Update ScenarioMIP config files for main_v6 runs by flohump · Pull Request #1972 · remindmodel/remind

flohump · 2025-02-03T21:02:46Z

Purpose of this PR

Type of change

Config file update (project: ScenarioMIP)

Checklist:

My code follows the coding etiquette
I performed a self-review of my own code
I explained my changes within the PR, particularly in hard-to-understand areas
I checked that the in-code documentation is up-to-date
I adjusted the reporting in remind2 where it was needed
I adjusted forbiddenColumnNames in readCheckScenarioConfig.R in case the PR leads to deprecated switches
I checked the log.txt file of my runs for newly introduced summation, fixing or variable name errors
All automated model tests pass (FAIL 0 in the output of make test)
The changelog CHANGELOG.md has been updated correctly

laurinks

Thanks, @flohump, for updating and streamlining the coupled config for ScenarioMIP!

For the documentation, I think it would be helpful to note down what changed content-wise and what changed only in terms of naming. Here is my attempt.

Renaming/restructuring:

s32_aff_plantation: Switch replaced by setting AR-plant / AR-Natveg in column f
s32_npi_ndc_reversal and s35_npi_ndc_reversal replaced by setting NPI-revert in column f
Setting SDP-MC|SSP1-POP-GDP renamed to VLLO in column f

Content changes:

AR-plant as new default for VLHO scenario.

Could you add a link to an explanation of s32_planning_horizon (used of VLHO variant) and s29_treecover_target and briefly comment on the choices? And for the renaming of the column to f ?

laurinks · 2025-02-06T17:57:39Z

Two more questions:

Should we make analogous changes to scenario_config_coupled.csv (as we are trying to keep the default REMIND scenarios (standalone and coupled) closely harmonized with ScenarioMIP scenarios)?
Is it fine to keep the elastic demand for now or should we switch it off for the next test runs (with the goal of switching back on for the next submission runs - if tax recycling available by then)?

LaviniaBaumstark · 2025-03-05T09:47:43Z

is this PR relevant for the next REMIND release?

laurinks · 2025-03-05T15:56:25Z

Yes, this is relevant for the next REMIND release as we will use it for ScenarioMIP coupled runs. We need to review the coupling configs regarding:

potential changes made in MAgPIE that are relevant for ScenarioMIP/default runs and require specific settings in the coupling config
streamlining (purpose of this PR)
decisions regarding coupling (i.e. removing low pass filter - if finally agreed)

@flohump: When do you expect 1 to be (almost) final so that we can proceed with this?

flohump · 2025-03-06T10:06:08Z

Yes, this is relevant for the next REMIND release as we will use it for ScenarioMIP coupled runs. We need to review the coupling configs regarding:

potential changes made in MAgPIE that are relevant for ScenarioMIP/default runs and require specific settings in the coupling config

streamlining (purpose of this PR)

decisions regarding coupling (i.e. removing low pass filter - if finally agreed)

@flohump: When do you expect 1 to be (almost) final so that we can proceed with this?

The settings for soil carbon management (still in the making) also need to be included in the scenario_config_coupled.csv.
I guess early next, we can finalize it.

# Conflicts: # config/scenario_config_ScenarioMIP.csv # config/scenario_config_coupled_ScenarioMIP.csv

laurinks · 2025-03-14T10:50:29Z

Comparison of scenario_config_ScenarioMIP.csv with scenario_config.csv (REMIND default):

> compareScenConf(fileList = c("./config/scenario_config.csv","./config/scenario_config_ScenarioMIP.csv"),remindPath = ".",renamedRows = c("SSP2-NPi2025" = "SMIPv06-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def","SSP1-NPi2025" = "SMIPv06-M-SSP1-NPi2025-def","SSP3-NPi2025" = "SMIPv06-M-SSP3-NPi2025-def","SSP2-rollBack"="SMIPv06-H-SSP2-rollBack-def","SSP3-rollBack"="SMIPv06-H-SSP3-rollBack-def","SSP2-PkBudg1000"="SMIPv06-L-SSP2-PkBudg1000-def", "SSP1-PkBudg1000"="SMIPv06-L-SSP1-PkBudg1000-def","SSP3-PkBudg1000"="SMIPv06-L-SSP3-PkBudg1000-def", "SSP2-EcBudg400"="SMIPv06-VLHO-SSP2-EcBudg400-def", "SSP2-PkBudg650" = "SMIPv06-VLLO-SSP2-PkBudg650-def", "SSP1-PkBudg650" = "SMIPv06-VLLO-SSP1-PkBudg650-def") )

Output (start, path_gdx_xxx, description entries removed for better readability, scenarios that were added/deleted removed for better readability):

Main differences concern carbon price (initial values and differentiation), ProdCost and EW. Further differences at places were ScenarioMIP links certain assumptions to emissions scenario instead of SSP (e.g. AP).

File comparison: ./config/scenario_config.csv -> ./config/scenario_config_ScenarioMIP.csv
Columns deleted: c_ccscapratescen, c_tech_earlyreti_rate, capitalMarket, CES_parameters, cm_bioenergy_SustTax, cm_emiMktTarget, cm_nucscen, cm_prtpScen, cm_taxCO2_regiDiff_endYr, extramappings_historic, regionmapping, slurmConfig
Columns added:   cm_nash_autoconverge, cm_taxCO2_historical, cm_taxCO2_historicalYr, cm_taxCO2_IncAfterPeakBudgYr, cm_taxCO2_interpolation, cm_taxCO2_startYearValue, copyConfigFrom
Renamed columns: -
Renamed rows:    SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv06-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def, SSP1-NPi2025 -> SMIPv06-M-SSP1-NPi2025-def, SSP3-NPi2025 -> SMIPv06-M-SSP3-NPi2025-def, SSP2-rollBack -> SMIPv06-H-SSP2-rollBack-def, SSP3-rollBack -> SMIPv06-H-SSP3-rollBack-def, SSP2-PkBudg1000 -> SMIPv06-L-SSP2-PkBudg1000-def, SSP1-PkBudg1000 -> SMIPv06-L-SSP1-PkBudg1000-def, SSP3-PkBudg1000 -> SMIPv06-L-SSP3-PkBudg1000-def, SSP2-EcBudg400 -> SMIPv06-VLHO-SSP2-EcBudg400-def, SSP2-PkBudg650 -> SMIPv06-VLLO-SSP2-PkBudg650-def, SSP1-PkBudg650 -> SMIPv06-VLLO-SSP1-PkBudg650-def

Changes in the rows:
~ SSP3-rollBack -> SMIPv06-H-SSP3-rollBack-def:
    cm_budgetCO2from2020: 0 -> 1150 (default: 0)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
~ SSP2-NPi2025 -> SMIPv06-M-SSP2-NPi2025-def:
    cm_budgetCO2from2020: 0 -> 1150 (default: 0)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
+ SMIPv06-ML-SSP2-PkBudg1500-def was added.
~ SSP2-PkBudg1000 -> SMIPv06-L-SSP2-PkBudg1000-def:
    cm_taxCO2_startyear: 75 -> 85 (default: -1)
    cm_peakBudgYr: 2080 -> 2070 (default: 2050)
    cm_taxCO2_regiDiff: initialSpread10 -> none (default: initialSpread10)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
    cm_taxCO2_historical: NA -> 60 (default: gdx_ref)
    cm_taxCO2_historicalYr: NA -> 2025 (default: last)
    cm_taxCO2_IncAfterPeakBudgYr: NA -> 5 (default: 0)
    cm_taxCO2_interpolation: NA -> (EUR,USA,JPN,NEU,CAZ).2030.2040 1,(REF,CHA,LAM,MEA).2030.2060 1.25,OAS.2030.2070 1.5,IND.2030.2070 2,SSA.2030.2070 3 (default: off)
    cm_taxCO2_startYearValue: NA -> EUR 130,(CAZ,USA,JPN,NEU) 40,LAM 25,(MEA,REF,CHA,OAS) 15,IND 10,SSA 5 (default: )
~ SSP2-EcBudg400 -> SMIPv06-VLHO-SSP2-EcBudg400-def:
    cm_taxCO2_startyear: 70 -> 80 (default: -1)
    cm_taxCO2_regiDiff: initialSpread20 -> none (default: initialSpread10)
    cm_taxCO2_interpolation: NA -> (EUR,USA,JPN,NEU,CAZ).2030.2040 1,(REF,CHA,LAM,MEA).2030.2060 1.25,OAS.2030.2070 1.5,IND.2030.2070 2,SSA.2030.2070 3 (default: off)
    cm_taxCO2_startYearValue: NA -> off (default: )
~ SSP1-PkBudg650 -> SMIPv06-VLLO-SSP1-PkBudg650-def:
    cm_peakBudgYr: 2055 -> 2050 (default: 2050)
    cm_taxCO2_regiDiff: initialSpread10 -> none (default: initialSpread10)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    cm_1stgen_phaseout: 1 -> 0 (default: 0)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
    cm_taxCO2_historical: NA -> 60 (default: gdx_ref)
    cm_taxCO2_historicalYr: NA -> 2025 (default: last)
    cm_taxCO2_IncAfterPeakBudgYr: NA -> 2 (default: 0)
    cm_taxCO2_interpolation: NA -> (EUR,USA,JPN,NEU,CAZ).2030.2040 1,(REF,CHA,LAM,MEA).2030.2050 1.25,OAS.2030.2050 1.5,IND.2030.2050 2,SSA.2030.2050 3 (default: off)
    cm_taxCO2_startYearValue: NA -> EUR 150,(CAZ,NEU,USA,JPN) 60,(REF,CHA,LAM,MEA) 30,OAS 20,IND 15,SSA 10 (default: )
~ SSP2-rollBack -> SMIPv06-H-SSP2-rollBack-def:
    cm_budgetCO2from2020: 0 -> 1150 (default: 0)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    cm_APscen: SSP2 -> CLE (default: SSP2)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
~ SSP2-PkBudg650 -> SMIPv06-VLLO-SSP2-PkBudg650-def:
    cm_peakBudgYr: 2055 -> 2050 (default: 2050)
    cm_taxCO2_regiDiff: initialSpread10 -> none (default: initialSpread10)
    cm_fetaxscen: 3 -> 2 (default: 3)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    c_ccsinjecratescen: 1 -> 5 (default: 1)
    cm_CESMkup_build: standard -> feelhpb 1.4, fehob 0.8, feheb 0.15 (default: standard)
    cm_maxProdBiolc: off -> 100 (default: off)
    cm_APscen: SSP2 -> MFR (default: SSP2)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
    cm_taxCO2_historical: NA -> 60 (default: gdx_ref)
    cm_taxCO2_historicalYr: NA -> 2025 (default: last)
    cm_taxCO2_IncAfterPeakBudgYr: NA -> 2 (default: 0)
    cm_taxCO2_interpolation: NA -> (EUR,USA,JPN,NEU,CAZ).2030.2040 1,(REF,CHA,LAM,MEA).2030.2050 1.25,OAS.2030.2050 1.5,IND.2030.2050 2,SSA.2030.2050 3 (default: off)
    cm_taxCO2_startYearValue: NA -> EUR 150,(CAZ,NEU,USA,JPN) 60,(REF,CHA,LAM,MEA) 30,OAS 20,IND 15,SSA 10 (default: )
    copyConfigFrom: NA -> SMIPv06-VLLO-SSP1-PkBudg650-def
+ SMIPv06-H-SSP1-rollBack-def was added.
~ SSP1-NPi2025 -> SMIPv06-M-SSP1-NPi2025-def:
    cm_budgetCO2from2020: 0 -> 1150 (default: 0)
    cm_fetaxscen: 2 -> 3 (default: 3)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    c_ccsinjecratescen: 5 -> 1 (default: 1)
    cm_maxProdBiolc: 100 -> off (default: off)
    cm_1stgen_phaseout: 1 -> 0 (default: 0)
    cm_APscen: MFR -> SSP2 (default: SSP2)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
~ SSP1-PkBudg1000 -> SMIPv06-L-SSP1-PkBudg1000-def:
    cm_taxCO2_startyear: 75 -> 85 (default: -1)
    cm_peakBudgYr: 2080 -> 2070 (default: 2050)
    cm_taxCO2_regiDiff: initialSpread10 -> none (default: initialSpread10)
    cm_fetaxscen: 2 -> 3 (default: 3)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    c_ccsinjecratescen: 5 -> 1 (default: 1)
    cm_maxProdBiolc: 100 -> off (default: off)
    cm_1stgen_phaseout: 1 -> 0 (default: 0)
    cm_APscen: MFR -> SSP2 (default: SSP2)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
    cm_taxCO2_historical: NA -> 60 (default: gdx_ref)
    cm_taxCO2_historicalYr: NA -> 2025 (default: last)
    cm_taxCO2_IncAfterPeakBudgYr: NA -> 5 (default: 0)
    cm_taxCO2_interpolation: NA -> (EUR,USA,JPN,NEU,CAZ).2030.2040 1,(REF,CHA,LAM,MEA).2030.2060 1.25,OAS.2030.2070 1.5,IND.2030.2070 2,SSA.2030.2070 3 (default: off)
    cm_taxCO2_startYearValue: NA -> EUR 130,(CAZ,USA,JPN,NEU) 40,LAM 25,(MEA,REF,CHA,OAS) 15,IND 10,SSA 5 (default: )
~ SSP3-NPi2025 -> SMIPv06-M-SSP3-NPi2025-def:
    cm_budgetCO2from2020: 0 -> 1150 (default: 0)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    cm_APscen: CLE -> SSP2 (default: SSP2)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
~ SSP3-PkBudg1000 -> SMIPv06-L-SSP3-PkBudg1000-def:
    subsidizeLearning: off -> globallyOptimal (default: off)
    cm_taxCO2_startyear: 75 -> 85 (default: -1)
    cm_peakBudgYr: 2080 -> 2070 (default: 2050)
    cm_taxCO2_regiDiff: initialSpread10 -> none (default: initialSpread10)
    cm_33EW: 0 -> 1 (default: 0)
    cm_APscen: CLE -> SSP2 (default: SSP2)
    c_changeProdCost: 1 -> 5 (default: 5)
    cm_taxCO2_historical: NA -> 60 (default: gdx_ref)
    cm_taxCO2_historicalYr: NA -> 2025 (default: last)
    cm_taxCO2_IncAfterPeakBudgYr: NA -> 5 (default: 0)
    cm_taxCO2_interpolation: NA -> (EUR,USA,JPN,NEU,CAZ).2030.2040 1,(REF,CHA,LAM,MEA).2030.2060 1.25,OAS.2030.2070 1.5,IND.2030.2070 2,SSA.2030.2070 3 (default: off)
    cm_taxCO2_startYearValue: NA -> EUR 130,(CAZ,USA,JPN,NEU) 40,LAM 25,(MEA,REF,CHA,OAS) 15,IND 10,SSA 5 (default: )

$allwarnings
NULL

laurinks

MAgPIE changes in coupling config look good to me.

update MAgPIE start config

b44bc84

flohump requested a review from laurinks February 3, 2025 21:02

laurinks reviewed Feb 6, 2025

View reviewed changes

flohump added 4 commits March 13, 2025 12:16

update scenario config soil carbon management and raw LUC CO2 emissions

346c2b2

MAgPIE settings

73382e7

Merge branch 'develop' of github.com:remindmodel/remind into f_coupling2

7b096d4

# Conflicts: # config/scenario_config_ScenarioMIP.csv # config/scenario_config_coupled_ScenarioMIP.csv

Update MAgPIE settings ScenarioMIP

9325d43

laurinks changed the title ~~update MAgPIE start config~~ Update ScenarioMIP config files for main_v6 runs Mar 14, 2025

laurinks added 2 commits March 14, 2025 11:35

Update ScenarioMIP config files for main_v6

edd0328

Update changelog

e392380

laurinks self-requested a review March 14, 2025 11:03

laurinks approved these changes Mar 14, 2025

View reviewed changes

Correct VLLO to VLLO|SSP1-POP-GDP

296d88b

laurinks merged commit 080ab06 into develop Mar 14, 2025

laurinks deleted the f_coupling2 branch March 14, 2025 13:45

laurinks mentioned this pull request Mar 14, 2025

Update default scenario config and coupled scenario config #2036

Merged

11 tasks

Provide feedback

Saved searches

Use saved searches to filter your results more quickly

Uh oh!

Update ScenarioMIP config files for main_v6 runs - #1972

Update ScenarioMIP config files for main_v6 runs#1972
laurinks merged 8 commits into
developfrom
f_coupling2

flohump commented Feb 3, 2025 •

edited by laurinks

Loading

Uh oh!

laurinks left a comment •

edited

Loading

Uh oh!

laurinks commented Feb 6, 2025

Uh oh!

LaviniaBaumstark commented Mar 5, 2025

Uh oh!

laurinks commented Mar 5, 2025

Uh oh!

flohump commented Mar 6, 2025

Uh oh!

laurinks commented Mar 14, 2025 •

edited

Loading

Uh oh!

laurinks left a comment

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

3 participants

Uh oh!

Conversation

flohump commented Feb 3, 2025 • edited by laurinks Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Purpose of this PR

Type of change

Checklist:

Uh oh!

laurinks left a comment • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

laurinks commented Feb 6, 2025

Uh oh!

LaviniaBaumstark commented Mar 5, 2025

Uh oh!

laurinks commented Mar 5, 2025

Uh oh!

flohump commented Mar 6, 2025

Uh oh!

laurinks commented Mar 14, 2025 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

Uh oh!

laurinks left a comment

Choose a reason for hiding this comment

Uh oh!

Reviewers

Assignees

Labels

Projects

Milestone

Development

Uh oh!

3 participants

flohump commented Feb 3, 2025 •

edited by laurinks

Loading

laurinks left a comment •

edited

Loading

laurinks commented Mar 14, 2025 •

edited

Loading