Component Audit Authority Map

Astryx Component Audit Rubric — Authority Map

Rubric v1.15.3 mapped against repository authority at 4a8ded06fbc33df70829e87ea1a7c3e22131d7b3. Generated 2026-09-07. The rubric's current version may be newer; use this page's per-check classifications until a later mapping supersedes them.

Executive summary

• 249 checks, 249 unique IDs, no other ID families: Q 12, A 21, T 35 (including T2b), P 42, B 16, D 16, V 16, C 22, X 21, I 21, R 11, L 16.
• Per-check classifications remain 59 current repository authority, 8 objective external standards, 69 procedural/scoring-only, 16 draft/non-authoritative, 91 missing-owner, and 6 conflict/stale.
• Fetched origin/main now contains 44 current authority records, including landed spec:AST-029; component authority remains sparse: 9 of 44 Core component specs are current, and 35 are draft.
• AST-029 is authority: current, phase: accepted. TDD is owned by spec:AST-029/DEC-4 and its FR12 verification row; storage by FR13/DEC-5; scoring and targeted invalidation by FR14–FR15/DEC-6. FR11 keeps auto-merge unavailable until phase: shipped and atomic activation.

Classification legend

Code	Classification	Meaning
C	Current repository authority	Exact current record requirement/invariant owns the check, subject to its declared scope.
E	Objective external standard	A named normative standard supplies the pass/fail outcome; Astryx technique wording is not independently authoritative.
P	Procedural/scoring-only	The rubric may own how to review, gather evidence, document, or score; it does not define product behavior.
D	Draft/non-authoritative citation	A matching repository record exists but is authority: draft; it cannot currently gate or justify remediation.
M	Missing owner	The claim is product/implementation policy but no current record owns it. Wiki prose, implementation, lint, tests, and old PRs are evidence—not authority.
X	Conflict/stale assertion	The rubric contradicts current authority, contradicts itself, or imposes a stale universal rule.

Per-rule mapping

Q

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
Q1	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
Q2	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
Q3	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
Q4	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
Q5	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV4, INV6–INV7
Q6	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
Q7	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
Q8	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
Q9	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
Q10	C	spec:AST-027/FR7–FR10; architecture:layer-runtime/INV1–INV3
Q11	C	spec:AST-017/FR7
Q12	C	spec:AST-020/FR6; spec:AST-029/FR5, FR10

A

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
A1	E	WCAG 2.2 SC 4.1.2 (Name, Role, Value)
A2	C	spec:AST-020/FR1–FR2
A3	E	WCAG 2.2 SC 4.1.2 and SC 1.4.1
A4	X	Blanket “full APG” requirement conflicts with spec:AST-020/FR2: APG applies only when a current owner adopts that pattern; another standards-valid model may be authoritative.
A5	E	WAI-ARIA APG modal-dialog focus contract; WCAG 2.2 SC 2.4.3/2.4.11 where applicable
A6	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
A7	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
A8	C	architecture:interaction-modality/INV4
A9	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
A10	E	WCAG 2.2 SC 2.5.8 (Target Size (Minimum))
A11	C	family:buttons/FR3–FR5; family:input-fields/FR4–FR7 (only for those members)
A12	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
A13	D	design:motion/DR5 (draft); exact useEntryAnimation technique is not owned
A14	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
A15	C	architecture:interaction-modality/INV1–INV3
A16	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
A17	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
A18	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
A19	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
A20	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
A21	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.

