Skip to content

Merging of pages doesn't work #41

Description

@namevaw

Search first

  • I searched and no similar issues were found

What Happened?

When a page is merged with another page, the resulting reference count is not updating correctly, unless the reference to the page to be merged is in the child node of the node containing the reference to the page to be merged with.
e.g. Merging #B with #A as follows, doesn't result in increased count of references to page #A
- #A
- #B
, but when #B is in a child node of #A ...
- #A
--- #B
.... .it works as expected.

Detailed description of the anomalies observed is provided in the "Reproduce the Bug" section.

Also, the symptoms I experienced are already described thoroughly in the following links:

  1. merging pages are incorrect #8286
  2. marging pages isn't working

Reproduce the Bug

1.Create 2 sibling blocks containing 2 different page references, e.g: "A1" and "A2" in them
- Block 1 #A1
- Block 2 #A2 ; ( to be merged with "A1")
2. Verify that both "A1" and "A2" have one linked reference each... and multiple unlinked ones.
3. Merge "A2" to "A1" ( by opening the "A2" page, renaming "A2" to "A1" and clicking "yes" on the resulting dialog box i..e "Page “A1” already exists, merge to it?")
4. Open "A1" page. There is '1 Linked Reference to "A1" listed where 2 are expected. Restarting #Logseq doesn't change that.

NOTE: if content of the parent block of blocks "Block 1..." and "Block 2..." is edited in some way, e.g. by adding space before "Create", the reference count in the "A1" page will update correctly.
Editing the content of "Block 2" also results in correct number of references.
Editing the content of "Block 1" doesn't affect the number of listed linked references. (???)

  1. ! When "Block 2" is a child of "Block 1", the inconsistencies described above don't occur.

The following markdown can be pasted into a Logseq page:

 -
-   1.Create 2  sibling blocks containing 2 different page references, e.g: "A1" and "A2"  in them
  logseq.order-list-type:: number
	- Block 1 #A1
	- Block 2 #A2  ; ( to be merged with "A1")
- Verify that both "A1" and "A2" have one linked reference each... and multiple unlinked ones.
  logseq.order-list-type:: number
- Merge "A2" to "A1" ( by opening the "A2" page, renaming "A2" to "A1"  and clicking "yes" on the resulting dialog box i..e "Page “A1” already exists, merge to it?")
  logseq.order-list-type:: number
- Open "A1" page. There is '1 Linked Reference to "A1" listed where 2 are expected. Restarting #Logseq doesn't change that.
  logseq.order-list-type:: number
  > NOTE: if content of the parent block of blocks "Block 1..." and "Block 2..." is edited in some way, e.g. by adding space before "Create", the reference count in the "A1" page will update correctly.  
Editing the content of "Block 2" also results in correct number of references.  
Editing the content of "Block 1" doesn't affect the number of listed linked references. (???)  
- ! When "Block 2" is a child of  "Block 1", the inconsistencies described above don't occur.
  logseq.order-list-type:: number

Expected Behavior

after merging pages, all of them should appear as linked references?

(the above paragraph is an excerpt from merging pages are incorrect #8286

Screenshots

No response

Desktop or Mobile Platform Information

App Version: 1.0.0
Git Revision: 680b371
Platform: Mozilla/5.0 (Windows NT 10.0 Win64 x64) AppleWebKit/537.36 (KHTML like Gecko) LogseqOG/1.0.0 Chrome/140.0.7339.240 Electron/38.4.0 Safari/537.36
Language: en-US
Plugins: logseq-regex-linker (v2.0.1), logseq-plugin-hierarchy-tool (v1.2.0), logseq-block-calendar (v0.2.11), logseq-elysium (v0.1.1), logseq-plugin-automatic-url-title (v1.1.0), logseq-plugin-template-block-from-toolbar (v1.1.0), logseq-query-builder-plugin (0.81), logseq-todo-plugin (v1.22.0), logseq-journals-calendar (v0.11.0), logseq-dynamic-lookup (v1.4.0), logseq-lumalee (v0.2), logseq-bullet-threading (v1.1.4), logseq-flow-nord-theme (v0.10.41), logseq-page-tags-and-hierarchy (v2.25.2), logseq-datenlp-plugin (v4.7.3), logseq-get-youtube-captions (v1.3.0), logseq-inbox-telegram-plugin (v0.1.5), logseq-todo-master (v1.10.3), logseq-page-breadcrumb (v1.0.1), logseq-agenda (v3.13.1), logseq-hypothesis (v0.2.4), logseq-add-para-properties (v1.2.1), logseq-kanban-plugin (v3.8.1), logseq-tags (v0.1.2), logseq-graph-analysis (0.12.0), logseq-smartblocks (3.51), logseq-mark-map (v0.4.6)

Additional Context

No response

Are you willing to submit a PR? If you know how to fix the bug.

  • I'm willing to submit a PR (Thank you!)

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions