chore(orchestrator): close agnosticism-remediation umbrella (done.md) - #589
Merged
Merged
Conversation
Commit the closure marker for the agnosticism-remediation umbrella, whose final stage (T-C principle-test slot 21) merged via #577. The marker was authored but left untracked; this closes the done.md gap so priority-score.sh Layer C3 tags the umbrella DONE instead of resurfacing it as open backlog. - Umbrella stages: T-A #570, T-B #575, T-C #577 (all merged to staging). - Marker matches the binding done.md schema (Final PR / Closed / Summary). - No capability surface (closure-convention doc edit), no §1.7 path touched.
artyhoo
enabled auto-merge (squash)
June 16, 2026 20:39
artyhoo
added a commit
that referenced
this pull request
Jul 23, 2026
…+ population report (#1117) * docs(umbrella-donemd-backfill): Commit A — done.md for 12 CLOSED-VERIFIED candidates Stage 1 of umbrella-donemd-backfill. Closes 12 stale no-done.md dirs where closure is proven by either parent-umbrella's done.md naming the per-stage PR (3 cases) or parent-umbrella's final PR closing the meta-launch runtime state (4 cases) or direct branch-name PR match where the branch IS the slug (5 cases). Per-candidate evidence (full matrix + population enumeration in report.md landed in Commit C): agnosticism-remediation-t-a/b/c (parent done.md names per-stage PRs): - T-A #570 — CC-qualify skill auto-activation + doc-claims probe - T-B #575 — portable AGENTS.md rule index + rules-autoload coverage probe - T-C #577 — agnosticism-conformance principle test slot 21 Parent (agnosticism-remediation) closed by #589 (2026-06-16). *-meta-launch dirs whose parent umbrella is closed (meta-launch runtime state included in parent's final PR): - consumer-upgrade-path-meta-launch ← parent #615 - egress-host-push-default-meta-launch ← parent #760 - generator-require-composite-tier-meta-launch ← parent #708 - hook-test-suite-rot-meta-launch ← parent #608 Branch-name PR matches (branch IS slug; no kickoff.md to verify final-stage trap T-UDB-C against; dir is runtime batch state for the named work): - wave-5-trio-followup ← PR #37 (chore/wave-5-trio-followup, 2026-05-11) - wave-7-hot-checks-joint-closure ← PR #29 (wave-7-hot-checks-joint-closure, 2026-05-11) - wave-8-retro-h8-gate5-13-31 ← PR #48 (chore/wave-8-retro-h8-gate5-13-31, 2026-05-12) - phase-9-implementation ← PR #18 (docs/phase-9-implementation, 2026-05-09) - audit-fixes-2026-05 ← PR #1 (feat/audit-fixes-2026-05, 2026-05-07) Structural note (load-bearing, surfaced in report §1): all 12 target dirs lack kickoff.md (untracked + nothing on disk). priority-score.sh skips such dirs at line 144 (`if [[ ! -f "${kickoff}" ]]; then … continue`) — so writing done.md here is documentation, not a priority-score.sh panel-state change. The 65 no-done dirs with kickoff.md are all excluded by either the explicit live-program list or the 45-day live-signal rule, so Stage 1 yields zero priority-score.sh panel changes (correctly: there are no actionable closures in the live-program-with-kickoff population). Prior-art: skipped — refactor only, no new capability * docs(umbrella-donemd-backfill): Commit C — report.md + .gitignore exception Stage 1 report for umbrella-donemd-backfill. Adds the population enumeration, per-verdict counts, the full UNCLEAR table (22 rows with per-row signals), and an acceptance-gate self-check. Load-bearing structural finding in §1: 35 of 100 no-done.md dirs are runtime-only coordination slots (no kickoff.md on disk, no git history). priority-score.sh already filters these out at line 144 (kickoff-missing -> continue) BEFORE the Layer C3 done.md check at lines 222-231 runs, so the C3 layer never reaches them whether done.md exists or not. The 12 done.md files from Commit A add documentation value (visible closure marker) but do not change /pipeline panel output for those 12 -- they cover the 12 of 65 real-umbrella no-done.md dirs where closure was provable via parent-umbrella or branch-name PR evidence. Per-verdict counts (per §2 of the report): - CLOSED-VERIFIED: 12 (done.md landed in Commit A) - SUPERSEDED: 0 (none of the 34 candidates has kickoff.md -> S3 superseded-marker check is inapplicable) - OBSOLETE-CANDIDATE: 0 (no per-dir visibly-overtaken evidence possible without kickoff context) - UNCLEAR: 22 (weak/ambiguous signals; first-class outcome per T14) .gitignore: extends the orchestrator-prompts exception list with report.md parallel to done.md/kickoff.md. Same durable-committed class -- the report is an audit artefact, not runtime state. Acceptance gate (§7 of the report): all 6 checks pass. priority-score.sh runs clean (the new done.md files land in already-skipped dirs + the 12 real-umbrella closures). ZERO done.md files under exclusion-list dirs. UNCLEAR section present. Prior-art: skipped -- prose-only doc commit, no new capability. * docs(umbrella-donemd-backfill): expand report §7 with full gate evidence Task 6 acceptance gate is complete. Updates §7 to record all 6 gate checks explicitly + triages the 5 pre-existing done.md files in exclusion-list dirs (multi-model-pipeline-pilot, launch-preannounce-track, python-delivery-v0, generation-live-delivery, meta-orchestrator-prior-art) as pre-existing state authored by other maintainers' past PRs, not leaks from this umbrella. `git log --author=Yhooi2 --since=2026-07-23` confirms zero of my commits today touched any of those 5 files. All 6 acceptance-gate checks pass: 1. priority-score.sh runs clean (exit 0, 367 lines, no parse breakage) 2. ZERO NEW done.md under exclusion-list dirs (5 pre-existing are not this umbrella's work) 3. Every done.md corresponds to a report row with cited PR + merge SHA 4. UNCLEAR section present with 22 rows (T14 compliance) 5. Population enumeration present with exact command + 100-dir count 6. Schema check passes on all 12 new done.md files Prior-art: skipped -- prose-only doc edit, no new capability.
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
What
Commit the
done.mdclosure marker for the agnosticism-remediation umbrella. The marker was already authored but left untracked in the working tree; this commits it.Why
The umbrella's final stage merged via #577 (T-C — agnosticism-conformance principle test, slot 21). Per the umbrella-closure convention (CLAUDE.md),
priority-score.shLayer C3 checksdone.mdexistence to tag an umbrellastatus=DONE. Without the committed marker the umbrella keeps resurfacing as open backlog (closure debt). This is the same closure-sweep pattern as #561/#565.Scope
.claude/orchestrator-prompts/agnosticism-remediation/done.md.# <umbrella> — DONE/ Final PR / Closed / Summary).Reviewer notes
.claude/orchestrator-prompts/**is outside the §4b path list)./pipelineno-arg overview as untracked uncommitted work; committed on maintainer request (create-PR).