T

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
T1	C	architecture:theme-tokens/INV3–INV4
T2	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV4, INV7–INV9
T2b	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T3	C	architecture:theme-tokens/INV3
T4	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV2–INV3, INV7
T5	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV6–INV7
T6	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV6
T7	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV2–INV5
T8	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T9	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T10	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T11	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T12	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV6
T13	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T14	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T15	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV4, INV6
T16	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV5–INV7; spec:AST-002/FR4
T17	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T18	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T19	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T20	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T21	C	architecture:theme-tokens/INV3
T22	D	design:color-emphasis/DR2, DR5 (draft)
T23	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV10–INV11; architecture:public-component-api/INV11
T24	C	architecture:container-padding/INV1–INV2, INV6
T25	D	design:motion/DR2–DR5 (draft); exact token/property list is not current authority
T26	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV6
T27	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T28	C	architecture:component-theming-surface/INV4–INV5
T29	C	spec:AST-002/FR4, FR6; architecture:component-theming-surface/INV5
T30	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
T31	C	architecture:theme-application/INV1, INV7–INV8; architecture:theme-authoring-contract/INV7
T32	C	architecture:theme-compilation/INV10; spec:AST-006/FR11
T33	C	spec:AST-017/FR1–FR8; architecture:public-component-api/INV9
T34	X	Conflicts with spec:AST-004/FR1 (empty unselected indicator space MUST collapse). Also exposes a current-current conflict: component:Selector/FR3 says every row reserves a column.

P

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
P1	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P2	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV5
P3	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV5–INV7
P4	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV2
P5	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV2
P6	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P7	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV2; family:layout-primitives/FR2
P8	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV3
P9	X	Uses onChangeAction, while current family:input-fields/FR6 and the rubric’s own P24/P25 use changeAction; family:input-fields/AV5 also says members need not add every optional concept.
P10	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV2; spec:AST-002/FR4, FR7, FR11, FR16
P11	C	spec:AST-017/FR1–FR8; architecture:public-component-api/INV9
P12	C	spec:AST-017/FR3; architecture:public-component-api/INV9
P13	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV3
P14	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P15	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P16	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV2
P17	X	Stale universal hooks-barrel rule. architecture:public-component-api/INV1 requires package entry-point or component-subpath reachability, not export from src/hooks/index.ts.
P18	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P19	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P20	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
P21	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
P22	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV2–INV3
P23	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P24	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P25	C	family:input-fields/FR6; family:buttons/FR5 (only for those members)
P26	C	spec:AST-002/FR2, FR4, FR6
P27	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV5–INV6
P28	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV5–INV7
P29	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV5
P30	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P31	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
P32	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV2; architecture:component-theming-surface/INV14
P33	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P34	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
P35	C	spec:AST-017/FR4, FR8; architecture:public-component-api/INV9
P36	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
P37	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P38	C	spec:AST-002/FR1–FR6, FR8–FR10
P39	C	spec:AST-002/FR3, FR8–FR9; architecture:public-component-api/INV4–INV5
P40	C	architecture:icon-resolution-and-component-slots/INV1–INV8; spec:AST-002/FR4
P41	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
P42	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.

B

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
B1	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
B2	C	architecture:interaction-modality/INV4
B3	C	architecture:interaction-modality/INV1–INV3
B4	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
B5	C	architecture:interaction-modality/INV5; family:buttons/FR3–FR4; family:input-fields/FR4 (scoped)
B6	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
B7	D	design:system-states/DR2–DR5 (draft)
B8	D	design:user-states/DR1, DR3–DR4 (draft)
B9	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
B10	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
B11	D	design:control-rhythm/DR1–DR2 (draft)
B12	P	Rubric-owned adversarial procedure under spec:AST-029/FR5 completeness; it does not itself define product behavior.
B13	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
B14	X	Its escape/top-layer requirement matches spec:AST-027/FR7–FR10, but “z-index follows semantic layer order” conflicts with spec:AST-027/FR4, which forbids global numeric rank/bands.
B15	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
B16	P	Rubric-owned bug-fix review procedure. For Night Watch audit-authored behavior tests specifically, spec:AST-029/DEC-4 requires a red-first observable-behavior TDD cycle.

D

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
D1	C	architecture:theme-tokens/INV3; family:layout-primitives/FR1, FR4
D2	D	design:spatial-hierarchy/DR1–DR2 (draft)
D3	D	design:spatial-hierarchy/DR4 (draft)
D4	D	design:shape-relationships/DR1–DR3 (draft)
D5	D	design:control-rhythm/DR1–DR3 (draft)
D6	D	design:typography-hierarchy/DR1–DR5 (draft)
D7	E	WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.3 and SC 1.4.11
D8	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
D9	D	design:color-emphasis/DR5 (draft)
D10	E	WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.1 (Use of Color)
D11	X	Directly conflicts with spec:AST-027/FR1 and FR4: z-index is local and has no system-wide semantic rank. Floating order is owned by FR7–FR10/top layer.
D12	D	design:motion/DR1–DR5 (draft)
D13	D	design:user-states/DR1, DR3–DR4 (draft)
D14	D	design:ordered-collection-reordering/DR1–DR8 (draft)
D15	D	design:template-composition/DR1–DR5 (draft)
D16	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.

V

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
V1	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V2	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V3	P	Rubric-owned test-quality procedure. For Night Watch remediation, spec:AST-029/DEC-4 requires the seam to come from current contracts or established public interfaces.
V4	P	Rubric-owned test-quality procedure. spec:AST-029/DEC-4 rejects implementation-coupled tests for Night Watch remediation.
V5	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V6	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V7	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V8	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V9	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V10	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V11	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V12	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V13	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V14	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
V15	P	Rubric-owned visual evidence procedure within spec:AST-029/FR5, FR7, and FR10 evidence/report boundaries.
V16	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.

C

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
C1	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C2	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C3	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C4	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C5	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C6	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C7	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C8	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C9	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C10	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C11	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C12	C	spec:AST-002/FR4 (plus applicable component/family contract)
C13	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C14	C	architecture:public-component-api/INV3–INV5; spec:AST-002/FR3
C15	C	spec:AST-002/FR4; architecture:icon-resolution-and-component-slots/INV1–INV8
C16	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C17	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C18	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C19	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C20	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C21	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
C22	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.

X

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
X1	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X2	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X3	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X4	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X5	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X6	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X7	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X8	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X9	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X10	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X11	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X12	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X13	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X14	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X15	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X16	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X17	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X18	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X19	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X20	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
X21	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.

I

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
I1	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I2	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I3	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I4	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I5	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I6	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I7	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I8	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I9	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I10	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I11	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I12	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I13	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I14	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I15	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I16	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I17	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I18	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I19	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I20	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
I21	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.

R

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
R1	E	WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.10 (Reflow)
R2	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
R3	C	spec:AST-012/FR1, FR8
R4	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
R5	E	WCAG 2.2 SC 1.4.10 and SC 2.1.1 where the dialog/overlay owns the task
R6	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
R7	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
R8	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
R9	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
R10	M	No current record adopts this universal claim; cited wiki/code/lint/test/PR is evidence or implementation, not authority.
R11	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.

L

ID	Class	Authority or disposition
L1	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L2	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L3	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L4	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L5	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L6	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L7	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L8	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L9	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L10	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L11	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L12	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L13	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.
L14	C	spec:AST-017/FR7–FR8
L15	C	architecture:knowledge-contracts/INV8
L16	P	Rubric-owned review, evidence, documentation, or scoring procedure; not product behavior authority.

Missing and conflicting authority, grouped by proposed owner

• Accessibility contract owner (extend spec:AST-020 only for universal outcomes; otherwise component/family owners): A6, A7, A9, A12, A14, A16, A17, A20, A21
• Theming/StyleX/icon/RSC architecture or contributor-policy owner: Q4, Q6, Q7, T2b, T8, T9, T10, T11, T13, T14, T17, T18, T19, T20, T27, T30
• Public API architecture/family owner: P1, P6, P14, P15, P18, P19, P23, P24, P30, P33, P37, P41, P42
• Behavior/design owner: B4, B6, B9, B10, D8, D16
• React/DOM/code-health architecture or contributor-policy owner: C1, C2, C3, C4, C5, C6, C7, C8, C9, C10, C11, C13, C16, C17, C18, C19, C20, C21, C22
• I18n/RTL architecture owner: I1, I2, I3, I4, I5, I6, I7, I8, I9, I10, I11, I12, I13, I14, I15, I16, I17, I18, I19, I20, I21
• Responsive/composition architecture owner: R2, R4, R6, R7, R8, R9, R10

Conflicts requiring owner resolution

• A4: Blanket “full APG” requirement conflicts with spec:AST-020/FR2: APG applies only when a current owner adopts that pattern; another standards-valid model may be authoritative.
• T34: Conflicts with spec:AST-004/FR1 (empty unselected indicator space MUST collapse). Also exposes a current-current conflict: component:Selector/FR3 says every row reserves a column.
• P9: Uses onChangeAction, while current family:input-fields/FR6 and the rubric’s own P24/P25 use changeAction; family:input-fields/AV5 also says members need not add every optional concept.
• P17: Stale universal hooks-barrel rule. architecture:public-component-api/INV1 requires package entry-point or component-subpath reachability, not export from src/hooks/index.ts.
• B14: Its escape/top-layer requirement matches spec:AST-027/FR7–FR10, but “z-index follows semantic layer order” conflicts with spec:AST-027/FR4, which forbids global numeric rank/bands.
• D11: Directly conflicts with spec:AST-027/FR1 and FR4: z-index is local and has no system-wide semantic rank. Floating order is owned by FR7–FR10/top layer.

Draft design dependencies

• Motion: A13, T25, D12 → design:motion/DR1–DR5 (draft).
• State/color: T22, B7, B8, D9, D13 → design:color-emphasis, design:system-states, and design:user-states (all draft).
• Layout/form: B11, D2–D6, D14–D15 → the corresponding spatial, shape, control-rhythm, typography, reorder, and template design records (all draft).

Landed AST-029 audit-system authority

• Contract assembly and conflicts: FR2–FR6 require current component/module, family, design, architecture, and system authority plus objective standards; drafts cannot clear findings.
• TDD remediation: DEC-4 is the operative current decision, with the Verification table’s FR12 row. Night Watch derives the seam from a current contract or established public interface, proves red before production changes, and implements one minimal observable slice.
• Storage and scoring: FR13/DEC-5 preserve the wiki ledger, PR evidence, and exact-head Check Run split. FR14–FR15/DEC-6 assemble applicable authority without changing weights and invalidate only affected scores.
• Activation: FR11 keeps every audit PR manual-review-only until AST-029 is phase: shipped and all activation surfaces land atomically.

Cross-cutting stale assertion

1. The wiki still says AST-029 is draft in the contract-establishment and Night Watch sections. Fetched origin/main is now current/accepted; the wiki should link to the landed record while preserving FR11’s manual-review-only state.

Prioritized migration plan

1. Stop false BLOCKs first. Resolve A4, T34, P9, P17, B14, and D11; reconcile the current-current spec:AST-004/FR1 vs component:Selector/FR3 conflict; update the wiki’s AST-029 status without enabling auto-merge before FR11 is shipped.
2. Create the missing high-impact owners. Establish current i18n/RTL and React/DOM contracts, then adopt or explicitly downgrade the unsupported BLOCK-capable theming/API/accessibility checks. Keep rules advisory/procedural until the owner is current.
3. Promote design deliberately, then rebind scores. Review the draft design records one decision at a time, move accepted requirements to current, update rubric citations to exact IDs, and invalidate only affected component scores per spec:AST-029/FR15.

Notes on scope

• C does not mean universal when the cited record is a family/component contract; it applies only to linked members. Audit assembly must follow spec:AST-029/FR2, FR14.
• E credits only the external user outcome. Astryx-specific implementation recipes still need a current owner or remain advisory.
• P may remain in the wiki because scoring and workflow are the rubric’s legitimate authority. It must not be cited as product behavior authority.
• No implementation, wiki page, draft record, lint rule, test, or historical PR was treated as product authority.