feat(cli): ship agent tooling and offline docs with agent init (#1024, #1061)

[rickylabs]

Summary

Ships the consumer-facing agent-grade tool bundle with netscript agent init and adds opt-in, version-locked offline documentation through netscript agent init --with-docs. The work is harnessed in independently gated slices and consumes the task router merged by #1079.

The tooling implementation for #1024 is intentionally partial at close-gate: its final clone-independent runtime criterion remains open because the installed validator correctly rejects pinned host ports emitted by the current public 0.0.3 scaffold. This PR therefore references, but does not close, #1024.

Scope

• Archetype / area: Archetype 6 CLI/tooling + docs overlay
• Refs feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024
• Closes feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061

Slices

• S0 Research, locked plan, and Design checkpoint
• S1 Install and symptom-route the eight consumer tools; make scaffold E2E clone-independent and host-port enforcing
• S2 Add agent init --with-docs with router-bearing prose and exact-version every-subpath API docs
• S3 Rebase integration, final gates, acceptance mirror, and authoritative IMPL-EVAL — 5d940069e

Definition of Done

#1024

• An explicit, documented list defines which .llm/tools/ are agent-grade and consumer-facing versus repository-internal.
• netscript agent init installs that subset into the project, or exposes it via the NetScript MCP server, or both.
• The installed skills reference each shipped tool from the symptom it solves, not only in a capability table.
• run-deno-check.ts (or its MCP equivalent) is the documented way to type-check, with the deno check excluded-file exit-0 trap called out explicitly.
• check-aspire-host-ports.ts runs against generated scaffolds so the rule it encodes is enforced on what consumers actually receive.
• A scaffolded project can run the full e2e smoke without cloning the framework repository.

#1061

• netscript agent init --with-docs installs a local documentation bundle into the generated project; without the flag, behaviour is unchanged.
• The bundle includes per-package API surfaces generated from the installed package versions, covering every export subpath.
• The bundle records the version it was built for, and generation fails loudly if that disagrees with the installed CLI rather than emitting a mismatched bundle.
• The capability is discoverable from the symptom in the installed agent surface, not only as a CLI flag.
• Documented in the CLI reference with its size implication stated, so the opt-in is an informed choice.

Acceptance evidence

S1 evidence is recorded in issue #1024; criteria 1–4 are checked. S2 evidence is recorded in issue #1061; all five #1061 criteria are checked.

A fresh installed tool invoked from /tmp passed 22 exact-release steps and then enforced the final-artifact host-port gate, rejecting six pins from public 0.0.3. That proves #1024 criterion 5. Criterion 6 remains unchecked and #1024 remains open.

Validation

• PLAN-EVAL — PASS (OpenHands/Qwen 3.7 Max)
• S1 — PASS: focused 26/26; scoped check/lint/fmt clean; quality/arch/doc lint clean; Claude Opus review PASS
• S2 — PASS: combined regressions 37/37; docs links/accuracy, site build, publish dry-run, byte-stable assets, real 168-file consumer install, and Claude Opus review all PASS
• Post-rebase static gates — PASS: root check 2,541 files / 22 batches / zero diagnostics; root test 2,571 passed (567 steps), zero failed, 16 ignored; focused conflict surface 26/26; agent-surface lint/fmt, CLI doc lint, and asset freshness PASS
• Consumer runtime — 22 generated-project steps passed; final host-port gate correctly rejected six public-0.0.3 pins; exact owned cleanup verified
• Local pre-rebase scaffold.runtime — 47/48 with the existing HTTP 503 / Prisma database-unhealthy shape; cleanup passed, zero survivors
• Final clean-host CI scaffold.runtime — PASS in one pass with cleanup (run 30815021273)
• Post-rebase IMPL-EVAL — PASS at 5d940069e (OpenHands/Qwen 3.7 Max, xhigh); all checked boxes and feat(cli,mcp): scaffold agent surface — app-scoped conventions and an evidence-gated diagnostic surface #1078 conflict resolution verified
• CI — PASS: core CI, code quality, public-surface diff, and CLI E2E
• Close-gate — PASS; closing issue set is feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 only
• Review-thread gate — PASS; zero threads

Harness

• Run dir: .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/
• Final head: 5d940069e
• Status: ready for merge.

Drift / Debt

• Baseline advanced to current main d0802e150; the two rebase conflicts retained feat(cli,mcp): scaffold agent surface — app-scoped conventions and an evidence-gated diagnostic surface #1078’s MCP diagnostics and receipt-gated drift contract while composing this slice’s tool/docs discovery.
• Public 0.0.3 still emits pinned host ports; the installed no-checkout acceptance remains open under feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024.
• Architecture debt: none accepted; unrelated existing CLI debt remains unchanged.

[rickylabs]

[PHASE: RESEARCH]

Re-baselined #1024 and #1061 against origin/main at e5bae2858.

Findings

1. The requested seven lightweight runners are consumer-copyable, but the scaffold E2E is repository-bound today: it imports agentic teardown internals and defaults to packages/cli/bin/netscript-dev.ts.
2. agent init currently installs skills/MCP only and accepts no --with-docs option.
3. The installed help surface names local docs paths that are not created, which the fresh-project path-closure fixture must eliminate.
4. PR docs: sequence the agent-facing documentation surfaces (#1068, #1069, #1070, #1020) #1079 merged the docs: add a task router above the llms.txt catalog (agents read six pages and never reach the web layer) #1068 task router; this branch rebased cleanly and will consume its generated llms.txt without editing router sources.
5. Baseline CLI doc lint is clean (3 exports, 0 diagnostics); focused agent-init tests pass 9/9.

Next

• Enforce the separate-session PLAN-EVAL hard stop before implementation.

[rickylabs]

[PHASE: PLAN]

The locked plan uses Archetype 6 plus the docs overlay and splits implementation into two independently reviewed commits.

Locked slices

1. A checked-in eight-tool consumer manifest drives embedding, installation, symptom routing, path closure, clone-independent scaffold E2E, and generated host-port enforcement.
2. agent init --with-docs writes a compressed, router-bearing prose corpus and generates exact-version API docs for every installed NetScript export subpath; mismatch or subprocess failure aborts before docs writes.

Gates

Focused red/green fixtures; scoped check/lint/fmt wrappers; generated-asset freshness; CLI doc lint and publish dry-run; quality:scan; arch:check; docs gates; fresh-project path closure; guarded non-concurrent runtime smoke; formal IMPL-EVAL.

Next

• Qwen PLAN-EVAL on the local Claude/OpenRouter formal-evaluation route. Do not implement before PASS.

[rickylabs]

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max provider=openrouter effort=high output=pr-comment iterations=300

use harness

PLAN-EVAL request: agent init tooling and offline docs bundles

Evaluate the locked plan for PR #1092 only. Do not implement, edit product code, tick issue boxes,
or change deno.lock.

SKILL

• .agents/skills/netscript-harness — evaluator protocol, Plan-Gate, tracked verdict semantics.
• .agents/skills/netscript-cli — agent init, scaffold output, fixture expectations.
• .agents/skills/netscript-tools — shipped .llm/tools and trustworthy validation evidence.
• .agents/skills/netscript-doctrine — Archetype 6 and docs-overlay architecture fitness.
• .agents/skills/netscript-pr — structured PLAN-EVAL PR comment and repository targeting.
• .agents/skills/rtk — compact read-heavy git/grep inspection.

Scope and authority

• Repository: rickylabs/netscript
• Branch: feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle
• Run: .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/
• Issues: feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 and feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061; read both full issue bodies and all eleven acceptance criteria.
• Read the run's research.md, plan.md, worklog.md, context-pack.md, drift.md, and
  supervisor.md.
• Read the harness PLAN-EVAL protocol and verdict definitions referenced by the harness skill.
• Spot-check current agent init, the eight proposed tool entrypoints, the merged docs: add a task router above the llms.txt catalog (agents read six pages and never reach the web layer) #1068 task router,
  and the external docs-bundle assumptions needed to judge feasibility.

Challenge especially:

1. whether project lock/config evidence can prove exact installed @netscript/* versions;
2. whether strict same-release docs/CLI matching is valid and fails before partial writes;
3. whether scaffold E2E can be dependency-closed and framework-clone-independent while invoking
   host-port validation and handling a missing binary without a thrown-process escape;
4. whether generated path-closure and no-fixture-mutation tests actually cover every installed
   reference;
5. whether the two commit slices are independently reviewable and have adequate gates.

Required output

Write the complete evaluation to
.llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/plan-eval.md. It must use the harness verdict
vocabulary and end in exactly one authoritative verdict: PASS or FAIL_PLAN. Include concrete,
actionable findings with file/decision references and distinguish blockers from advisory notes.

