update go module dependencies - #11
Conversation
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Now I have enough to perform the selector-mode adjudication. Let me analyze the diff and findings:
Step 4c-sel CLASSIFY:
Changed files: CHANGELOG.md, go.mod, go.sum
| Rule | Decision | Reason |
|---|---|---|
changelog/conventional-prefix-required |
Applicable | CHANGELOG.md changed; entry lacks prefix |
go-mod-dependency-fix/tidy-after-get-update |
Skipped | go mod tidy was run (both go.mod + go.sum updated together) |
changelog/unreleased-entry-required |
Skipped | Entry exists — not violated |
adr/required-for-irreversible-architecture-decisions |
Skipped | Toolchain version bump ≠ irreversible architecture decision |
Step 4d-sel ADJUDICATE:
changelog/conventional-prefix-required: The entryupdate Go to 1.26.6 and update dependenciesstarts with bareupdateinstead ofchore:. Per the changelog guide, dependency updates should usechore:and include version numbers. Severity: Should Fix (Important).
The go mod tidy was properly run (both go.mod and go.sum updated together with consistent entries). No other violations.
PR Review: update go module dependencies
Must Fix (Critical): None.
Should Fix (Important):
CHANGELOG.md:10— changelog entry uses bareupdateinstead ofchore:prefix. Perchangelog/conventional-prefix-required, dependency updates must usechore:and include version numbers. Should bechore: Update Go to 1.26.6 and update dependencies. (rule:changelog/conventional-prefix-required)
Nice to Have (Optional): None.
Notes:
golang.org/x/modupdatedv0.39.0 → v0.40.0(fixes GO-2026-6179 and GO-2026-6180 — correct)golang.org/x/netupdatedv0.57.0 → v0.58.0Go toolchainupdated1.26.5 → 1.26.6(patch, non-breaking)- All
bborbe/*dependencies updated to latest patch versions go mod tidywas run (bothgo.modandgo.sumupdated together) —go-mod-dependency-fix/tidy-after-get-updatesatisfied- precommit skipped (selector mode) — CI covers lint+test
Traceability:
- Candidates: 4 judgment rules matched by Step 4b-i glob filter
- Applicable: 1 rule selected by Step 4c-sel
- Skipped:
go-mod-dependency-fix/tidy-after-get-update→ tidy was run;adr/required-for-irreversible-architecture-decisions→ toolchain patch bump not architectural;changelog/unreleased-entry-required→ entry present; 1 more skipped
{
"verdict": "approve",
"summary": "Dependency update is clean — golang.org/x/mod and golang.org/x/net security patches applied, go toolchain bumped to 1.26.6, all bborbe/* deps updated to latest. The only finding is the CHANGELOG entry missing the `chore:` conventional prefix (Should Fix level). go mod tidy was run correctly.",
"comments": [
{
"file": "CHANGELOG.md",
"line": 10,
"severity": "major",
"message": "changelog: entry uses bare 'update' instead of 'chore:' prefix — use 'chore: Update Go to 1.26.6 and update dependencies' per changelog/conventional-prefix-required"
}
],
"concerns_addressed": [
"security: vulnerabilities GO-2026-6179 and GO-2026-6180 fixed via golang.org/x/mod@v0.40.0",
"correctness: Go toolchain updated 1.26.5 -> 1.26.6; patch release, no breaking changes",
"correctness: 11 dependencies updated; go mod tidy run correctly (both go.mod and go.sum updated together)",
"tests: precommit skipped in selector mode — CI covers lint+test"
]
}# Conflicts: # CHANGELOG.md # go.mod # go.sum
superseded by new automated review
There was a problem hiding this comment.
Step 4c-sel CLASSIFY
The diff changes only CHANGELOG.md, go.mod, and go.sum. Applying the Step 4b-i glob filter over the rules index:
Candidates (matching triggers):
| Rule | Owner | applies_when |
|---|---|---|
changelog/conventional-prefix-required |
agent-auditor | CHANGELOG.md |
go-mod-dependency-fix/tidy-after-get-update |
go-quality-assistant | go.mod, go.sum |
go-mod-dependency-fix/exclude-over-cross-repo-replace |
go-quality-assistant | go.mod |
All other rules have triggers that don't match the changed files (no .go files, no agents/**, no commands/**, no skills/**, no main.go, etc.).
Step 4d-sel ADJUDICATE
Mechanical findings: Step 4a returned {stats: {findings_count: 0}} — zero findings. No violations to adjudicate.
Rule-level scan:
-
changelog/conventional-prefix-required: The## Unreleasedbullet is- chore: bump \github.com/bborbe/run` v1.9.34 -> v1.9.35.chore:` is a valid conventional prefix. No violation. -
go-mod-dependency-fix/tidy-after-get-update: The diff showsgithub.com/bborbe/runversion bumped fromv1.9.34tov1.9.35in bothgo.modandgo.sum.go.sumdiff shows the old hash removed and new hash added — this is exactly the signature ofgo mod tidy. Additionally, thereplaceandexcludedirectives were changed from parenthesized block form to single-line form (cosmetic), andbazelbuild/buildtoolswas moved fromrequireto a local replace (downstream effect of the tidy). No orphaned hashes. No violation. -
go-mod-dependency-fix/exclude-over-cross-repo-replace: Thereplacedirective isgithub.com/bazelbuild/buildtools => github.com/bazelbuild/buildtools v0.0.0-20250826111327-4006b543a694— same repo on both sides (not cross-repo). Theexcludedirective forcloud.google.com/go v0.26.0is a legitimate version exclusion, not a cross-repo replace. No violation.
Citation validation: Not needed — no findings were emitted from adjudication.
Step 3: LICENSE present. Precommit skipped (selector mode).
Selector mode traceability:
- Candidates: 3 rules matched by Step 4b-i glob filter
- Applicable: 3 rules selected by Step 4c-sel
- Skipped: none
Must Fix (Critical)
None.
Should Fix (Important)
None.
Nice to Have (Optional)
None.
Notes:
- The
replaceandexcludedirective reformatting (block → single line) is cosmetic and does not affect module resolution behavior. - The dependency update (
bborbe/runv1.9.34 → v1.9.35) is a patch bump — no semver risk. - CI will verify the build and tests with the new dependencies.
{
"verdict": "approve",
"summary": "Dependency update PR touching only go.mod/go.sum/CHANGELOG.md. The go mod tidy signature is present in go.sum, conventional changelog prefix is correct, replace/exclude directives are properly scoped, and the mechanical funnel found zero violations. Approve.",
"comments": [],
"concerns_addressed": [
"security: no CVE data provided — security posture of v1.9.35 vs v1.9.34 unknown, but no mechanical finding was raised by the security rules",
"correctness: no API breaking change at patch version bump — no go.mod API signature issues",
"tests: go.sum tidy signature present, CI will verify build and test pass"
]
}
Automated Go toolchain + dependency update.
CHANGELOG entry stays under
## Unreleased— the release agent versions and tags on merge.