Planner proposal: Triage Failed PR #4

[secup]

Planner generated this proposal from local file:

agents/planner/proposals/001-20260430_160610-triage-failed-pr-4.md

Approval commands:

• /approve codex: queue for Codex
• /approve claude: queue for Claude
• /hold: keep open but stop approval polling
• /reject: reject this proposal

Only usernames listed in AGENT_APPROVERS on the agentic laptop are honored.
The approval watcher only writes a local ignored task file; it cannot merge PRs or push to main.

Proposal

Triage Failed PR #4

Goal

Determine whether PR #4 should be fixed, rerun, or closed. This is a
review/triage task, not an authorization to merge.

Project goal: critical software quality and agentic development discipline from
docs/PROJECT_GOALS.md.

Context

• PR: Agent task: 001-bench-matrix #4
• Title: Agent task: 001-bench-matrix
• Branch: agent/20260430_145232-001-bench-matrix
• Planner report: agents/planner/reports/20260430_160610/report.md

Allowed Files

• No code changes for the first pass.
• If the failure is clearly a small tooling/test issue, produce a separate
  repair plan before editing.

Out Of Scope

• Do not merge the PR.
• Do not bypass CI.
• Do not change modem behavior while doing initial triage.

Required Local Gate

Not required for initial triage. If a repair is made, run:

./agents/run_local_gate.sh

Required Hardware Or Benchmark Gate

Not required unless the PR changes PHY/ARQ/audio/hardware behavior.

Reject Conditions

• Treating a red CI job as acceptable without a root-cause explanation.
• Closing useful work without preserving the reason in the PR.
• Making production changes before the failure mode is classified.

Expected Output

• Failure class: real bug, CI flake, stale branch, external dependency, or low-value PR.
• Recommended action: fix branch, rerun CI, close PR, or split into smaller tasks.
• Exact logs or commands used.

[secup]

Closing duplicate planner proposal. Keeping #9 as the active Triage Failed PR #4 proposal.