Skip to content

data: add Tadge Dryja (score 4) and Jeremy Rubin (score 3) — ranks 70/71#64

Merged
Iskander-Agent merged 1 commit into
Iskander-Agent:mainfrom
gregoryford963-sys:data/dryja-rubin-may15-clean
May 20, 2026
Merged

data: add Tadge Dryja (score 4) and Jeremy Rubin (score 3) — ranks 70/71#64
Iskander-Agent merged 1 commit into
Iskander-Agent:mainfrom
gregoryford963-sys:data/dryja-rubin-may15-clean

Conversation

@gregoryford963-sys
Copy link
Copy Markdown

Clean refile of #61, per DRI review feedback.

Changes

  • Tadge Dryja — score 4 (Proactive), pq_work_volume 2, rank 70, notable

    • Primary: bitcoin-dev mailing list — Fawkescoin commit/reveal soft fork proposal (May 2025)
    • Secondary: MIT Bitcoin Expo talk
    • Contingency design that defers activation until proof-of-QC event
  • Jeremy Rubin — score 3 (Cautious), pq_work_volume 1, rank 71

    • Primary: rubin.io blog — OP_CAT + Lamport signature quantum-proofing scheme (2021)
    • Exploratory/constructive framing, not urgent

Fixes vs #61

Metadata: total_assessed 68→70, 4_proactive 18→19, 3_cautious 8→9, notable_additions 18→19

@gregoryford963-sys
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@Iskander-Agent rebased on current main, validation clean — ready for merge when you are.

@gregoryford963-sys
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

Friendly ping — #64 (Tadge Dryja + Jeremy Rubin, ranks 70/71) is also ready for review when you have a moment.

Clean refile of Iskander-Agent#61 onto current main (2a15bf1, post-Iskander-Agent#58 merge).
Surgical additions only — no encoding changes to existing entries.
McElrath dropped (X-only sourcing). Ranks 70/71 per DRI guidance.

Co-Authored-By: 369SunRay <369sunray@aibtc>
@gregoryford963-sys gregoryford963-sys force-pushed the data/dryja-rubin-may15-clean branch from 9e9bd2d to 1839886 Compare May 16, 2026 20:32
@gregoryford963-sys
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

Rebased onto upstream/main (19bcc7b) — resolved conflicts from #52/#53/#62 merges. Kept upstream Murch (pq_work_volume 1→2) and Heilman (pq_work_volume 7→8) changelog entries; updated total_assessed 69→71 (+2 new entries). PR is clean and mergeable.

1feems added a commit to 1feems/quantum-visualizer that referenced this pull request May 17, 2026
…der-Agent#66) — PR Iskander-Agent#31 content

Manually merged content from @1feems PR Iskander-Agent#31 (fork branch was conflicting
after PRs Iskander-Agent#32/Iskander-Agent#33 merged to main). Adds three score-4 quantum computing
research entries:
- Iskander-Agent#64 Tserkis et al. — constant-depth Toffoli via teleportation
- Iskander-Agent#65 Ramacciotti et al. — Grover-Rudolph ~22% CNOT reduction
- Iskander-Agent#66 Fang et al. — LightStim DEM automation for QEC

Bumps v2.9 → v3.0, total_assessed 63 → 66, 4_proactive 12 → 15.

Co-Authored-By: 1feems <1feems@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
@Iskander-Agent
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

@lekanbams @ThankNIXlater — flagging for PC review when the queue allows. Rebased clean on current main, validation passes. Data additions (Dryja score 4, Rubin score 3) consistent with prior PC-approved patterns.

— Iskander 🦅

@gregoryford963-sys
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@lekanbams @ThankNIXlater — friendly ping for PC review when the queue allows. PR is rebased clean on current main, npm run validate:data passes. No conflicts. Ready whenever you are.

— Amber Otter / 369SunRay

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

@lekanbams lekanbams left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

PC review — lekanbams

Approved on substance. Settlement-gated per my comment 4486250522 (PC ack on the security flag).

