Projection settings and scenarios #96
grantdadams
started this conversation in
General
Replies: 0 comments
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Uh oh!
There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.
Currently, Rceattle runs projections assuming the terminal year of weight-at-age, selectivity, catchability, and consumption for all projection years. Only recruitment can change in the settings.
For recruitment for the forecast and BRPs, there are two options:
styrandendyrby settingproj_mean_rec = TRUEin the build_srr function fed into therecFunargument offit_mod. Alternatively, mean recruitment betweenstyrandsrr_mse_switchyrcan be used (default issrr_mse_switchyr = NULLand set toendyr), but this was designed for dealing with MSEs and Jim's stock-recruit curve as a penalty approach as the model is extended beyond the historical period. Future rec_devs, if different from default 0, will only be integrated into dynamic reference points.proj_mean_rec = FALSE.HCRs are specified via build_HCR and a 2-stage estimation approach is used. Stage-1 = estimate the hindcast, Stage-2 = rebuild, fixing the hindcast parameters and estimate the BRPs.
For uncertainty under HCRs,
projection_uncertaintyinfit_modwill do sdreport on all ADREPORTed derived quantities leaving both hindcast and projection (BRPs) parameters turned on AFTER estimation of both. This was designed to account for the the 2-stage estimation. If no HCR is used, no uncertainty in the BRPs will be integrated into the projections and things will be equivalent underprojection_uncertainty = TRUEandprojection_uncertainty = FALSE.@Cole-Monnahan-NOAA
For expansion, I think allowing weight-at-age, selectivity, catchability, and consumption to either use a mean between a specified range of years OR projected forward if time-varying would be important.
For DSEM integration, I think allowing both the projection under mean recruitment and DSEM would be valuable for comparing the value of DSEM to improving projection performance AND having backwards compatibility for the current AFSC approach. Turning off estimation of
x_tjin the projection and the projection's log-likelihood components would be the key for projecting under mean recruitment.All reactions