Skip to content

audit: PR #260 (ui-014 DOM test environment) - Grade B#268

Closed
vertz-tech-lead[bot] wants to merge 10 commits intomainfrom
audit/pr260-ui-014
Closed

audit: PR #260 (ui-014 DOM test environment) - Grade B#268
vertz-tech-lead[bot] wants to merge 10 commits intomainfrom
audit/pr260-ui-014

Conversation

@vertz-tech-lead
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

Audit Summary

PR Audited: #260 - feat(ui-014): Configure bun test with happy-dom environment for task-manager
Agent: vertz-dev-dx[bot]
Grade: B
Merged: 2026-02-14T00:58:21Z

Key Findings

Strengths:

  • Successfully delivered test infrastructure (13/17 tests now passing vs 0/17)
  • Clean, focused implementation
  • Proper git/PR process (branch naming, commits, different reviewer)
  • Tests existed before this PR (TDD compliant for infrastructure work)
  • Quality gates passed (tests, typecheck, lint)

⚠️ Major Issue:

  • Missing changeset for package.json change (added happy-dom dependency)
  • This violates RULES.md requirement for all package modifications

Recommendations

  1. Immediate: Add changeset for future package.json changes
  2. Update ticket status (UI-014 still shows Todo)
  3. Enforce changesets with pre-commit hooks

Files Added

  • plans/audits/2026-02-14-pr260-dx.md — Human-readable report
  • plans/audits/data/2026-02-14-pr260-dx.json — Machine-readable structured data

Full report: See markdown file for detailed evidence and recommendations.


Auditor: agent:auditor (subagent)
Timestamp: 2026-02-14T14:06:00Z

vertz-tech-lead[bot] and others added 10 commits February 14, 2026 13:11
- Move DOM shim from task-manager example into @vertz/ui-server/dom-shim
- Add SSRNode, SSRElement, SSRTextNode, SSRDocumentFragment classes
- Add installDomShim(), removeDomShim(), toVNode() utilities
- Add server-side JSX runtime to @vertz/ui-server/jsx-runtime
- Support VNode generation for SSR without DOM
- Add comprehensive tests for DOM shim and JSX runtime
- Export both as subpaths in package.json

Part of zero-config SSR milestone (issue #265)
- Add jsx(), jsxs(), jsxDEV(), Fragment() for DOM-based rendering
- Export as @vertz/ui/jsx-runtime subpath
- Add comprehensive tests with happy-dom environment
- Supports event handlers, attributes, children, and components

Part of zero-config SSR milestone (issue #265)
- Add ssr: boolean | SSROptions to plugin options
- Implement configureServer hook that intercepts HTML requests
- Auto-generate virtual SSR entry module (\0vertz:ssr-entry)
- Install DOM shim and render app server-side
- Inject SSR'd HTML into index.html template
- Add JSX runtime alias swap for SSR builds (@vertz/ui → @vertz/ui-server)
- Support auto-detection of entry from index.html
- Support <!--ssr-outlet--> or <div id="app"> injection

Part of zero-config SSR milestone (issue #265)
- Auto-detect SSR context (globalThis.__SSR_URL__)
- Use __SSR_URL__ instead of window.location in SSR
- Skip popstate listener setup in SSR
- Skip history.pushState/replaceState in SSR
- Make initialUrl parameter optional (auto-detect from context)
- All router tests still pass

Part of zero-config SSR milestone (issue #265)
Delete ~500 lines of SSR boilerplate:
- src/dom-shim.ts (SSRElement, installDomShim — now in @vertz/ui-server/dom-shim)
- src/jsx-runtime-server.ts (server JSX — now in @vertz/ui-server/jsx-runtime)
- src/jsx-dev-runtime-server.ts (dev re-export)
- src/entry-server.ts (SSR entry — now auto-generated by vertz plugin)
- src/entry-client.ts (client entry — merged into index.ts)
- src/server.ts (custom Vite middleware server — no longer needed)
- src/jsx-runtime.ts (client JSX — now in @vertz/ui/jsx-runtime)
- src/__tests__/dom-shim.test.ts (moved to ui-server)
- src/__tests__/jsx-runtime-server.test.ts (moved to ui-server)

Update config:
- vite.config.ts: add ssr: true to vertzPlugin()
- tsconfig.json: jsxImportSource → @vertz/ui
- package.json: remove jsx-runtime/jsx-dev-runtime exports

Update src/index.ts:
- Export App as default for SSR auto-detection
- Skip client-only init during SSR
- Handle SSR→client remount

Add @vertz/ui jsx-dev-runtime subpath (aliases to jsx-runtime)

Part of zero-config SSR milestone (issue #265)
- Test SSR option parsing (true, options object)
- Test virtual SSR entry module resolution and generation
- Test configureServer hook behavior (enabled/disabled)
- Test JSX runtime alias swap for SSR builds
- 12 new tests, all passing

Part of zero-config SSR milestone (issue #265)
- Add type assertion in @vertz/ui-server/jsx-runtime line 34 (VNode | RawHtml)
- Update return type in @vertz/ui/jsx-runtime to Node | Node[] | null
- Create globals.d.ts to declare __SSR_URL__ global for SSR context

Addresses Nora's review comments on PR #267.
All packages now pass typecheck.
@vertz-tech-lead
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Closing due to worktree pollution. This PR was created from a dirty worktree and contains 10 commits of SSR implementation (36 files changed) that belong to PR #267, not an audit document.

The branch was created while uncommitted SSR work was present in the working tree, causing it to include the entire SSR feature instead of just an audit document.

If an audit document for PR #260 is needed, it should be recreated from a clean main branch with only the audit markdown file.

@vertz-tech-lead vertz-tech-lead Bot closed this Feb 14, 2026
@viniciusdacal viniciusdacal deleted the audit/pr260-ui-014 branch February 22, 2026 16:15
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

0 participants