AS8 — Auth Audit Observability (plan-of-record + PLAN-EVAL gate)

[rickylabs]

AS8 — Auth Audit Observability

Closes the last auth-layer gap: auth is observability-bare today. This slice makes every
signin / callback / signout / session / me operation reconstructable from traces + structured,
audit-safe logs, connected end-to-end (API → backend → durable auth.* event) — the same
bar the workers plugin already meets for API→queue→worker→polyglot.

Net-new and additive: no behaviour change to auth flows. It mirrors two in-repo exemplars rather
than inventing a mechanism:

• sagas — runtime-injected tracer (createSagaTelemetry() DI seam) + typed SagaAttributes.
• workers — W3C traceparent/tracestate inject→queue→extract + durable persistence.

Locked decisions (see plan.md §2)

#	Decision
D1	Instrument at the service + injected-tracer seam, not inside the pure better-auth/workos backends.
D2	auth.subject_hash = stable, salted, one-way HMAC-SHA-256 (audit correlation without storing raw subject/PII).
D3	Mandatory, tested redaction — extend SENSITIVE_FIELD_FRAGMENTS; redactAuthPrincipal() strips token-bearing claims before any span attr / log field.
D4	Per-operation child spans parented via getParentContextFromHeaders(ctx.traceHeaders).
D5	Durable-event propagation — inject traceparent/tracestate onto emitted auth.* events + persist on the event record.
D6	Typed error taxonomy (AUTH_INVALID_CREDENTIALS, AUTH_SESSION_EXPIRED, …) replaces opaque string reasons.
D7	Middleware seam is out of scope (follow-up only if AS7 fitness flags it).

Status

• Plan-of-record only right now. research.md + plan.md are committed; implementation has not
  started.
• Re-baselined to main (2026-06-21): the auth umbrella merged via Framework Prime-Time Hardening (umbrella) #73 (6f1c40f0), so the plan's
  S6/S7/AS7 dependencies are satisfied on main; all 16 plan file:line references re-verified
  present on origin/main, and packages/plugin-auth-core has no existing telemetry surface
  (confirms net-new).
• A PLAN-EVAL PASS was witnessed against the umbrella-tip base; this PR re-confirms the
  main-rebased plan with a persisted PLAN-EVAL (OpenHands minimax-M3) before any code.

Gate plan

deno task check · scoped check/lint/fmt on packages/plugin-auth-core + plugins/auth · scoped
deno task test · jsr-audit A1 doc-lint (additive surface stays slow-types-clean). scaffold.runtime
only at merge-readiness (expensive).

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

[rickylabs]

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/minimax/minimax-m3 output=pr-comment

use harness. Act as the PLAN-EVAL evaluator (separate session) for the AS8
auth-audit-observability slice. This is the Plan-Gate hard stop before any implementation — no
source changes, no generator work.

SKILL

Read each before evaluating:

• netscript-harness — .llm/harness/evaluator/plan-protocol.md, .llm/harness/gates/plan-gate.md,
  .llm/harness/gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md, .llm/harness/evaluator/verdict-definitions.md.
• netscript-doctrine — ARCHETYPE-5 (plugin plugins/auth) + supporting ARCHETYPE-2/3 packages
  (packages/plugin-auth-core), SCOPE-service.md overlay.
• netscript-deno-toolchain, jsr-audit (A1 doc-lint full export set), netscript-tools, rtk.

Inputs (committed on THIS PR branch feat/prime-time/auth-s8-audit-observability)

• .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/research.md
• .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/plan.md

Branch base is main @ 6f1c40f0 (the auth umbrella merged via #73; this plan was re-baselined from
the umbrella tip to main).

Task

1. Read the harness plan-protocol + plan-gate checklist + both artifacts.
2. Evaluate against the plan-gate:
   • archetype + scope selection correct (ARCHETYPE-5 + supporting 2/3, SCOPE-service);
   • contract-first ordering (typed AuthAttributes/AuthSpanNames/AuthErrorCode → createAuthTelemetry()
     → service wiring → tests);
   • zero-cast compliance (no new any/as unknown as outside the two sanctioned exemplars,
     neither of which is in scope);
   • gate set adequacy (scoped check/lint/fmt + scoped test + jsr-audit A1; scaffold.runtime deferred);
   • the 16 referenced file:line anchors resolve on this branch and the telemetry surface is net-new
     (packages/plugin-auth-core has no existing telemetry/);
   • soundness of D2 salted HMAC subject-hash, D3 mandatory tested redaction, D5 durable-event
     traceparent propagation against the AS4 emit seam, D6 typed error taxonomy via ErrorHandlingPlugin.
3. Emit PASS or FAIL_PLAN with concrete, file-anchored reasons. Two FAIL_PLAN cycles → escalate.
4. Write .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/plan-eval.md and post the verdict as a PR comment.
5. Do NOT implement, modify source, or commit deno.lock churn / junk files.

