Skip to content

Designer Drift AuditDesigner files missing skills/lsp/evals field guidance and Ad Hoc Evaluation Mode cross-reference #49899

Description

@github-actions

Designer Drift Report — 2026-08-03

Summary

2 drift items found across 2 categories: missing frontmatter field coverage (skills, lsp, evals) and a missing cross-reference to the newly added Ad Hoc Evaluation Mode / Failure Classification content. Trigger, safe-output, network-ecosystem, and pattern coverage are all fully in sync.

View Drift Items by Category

Frontmatter Field Coverage

  • Source: .github/aw/syntax.md (index → skills.md, lsp.md, evals.md)
  • Missing from: .github/aw/designer.md (both the Decision Heuristics mapping tables and the Generation Template)
  • Details: syntax.md documents three top-level frontmatter fields — skills (skill loading), lsp (language server integration), and evals (BinEval binary evaluations) — but designer.md never mentions any of them in its "User says... → Maps to" tables, its Generation Template skeleton, or its References section.
  • Suggested fix: Add a short mapping row for each (e.g. "uses reusable skill bundles" → skills:, "wants LSP-backed code intelligence" → lsp:, "wants binary pass/fail evaluations" → evals:), and add skills.md/lsp.md/evals.md to the References list alongside the other syntax sub-files.

Recent Changes Without Sync

  • Source: .github/aw/create-agentic-workflow.md (Ad Hoc Evaluation Mode, Multi-Scenario Evaluation Example, Failure Classification — added in commit 5325893)
  • Missing from: .github/aw/designer.md and .github/agents/interactive-agent-designer.agent.md
  • Details: The same commit that added designer.md and the interactive-agent-designer agent also introduced a distinct "Ad Hoc Evaluation Mode" workflow (exploratory recommendations without file creation, multi-scenario comparison tables, and a 3-tier failure classification: invocation_unavailable / command_not_supported / response_unavailable) in create-agentic-workflow.md. Neither designer.md nor the interactive-agent-designer agent references this mode, so a user asking the designer for an exploratory "what would you recommend" evaluation has no pointer to it.
  • Suggested fix: Add a short note in designer.md's "When to Use This Skill" section pointing to create-agentic-workflow.md#ad-hoc-evaluation-mode for exploratory/no-file-creation requests, mirroring the existing cross-references to create-agentic-workflow.md and agentic-chat.md.

No Drift

  • ✅ Trigger coverage — all trigger types in triggers.md (pull_request, schedule/fuzzy scheduling, slash_command, label_command, workflow_dispatch, deployment_status, workflow_run, issues, forks) are represented in designer.md's Trigger Mapping table.
  • ✅ Safe output coverage — all ~44 safe-output action types from safe-outputs*.md and all-safe-output-types.txt are represented in designer.md's Safe Output Mapping table.
  • ✅ Network/tool coverage — all real ecosystem identifiers from network.md (the "Valid Values" and "Ecosystem Identifiers" tables) appear in designer.md's Network Mapping table; the "missing" entries found during comparison (npm, pip, cargo, docker, etc.) are network.md's documented invalid shorthands, not real identifiers, so this is not drift.
  • ✅ Pattern coverage — all 19 named patterns from patterns.md (MonitorOps, BatchOps, ChatOps, DailyOps, IssueOps, etc.) are referenced in designer.md's Pattern Heuristics table.
  • ✅ Stale references — no docs, fields, or options referenced by the designer files were found to be removed from the reference docs.

Methodology

Compared outlines of 8 reference docs (syntax.md, safe-outputs.md, network.md, patterns.md, subagents.md, token-optimization.md, triggers.md, create-agentic-workflow.md) against both designer files (.github/aw/designer.md and .github/agents/interactive-agent-designer.agent.md).
Reference doc commits (last 7 days): 1
Designer file commits (last 7 days): 1 (same commit — designer.md and the interactive-agent-designer agent were added together with the reference docs, but the Ad Hoc Evaluation Mode content added in create-agentic-workflow.md in that same commit was not cross-linked from the designer files)

Generated by 🔍 Designer Drift Audit · auto · 81.5 AIC · ⌖ 2.5 AIC · ⊞ 7.4K ·

  • expires on Aug 9, 2026, 8:58 PM UTC-08:00

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions