Skip to content

Updates to Costing and ROI analysis#1711

Merged
tbhallett merged 39 commits intomasterfrom
sakshi/comparison_of_horizontal_v_vertical_v2
Jan 27, 2026
Merged

Updates to Costing and ROI analysis#1711
tbhallett merged 39 commits intomasterfrom
sakshi/comparison_of_horizontal_v_vertical_v2

Conversation

@sakshimohan
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

@sakshimohan sakshimohan commented Sep 26, 2025

This PR updates the scripts and RF used to produce the results for the following papers -

  1. Estimating System-Wide Healthcare Costs Using a Health System Model: Application to the Thanzi La Onse Model of Malawi (ACCEPTED - Applied Health Economics and Health Policy - January 2026)
  2. System-Wide Investments Generate Health and Enhance HIV, TB and Malaria Control in Malawi (REVISION Submitted - Nature Communications - December 2025)

- Note that Xpert costs no longer need to be estimated separately.
@sakshimohan sakshimohan marked this pull request as ready for review September 26, 2025 11:21
@sakshimohan sakshimohan marked this pull request as draft September 26, 2025 11:21
…Plane

+ Add ROI bar plots at two implementation cost assumptions
+ fix calculation of roi at upper bound ASC
+ formatting fixes to plots
(Note that the RF should be taken from  branch - tara/gff_hss_and_htm_scale_up
@sakshimohan sakshimohan requested review from tbhallett and removed request for tbhallett December 19, 2025 16:49
@sakshimohan
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Will request review once the manuscript has been accepted in its current form

@sakshimohan sakshimohan marked this pull request as ready for review January 16, 2026 16:57
@sakshimohan
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Hi @tbhallett @tdm32 - Could we merge this PR into master ahead of the publication of the costing paper? The changes are only to analysis scripts -

  1. The scripts under src/scripts/costing which i. provide functions for cost analyses, ii. run the analyses for the costing manuscript
  2. src/scripts/costing/manuscript_analysis/scenario_full_system_cost.py - Scenario script for the costing paper
  3. roi_analysis_horizontal_vs_vertical.py - analysis script for the revised ROI paper with Nature Comms
  4. resources/costing/ResourceFile_Costing_Consumables.csv - Minor updates to the costing RF for consumables.

@sakshimohan sakshimohan changed the title Updates to ROI analysis Updates to Costing and ROI analysis Jan 16, 2026
@tdm32
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator

tdm32 commented Jan 16, 2026

Hi @tbhallett @tdm32 - Could we merge this PR into master ahead of the publication of the costing paper? The changes are only to analysis scripts -

  1. The scripts under src/scripts/costing which i. provide functions for cost analyses, ii. run the analyses for the costing manuscript
  2. src/scripts/costing/manuscript_analysis/scenario_full_system_cost.py - Scenario script for the costing paper
  3. roi_analysis_horizontal_vs_vertical.py - analysis script for the revised ROI paper with Nature Comms
  4. resources/costing/ResourceFile_Costing_Consumables.csv - Minor updates to the costing RF for consumables.

Hi @sakshimohan , I can review this next week. You can add a tag to your working branch with all of these up-to-date scripts and add that to the paper as master will always move on so you would probably want to link to the exact version used to produce your results.

@sakshimohan
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Hi @tbhallett @tdm32 - Could we merge this PR into master ahead of the publication of the costing paper? The changes are only to analysis scripts -

  1. The scripts under src/scripts/costing which i. provide functions for cost analyses, ii. run the analyses for the costing manuscript
  2. src/scripts/costing/manuscript_analysis/scenario_full_system_cost.py - Scenario script for the costing paper
  3. roi_analysis_horizontal_vs_vertical.py - analysis script for the revised ROI paper with Nature Comms
  4. resources/costing/ResourceFile_Costing_Consumables.csv - Minor updates to the costing RF for consumables.

Hi @sakshimohan , I can review this next week. You can add a tag to your working branch with all of these up-to-date scripts and add that to the paper as master will always move on so you would probably want to link to the exact version used to produce your results.

Thanks, @tdm32. That makes sense. I'll follow up with Asif on how to add a tag.

@sakshimohan
Copy link
Copy Markdown
Collaborator Author

Hi @tdm32. I've now submitted the final version of the costing manuscript to AHEHP with the Zenodo link for the final costing updates. When you get a chance, could you please approve this PR? I imagine the journal will still take a few weeks to process/edit the final version, so no immediate rush.

@tbhallett tbhallett merged commit c392004 into master Jan 27, 2026
66 checks passed
@tbhallett tbhallett deleted the sakshi/comparison_of_horizontal_v_vertical_v2 branch January 27, 2026 12:41
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

3 participants