[rickylabs]

OpenHands Agent — Completed

Model: openrouter/minimax/minimax-m3
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-103/run-27899218985-1 (committed to the PR branch)
Artifact: openhands-agent-27899218985-1

AS8 — Auth Audit Observability — PLAN-EVAL summary

Summary

PLAN-EVAL pass for slice auth-audit-observability on branch
feat/prime-time/auth-s8-audit-observability (HEAD 3b9c75b1, base
origin/main @ 6f1c40f0). Re-baseline already applied; both prior
umbrellas (feat/prime-time/auth #86 and feat/prime-time #73) are in
main, so S6 + S7 + AS7 dependencies are satisfied at base.

Verdict: PASS.

Changes

• .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/plan-eval.md — new file, the
  PLAN-EVAL verdict artifact with all anchors verified against main
  @ 6f1c40f0, archetype/scope/zero-cast/gate-set/soundness checks
  recorded with concrete file:line evidence.
• No source modifications, no deno.lock churn, no junk files.

Validation

Anchor resolution sweep (18 anchors) — all green:

• packages/auth-better-auth/src/better-auth.ts:136-162 — bare
  better_auth_session_lookup_failed confirmed.
• packages/auth-workos/src/workos-authenticator.ts:147-187 — bare
  workos_session_cookie_missing / workos_authentication_failed
  confirmed.
• packages/service/src/builder/service-builder-impl.ts:244-267,
  packages/service/src/primitives/handlers.ts:72-114 — both resolve.
• packages/logger/constants.ts:11-19 — SENSITIVE_FIELD_FRAGMENTS
  list verified; extension with sessionid/accesstoken/refreshtoken/ jwttoken is additive, non-conflicting.
• packages/logger/orpc-plugin.ts:376-394 — redactSensitiveFields
  confirmed.
• packages/telemetry/{deno.json:6-14, src/context/{mod,payload-context,w3c}.ts, src/instrumentation/worker.ts, src/public/mod.ts} — all resolve;
  packages/telemetry exports ., .config, ./tracer, ./context,
  ./attributes, ./instrumentation, ./registry, ./orpc.
• plugins/sagas/services/src/main.ts:93 (createSagaTelemetry()
  injection), plugins/sagas/src/telemetry/otel-saga-tracer.ts:22-44 —
  both resolve.
• plugins/workers/{services/src/main.ts:62, services/src/routers/jobs.ts:93-119, worker/job-dispatcher.ts:27-28,58-66} — all resolve.
• plugins/auth/services/src/main.ts:74 — auth's .withRPC({ traceContext: true }) confirmed (matches workers main.ts:62 pattern).

Doctrine and gate-set checks — all green:

• Archetype selection: ARCHETYPE-5 (plugin) + supporting ARCHETYPE-2/3
  (packages/plugin-auth-core) + SCOPE-service.md overlay. Correct.
• Contract-first ordering: AuthAttributes/AuthSpanNames/AuthErrorCode typed constants → createAuthTelemetry() → service wiring → tests. Mirrors sagas DI seam (plugins/sagas/services/src/main.ts:93).
• Zero-cast compliance: no router-composition Class A (auth does not use
  that router shape) and no external-boundary Class B (backends stay
  pure). Confirmed against arch-debt.md:875,889.
• Gate set: deno task check + --unstable-kv on KV-touching paths;
  scoped run-deno-{check,lint,fmt}.ts on packages/plugin-auth-core +
  plugins/auth (--ext ts,tsx); deno task test for auth +
  plugin-auth-core; jsr-audit A1 full export set on
  packages/plugin-auth-core. scaffold.runtime deferred to
  umbrella merge-readiness (per AGENTS.md trigger template).
• Net-new surface: packages/plugin-auth-core/src/telemetry/ does not
  exist today; no conflict.
• Decision soundness:
  • D2 salted HMAC auth.subject_hash (deployment-config salt,
    non-derived, stable, non-reversible, non-cross-deployment-linkable).
  • D3 mandatory tested redaction with redactAuthPrincipal() +
    SENSITIVE_FIELD_FRAGMENTS extension + negative assertions over
    serialized output.
  • D5 durable-event traceparent propagation against AS4 emit seam;
    contingency path is debt entry (not cast) if the typed seam
    blocks it — already declared in plan.md §6.
  • D6 typed error taxonomy (AUTH_INVALID_CREDENTIALS, etc.)
    classified via ErrorHandlingPlugin
    (packages/telemetry/src/orpc/error-plugin.ts).
  • D7 middleware seam (packages/service/src/auth/auth-middleware.ts)
    explicitly out of scope.

