FastAPI migration testing of Validator's workflow

[manjitapandey]

Go on Tasking Manager staging site: https://tasks-stage.hotosm.org/
Testing the Explore Projects Page:

• Verify that project cards are displayed across different pages.
• Confirm that the map next to each project card can be shown or hidden.
• Apply filters and search for specific projects; confirm that results update as expected.
• Download project data as a CSV file and confirm it downloads without issues.

Testing Project Details Page:

• Click on any project card to open its Project Details page.
• Check that you can both view and post project-specific questions and comments. Also check tagging the users and authors and confirm if they get the notifications.
• Test marking projects as favourites by clicking on ‘mark as favourite’ on the bottom ribbon of the project details page. Also try removing the project from your favourite.
• Confirm that similar projects and the contribution timeline are visible and accurate.
• Click on the Contribute button at the bottom right corner and confirm that it takes you to the project’s Tasks page.

On the Tasks Page:

• Users should be able to view project’s instructions.
• Users should be able to view the Contributions on the contribution tab. Try applying the filters of the contribution tab and verify the filtered data is correct.
• Verify that the status of tasks is visible and accurate when viewed on the map.
• Confirm that you can access the history (Activities and comments) of individual tasks. Also verify that you can post comments on the specific task.

Validating a Task:

• Lock a single mapped task for validation.
• Lock multiple mapped tasks for validation.
• Test stopping the validation process midway clicking on stop validation.
• Try marking the tasks as both validated and invalidate and observe if the status is updated correctly on map through colours.
• Try multiple tasks locking and validating one and invalidating others.
• Try adding the comments on the task and confirm that it's posted and tagged.
• Ensure the notification and email is sent to respective mappers about validation and invalidation of task.
• Ensure that you are not able to validate projects where permission is restricted to only team members which you are not the part of.
• Also confirm the error message is displayed trying to validate the task you mapped by yourself.
• Confirm the state of task is changed to ready to validate while requesting for revalidation of already validated task. Also ensure the activity is captured in task history.

[adiatmad]

1. I can validate my mapped task, here. FYI, I have admin access.

Also confirm the error message is displayed trying to validate the task you mapped by yourself.

---

[manjitapandey]

You shouldn't be able to validate the task mapped by yourself unless you have super admin access. If you have super admin access on staging, then its expected behavior. Otherwise, it seems to be an issue.

[martien-176]

@manjitapandey and Dinar, with me, i cannot validate a self mapped task.

I am admin on the staging.

[martien-176]

I found an issue related to validation, but not in this test list.

In a validated task do "Opening editor -> iD Editor": the task opens in iD, but without task border.
"Opening editor -> JOSM": JOSM opens including task border.

I tested with Firefox and Chrome, Windows 10.

[martien-176]

Completed the validator workflow testing: all items okay.

[manjitapandey]

I am admin on the staging.

Can you confirm you are a super admin or organization admin?

In a validated task do "Opening editor -> iD Editor": the task opens in iD, but without task border.
"Opening editor -> JOSM": JOSM opens including task border.

I tested with Firefox and Chrome, Windows 10.

I tried to reproduce it on same browser but couldn't replicate the behavior. I can see those pink task boundaries for both single task selection and multiple tasks selection. Can you retry again and provide some more info? Screenshot maybe

[adiatmad]

A validator in Slack HOTOSM here raised an interesting question about the confusion between the development and live servers: How can we ensure we’re working on the correct one?

I propose adding a banner or something else on the development server to make it clear. Thank you!

[martien-176]

I am admin on the staging.

Can you confirm you are a super admin or organization admin?

In a validated task do "Opening editor -> iD Editor": the task opens in iD, but without task border.
"Opening editor -> JOSM": JOSM opens including task border.
I tested with Firefox and Chrome, Windows 10.

I tried to reproduce it on same browser but couldn't replicate the behavior. I can see those pink task boundaries for both single task selection and multiple tasks selection. Can you retry again and provide some more info? Screenshot maybe

https://tasks-stage.hotosm.org/projects/15973/tasks?search=374

I tested with this task and made an animated gif. Maybe i am missing something?

[manjitapandey]

I propose adding a banner or something else on the development server to make it clear. Thank you!

We have added a banner on staging server. Please confirm if this works good or should we make it more clear.

One more thing is we can only add the banner on homepage and can't be seen on other pages. Guess that won't cause lots of issue.

cc: @adiatmad , @martien-176

[martien-176]

I am admin on the staging.

Can you confirm you are a super admin or organization admin?

In a validated task do "Opening editor -> iD Editor": the task opens in iD, but without task border.
"Opening editor -> JOSM": JOSM opens including task border.
I tested with Firefox and Chrome, Windows 10.

I tried to reproduce it on same browser but couldn't replicate the behavior. I can see those pink task boundaries for both single task selection and multiple tasks selection. Can you retry again and provide some more info? Screenshot maybe

https://tasks-stage.hotosm.org/projects/15973/tasks?search=374

I tested with this task and made an animated gif. Maybe i am missing something?

https://tasks.hotosm.org/projects/15973/tasks?search=374&page=1

Additional test on live server, tested on same firefox profile: task border is visible. See screenshot.

Firefox version 135.0 (64-bit)
Windows 10

[manjitapandey]

@manjitapandey and Dinar, with me, i cannot validate a self mapped task.

I am admin on the staging.

Hi I just checked on the staging server and found that Dinar is an superadmin so he could validate the task mapped by himself however, Martien is an organisational admin (slightly different from super admin). Hence, the user being able to validate self mapped task is not an issue but expected behavior.

[manjitapandey]

In a validated task do "Opening editor -> iD Editor": the task opens in iD, but without task border.
"Opening editor -> JOSM": JOSM opens including task border.

I can now reproduce the issue. Will pass it to the developer and update you @martien-176 .
I will also add it on the workflow so that others can confirm it too. Thanks

[Pseudorandom-Pseudonym]

Testing the Explore Projects Page:

• Apply filters and search for specific projects; confirm that results update as expected.

It appears that issue #6648 which I reported during the first round of FastAPI testing occurs on the FastAPI staging site.

[Pseudorandom-Pseudonym]

Testing Project Details Page:

• Confirm that similar projects and the contribution timeline are visible and accurate.
  There are Sometimes Discrepancies Beetween a Project's Contribution Timeline and its Actual % of Mapped, and Validated Tasks #6751