-tenant.yaml - Clarified RBAC patterns
  • multi-pool-tenant.yaml - Fixed syntax and structure

All examples include:

  • Inline documentation explaining configuration choices
  • Architectural warnings about RustFS behavior
  • kubectl verification commands
  • Production best practices

📝 CHANGELOG.md (175 lines)

Following Keep a Changelog format:

  • Documents all changes from v0.1.0 through unreleased features
  • Multi-pool scheduling enhancements (2025-11-08)
  • Critical port corrections (console: 9090→9001, IO: 90→9000)
  • Volume path standardization (/data/{N}/data/rustfs{N})
  • Architecture corrections and clarifications
  • Verification against RustFS source code, Helm charts, and official docs

🗺️ ROADMAP.md (346 lines)

Establishes clear development path toward v1.0:

  • Core Stability

    • Secret-based credential management
    • Status condition management
    • StatefulSet update/rollout management
    • Integration tests
  • Advanced Features

    • Tenant lifecycle management with finalizers
    • Pool lifecycle operations (add/remove/scale)
    • TLS/certificate automation
    • Monitoring and alerting
  • Enterprise Features

    • Multi-tenancy enhancements
    • Security hardening (Pod Security Standards)
    • Compliance and audit logging
    • Advanced networking
  • Production Ready

    • 95%+ test coverage
    • Complete documentation
    • Ecosystem integration (OperatorHub, Helm)
    • Community support channels

Also includes:

  • Technical debt tracking
  • Community contribution goals
  • Success metrics
  • Release schedule (quarterly pre-1.0, monthly post-1.0)

Statistics

  • 16 files changed: 3,879 insertions(+), 31 deletions(-)
  • New documentation: ~3,900 lines
  • New examples: 8 comprehensive YAML files
  • Commits: 4 well-organized commits

Testing

  • Documentation reviewed for accuracy against RustFS source
  • Examples validated for correct Kubernetes syntax
  • All examples include verification commands
  • No code changes - documentation only

Impact

  • ✅ Prevents common misconfigurations through architecture docs
  • ✅ Accelerates new user onboarding with comprehensive examples
  • ✅ Establishes clear project direction with roadmap
  • ✅ Creates foundation for community contribution
  • ✅ 100% backward compatible (no breaking changes)

Discussion Points

This PR is intended to facilitate discussion around:

  1. Roadmap priorities - Are the proposed features and timeline reasonable?
  2. Example coverage - Are there additional use cases we should document?
  3. Architecture understanding - Any corrections or clarifications needed?
  4. Community goals - How can we best support contributors?

Feedback welcome on all aspects! 🙏

Added three key documentation files to guide operator development and usage:

- architecture-decisions.md: Documents critical architectural understanding of
  RustFS unified cluster model, erasure coding behavior, and valid/invalid
  multi-pool use cases. Includes warnings about storage class mixing pitfalls.

- multi-pool-use-cases.md: Comprehensive guide covering valid multi-pool
  scenarios (capacity expansion, geographic distribution, spot instances,
  hardware migration) with concrete examples and anti-patterns to avoid.

- DEVELOPMENT-NOTES.md: Development workflow documentation including build
  commands, testing procedures, and contribution guidelines.

These docs prevent common misconfigurations and establish architectural
understanding for contributors.
Moved examples from deploy/rustfs-operator/examples/ to project root examples/
directory for better visibility and accessibility.

New examples added:
- cluster-expansion-tenant.yaml: Demonstrates capacity expansion and gradual
  hardware migration using multiple pools
- geographic-pools-tenant.yaml: Multi-region deployment with topology
  constraints for compliance and disaster recovery
- hardware-pools-tenant.yaml: Heterogeneous disk sizes within same storage
  class for efficient capacity utilization
- spot-instance-tenant.yaml: Cost optimization using spot instances with
  appropriate tolerations and affinity rules
- production-ha-tenant.yaml: Production-ready HA setup with topology spread
  constraints and resource limits
- README.md: Comprehensive guide with usage instructions, architectural
  warnings, and kubectl verification commands