Responses to review comments or issue comments

None. This is a Plan-Gate pass on a fresh plan-of-record branch; no
prior review comments to address. The trigger comment itself requested
this PLAN-EVAL pass; verdict artifact is the response and will be
posted by the workflow from plan-eval.md.

Remaining risks

• deno.lock may move on first run; IMPL-EVAL must verify and only
  commit reviewed changes.
• D5 contingency: if injectContext() cannot fit on the AS4 emit
  payload without a typed change, the generator must file a scoped
  arch-debt.md entry rather than smuggle a cast. This is a Plan
  constraint, not a Plan-Gate failure.
• Middleware (packages/service/src/auth/auth-middleware.ts) remains
  un-instrumented by design; AS7 fitness flags could promote it to a
  follow-up slice if it surfaces as an observability gap.
• No new arch-debt.md entries are filed by this plan.

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/27899218985

[rickylabs]

[PHASE: IMPL] [VERDICT: LANDED]

AS8 auth audit observability implementation slice landed and pushed.

Scope

• Added @netscript/plugin-auth-core/telemetry with typed auth attributes/span names/events, outcome/error taxonomies, salted HMAC subject hashing, principal redaction, and no-op-safe createAuthTelemetry().
• Injected auth telemetry at the auth service seam and wrapped signin, callback, signout, session, and me with parented child spans from ctx.traceHeaders.
• Persisted traceparent / tracestate on auth durable stream lifecycle events and session records.
• Added redaction/attribute/propagation tests and updated harness artifacts.

Commits

• 17b27819 — feat(auth): add audit telemetry observability
• b38d9607 — chore(harness): record auth observability commit

Validation

• deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx — PASS, filesSelected=22, failedBatches=0
• deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx — PASS, filesSelected=29, failedBatches=0
• deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts --root packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx — PASS
• deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts --root plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx — PASS
• deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx — PASS
• deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx — PASS
• deno task check from packages/plugin-auth-core — PASS
• deno task test from packages/plugin-auth-core — PASS, 26 passed / 0 failed
• deno task check from plugins/auth — PASS
• deno task test from plugins/auth — PASS, 17 passed / 0 failed
• root deno task check — PASS, filesSelected=1730, batches=15, failedBatches=0
• full export-set deno doc --lint for packages/plugin-auth-core — PASS, 9 files checked
• .llm/tools/fitness/audit-jsr-package.ts --root packages/plugin-auth-core --text — PASS exit 0; dry-run OK; helper reports only the known banner-style slow-types warning line
• deno task publish:dry-run from packages/plugin-auth-core — PASS
• forbidden cast scan over changed implementation/test scope — PASS: no any or as unknown as
• lock hygiene — PASS: deno.lock unchanged

Notes

• Remote branch already contained OpenHands PLAN-EVAL artifacts; local commits were rebased on top before push.
• commits.md, worklog.md, context-pack.md, and drift.md are updated for IMPL-EVAL handoff.

[rickylabs]

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max provider=openrouter output=pr-comment iterations=800

use harness

You are the IMPL-EVAL (final evaluator pass) for slice AS8 — Auth Audit Observability on PR
#103, branch feat/prime-time/auth-s8-audit-observability (base main). You are a SEPARATE session
from the generator (WSL Codex authored the implementation); the generator does NOT self-certify. Do
NOT implement or "fix" anything — evaluate, run the gates, and emit a verdict.

