Part of #6
Question
What do the candidate base images for the Core container actually scan at, and how does each get Node 24 + git without curl … nodesource | bash?
The Core cannot be distroless — it spawns PTY sessions, so it needs a shell, git, a Node runtime for the agent CLIs, and enough of a userland to be a machine you do work on. Today it is ubuntu:24.04 + apt-get install build-essential python3 unzip zip jq ripgrep vim-tiny + a piped NodeSource install, which is where the "1k+ vulnerabilities on steps 6 and 7" and the "13 on the base" come from.
Produce, for each candidate, a measured baseline rather than an opinion:
debian:13-slim / debian:12-slim
ubuntu:24.04 and ubuntu:24.04 minimal/chiseled
cgr.dev/chainguard/wolfi-base (and what the free :latest-only tier means for pinning)
- Anything else that credibly clears the bar
For each, report: CVE count by severity from the same scanner the user is using; whether a shell and a package manager are present; how Node 24 arrives (distro package / official nodejs.org tarball / apk); how git arrives; approximate final image size with git + Node 24 installed; and licensing or registry-access constraints.
Also settle the sub-question that keeps the count honest: which of the current apt packages does a Core actually need at runtime? build-essential, python3, vim-tiny, zip and unzip are in there for the dev fixture's convenience, not because the daemon requires them — separate what the daemon needs, what the agent CLIs need, and what nobody needs.
Do not pick the base — that is the next ticket. Deliver the evidence it will be picked on.
Part of #6
Question
What do the candidate base images for the Core container actually scan at, and how does each get Node 24 + git without
curl … nodesource | bash?The Core cannot be distroless — it spawns PTY sessions, so it needs a shell, git, a Node runtime for the agent CLIs, and enough of a userland to be a machine you do work on. Today it is
ubuntu:24.04+apt-get install build-essential python3 unzip zip jq ripgrep vim-tiny+ a piped NodeSource install, which is where the "1k+ vulnerabilities on steps 6 and 7" and the "13 on the base" come from.Produce, for each candidate, a measured baseline rather than an opinion:
debian:13-slim/debian:12-slimubuntu:24.04andubuntu:24.04minimal/chiseledcgr.dev/chainguard/wolfi-base(and what the free:latest-only tier means for pinning)For each, report: CVE count by severity from the same scanner the user is using; whether a shell and a package manager are present; how Node 24 arrives (distro package / official
nodejs.orgtarball / apk); howgitarrives; approximate final image size with git + Node 24 installed; and licensing or registry-access constraints.Also settle the sub-question that keeps the count honest: which of the current apt packages does a Core actually need at runtime?
build-essential,python3,vim-tiny,zipandunzipare in there for the dev fixture's convenience, not because the daemon requires them — separate what the daemon needs, what the agent CLIs need, and what nobody needs.Do not pick the base — that is the next ticket. Deliver the evidence it will be picked on.