Incompatible with version 1 modules: nagios, munin, firewall ?

[jskarpe]

Is the monitoring supposed to integrate with version 1 modules?

It seems to work for monit, but nagios, munin and firweall appears to be missing config.

My config:

include monit
include nagios
include iptables
include munin
include munin::server
class {
    "mysql" :
        puppi => true,
        monitor => true,
        monitor_tool => ["nagios", "monit", "munin"],
        firewall => true,
        firewall_src => ["10.47.0.0/24", "10.54.0.0/24"],
}

monit config /etc/monit.d/mysql_process is created, but no hosts are created in nagios or munin. Also, the iptables list is blank.

[alvagante]

For iptables you need to add
firewall_tool => 'iptables',

For monitoring:

• Add puppi to the monitor_tool arrays for a useful "puppi check" (this is not required for what you asked)
• It should work with Munin and Nagios too but note that:
  -- For nagios you need include nagios on the nagios server only
  -- For munin you need include munin::server on the munin server only

I've currently a customer with a setup of > 500 nodes with nagios, munin, monit and puppi set as monitoring tools using the old modules so there should not be probems in that. Still I might have missed something in the documentation for proper setup from scratch, so let's drill this down.
I would reccomend at least to use to different nodes for tests:

• The monitoring node should have at least
  include nagios
  include munin
  include munin::server
• The monitored nodes need
  include monit
  include munin
  include iptables

Note that you don't need to pass every time for your classes all those puppi/monitor/firewall variables. You can set them at top scope.

[jskarpe]

You're suggesting it doesn't work to monitor localhost?

[alvagante]

Not exactly. Never tested all of the on the same node, but my nagios / munin servers for sure monitor themselves.

[jskarpe]

My bad - storeconfig wasn't enabled for puppet master