@IsUrl() with options has bad feedback when invalid

[j-maas]

When you pass the URL test.org to the isUrl() validator with the option require_protocol, it simply returns "url must be an URL address". This is the same for the other options, like require_tld. A user will not be able to understand what they did wrong.

I understand that class-validator delegates the URL validation to another library, but it looks like that library simple returns false without further information. Now, I'm not sure whether to open the issue here or on that library.

Is it possible to add discrimination of these errors here?

[NoNameProvided]

Hi @y0hy0h!

As you wrote we do not have the reason why the validation failed, so we can show only a general error message. You can try opening an issue at that repo to see if they are willing to add different function calls for it.

[lock]

This thread has been automatically locked since there has not been any recent activity after it was closed. Please open a new issue for related bugs.