Skip to content

Add specscore consilium verdict subcommand #8

@trakhimenok

Description

@trakhimenok

Context

The sidekick-consilium Feature in synchestra-io/specstudio-skills ships the contract for a new deterministic CLI arbiter that turns 9 typed votes (from a 9-role panel) into a verdict. REQs specscore-consilium-verdict-subcommand, arbiter-gate-rules, arbiter-reproducibility, and roster-validation define the contract.

Tracking stub in the producing repo: spec/plans/sidekick-consilium-arbiter-companion.md.

What needs to ship

A new subcommand specscore consilium verdict accepting --votes, --roster, --gate, --seed. Applies the 13-step gate algorithm from REQ arbiter-gate-rules and emits a structured YAML verdict + rule_trace to stdout. Snapshot-testable: same inputs always produce identical output.

Acceptance

A 13-step gate algorithm implementation with snapshot tests over fixtures covering each rule path: adversary-veto, low-confidence-abstain veto, strict-gate pass, supermajority pass (when require_all_builders=false), median-confidence-fails, cost-ceiling-fails, complexity-ceiling-fails, builders-majority-reject, and the fall-through to needs-human-review.

Cross-reference

  • Feature spec: spec/features/sidekick-consilium/README.md REQs 23–25
  • Companion plan: spec/plans/sidekick-consilium-arbiter-companion.md

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions