Skip to content

Releases: NickGillArizona/Duty-Without-Data

v1.1.0 - structural redesign

Choose a tag to compare

@NickGillArizona NickGillArizona released this 02 Aug 21:35

This release is the structural redesign of the archive's reader surfaces. It
changes how the repository is organized, navigated, and presented; it changes
no census figure, no registered claim, and no manuscript content. v1.0.0
remains the initial release of record, and the manuscript's Data Availability
citation (release v1.0.0, root commit 5b4c27b) continues to resolve.

Comment-window surfaces

  • The comment pages (COMMENT.md, the /comment/ page, the take-action kit)
    state the Form HUD-27061 comment deadline in deadline-anchored form:
    comments are due August 11, 2026 (91 Fed. Reg. 35,697), with the July 12,
    2026 record cutoff stated and readers directed to the official docket for
    any later development. Both ICR outcomes -- renewal or an unrepaired
    expiration -- remain stated as open on every status surface; the section
    553(e) petition materials remain the durable route. Retrospective
    retirement language ships in a post-deadline update only after closure is
    verified on regulations.gov.

Structure

  • TAKE_ACTION.md moved to action/TAKE_ACTION.md;
    LIMITATIONS_AND_NEGATIVE_RESULTS.md is consolidated into
    article/EVIDENCE_AND_LIMITS.md (with a new reproducible-versus-judgment
    table); CREDITS.md folded into THIRD_PARTY_NOTICES.md. Every moved or
    consolidated root file leaves a forwarding stub, so no inbound link breaks.
  • article/READER_GUIDE.md is a one-page router: what is canonical versus
    supplementary versus historical, which surface answers which question, and
    where the evidence boundary lives.
  • article/THE_ARGUMENT.md is rewritten as a fifteen-minute read: six
    sections, the wide doctrinal tables converted to headed prose, no action
    deadline, no methodology discussion. The census claim block and every
    registered claim string are byte-identical to the prior version.
  • Appendix C is organized into two labeled parts -- the public administrative
    record (secs. C.1-C.3) and the author's participation and analysis
    (secs. C.4-C.6) -- with section numbers and anchors unchanged.

Pages site

  • The site now has a local layout and stylesheet (skip link, semantic
    landmarks, breadcrumbs, primary and footer navigation, print styles, light
    and dark from the system preference, WCAG AA contrast, no JavaScript) and
    six content pages: /argument/, /evidence-and-limits/,
    /administrative-record/, /methods-and-replication/, /download-and-cite/,
    and /accessibility/. The accessibility page states what is tested
    automatically, what is not yet tested, and how to report a barrier.
  • Every census figure on a site page renders from _data/series.yml, which
    is generated from the series of record; no census number is hand-typed
    into a page.

Verification

  • A twentieth release check (scripts/check_generated_surfaces.py) verifies
    that the generated surfaces (claims index, site data) match their sources,
    that dated status lines on the record pages are no older than the newest
    chronology event (the gap class behind the v1.0.0 record-README staleness),
    that stated appendix counts match the files present, and that the footnote
    index carries every registered pointer route.
  • article/CLAIMS_INDEX.md is the generated, reader-facing rendering of the
    claims ledger; the gate fails if the two drift.
  • The claims ledger's evidence routes are typed. Twelve rows recorded only
    "primary source as cited; full audit memorandum retained privately." Ten of
    them are supported by material already committed here and now name it: the
    archived 1989 Part 121 promulgation, the Part 121 and Part 8 regulatory-text
    captures, the NSPIRE final rule, PIH Notice 2022-03, the HUD-50058 field
    specification, and the HUD OIG report. The two case rows name corpus
    membership in the published database and direct the cited proposition to the
    reporter, because the minimized public projection carries no opinion text.
    The remaining two rows have no public in-repository artifact -- 24 C.F.R.
    Part 100 regulatory text is not archived here, and the supplementary
    Loper Bright ratchet analysis is retained privately -- and now say so
    plainly. Reported coverage moves from 41 to 51 of 53 rows carrying a
    claim-specific public route; all 104 path routes resolve.
  • results/README.md is tiered explicitly (current citable / supporting /
    as-run validation records, with an index of the frozen run directories);
    method/prompts/MANIFEST.md states each frozen instrument's task and
    attribution; record/hud-27061/source_manifest.csv states each archived
    document's date, agency, status, and cited proposition.

All twenty release checks pass on this tree.

v1.0.1 - correction and curation

Choose a tag to compare

@NickGillArizona NickGillArizona released this 02 Aug 21:34

This release corrects errors identified in post-release review and completes a
curation pass. v1.0.0 remains unchanged as the initial release of record; the
manuscript's Data Availability citation (release v1.0.0, root commit
5b4c27b) continues to resolve.

Corrections

  • Appendix M, sec. M.4 — the Form HUD-27061 Federal Register citations
    misattributed two unrelated documents and described a "Final Notice" that does
    not exist in this sequence. The corrected sequence: 60-day notice, 87 Fed.
    Reg. 58,524 (Sept. 27, 2022); 30-day notice, 88 Fed. Reg. 5,370 (Jan. 27,
    2023), which carries the reversion to the narrower instrument; OMB approval
    June 13, 2023 (ICR 202301-2535-001).
  • Appendix M, sec. M.9 — the 51-jurisdiction QAP scan now states its
    arithmetic explicitly: 3 retrieval errors are excluded; the four categories
    sum over the 48 non-error records; the 7 manual-review jurisdictions are
    counted within the None category.
  • record/hud-27061/README.md — a stale "not yet published" renewal row is
    replaced with the June 12, 2026 notice (91 Fed. Reg. 35,697; comments due
    Aug. 11, 2026) and the expiration-passed, both-outcomes-open posture.
  • CITATION.cff — the abstract no longer implies that privately retained
    doctrinal-audit memoranda are contained in the repository.
  • method/METHODOLOGY.md — the raw-output publication claim is scoped to the
    validation ensemble; the primary pipeline publishes adjudication-tier
    metadata (boundary: method/SYSTEM_MAP.md).
  • Document-level figures — six superseded document-level decline figures now
    carry inline supersession labels at the point of use.
  • Manuscript mirror — synced to the final pre-publication draft
    (refinements to notes 106, 157, 166, 171, 175, and 176).
  • scripts/make_figures.py — restored, so the committed figure generator
    scripts/make_fig1.py runs from a clean clone.

Curation

  • The three public datasets are minimized projections: five free-text fields
    removed; every registered baseline re-derives unchanged from the published
    files.
  • article/CLAIMS_LEDGER.csv is now the 53-row article ledger, and a new
    release check verifies it row-by-row (99/99 evidence routes resolve).
  • The README leads with the Note and its reader routes, and the timeline
    caption carries the three notice dates and citations in text.
  • Figure 1 titles are neutral descriptions ("Case composition and
    qualifying-judgment rates"); all plotted values are unchanged and
    guard-checked.
  • The social-preview card is a restrained typographic design
    (scripts/make_social_preview.py).
  • Dependabot updates are grouped on a monthly schedule.
  • The methods overview is retitled (method/METHOD_SPECIFICATION.md) and
    agreement statistics are reported with numeric bands.
  • The appendix count reads fifteen consistently across surfaces.

All nineteen release checks pass on this tree.

v1.0.0

Choose a tag to compare

@NickGillArizona NickGillArizona released this 31 Jul 17:42

First public release of the research and replication archive for "Duty Without Data: Disability Fair Housing and the Record-Dependent Right," forthcoming in the Arizona Law Review.

The archive holds the manuscript, the appendices, the Form HUD-27061 administrative record, the case-level outcome census and its validation audits, the comparator and cost-burden analyses, and the model Section 553(e) petition materials. Start with README.md; article/NOTE_TO_REPOSITORY_CROSSWALK.md maps the article's footnotes to their supporting files.