Replies: 11 comments 4 replies
|
@its475 Thanks a lot for all the detailed notes and suggestions – they’re very on point. |
|
@its475 Thanks for the detailed UI suggestions, most of them are in v1.17.0:
On the CPU/GPU fan gauges I decided to keep both the ring and the RPM readout rather than merge them, because they show two genuinely different things: the ring is the fan duty (the % power the profile/curve requests), while the value below is the resulting RPM (the physical speed, which also depends on temperature, wear and airflow). Showing duty as a 0-100% ring stays meaningful, and the RPM tile keeps the real-world number, so both are worth having. The circular gauges themselves and the dark-theme input fields you mentioned are noted for a future pass. Thanks again for the thoughtful feedback! |
|
@wygodad Hi After the latest update V1.17.1 I found some issues: |
|
@alibi90 Thanks for the detailed report - all three items are fixed in v1.18.0, just released:
v1.18.0 also brings a full visual refresh (new logo and icons, new dark theme matching the website, faster tab switching), so quite a lot changed - feedback is welcome as always. Thanks again for testing and writing this up! |
|
Hello @wygodad, I've taken a look at the new 1.18.0 update and I need to report some bugs and suggestions to improve the app. Let's start with the bugs. First of all, I don't understand why, when I go to the settings tab and modify/interact with the displayed overlay panels, checking the various options also selects the "Corners" field at the bottom right. (Video-2.mp4). VIdeo-2.mp4Another issue I've noticed is that if I enable the "Charge Limit" overlay, even though I've disabled the charging limit, the overlay still shows that the battery charge is limited to 60%. (Video-3.mp4). Video-3.mp4Another problem I've encountered with the overlay concerns the CPU and GPU fan speeds not being recorded (my PC is an MSI thin GF63 12VE). Additionally, the "Fan Boost" module in the overlay section doesn't appear at all, even if enabled in settings. The "Fan %" module in the overlay section also doesn't work because it shows me "40/0% fans" – so it's not actually recording fan speeds. (Image-9.png).
Now let's move on to suggestions. To start, I'd like to ask if it's possible to change the color of the input fields, particularly the borders of the "Shortcuts" section in settings, to match the app's theme. If you're using dark mode, they appear white and aren't very pleasant to look at. (Image-10.png).
Regarding the new app icon, I really don't like it – it looks like some kind of hack or something similar. Even the little ghost that appears in the system tray looks like some hacker or VPN app xD. Instead, if you want to keep this new icon, you could add a "Use Legacy Icon" option in the app settings to use the previous icon both in the system tray and the taskbar. (Image-11.png).
My last suggestion concerns the "Battery" section: in my opinion, you should remove this section from the settings if you intend to keep it already in the first "Scenario" tab, or vice versa. (Image-12.png). I believe that the fewer settings the user has in front of them, the cleaner and more intuitive the interface becomes.
Also, would it be possible to remove the "Send feedback" option when right-clicking on the GhostDeck icon in the system tray? Sorry, it's just that I believe the more minimal and clean an app appears, the clearer and more understandable it is to use. So, I think secondary functions shouldn't necessarily be eliminated, but at least made more compact or hidden within the app. Other than that, you've done an excellent job – I really like the new graphics, the new icons in the "Scenario" section, and the improved app theme. |
|
Thanks for the thorough testing - every item here led to a real fix. All of the below ships in v1.18.1:
Thanks again - this kind of report is exactly what makes the app better. |
|
A couple more of your points are handled in v1.19.0 (just released): "Start over" in the report wizards. Both wizards (Report my model and Fan curve) now have a Start over button next to the main one — so if you run a capture in the wrong MSI Center state, you can just reset and go again without restarting the app. Thanks for flagging that gap. The scroll glitching. I chased this one but want to be straight with you about where it landed: I tried the standard fix (compositing the whole window while scrolling), and it removed the tearing — but it made every tab noticeably slower to paint and flashed white on startup, so I reverted it. Instead, v1.19.0 rebuilds the window hidden shortly after startup and keeps it alive when you close it (it hides to the tray instead of being destroyed), which makes tab switching and reopening instant. If you still catch the scroll glitch on the new build, a short screen clip plus your Windows display scaling (100 % / 125 % / 150 %?) would really help me pin down the exact spot. On the collapsing-panels idea. It's a good one, and you actually named the catch yourself: the settings cards sit in two columns of different heights. If one panel collapses, that column suddenly gets shorter, everything below it jumps up, and the two columns end up badly mismatched — so a naive "collapse when disabled" makes the layout feel jumpy. I'm keeping it on the list in a narrower form: collapse only the tallest sections (Gaming overlay, Keyboard shortcuts) to their header when turned off, which wouldn't disturb the rest of the grid. No timeline promise, but it's noted. Everything above is in the latest release — thanks again for the detailed testing, it genuinely shapes each update. |