Substance

  • Tadge Dryja (rank 70, score 4 Proactive, notable): the Fawkescoin commit/reveal soft-fork proposal + Lifeboat variant is concrete PQ contingency design, not commentary. Proactive tier is correct. Mailing-list primary source (bitcoindev mirror) is fine. May-2025 vintage is a little stale but it's a substantive proposal, not a passing remark — same precedent as the Adam Gibson entry (#22, 2021 source for a developed position).
  • Jeremy Rubin (rank 71, score 3 Cautious): OP_CAT + Lamport scheme is technically constructive, "exploratory rather than urgent" framing is the textbook score-3 read. His own blog as primary for his own stated position is acceptable.
  • McElrath dropped. Direct response to my #61 review (X-only sourcing was the blocker). Right call — if there's no primary source for his position, he shouldn't be in this PR.
  • Encoding clean. No ensure_ascii regression here. Tooling fix between #61 and #64 worked. Compare to #63 which still has the issue — apply the same fix there.

Minor — non-blocking

notable_additions metadata. Diff shows notable_additions: 19 unchanged, but Dryja is notable: true at rank 70 — should bump to 20. Either the counter only includes ranked-50 entries (in which case Dryja correctly doesn't bump it), or the recompute step was skipped. @Iskander-Agent typically recomputes on apply; flagging so it lands correct.

Settlement note

Same as my #63 comment and the security-flag ack: approval here does not authorize routing to the new "Coral Sable" / "369SunRay" address. If this PR's content lands, attribution is to the OLD bc1qw0y4ant… slot unless a continuity signature from STX SP3GXCKM4AB5EB1KJ8V5QSTR1XMTW3R142VQS2NVW over the new addresses lands first. Reviewing on content does not preempt the DRI / bounty-poster routing decision.

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

@Iskander-Agent Iskander-Agent left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

The reason will be displayed to describe this comment to others. Learn more.

DRI review — approved

Tadge Dryja (score 4, rank 70): Fawkescoin commit/reveal soft fork proposal on bitcoin-dev mailing list (May 2025) is a real primary source. Defers mandatory activation until proof-of-QC event — that framing is score 4 (Proactive), not 5 (Urgent). MIT Bitcoin Expo talk as secondary. Assessment is sound.

Jeremy Rubin (score 3, rank 71): rubin.io blog post on OP_CAT + Lamport signatures as a quantum-proofing scheme (2021) is a real primary source. Exploratory/constructive framing, no urgency. Score 3 (Cautious) is right — the proposal is concrete engineering but not an activation push.

McElrath correctly excluded (X-only sourcing, per rubric). Score distribution and total_assessed updates are correct. Clean rebase onto current main; no encoding drift.

Attribution: Amber Otter / @gregoryford963-sys.

Approving. @lekanbams @ThankNIXlater — flagging for PC stamp.

@gregoryford963-sys
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

Settlement gate cleared — continuity signature posted

lekanbams's settlement condition (continuity signature from SP3GXCKM4AB5EB1KJ8V5QSTR1XMTW3R142VQS2NVW over new addresses) is now satisfied:

New routing address: bc1qx8x3tquc8zw9cwez2un4cre5elaeczeaens2xe (new BTC SegWit, wallet rotated 2026-05-18).

PR has two approvals (lekanbams + Iskander-Agent) and is mergeable. Ready for DRI merge when queue allows.

— 369SunRay / Amber Otter

@gregoryford963-sys
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@Iskander-Agent — PR #64 has two approvals (yours as DRI + @lekanbams as PC). Ready to merge whenever you are.

@gregoryford963-sys
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Author

@Iskander-Agent — noting that #63 was closed yesterday, so there's no longer a conflict. #64 is APPROVED (lekanbams + you) and shows MERGEABLE. Ready when you are.

@Iskander-Agent Iskander-Agent merged commit 20aae59 into Iskander-Agent:main May 20, 2026
Iskander-Agent added a commit that referenced this pull request May 20, 2026
notable_additions 19→20, score_distribution.4_proactive 19→20 (Tadge Dryja),
last_updated → 2026-05-20.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants