Clean-up of 45_carbonprice module by laurinks · Pull Request #1858 · remindmodel/remind

laurinks · 2024-10-10T15:08:31Z

Purpose of this PR

Clean-up of 45_carbonprice module:

Remove realizations diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin (superseded by diffLin2Lin), exponential (superseded by diffExp2Lin) and linear (superseded by diffLin2Lin),
Consistent update of scenario config files (affects project files),
Improved documentation of diffLin2Lin and diffExp2Lin in main.gms.

Type of change

(Make sure to delete from the Type-of-change list the items not relevant to your PR)

Refactoring
Minor change (default scenarios show no differences)
This change requires a documentation update

Checklist:

My code follows the coding etiquette
I performed a self-review of my own code
I explained my changes within the PR, particularly in hard-to-understand areas
I checked that the in-code documentation is up-to-date
I adjusted the reporting in remind2 where it was needed
I adjusted forbiddenColumnNames in readCheckScenarioConfig.R in case the PR leads to deprecated switches
All automated model tests pass (FAIL 0 in the output of make test)
The changelog CHANGELOG.md has been updated correctly

…n2Lin by setting carbonprice constant after 2110 in both cases

…t files of module carbonprice

laurinks · 2024-10-10T15:23:06Z

File comparison: /p/projects/rd3mod/github/repos/remindmodel/remind/develop/config/scenario_config_21_EU11_ARIADNE.csv -> config/scenario_config_21_EU11_ARIADNE.csv Columns deleted: - Columns added: - Renamed columns: cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear Renamed rows: - Changes in the scenarios: ~ KN2045_Bal_v4: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ KN2045_Elec_v4: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ KN2045_H2_v4: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ KN2045_EnSov: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ KN2045plus_EasyRide: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ KN2045plus_LowDemand: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ KN2045minus_WorstCase: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ KN2045minus_SupplyFocus: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) $allwarnings NULL

laurinks · 2024-10-10T15:24:33Z

File comparison: /p/projects/rd3mod/github/repos/remindmodel/remind/develop/config/scenario_config_21_EU11_ECEMF.csv -> config/scenario_config_21_EU11_ECEMF.csv Columns deleted: - Columns added: - Renamed columns: cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear Renamed rows: - Changes in the scenarios: ~ xx_DIAG-NZero: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP1_Nzero: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP1_NZero-LimBio: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP1_NZero-LimCCS: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP1_NZero-LimNuclear: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_OPT-CP: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_OPT-CP-LimBio: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_OPT-CP-LimCCS: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_OPT-CP-LimNuclear: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_OPT-REG: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_OPT-REG-LimBio: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_OPT-REG-LimCCS: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_OPT-REG-LimNuclear: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_RAP-CP: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_RAP-CP-LimBio: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_RAP-CP-LimCCS: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_RAP-CP-LimNuclear: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_RAP-REG: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_RAP-REG-LimBio: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_RAP-REG-LimCCS: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP5_RAP-REG-LimNuclear: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ test_WP1_Nzero_DEU: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP1_Nzero_highPrecision_10tCO2eq: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP1_Nzero_highPrecision_5tCO2eq: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP1_Nzero_highPrecision_1tCO2eq: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ xx_WP1_Nzero_highPrecision_0p4tCO2eq: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) $allwarnings NULL

laurinks · 2024-10-10T15:25:21Z

File comparison: /p/projects/rd3mod/github/repos/remindmodel/remind/develop/config/scenario_config_DeepEl.csv -> config/scenario_config_DeepEl.csv Columns deleted: - Columns added: - Renamed columns: cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear Renamed rows: - Changes in the scenarios: ~ SSP2-PkBudg500-DeepEl: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg1150-DeepEl: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) $allwarnings NULL

laurinks · 2024-10-10T15:26:30Z

File comparison: /p/projects/rd3mod/github/repos/remindmodel/remind/develop/config/scenario_config_EL2p0DeepDive.csv -> config/scenario_config_EL2p0DeepDive.csv Columns deleted: - Columns added: - Renamed columns: cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear Renamed rows: - Changes in the scenarios: ~ SSP2EU-noDSPkB500-noDS_betax_DeepDive: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-DSPkB500-DS_betax_DeepDive: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-noDSPkB650-noDS_betax_DeepDive: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-DSPkB650-DS_betax_DeepDive: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-noDSPkB1050-noDS_betax_DeepDive: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-DSPkB1050-DS_betax_DeepDive: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-noDSPkB500-noDS_betax_AgMIP: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-DSPkB500-DS_betax_AgMIP: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-noDSPkB650-noDS_betax_AgMIP: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-DSPkB650-DS_betax_AgMIP: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-noDSPkB1050-noDS_betax_AgMIP: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-DSPkB1050-DS_betax_AgMIP: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-noDSPkB500-noDS_betax_DeepDive_noNDC: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-DSPkB500-DS_betax_DeepDive_noNDC: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-noDSPkB650-noDS_betax_DeepDive_noNDC: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-DSPkB650-DS_betax_DeepDive_noNDC: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-noDSPkB1050-noDS_betax_DeepDive_noNDC: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2EU-DSPkB1050-DS_betax_DeepDive_noNDC: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) $allwarnings NULL

laurinks · 2024-10-10T15:27:49Z

File comparison: /p/projects/rd3mod/github/repos/remindmodel/remind/develop/config/scenario_config_ELEVATE4p4.csv -> config/scenario_config_ELEVATE4p4.csv Columns deleted: - Columns added: - Renamed columns: cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear Renamed rows: - Changes in the scenarios: $allwarnings NULL

laurinks · 2024-10-10T15:30:09Z

File comparison: /p/projects/rd3mod/github/repos/remindmodel/remind/develop/config/scenario_config_IKEA.csv -> config/scenario_config_IKEA.csv Columns deleted: - Columns added: - Renamed columns: cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear Renamed rows: - Changes in the scenarios: ~ testOneRegi-Base_500_debug: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg1150: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg650: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg620: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg590: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg560: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg530: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg500_floor2: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg650_floor2: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg1150_floor2: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg500_floor3: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg650_floor3: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg1150_floor3: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg600_cost_budget1_2030bionu: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg600_cost_budget2_2030bionu: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg600_cost_budget5_2030bionu: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg620_cost_budget5_2030bionu: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg650_cost_budget5_2030bionu: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg600_cost_year_2030: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg590_budget_year_2030: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg650_floor2_demInc: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ SSP2-PkBudg1150_floor2_demInc: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) $allwarnings NULL

laurinks · 2024-10-10T15:30:57Z

File comparison: /p/projects/rd3mod/github/repos/remindmodel/remind/develop/config/scenario_config_NGFS_v5.csv -> config/scenario_config_NGFS_v5.csv Columns deleted: - Columns added: - Renamed columns: cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear Renamed rows: - Changes in the scenarios: ~ o_1p5c: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_lowdem: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_2c: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ d_delfrag: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ d_rap: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_1p5c_KLW_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_lowdem_KLW_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_2c_KLW_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ d_delfrag_KLW_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ d_rap_KLW_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_1p5c_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_1p5c_d95: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_1p5c_d50high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_1p5c_d95high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_1p5c_d50_cpricereg: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_1p5c_d95_cpricereg: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_1p5c_dni50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_1p5c_dni95: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_lowdem_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_lowdem_d95: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_lowdem_d50high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_lowdem_d95high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ o_2c_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ o_2c_d95: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ o_2c_d50high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ o_2c_d95high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ o_2c_d50_cpricereg: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ o_2c_d95_cpricereg: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ o_2c_dni50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ o_2c_dni95: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ d_delfrag_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ d_delfrag_d95: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ d_delfrag_d50high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ d_delfrag_d95high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) ~ d_rap_d50: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ d_rap_d95: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ d_rap_d50high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) ~ d_rap_d95high: carbonprice: diffCurvPhaseIn2Lin -> diffLin2Lin (default: none) cm_co2_tax_2020 -> cm_co2_tax_startyear: 200 -> 150 (default: -1) $allwarnings NULL

laurinks · 2024-10-11T07:09:27Z

-*' * (none): no tax policy (combined with all emiscens except emiscen = 9)
-*' * (exponential): [please use new diffExp2Lin with cm_co2_tax_spread = 1 and iterative_target_adj = 5 for exponential carbon pricing until end of century (without regional differentiation)] 4.5% exponential increase over time of the tax level in 2020 set via cm_co2_tax_2020 (combined with emiscen = 9 and cm_co2_tax_2020>0)
-*' * (expoLinear): 4.5% exponential increase until c_expoLinear_yearStart, transitioning into linear increase thereafter
+*' * (diffExp2Lin) and (diffLin2Lin): standard carbonprice realizations for ambitious climate policy scenarios [REMIND default for peak budget runs: diffLin2Lin in combination with iterative_target_adj = 9], 


Improved documentation of (diffExp2Lin) and (diffLin2Lin).

laurinks · 2024-10-11T07:10:58Z

 *' * (NPi): National Policies Implemented, extrapolation of historical (until 2020) carbon prices
+*' * (none): no tax policy (combined with all emiscens except emiscen = 9)
+
+***  (exponential) is superseded by (diffExp2Lin): For a globally uniform, exponentially increasing carbonprice path until end of century [in combination with cm_iterative_target_adj = 0 or 5], set cm_co2_tax_spread = 1, set cm_peakBudgYr = 2110, and choose the initial carbonprice in cm_startyear via cm_co2_tax_startyear. 