|
@wygodad Hi, I've taken a look at the new update and I have a request for you. Is there a way to set a profile to activate automatically at PC startup? For example, if I want my PC to boot up with the "Silent" profile automatically active, or "Performance", is that possible? |
|
@wygodad Furthermore, I really appreciate the new features you've added, but be aware that the settings are becoming more cluttered. It's normal – the more features and customizations are added, the more the settings panel becomes messy and less intuitive. I would consider the idea of collapsible panels for features that are disabled. However, you'll have to try out some solution yourself to make this idea work. You could either put all the settings modules on a single row, or try to align rows of similar height by pairing them up. |
|
@its475 Your "the settings are becoming more cluttered" comment kept nagging me - you were right, the page had quietly grown to eleven sections. v1.24.0 rebuilds the whole tab:
Also in this release, since you were the first to push for cleaner UI overall: the Updates tab now shows full release notes inline (click an entry) with download counts, and from 1.24.0 every published Thanks again for the honest feedback - it directly shaped this release. |
|
Hi @wygodad , I took a look at the newly released GhostDeck update and I have some suggestions for you, as well as a few bugs to report. Let's start with the bugs. As you can see from the video, the "Settings" > "Gaming" section has a bug with the app window resizing (Video-6.mp4). Video-6.1.mp4As for the "Settings" section, I think it would be better if the app defaulted back to the "Start" screen every time I click the settings icon again, instead of picking up from the last sub-category I touched. I'm not sure if this is intentional or not. I really like the new settings section, especially the "Start" page, which makes the interface very clean. The only thing I don't really appreciate is the top panel for choosing the subsection. If I can already use the large panels by clicking on them to access the settings sub-sections, what's the point of adding the top grid as well? (Image-13.png) As for going back to the "Start" settings page, simply clicking the settings icon at the top again would be enough.
Regarding the other settings sections, a couple of icons are still missing—for example, in "Settings" > "Power" > "Display"—but these are minor details (Image-14.png).
The "Hotkeys" section is nice, but I would opt for something that expands to full screen, like the "Gaming" section. As for the "Status" section, I would use the same interface as "Settings" > "Start", adding a page identical to the settings start page where you can access the "Charts", "History", "Gaming", "EC Bytes", and "Change log" sub-sections. Maybe add another subsection like "Fan Curve" to make it an even 6. Other than that, I really like the new interface. It could still be simplified and made a bit more minimal, but it's already great as it is. |








Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
"Hi, I've taken a look at your app and I really like it, but I'd like to give you some suggestions to make it more minimal.
First of all, I would personally remove the "Models" section at the top (See file called Image-1.png). At most, I'd put a button in the settings at the bottom of the page that redirects to a GitHub page where you can check all the updated models supported by the app.
Another change I'd make in the settings is to move the "Update" section to the bottom left, so that it aligns in height with the "Power" and "Keyboard Shortcuts" modules on the right (image-2.png).
In the "Keyboard Shortcuts" section, I'd add small toggle-style buttons on the left to quickly enable or disable each shortcut. For example, if I didn't want to use certain shortcuts because they might get triggered accidentally by pressing keys, I could turn them off completely. Or u can also add a single button on the categhory. (Image-3.png)
Another interesting change would be to display all the colors in the "Appearance" section in a single row, instead of showing those three small colors wrapped onto separate lines. (Image-4.png)
The "Gaming Overlay" section could also be made a little more minimal.
In the "Status" section, instead of showing a percentage on the "CPU Fan" and "GPU Fan" graphs, you could display the fan speed in RPM, and remove the items below that I've pointed out in the image. As for the "CPU Usage" graph, you could remove the "VRAM" label and place it under "RAM" using another progress bar instead. (Image-5.png)
The "Scenario" section is already very minimal and looks great.
In my opinion, the panel that opens when you click on the tray icon is too cluttered, with too many settings. Just the ones I've shown in the photo would be enough—from the "Open Panel" section, you can handle the rest yourself. (Image-6.jpeg)
It would also be nice to have checkbox-style squares for the "Fan Boost", "Gaming Overlay", and "Lock Overlay"
options, where a small checkmark appears inside the square when activated.
I hope you find these suggestions useful and to your liking. The app is already very aesthetically pleasing, but I think a few small UI tweaks could make it even more minimal and pleasant to look at. Let me know what you think."
All reactions