SKILL

Activate and follow these repo skills BEFORE evaluating (read each SKILL.md; if a skill is named
but absent from .claude/skills/, read .agents/skills/<name>/SKILL.md):

• netscript-harness — IMPL-EVAL protocol, verdict definitions, archetype + gate selection, run
  artifacts. This governs your whole pass.
• netscript-doctrine — package/plugin archetype, public-surface rules, ports/base-class/extension
  seams, gates, debt. AS8 touches packages/plugin-auth-core (a package) and plugins/auth (a
  plugin) — apply the matching archetype gates to each.
• netscript-tools — scoped check/lint/fmt wrappers, validation evidence, raw git verification,
  lock hygiene.
• netscript-deno-toolchain — deno check --unstable-kv, deno test, deno doc for surface
  inspection; never decide "latest/outdated" from deno outdated --latest.
• jsr-audit — if the public export surface of plugin-auth-core changed, sanity-check slow-types /
  doc-lint on the full export map (not mod.ts alone).
• rtk — prefix read-heavy git/gh/grep/ls with rtk to cut output tokens.

What AS8 delivered (verify against the plan, do not trust this summary)

A new auth audit/telemetry surface plus wiring. Implementation commit 17b27819
(feat(auth): add audit telemetry observability), HEAD b38d9607. Touched (22 files in the impl
commit): packages/plugin-auth-core/src/telemetry/{attributes,instrumentation,redaction,mod}.ts +
telemetry_test.ts; plugin-auth-core/src/{domain,ports,public,streams}/mod.ts + deno.json;
packages/logger/constants.ts; plugins/auth/services/src/{main.ts,routers/v1-handlers.ts, routers/v1-types.ts}; plugins/auth/streams/{producer.ts,schema.ts}; plugins/auth/deno.json;
and tests plugins/auth/tests/services/auth-service_test.ts, tests/streams/streams_test.ts.

Read first (run artifacts under .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/)

plan.md, plan-eval.md (the PLAN-EVAL PASS of record), research.md, worklog.md,
context-pack.md, drift.md, commits.md. Then the harness evaluator docs
(.llm/harness/evaluator/protocol.md, verdict-definitions.md, gates/plan-gate.md,
gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md) and the selected archetype docs.

Evaluate (the bar)

1. Plan conformance — does the implementation match the PLAN-EVAL-PASSed plan's locked scope and
   contract? Flag undocumented scope creep (record as drift, not silent acceptance).
2. Contract-first + public surface — typed attributes/contracts before implementation; the
   plugin-auth-core public export surface is intentional and doc-lintable; no leaking of internal
   types through the public mod.ts.
3. Audit/telemetry correctness — spans/audit records carry the typed attributes; redaction is
   real and tested (no secrets/PII/token material in attributes or audit logs); instrumentation
   wraps the v1 handlers and streams producer without changing their behavior contract.
4. Tests meaningful, not theatre — telemetry_test.ts, auth-service_test.ts, streams_test.ts
   actually assert redaction + attribute presence + handler behavior; they pass.
5. Zero-cast policy (NON-NEGOTIABLE) — the ONLY sanctioned casts are: centralized contract
   as unknown as <XContractV1>; top-level router any + deno-lint-ignore in
   plugins/*/services/src/router.ts; Class-B external-boundary casts matching the sagas exemplar.
   ANY other as/any is a FAIL_FIX — do not accept it as deferred debt.
6. Fail-loud, no silent no-ops — any unsupported path throws/rejects with a typed error, not a
   silent stub.
7. Lock + artifact hygiene — no deno.lock churn introduced by the impl commit; no stray/junk
   tracked files; run artifacts complete.

Gates to run (report raw exit codes; use the scoped wrappers, not raw root CLI)

deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts  --root packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts  --root plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts   --root packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts   --root plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx
deno test packages/plugin-auth-core/src/telemetry/telemetry_test.ts --unstable-kv
deno test plugins/auth/tests --unstable-kv

For any targeted deno check that touches workspace code, include --unstable-kv. Do NOT run the
expensive scaffold.runtime e2e gate for this slice — it is out of AS8 scope.

Output

Write your verdict to .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/evaluate.md per the protocol, then
post a PR-comment summary on #103 containing: the verdict
(PASS | FAIL_FIX | FAIL_RESCOPE | FAIL_DEBT), the raw gate exit codes, any zero-cast or
redaction findings with file:line, and a short rationale. Preserve lock hygiene: do NOT commit
deno.lock re-resolution or source churn unless a reviewed fix is in scope (it is not — you are the
evaluator). Two FAIL_* cycles escalate.

[rickylabs]

OpenHands Agent — Completed

Model: openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Summary source: agent-after-retry
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-103/run-27900718714-1 (committed to the PR branch)
Artifact: openhands-agent-27900718714-1

Run Summary — AS8 IMPL-EVAL Pass

Summary

Executed IMPL-EVAL evaluation for AS8 — Auth Audit Observability (PR #103, branch feat/prime-time/auth-s8-audit-observability, impl commit 17b27819). All 8 required gates passed with exit code 0. Zero-cast policy compliant. Redaction correctness verified. Verdict determined: PASS.

Task incomplete: evaluation verdict was determined but the formal verdict document and PR comment were not written (see Remaining risks).

Changes

No source, lock, or artifact changes were made during this evaluation pass. The agent performed read-only inspection and gate execution.

Files inspected

• Run artifacts: .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/{plan.md, plan-eval.md, worklog.md, drift.md, commits.md, context-pack.md}
• Skill docs: AGENTS.md, .agents/skills/netscript-harness, .agents/skills/netscript-doctrine, .agents/skills/netscript-tools, .agents/skills/netscript-deno-toolchain, .agents/skills/jsr-audit, .agents/skills/rtk
• Harness evaluator protocol: .llm/harness/evaluator/{protocol.md, verdict-definitions.md, gates/plan-gate.md, gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md}
• Implementation: packages/plugin-auth-core/src/telemetry/{attributes.ts, redaction.ts, instrumentation.ts, telemetry_test.ts, mod.ts}
• Implementation: packages/plugin-auth-core/src/{domain,ports,public,streams}/mod.ts, packages/plugin-auth-core/deno.json
• Implementation: plugins/auth/services/src/{main.ts, routers/v1-handlers.ts, routers/v1-types.ts, router.ts}
• Implementation: plugins/auth/streams/{producer.ts, schema.ts}, plugins/auth/deno.json
• Tests: plugins/auth/tests/{services/auth-service_test.ts, streams/streams_test.ts}

Validation

Gates executed (all exit code 0)

#	Gate	Exit Code	Result
1	deno check packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx	0	0 type errors across 22 files
2	deno check plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx	0	0 type errors across 29 files
3	deno lint packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx	0	0 violations
4	deno lint plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx	0	0 violations
5	deno fmt --check packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx	0	0 fmt findings
6	deno fmt --check plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx	0	0 fmt findings
7	deno test packages/plugin-auth-core/src/telemetry/telemetry_test.ts -A	0	3/3 passed (hashSubject, redactAuthPrincipal, createAuthTelemetry)
8	deno test plugins/auth/tests -A	0	17/17 passed (services + streams + scaffold + public)

Zero-cast policy audit (NON-NEGOTIABLE)

Scanned all touched source files for as unknown / as any / : any usage. Two cast sites found, both sanctioned:

• plugins/auth/services/src/router.ts:19,22,28: SANCTIONED — top-level router any + // deno-lint-ignore no-explicit-any annotations (per doctrine Class-B exception for router composition boundaries)
• plugins/auth/services/src/main.ts:90: SANCTIONED — Class-B external-boundary cast (ctx as PluginServiceContext & { appsettings?: {...} } to access runtime-injected config not typed in SDK contract); matches approved pattern from packages/plugin-sagas-core exemplar documented in doctrine

Durable-event traceparent persistence (D5) — independently verified

Follow-up from PLAN-EVAL concern: verified that traceparent/tracestate are persisted to AS4 durable stream backend, not merely passed through producer options (in-memory only).

• packages/plugin-auth-core/src/domain/mod.ts:79-95: AuthSession type includes traceparent?: string and tracestate?: string fields
• plugins/auth/streams/producer.ts:227-239: withSessionTraceContext() helper merges trace context onto session object
• plugins/auth/streams/producer.ts:152-180: Auth session projections (emitOidcCompleted, emitTokenRefreshed, emitSessionRevoked) call withSessionTraceContext() before streamProducer.upsert('authSession', session)
• Domain-level typed change, not a cast — clean implementation. deno check confirms type safety.

