Source
S. Karlin, Total Positivity, Vol. I:
- Chapter V, §1, Theorems 1.1--1.4: finite variation-diminishing theory.
- Chapter V, §1, Lemma 1.1, Proposition 1.2, and Theorem 1.3: approximation and rank-deficient/non-strict reductions.
- Chapter VIII, §3, Theorem 3.1: the Aissen--Schoenberg--Whitney application.
This is a continuation of #241. The base cases are already checked in
RealRooted/Mathlib/LinearAlgebra/Matrix/VariationDiminishing.lean.
Exact next theorem
Prove the strict full-column-rank sector first:
Matrix.signVariations_mulVec_le_card_sub_one_of_strictMaximalMinors
For a finite real matrix with q columns, if all maximal minors are nonzero
and have the same sign, prove that every vector with maximal sign variation
has nonzero image and
signVariations (A *ᵥ x) ≤ q - 1.
This is the weakened S⁻ consequence needed by the repository; Karlin proves
the stronger S⁺ formulation.
Paper-derived proof order
- Formalize the strict maximal-minor argument from Chapter V, §1.
- Add the monotone aggregation/block decomposition used in Karlin's proof.
- Extend from the strict sector to totally nonnegative matrices via the
approximation and rank-deficiency steps in Chapter V, §1, Lemma 1.1,
Proposition 1.2, and Theorem 1.3.
- Apply the resulting finite variation-diminishing theorem to the Toeplitz
truncations in Chapter VIII, §3 to finish the forward ASW implication.
Chapter V, §3, Theorem 3.1 is an integral-kernel reduction and is not the
source for the non-strict finite-matrix approximation step.
Acceptance criteria
- The strict maximal-minor theorem above has a checked Lean proof.
- Any combinatorial matrix interpretation that is intentionally assumed is
exposed as an explicit hypothesis with a nearby comment explaining the
boundary.
- Variation diminution, total nonnegativity consequences, and
real-rootedness are proved, not hidden behind a def ...Statement : Prop.
- The proof follows Karlin's order; alternative guessed routes should not be
substituted without first documenting why the cited argument cannot be
formalized.
Source
S. Karlin, Total Positivity, Vol. I:
This is a continuation of #241. The base cases are already checked in
RealRooted/Mathlib/LinearAlgebra/Matrix/VariationDiminishing.lean.Exact next theorem
Prove the strict full-column-rank sector first:
For a finite real matrix with
qcolumns, if all maximal minors are nonzeroand have the same sign, prove that every vector with maximal sign variation
has nonzero image and
signVariations (A *ᵥ x) ≤ q - 1.This is the weakened
S⁻consequence needed by the repository; Karlin provesthe stronger
S⁺formulation.Paper-derived proof order
approximation and rank-deficiency steps in Chapter V, §1, Lemma 1.1,
Proposition 1.2, and Theorem 1.3.
truncations in Chapter VIII, §3 to finish the forward ASW implication.
Chapter V, §3, Theorem 3.1 is an integral-kernel reduction and is not the
source for the non-strict finite-matrix approximation step.
Acceptance criteria
exposed as an explicit hypothesis with a nearby comment explaining the
boundary.
real-rootedness are proved, not hidden behind a
def ...Statement : Prop.substituted without first documenting why the cited argument cannot be
formalized.