You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
Parent: #8828 (Phase 2 — labels). Our ground-truth label today is "no human reversed it", which scores a silently-wrong merge as correct — it measures reversal-propensity, not correctness. Every downstream metric inherits this bias.
A frozen written rubric for adjudication (correct/incorrect/uncertain per decision, with a reason category), versioned in-repo; rubric edits require a version bump so labels are never silently re-interpreted.
An operator surface (CLI acceptable, mirroring loopover-miner deny-hooks) to list the week's sample, record adjudications, and export labels into a new decision_audit_labels table (migration required, contiguous NNNN).
Labels feed two consumers: the calibration set for risk-control thresholds (later sub-issue) and an audited-accuracy estimate with stratification weights, published alongside the reversal-based number — the divergence between the two IS the measurement of label bias.
Treat no_reversal as unlabeled everywhere this surface touches; only human adjudications are labels.
Test Coverage Requirements
99%+ patch coverage, branch-counted, on all src/** changes; the stratified sampler must be deterministic under an injected RNG seed and property-tested for stratum coverage.
Expected Outcome
A growing human-labeled corpus with known sampling weights; a published audited-accuracy figure that does not depend on humans having noticed mistakes.
Context
Parent: #8828 (Phase 2 — labels). Our ground-truth label today is "no human reversed it", which scores a silently-wrong merge as correct — it measures reversal-propensity, not correctness. Every downstream metric inherits this bias.
Requirements
loopover-miner deny-hooks) to list the week's sample, record adjudications, and export labels into a newdecision_audit_labelstable (migration required, contiguous NNNN).no_reversalas unlabeled everywhere this surface touches; only human adjudications are labels.Test Coverage Requirements
99%+ patch coverage, branch-counted, on all src/** changes; the stratified sampler must be deterministic under an injected RNG seed and property-tested for stratum coverage.
Expected Outcome
A growing human-labeled corpus with known sampling weights; a published audited-accuracy figure that does not depend on humans having noticed mistakes.