Redaction correctness

• redactAuthPrincipal (packages/plugin-auth-core/src/telemetry/redaction.ts:85-108): removes token-bearing claims via isSensitiveClaimKey() pattern matching (token/secret/credential/password/apikey/sessionid/authorization/refresh/jwt)
• hashSubject (packages/plugin-auth-core/src/telemetry/redaction.ts:65-83): HMAC-SHA-256 with deployment-owned salt via WebCrypto API; hex-encoded
• Principal metadata exposes only counts for scopes/roles (no raw values)

Test coverage meaningful (not theatre)

Reviewing telemetry_test.ts and auth-service_test.ts:

• Telemetry tests: hash stability across invocations, redaction removes auth-token claims, full createAuthTelemetry() round-trip with span/event attribute assertions
• Auth-service tests: 8 tests including signin/callback/session/me/signout round-trip + audit attribute verification per operation
• Streams tests: 4 tests including trace context persistence on persisted session

Verdict: tests are substantive, not boilerplate.

Remaining risks

Critical omissions (block PR merge)

1. Verdict file not written: .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/evaluate.md was not created. This is the formal IMPL-EVAL record required by the harness protocol (exit criteria Wave 0b·B — .agents/docs + skills cluster #5). The file must follow the canonical template with verdict, gate results, and rationale.

2. PR comment not posted: @openhands-agent output=pr-comment was requested in the trigger but no comment was posted to PR AS8 — Auth Audit Observability (plan-of-record + PLAN-EVAL gate) #103. The evaluation verdict, gate results table, and D5 follow-up findings were not communicated to the PR thread.

3. JSR slow-types validation incomplete: Skill activation requested netscript-deno-toolchain and jsr-audit but deno doc surface inspection and slow-types validation were not executed due to iteration constraints. Per doctrine, packages with expanded public surface require deno doc lint and JSR slow-types gate before publish. Risk: unvalidated slow-types in packages/plugin-auth-core public surface may fail JSR publish gate.

Recommendations

• Complete evaluate.md write using the harness verdict template
• Post PR comment with verdict, gate table, and D5 verification
• Run deno doc --lint on @netscript/plugin-auth-core to validate slow-types
• Consider JSR publish dry-run (deno task publish:dry-run) before merge

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/27900718714

[rickylabs]

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max provider=openrouter output=pr-comment iterations=600

use harness

You are the IMPL-EVAL evaluator for slice AS8 — Auth Audit Observability, PR #103, branch
feat/prime-time/auth-s8-audit-observability (base main, impl commit 17b27819, HEAD b38d9607).
You are a SEPARATE session from the generator (WSL Codex authored the implementation); the generator
does NOT self-certify. Do NOT implement or "fix" source — evaluate, run the gates, and render a
TERMINAL verdict with its formal artifact.

Context — this is a finalization pass. A prior IMPL-EVAL run (run-27900718714-1) determined
PASS and reported all 8 gates green, but EXHAUSTED ITERATIONS before writing the formal verdict
artifact and posting a parseable verdict comment, so the harness has no terminal record. Your job is
to render that terminal verdict properly. Do NOT blindly trust the prior summary — independently
re-run the gates below to confirm, then write the artifact and comment.

SKILL

Read each SKILL.md before acting (if absent from .claude/skills/, read
.agents/skills/<name>/SKILL.md):

• netscript-harness — IMPL-EVAL protocol (.llm/harness/evaluator/protocol.md), verdict
  definitions, evaluate.md template. Governs this pass.
• netscript-doctrine — package/plugin archetype + gates; AS8 touches packages/plugin-auth-core
  (package) and plugins/auth (plugin).
• netscript-tools — scoped check/lint/fmt wrappers, validation evidence, lock hygiene.
• netscript-deno-toolchain — deno check --unstable-kv, deno test, deno doc.
• jsr-audit — slow-types / doc-lint on the FULL export map (not mod.ts alone).
• rtk — prefix read-heavy git/gh/grep/ls.

Gates to independently re-run (report raw exit codes; scoped wrappers, not raw root CLI)

deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts  --root packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts  --root plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts   --root packages/plugin-auth-core --ext ts,tsx
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts   --root plugins/auth --ext ts,tsx
deno test packages/plugin-auth-core/src/telemetry/telemetry_test.ts --unstable-kv
deno test plugins/auth/tests --unstable-kv

Slow-types (the prior run's only substantive open risk — now confirmable)

Run deno doc --lint over the FULL @netscript/plugin-auth-core export map (all 9 entries from its
deno.json exports, incl. the new ./telemetry barrel which uses export *), e.g. from
packages/plugin-auth-core/:
deno doc --lint mod.ts src/config/mod.ts src/contracts/v1/mod.ts src/domain/mod.ts src/ports/mod.ts src/presets/mod.ts src/streams/mod.ts src/testing/mod.ts src/telemetry/mod.ts.
The supervisor already observed this at exit 0 (0 diagnostics); confirm it independently and record
the exit code. This closes the prior run's "remaining risk #3".

Other checks (confirm, do not re-derive at length)

• Zero-cast policy: only sanctioned casts allowed (centralized contract as unknown as <XContractV1>;
  top-level router any+deno-lint-ignore in plugins/*/services/src/router.ts; Class-B
  external-boundary casts matching the sagas exemplar). Any other as/any is FAIL_FIX.
• Redaction tested (no token/PII in attributes or audit logs); D5 traceparent persisted to durable
  stream events (domain-typed, not a cast); tests substantive.
• No deno.lock churn or junk files from the impl commit; CI on the PR is green incl.
  scaffold-runtime.

REQUIRED OUTPUT — render the terminal verdict (do this BEFORE any optional deep-dive; budget for it)

1. Write .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/evaluate.md using the harness verdict template:
   verdict token, the gate-results table with raw exit codes, slow-types result, zero-cast finding,
   redaction/D5 notes, and rationale.
2. Post a PR comment on AS8 — Auth Audit Observability (plan-of-record + PLAN-EVAL gate) #103 whose body contains a single machine-parseable verdict line on its own
   line, EXACTLY one of:
   Verdict: PASS · Verdict: FAIL_FIX · Verdict: FAIL_RESCOPE · Verdict: FAIL_DEBT
   followed by the gate table and a one-paragraph rationale.

Do NOT leave the run without (1) and (2). If every gate is green and slow-types is clean, the verdict
is PASS. Preserve lock hygiene: do not commit deno.lock re-resolution or source churn.

[rickylabs]

OpenHands Agent — Completed

Model: openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-103/run-27901147563-1 (committed to the PR branch)
Artifact: openhands-agent-27901147563-1

IMPL-EVAL — AS8 Auth Audit Observability

Summary

Verdict: PASS

Independent confirmation of AS8 implementation. Prior evaluator run (run-27900718714-1) computed
PASS but exhausted iterations before rendering the formal artifact. This session re-ran all gates
to confirm before writing the terminal verdict.

Changes

Scope: additive audit telemetry surface on packages/plugin-auth-core (new ./telemetry barrel
with AuthAttributes, createAuthTelemetry, hashSubject, redactAuthPrincipal,
SerializedTraceContext) plus wiring in plugins/auth services and streams.

Implementation commits:

• 17b27819 — feat(auth): add audit telemetry observability (WSL Codex authored)
• b38d9607 — chore(harness): record auth observability commit

Validation

All 8 scoped gates pass with raw exit 0:

#	Gate	Scope	Exit	Outcome
1	run-deno-check.ts	plugin-auth-core (22 files)	0	PASS
2	run-deno-check.ts	plugins/auth (29 files)	0	PASS
3	run-deno-lint.ts	plugin-auth-core (22 files)	0	PASS
4	run-deno-lint.ts	plugins/auth (29 files)	0	PASS
5	run-deno-fmt.ts	plugin-auth-core (22 files)	0	PASS
6	run-deno-fmt.ts	plugins/auth (29 files)	0	PASS
7	deno test telemetry_test.ts --unstable-kv	core telemetry unit	0	PASS (3/3)
8	deno test plugins/auth/tests --unstable-kv -A	auth plugin surface	0	PASS (17/17)

Slow-types (full 9-entry export map incl. ./telemetry barrel):

• deno doc --lint exit 0, 0 diagnostics
• Confirms closure of prior-run remaining risk Migrate shared Zod datetime codecs to Temporal #3

Zero-cast policy: PASS (no unsanctioned as/any in S8-changed files; D5 traceparent flows
through domain-typed SerializedTraceContext, not a cast)

Redaction: substantive (telemetry tests assert salted HMAC for subject hash, token/PII removed
from serialized principal output, no raw subject or access_token in span attributes)

Lock hygiene: clean (0 commits to deno.lock between main and HEAD; no junk artifacts)

Responses to review comments

N/A (separate evaluator session, not responding to review threads)

Remaining risks

None identified. All gates green, slow-types clean, cast/redaction/lock properties verified.
Formal verdict artifact written to .llm/tmp/run/auth-s8-audit-observability/evaluate.md.

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/27901147563