Round-5 prompt acceptance criteria diverges from v1.7.0 actual implementation — update docs/prompts/ or archive round-5

[ardelperal]

Symptom

The round-5 maintainer prompt at \docs/prompts/prompt-ia-mantenedora-codegraph-vba-round-5-2026-07-13.md\ (in consumer \DysTelefonica/GESTION_RIESGOS) specifies acceptance criteria that the shipped v1.7.0 fix does NOT meet:

Expected (per round-5 prompt):
\\sql
-- Post-fix esperado:
-- stub_true_count <500 (solo casos genuinos missing)
-- declared_targets = 0 (todas las repointadas)
\\

Actual (verified post-v1.7.0 reindex on gestion_riesgos, 332 modules, 2026-07-13):

• \stub_true_count\ = 3,270 (NOT <500)
• \declared_targets_with_stub_true\ = 253 (NOT 0)
• BUT
  epoint_decision_distribution\ is populated:
  • 2,801 \declined-runtime\ (DAO., fso., VBA., ListBox., Collection., err.)
  • 451 \declined-not-found\ (genuine missing callees — actionable noise)
  • 18 \declined-ambiguous\ (investigate)

Root cause

The prompt expected the post-extraction resolver to repoint every declared-target stub to its real node, reducing the stub count. The shipped implementation (#110, PR #113) instead annotates each stub with \metadata.repointDecision\ (one of:
eponted-to-real\ / \declined-runtime\ / \declined-ambiguous\ / \declined-not-found), letting consumer-side lints filter on the decision field instead of the count.

Suggested resolution

Two options:

1. Update the prompt template to reflect the actual contract: consumer-side lints should filter on
   epointDecision='declined-not-found'\ (451 actionable) rather than total \stub=true.
2. Archive round-5 prompt as historical (the criterion it specifies is not the criterion shipped), and generate a round-5-bis prompt that documents the actual
   epointDecision\ semantics.

Context

• Round-5 closed via PR fix(resolver-vba): decline runtime-object call stubs; preserve shadow user classes (#110) #113 (merged 2026-07-13T10:05:02Z)
• Round-6 (fix(extractor-vba): index Test_Helper.bas and Test_Fixtures.bas as nodes (round-6) #112) already closed 2026-07-13T10:55:05Z
• Consumer-side verification saved to engram topic \orchestrator/discipline/codegraph-runtime-snapshot\
• Sample consumer query (works on rebuilt DB):

\\sql
SELECT json_extract(e.metadata, '$.repointDecision') AS decision, COUNT(*) AS n
FROM edges e
WHERE e.kind='calls'
AND json_extract(e.metadata, '$.synthesizedBy')='vba-name-resolution'
AND json_extract(e.metadata, '$.stub')=1
GROUP BY decision;
-- declined-runtime: 2801, declined-not-found: 451, declined-ambiguous: 18
\\

/cc @ardelperal

[ardelperal]

Resuelto por PR #117 (squash-merged en main): docs/vba-stub-repoint-decision.md + server-instructions.ts actualizado. El criterio del round-5 prompt (stub_true<500) está reemplazado por el filtro repointDecision='declined-not-found' (<500), que es el contrato shipped.