Skip to content

[Docs]: Incorrect references in skill-reviewer agent #112

@sjnims

Description

@sjnims

Which documentation needs improvement?

Agent documentation

Specific Location

plugins/plugin-dev/agents/skill-reviewer.md - Lines 44 and 57

What's unclear or missing?

The skill-reviewer agent contains two inaccurate references:

Issue 1: Reference to non-existent "skill-creator" (Line 44)

Current text:

"Check adherence to skill-creator best practices"

Problem: There is no skill-creator agent in this plugin. The plugin has:

  • agent-creator (for creating agents)
  • skill-reviewer (for reviewing skills)
  • plugin-validator (for validating plugins)

Issue 2: Undocumented when_to_use deprecation claim (Line 57)

Current text:

"Optional fields: version, when_to_use (note: deprecated, use description only)"

Problem: The when_to_use field and its deprecation status are not mentioned in the official Claude Code documentation:

This claim cannot be verified against official docs and may confuse users or become outdated.

Suggested Improvement

Fix 1: Update line 44

Change:

4. Check adherence to skill-creator best practices

To:

4. Check adherence to skill development best practices

Or:

4. Check adherence to best practices from the skill-development skill

Fix 2: Update line 57

Either:

  • Option A: Remove the deprecation note if when_to_use was never an official field
  • Option B: Add a source citation if the deprecation is documented elsewhere
  • Option C: Simplify to just list the optional fields without deprecation commentary

Suggested:

- Optional fields: `version` (others may exist per Claude Code updates)

Type of issue

  • Incorrect information
  • Missing information
  • Unclear explanation
  • Broken link
  • Typo or grammar
  • Outdated content
  • Other

Additional Context

These issues were discovered during a comprehensive review of all 3 plugin subagents against official Claude Code plugin documentation.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Projects

No projects

Milestone

No milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions