-
Notifications
You must be signed in to change notification settings - Fork 913
Entropy - fix off by ones in continuous testing #8820
New issue
Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.
By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.
Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account
Conversation
|
@SparkiDev can you rebase this on master please so you get the updates to the workflow file? There are known issues with Ubuntu mirrors at the moment so the following has been added to the workflow file to update the repositories list after VM creation. Unfortunately your PR workflow file is missing the updates: LATEST: Your branch: |
038de3b to
ecba6eb
Compare
|
rebased and now failing on multi-test that is failing for all PRs. |
88beaec to
2fa7b9b
Compare
|
retest this please |
kaleb-himes
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Lab assessing the solution has approved of the changes and noted all concerns have been addressed.
|
I did notice a new behavior with this update, one now has to call wolfCrypt_Init() two times, once to "prime the entropy source" and then a second time to get a successful init. The first call seems to fail 100% of the time with Do we want to look into that more or is that expected? |
|
Since we're making a change anyway, now might be a good time to address that longer initial time slice we were seeing during startup sequences due the SHA3-256 Conditional Algorithm Self Test (CAST) on initial priming of the entropy pool, here is a tentitive patch to address that if you care to include it (no obligation): |
kaleb-himes
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Upon further testing there is an issue with the solution, seeing a failure in the adaptive proportion test.
1704 setting prop_cnt[12] updated to 3
1705 setting prop_cnt[87] updated to 3
1706 setting prop_cnt[154] updated to 2
1707 setting prop_cnt[140] updated to 3
1708 setting prop_cnt[177] updated to 2
1709 setting prop_cnt[146] updated to 1
1710 setting prop_cnt[200] updated to 2
5060 23,218,41,145,64,143,29,90,125,50,64,206,134,154,6,38,55,
5061 157,201,67,81,79,96,0,151,128,67,23,146,148,99,201,32,
5062 154,186,192,233,55,111,119,230,52,61,70,175,154,110,233,169,
5063 215,157,134,236,209,64,3,250,114,84,218,58,213,189,55,26,
5064 47,23,227,128,233,157,241,210,253,157,128,67,32,227,64,55,
5065 253,247,32,239,125,186,186,137,87,169,61,87,12,128,166,119,
5066 76,61,189,151,239,55,55,201,134,215,250,143,102,139,108,137,
5067 177,76,224,32,145,41,113,117,154,253,192,253,210,17,160,186,
5068 253,163,105,186,134,157,26,169,116,160,82,43,210,221,137,110,
5069 128,221,73,201,250,224,198,20,58,79,134,200,131,178,35,81,
5070 9,227,49,93,105,12,87,154,140,177,146,200,47,244,93,131,
5071 47,134,116,183,172,169,55,102,238,41,0,41,49,29,181,96,
5072 122,186,230,131,186,250,218,175,3,250,253,218,35,23,64,24,
5073 145,154,96,163,207,107,213,49,111,81,175,131,136,35,137,23,
5074 108,125,55,21,49,15,215,218,47,160,160,148,73,163,218,195,
5075 145,204,157,221,20,53,163,235,131,166,154,250,3,32,160,224,
5076 128,221,192,166,207,215,204,241,47,55,96,29,23,236,177,201,
5077 140,116,23,227,175,253,96,58,119,195,163,198,250,221,245,139,
5078 175,113,99,93,32,245,115,190,99,67,192,134,177,79,87,108,
5079 61,58,209,35,21,119,209,99,149,148,140,142,125,169,160,6,
5080 180,189,82,125,96,145,85,119,241,70,186,184,253,14,79,52,
5081 236,230,139,61,112,118,221,236,20,99,160,224,169,169,244,192,
5082 90,163,93,41,227,230,58,93,195,110,96,6,236,6,235,18,
5083 189,6,244,9,61,154,137,64,189,192,67,203,73,47,81,6,
5084 134,58,35,195,55,140,154,81,134,38,157,125,204,157,206,56,
5085 218,23,233,87,32,143,49,221,50,20,157,224,111,87,55,32,
5086 172,67,75,76,90,108,189,131,119,47,11,0,108,49,21,180,
5087 207,40,120,145,160,102,9,206,70,70,119,68,98,241,236,90,
5088 239,23,250,218,73,55,128,169,137,90,201,64,55,9,99,183,
5089 180,236,163,55,35,73,128,96,122,70,122,134,195,174,64,242,
5090 128,43,64,201,186,29,137,87,128,93,105,99,186,204,81,61,
5091 73,35,230,90,134,177,149,183,102,218,253,76,203,73,233,
5092 prop_cnt[val]: (65535) 1111 1111 1111 1111
5093 PROP_CUTOFF: (325) 0000 0001 0100 0101
5094 The value 200 appears 65535 times in the window
200 only appears in the window 2 times, not 65535 times. Something is a little off yet, we should re-assess.
4ac4a5e to
eb6cf0c
Compare
|
Made sure all values are reset. |
|
retest this please |
rep_cnt is count of contiguous bytes with same value. First ever sample must set count to 1. Wasn't filling the cache up completely. Off by one in check for initial fill.
eb6cf0c to
c724c65
Compare
kaleb-himes
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Choose a reason for hiding this comment
The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.
Thanks @SparkiDev
Description
rep_cnt is count of contiguous bytes with same value.
First ever sample must set count to 1.
Wasn't filling the cache up completely.
Off by one in check for initial fill.
Testing
./configure --disable-shared --enable-entropy-memuse
Checklist