Additional explanations on how to obtain behavior of superseded realizations (exponential) and (linear)

That is helpful, I think.

laurinks · 2024-10-11T07:11:44Z

 *' *  (10): used for cost-benefit analysis
 *' *JeS* WARNING: data for cm_emiscen 4 only exists for multigas_scen 2 bau scenarios and for multigas_scen 1
 *'
-parameter


Old switch, no longer used.

laurinks · 2024-10-11T07:13:35Z

 ***       (with iterative_target_adj = 5):  carbon price of developed countries keeps increasing linearly (with same slope) until end of century, i.e. no change after peak year 
 ***       (with iterative_target_adj = 0):  after year given by cm_peakBudgYr (default = 2050), carbon price of developed countries increases linearly with fixed annual increase given by cm_taxCO2inc_after_peakBudgYr (default = 0, i.e. constant),
-***                                         for linearly increasing carbon price (with same slope) until end of century, set cm_peakBudgYr = 2100         
+***                                         for linearly increasing carbon price (with same slope) until end of century, set cm_peakBudgYr = 2110         


Consistent implementation in (diffLin2Lin) and (diffExp2Lin): If linear/exponential increase is selected until end of century (e.g. with cm_iterative_target_adj = 5), carbonprices are set constant from 2110 onward.

laurinks · 2024-10-11T07:14:33Z



 *' @description BAU, tax30, and tax150 runs are set in a loop of 30 runs in total.
-*' The realization needs the realization "exogenous" of the 45_carbonprice module


Outdated documentation

laurinks · 2024-10-11T07:17:40Z

Not sure if this module is still in use. Nonetheless cleaned it up. Previously, it just used a copy-paste version of the 45_carbonprice/exponential with exponentially increasing carbonprices from 2010 onward (with the 2020 value set to 0,30,150). For simplicity, I reduced it to one line of code. Now, it is still exponentially increasing from 2010 onward but the startyear (default = 2005) value is set to 0,30,150.

orichters

I have to admit I did not check everything in detail, but overall it looks very convincing. Thanks for investing in checking documentation and tutorials, that is very appreciated! Also thanks for providing the human-readable summary of the config file changes!

orichters · 2024-10-11T10:07:58Z

 *' * (NPi): National Policies Implemented, extrapolation of historical (until 2020) carbon prices
+*' * (none): no tax policy (combined with all emiscens except emiscen = 9)
+
+***  (exponential) is superseded by (diffExp2Lin): For a globally uniform, exponentially increasing carbonprice path until end of century [in combination with cm_iterative_target_adj = 0 or 5], set cm_co2_tax_spread = 1, set cm_peakBudgYr = 2110, and choose the initial carbonprice in cm_startyear via cm_co2_tax_startyear. 


That is helpful, I think.

LaviniaBaumstark

thanks for all that cleaning!
the scenario:config.csv file is already using teh new formulation, right?

laurinks · 2024-10-11T11:53:48Z

Thanks for the reviews! @LaviniaBaumstark : Yes, diffLin2Lin was introduced as the REMIND default in PR#1747. That's why the clean-up changes now only affect some project configs.

laurinks added 5 commits October 10, 2024 10:39

Consistent treatment of end of century runs in diffExp2Lin and diffLi…

4e6d3ac

…n2Lin by setting carbonprice constant after 2110 in both cases

Update documentation of 45_carbonprice in main.gms

b4c520d

Clean-up of 45_carbonprice module: Removing superseded realizations

09a4bf0

cm_co2_tax_2020 removed as interface and deleted from all not_used.tx…

c34a15d

…t files of module carbonprice

forbidden column name added

5511f6b

laurinks commented Oct 10, 2024

View reviewed changes

laurinks commented Oct 11, 2024

View reviewed changes

Updated changelog

5ff49cc

laurinks requested review from LaviniaBaumstark and orichters October 11, 2024 07:25

orichters approved these changes Oct 11, 2024

View reviewed changes

LaviniaBaumstark approved these changes Oct 11, 2024

View reviewed changes

laurinks merged commit 54adc6c into remindmodel:develop Oct 11, 2024

laurinks deleted the 45_carbonprice branch October 11, 2024 11:54



		*' @description BAU, tax30, and tax150 runs are set in a loop of 30 runs in total.
		*' The realization needs the realization "exogenous" of the 45_carbonprice module

Uh oh!

Conversation

laurinks commented Oct 10, 2024 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Purpose of this PR

Type of change

Checklist:

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

laurinks Oct 10, 2024 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

orichters left a comment • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

LaviniaBaumstark left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

laurinks commented Oct 11, 2024

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

3 participants

laurinks commented Oct 10, 2024 •

edited

Loading

laurinks Oct 10, 2024 •

edited

Loading

orichters left a comment •

edited

Loading