Skip to content

Fix #7 #8: escape hatches for disciplined-* skills + judge 5-level verdict ladder#71

Merged
AlexMikhalev merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
feat/7-8-escape-hatches-verdict-ladder
May 10, 2026
Merged

Fix #7 #8: escape hatches for disciplined-* skills + judge 5-level verdict ladder#71
AlexMikhalev merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
feat/7-8-escape-hatches-verdict-ladder

Conversation

@AlexMikhalev
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Fixes #7, Fixes #8

Changes

#7: Escape hatches for disciplined-* skills

  • Added "Skip This Skill When..." section to all 7 disciplined-* SKILL.md files
  • Each skill has context-appropriate trivial-change escape criteria
  • Prevents the Eberhardt/Scott Logic bloat failure mode

#8: Judge 5-level verdict ladder

  • Extended verdict-schema.json from v1 (accept/improve/reject) to v2 (BLOCK/FIX_FIRST/SAFE_TO_COMMIT/SAFE_TO_DEPLOY_AFTER_RUNTIME_CHECK/INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE)
  • Updated run-judge.sh prompts, validation, and flow logic
  • Updated pre-push-judge.sh exit code labels
  • Updated judge SKILL.md with v2 thresholds and migration table
  • Updated kg/judge-verdicts.md with new synonyms

Test plan

  • verdict-schema.json validates as valid JSON
  • run-judge.sh passes bash syntax check
  • pre-push-judge.sh passes bash syntax check
  • Run CJE calibration with new ladder
  • Verify GPT-5 Nano correctly emits INSUFFICIENT_EVIDENCE on borderline cases

… to disciplined-* skills (#7) and extend judge verdict to 5-level ladder (#8)

Refs #7: Add 'Skip This Skill When...' sections to all 7 disciplined-* SKILL.md files
Refs #8: Extend verdict-schema.json from binary GO/NO-GO to 5-level ladder
(BLOCK, FIX FIRST, SAFE TO COMMIT, SAFE TO DEPLOY AFTER RUNTIME CHECK, INSUFFICIENT EVIDENCE)
Update run-judge.sh prompts, validation, and flow logic for new verdicts
Update pre-push-judge.sh exit code labels
Update judge SKILL.md with v2 thresholds and migration table
@AlexMikhalev AlexMikhalev merged commit 25bb372 into main May 10, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

quality-gate: Add ZDP gate checklists and ACGCS integration Convert Terraphim skills to Clawdbot skills (v0)

1 participant