Enhanced existing examples:
- simple-tenant.yaml: Added documentation for all scheduling fields
- minimal-dev-tenant.yaml: Corrected port references
- custom-rbac-tenant.yaml: Clarified RBAC patterns
- multi-pool-tenant.yaml: Fixed syntax and structure

All examples include:
- Inline documentation explaining configuration choices
- Architectural warnings about RustFS unified cluster behavior
- kubectl verification commands for testing
- Best practices for production deployments

Removed:
- deploy/rustfs-operator/examples/multi-pool-tenant.yaml (moved to examples/)
- deploy/rustfs-operator/examples/simple-tenant.yaml (moved to examples/)
Added CHANGELOG.md following Keep a Changelog format to track all notable
changes to the RustFS Kubernetes Operator.

Documented changes include:
- Multi-pool scheduling enhancements (2025-11-08)
- Required environment variables additions (2025-11-05)
- Critical port corrections (console: 9090→9001, IO: 90→9000)
- Volume path standardization (/data/{N} → /data/rustfs{N})
- Architecture corrections and clarifications
- Example improvements and bug fixes
- Documentation of valid vs invalid multi-pool use cases

Key architectural facts documented:
- Unified cluster architecture (all pools form ONE erasure-coded cluster)
- Uniform data distribution across ALL volumes
- No storage class awareness or intelligent placement
- Performance limited by slowest storage class
- External tiering via lifecycle policies

Verification against RustFS source code, Helm charts, and official
documentation ensures accuracy.

Test status: 25 tests passing, backward compatibility maintained.
Added ROADMAP.md outlining development plans from v0.2.0 through v1.0.0 and
beyond. This document serves as a foundation for community discussion and
priority alignment.

Key sections:
- Current status (v0.1.0) with completed features and known issues
- v0.2.0 (Q1 2026): Core stability with Secret management, status conditions,
  improved error handling, and integration tests
- v0.3.0 (Q2 2026): Advanced lifecycle management, pool operations, TLS
  automation, and monitoring integration
- v0.4.0 (Q3 2026): Enterprise features including multi-tenancy, security
  hardening, compliance, and advanced networking
- v1.0.0 (Q4 2026): Production ready with stability guarantees, complete
  documentation, and ecosystem integration
- Post-1.0: Future considerations (GitOps, multi-cluster, AI/ML optimization)

Also includes:
- Technical debt tracking
- Community and contribution goals
- Release schedule (quarterly pre-1.0, monthly post-1.0)
- Success metrics and contribution guidelines

Target 1.0 release: Q4 2026

This roadmap is a living document open to community input and feedback.
@Shahab96 Shahab96 changed the title Feature/docs and roadmap docs: Add comprehensive documentation, examples, and project roadmap Nov 13, 2025
@Shahab96 Shahab96 marked this pull request as ready for review November 13, 2025 07:07
@Shahab96 Shahab96 requested a review from bestgopher as a code owner November 13, 2025 07:07
Enhanced CLAUDE.md with critical information from recent documentation:

Critical Architectural Understanding:
- Added prominent warning about RustFS unified cluster architecture
- Clarified that all pools form ONE cluster, not separate clusters
- Documented valid vs invalid multi-pool use cases
- Reference to architecture-decisions.md for detailed ADRs

RustFS-Specific Standards:
- Service ports verified against source (IO: 9000, Console: 9001)
- Volume path patterns (/data/rustfs{N})
- Required environment variables
- Credential requirements

Enhanced Documentation:
- Updated CRD validation rules (2-server, 3-server requirements)
- SchedulingConfig with flatten pattern
- Persistence config details
- New spec fields: image_pull_policy, pod_management_policy

Development Context:
- Known issues and TODOs with specific line numbers
- Documentation structure (CHANGELOG, ROADMAP, docs/, examples/)
- All 10 examples organized by category
- Development priorities from ROADMAP (without timelines)
- Test coverage: 25 tests passing

Verification Standards:
- Sources for verifying RustFS behavior
- Warning against inventing features

This provides comprehensive guidance for future development sessions.
@bestgopher
Copy link
Collaborator

Is this ready to be merged?

@Shahab96
Copy link
Collaborator Author

Is this ready to be merged?

Yes

@bestgopher bestgopher merged commit da71fec into rustfs:main Nov 13, 2025
2 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

2 participants