Skip to content

docs(getff-any-stack-trace): S2b + R1 dispatch inputs (operator-invited) + meta-launch amendment - #1172

Merged
artyhoo merged 1 commit into
stagingfrom
s2b-authoring
Jul 31, 2026
Merged

docs(getff-any-stack-trace): S2b + R1 dispatch inputs (operator-invited) + meta-launch amendment#1172
artyhoo merged 1 commit into
stagingfrom
s2b-authoring

Conversation

@artyhoo

@artyhoo artyhoo commented Jul 25, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

What

Operator-invited insertion (2026-07-26) into the getff-any-stack-trace umbrella:

  • S2b dispatch input — close the python lane's empty git-hook rung. Task 0 is the missing prior-art verdict: SSOT feat(meta-orchestrator): §1.7 PR-body authoring mandate in kickoff template #216 REJECTed pre-commit as a delivery scaffolder, and python-delivery-v0/kickoff.md:97-98 consumed that as a verdict on the enforcement channel — pre-commit in its actual RUNNER role was never verdicted. S2b runs that verdict (criteria: zero installed prerequisites > augment-first > Node-free) and delivers the rung per its outcome, with a RED/GREEN firing proof that goes THROUGH git.
  • R1 dispatch input — a lane × channel-rung parity audit (npm / python / cargo + verify-go-absent, 7 rungs): every EXISTS cell needs firing evidence, every GAP cell a provenance classification (DECIDED-AGAINST / MISDECIDED / DEFERRED / SILENTLY-MISSED). One research patch, zero code.
  • Meta-launch amendment — launch-table rows, S2→S2b→S3 gate rewiring (R1 non-gating), declared S2b∥R1 parallelism with the full write-set enumeration (disjoint incl. the SSOT: one writer, one reader).

Review findings

Cold Phase -1 review of all three artefacts: REVISE — 1 BLOCKER, 4 MAJOR, 3 MINOR, every finding verified against the tree before applying:

  • BLOCKER — R1's kickoff was silent on the fidelity-verdict-in-pr-body required check, which has no paths filter and rejects skipped once a ## Provenance substrate is declared (packages/core/hooks/checks/pr-body-fidelity.ts:19); an autonomous worker harvested through aif would have hit an unpassable red check. R1 §7 now carries both legal shapes and who produces the GO block.
  • MAJOR ×4 — the S2b fidelity trap omitted the ## Fidelity verdict H2-heading requirement (pr-body-fidelity.ts:35); R1's scope comment claimed executor-tier dispatch without a marker (claim removed — routing follows project defaults); the meta-launch retained three parallelism statements contradicting the new declared S2b∥R1 pair (all three scoped to the spec stages); the amendment's S2b write-set was undercounted (missing the SSOT row + the likely hook template — the same enumeration-undercount class as S2's ban-encoding BLOCKER).
  • MINOR ×3 — excluded-columns rationale for R1's matrix (production audit / mutation gates named as exclusions, column 1 widened to lane-native edit-time channels); a bare-remote note for the pre-push fixture variant; an accept-time instruction to diff the test file for the new arm's existence (host-verify passes trivially without it — T14).

Gates: principle 12 → 7/7 PASS; host-verify.sh --list parses both kickoffs (S2b fence; R1 explicit ≥20-char opt-out).

Deliberately NOT done in this PR

No dispatch. The operator paused the session on limits; the next session merges this, re-probes in-flight, dispatches S2b + R1 to aif in parallel, and arms monitors. done.md remains S4's.

Fidelity verdict

FIDELITY: skipped — dispatch-input authoring plus a meta-launch amendment, no implementation surface, no substrate produced this diff; authored and cold-reviewed in-session with the findings enumerated above, applied at .claude/orchestrator-prompts/getff-any-stack-trace-s2b/kickoff.md:1 and getff-any-stack-trace-r1/kickoff.md:1; the stage PRs these kickoffs dispatch each carry their own cold verdict.

§1.7 Skipped: additive dispatch-input authoring and a meta-launch amendment across three orchestrator-prompt kickoff files — a path doc-authority-hierarchy.md §2 explicitly exempts from authority headers (tracked-but-header-exempt filename-convention transients). No discipline surface is created, extended, or superseded; the stage PRs these kickoffs dispatch carry the forward/backward sections where their diffs reach the trigger paths.

…ok rung + lane-parity audit (operator-invited)

Operator-invited insertion (2026-07-26): close the python lane's empty git-hook
rung inside this umbrella (S2b) and audit whether sibling lanes hide the same
class of gap (R1, lane x channel-rung parity matrix over npm/python/cargo +
verify-go-absent). Meta-launch amended: launch-table rows, S2->S2b->S3 gates,
S2b||R1 declared parallel (disjoint write-sets incl. the SSOT: one writer, one
reader).

S2b's Task 0 is the missing prior-art verdict this gap traces to: SSOT #216
REJECTed pre-commit as a delivery SCAFFOLDER, and python-delivery-v0's kickoff
conditional consumed that as a verdict on the enforcement CHANNEL — pre-commit
in its actual RUNNER role was never verdicted (T16-shaped conflation, provenance
in the kickoff header). R1 generalizes the lesson: every GAP cell must carry a
provenance classification (DECIDED-AGAINST / MISDECIDED / DEFERRED /
SILENTLY-MISSED), and every EXISTS cell firing evidence, not file existence.

Cold Phase -1 review: REVISE - 1 BLOCKER (R1 silent on the unconditional
fidelity-verdict required-check; pr-body-fidelity.yml has no paths filter and
`skipped` is rejected once a Provenance substrate is declared) + 4 MAJOR (missing
H2-heading requirement in the S2b fidelity trap; an executor-tier claim without a
marker; three unreconciled parallelism contradictions in the meta-launch; an
undercounted S2b write-set in the amendment) + 3 MINOR (excluded-columns
rationale, bare-remote note for a pre-push fixture, accept-time diff check for
the new test arm). All 8 applied; principle 12: 7/7 PASS; host-verify contracts
parse on both kickoffs (S2b fence, R1 explicit opt-out).

NOT dispatched: the operator paused the session on limits. Next session: merge
this PR (staging placement), re-probe in-flight, then dispatch S2b + R1 to aif
in parallel and arm monitors.

Prior-art: skipped — dispatch-input authoring and meta-launch amendment only;
no new capability, no dependency, no code module.
@artyhoo
artyhoo merged commit 5a72b70 into staging Jul 31, 2026
39 checks passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant