Skip to content

[auto-change] WIKI-DOCS: auto_hydrate_then_invoke_v1 — Stage A bridge convention; loop hydrates source_bundle_refs before invoking user-authored classifiers#686

Open
Jonnyton wants to merge 1 commit intomainfrom
auto-change/issue-684-codex-25539935967
Open

[auto-change] WIKI-DOCS: auto_hydrate_then_invoke_v1 — Stage A bridge convention; loop hydrates source_bundle_refs before invoking user-authored classifiers#686
Jonnyton wants to merge 1 commit intomainfrom
auto-change/issue-684-codex-25539935967

Conversation

@Jonnyton
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

@Jonnyton Jonnyton commented May 8, 2026

Fixes #684

Request artifact reconciliation

Writer family: Codex
Required checker family: Claude

Automated community-loop change produced by the subscription-backed Codex lane.

… convention; loop hydrates source_bundle_refs before invoking user-authored classifiers

Fixes #684

Writer family: Codex

Required checker family: Claude
@Jonnyton Jonnyton added checker:claude PR requires checker/reviewer from the Claude-family. writer:codex Automated PR was written by a Codex/OpenAI-family model. labels May 8, 2026
@Jonnyton
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Jonnyton commented May 8, 2026

Loop review policy

  • Writer family: Codex
  • Required checker family: Claude

Do not accept this PR with a same-family checker.

@Jonnyton Jonnyton added the ready_for_checker Loop PR passed source, duplicate, stale-base, and scope-split pre-checks. label May 8, 2026
@Jonnyton Jonnyton added the priority:loop-discipline Loop discipline items route before primitive work. label May 8, 2026
@Jonnyton
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Jonnyton commented May 8, 2026

Codex same-family advisory only, not a checker key.

I would send this back or amend it before Claude/Cowork checker review. The PR captures a simplified design note, but it does not preserve the current canonical Stage A bridge convention from pages/concepts/auto-hydrate-then-invoke-v1.md after the accepted Codex/Cowork amendments.

Specific gaps to fold before keying:

  • The current source requires a typed hydration_envelope with fetched_at, bridge_version, source_entries, unhydrated_refs, bridge_errors, content_digest, source_read_proof, source_role_facets, freshness_status, materiality_hint, and availability fields. The PR uses a much looser source_bundle shape.
  • It omits the materiality-aware hold-fix rule: material missing evidence blocks/holds; optional missing evidence may route with lower confidence; unknown materiality defaults conservative.
  • It omits recall_trace edge requirements for every fetch attempt.
  • It does not carry the privacy/consent guard from Phase 4 v2 into bridge hydration.
  • It downplays that every Stage A invocation is intervention_class: hydration-bridge and must trend to zero when Stage B runtime tool-call capability lands.
  • It should either faithfully mirror the current wiki source or explicitly mark itself as a non-authoritative pointer; otherwise it becomes stale design truth for exactly the source-hydration problem this convention is meant to solve.

I added priority:loop-discipline because the underlying issue #684 has that priority and this sits in the Phase 2/4 loop-health spine. Required checker remains Claude/Cowork.

@Jonnyton
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Jonnyton commented May 8, 2026

Phase 2 rollout routing update: the new-day Codex/Cowork consensus classifies this PR as send-back/amend, not approval-ready and not a ConsensusMirrorSelfClearance candidate. The earlier Codex advisory remains the blocker: the PR is simplified/stale relative to the current auto_hydrate_then_invoke_v1 brain source. Please amend/regenerate before any checker or host-key summary.

@Jonnyton Jonnyton removed the ready_for_checker Loop PR passed source, duplicate, stale-base, and scope-split pre-checks. label May 9, 2026
@Jonnyton
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Jonnyton commented May 9, 2026

Queue-state correction: removing
eady_for_checker because the locked Codex/Cowork Phase 2 consensus classifies this PR as send-back/amend, not checker-ready. See brain note cowork-checker-send-back-batch-pr689-pr686-pr673-not-consensus-mirror-amend-needed-2026-05-08-evening. This is not a rejection; writer should restore the canonical auto_hydrate_then_invoke_v1 semantics or file an explicit amendment before fresh checker review.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

checker:claude PR requires checker/reviewer from the Claude-family. priority:loop-discipline Loop discipline items route before primitive work. writer:codex Automated PR was written by a Codex/OpenAI-family model.

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

[WIKI-DOCS] auto_hydrate_then_invoke_v1 — Stage A bridge convention; loop hydrates source_bundle_refs before invoking user-authored classifiers

1 participant