Commit and push only the tracked evaluator artifact needed for this evaluation. Do not mutate
deno.lock, product code, generated assets, issue bodies, or unrelated run files. Post one structured
PR comment beginning [PHASE: PLAN-EVAL] and include the exact machine line
OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS for PASS, or OPENHANDS_VERDICT: FAIL_PLAN for FAIL_PLAN. The
tracked artifact is authoritative if a summary disagrees.

---

OUTPUT CONTRACT (mandatory — verdict first)

1. Post the verdict PR comment IMMEDIATELY after you form the verdict — BEFORE any
   optional deep-dive, extra verification, or long context dump. Iteration budgets
   exhaust; a verdict comment deferred to the end of the run is frequently lost.
2. That PR comment MUST start with the formal header line, exactly:
   [PHASE: ] [VERDICT: ]
   where is your eval phase (e.g. IMPL-EVAL, PLAN-EVAL) and is one
   of PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE, FAIL_DEBT, FAIL_PLAN.
3. ALWAYS end BOTH the verdict PR comment AND your summary file with one final
   machine-readable line of the exact form:
   OPENHANDS_VERDICT:
   using a literal token from: PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE, FAIL_DEBT, FAIL_PLAN,
   NONE. Use NONE only when no verdict could be reached.

[rickylabs]

OpenHands Agent — Completed

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

Model: openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Verdict source: summary-file
Verdict comment: #1092 (comment)
Summary source: agent
Housekeeping: ack=success trace=success commit-artifacts=success replies=skipped draft-pr=skipped
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-1092/run-30800996443-1 (in the Actions artifact)
Artifact: openhands-agent-30800996443-1

PLAN-EVAL: agent init tooling and offline docs bundles (#1092)

Summary

Evaluated the locked plan for PR #1092 (feat(cli): ship agent tooling and offline docs with agent init, closing #1024 and #1061) using the harness PLAN-EVAL protocol. All eight Plan-Gate checklist boxes are satisfied. The plan is complete and sound with ten locked decisions, two independently reviewable slices, eight risks with mitigations, and a comprehensive semantic test strategy.

Changes

• Tracked evaluator artifact: .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/plan-eval.md (committed and pushed)
• PR comment: Posted structured verdict on PR feat(cli): ship agent tooling and offline docs with agent init (#1024, #1061) #1092

Validation

• Read all run artifacts: research.md, plan.md, worklog.md, context-pack.md, drift.md, supervisor.md
• Read harness PLAN-EVAL protocol, verdict definitions, and Plan-Gate checklist
• Read issues feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 and feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 (all eleven acceptance criteria)
• Spot-checked current agent init implementation, skill manifest, command input/output
• Spot-checked all eight proposed tool entrypoints (all exist, standalone JSR imports)
• Verified E2E tool imports agentic teardown internals (probeAppHosts, registerAppHost) and uses inferRepoRoot() with netscript-dev.ts as default CLI
• Verified plan D3/D4/D5 correctly identify and address these dependencies
• Verified strict same-release matching semantics and fail-before-writes design

Remaining risks

None blocking. Five advisory notes recorded for IMPL-EVAL verification:

1. Lock/config parsing mechanism for workspace imports and missing deno.lock
2. Error handling structure for Deno.Command throws
3. Host-port validator subprocess invocation boundary
4. Generated TypeScript constant size vs CLI publish limits
5. Task router presence assertion in built site bundle

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/30800996443

[rickylabs]

[PHASE: PLAN-EVAL] [VERDICT: PASS]

Evaluator: OpenHands / OpenRouter / qwen/qwen3.7-max / high effort

Plan-Gate Checklist

• Research present and current. Re-baselined from ab0fa13fe to e5bae2858 to consume merged PR docs: sequence the agent-facing documentation surfaces (#1068, #1069, #1070, #1020) #1079.
• Decisions locked. Ten decisions (D1–D10) stated with rationales.
• Open-decision sweep. All decisions resolved or explicitly deferred.
• Commit slices. Two slices, ordered, < 30 files each, each naming what it proves.
• Risk register. Eight risks listed with mitigations.
• Gate set selected. Archetype 6 + docs overlay gates selected.
• Deferred scope explicit. Three deferred items scoped out with reasons.
• jsr-audit (package/plugin waves). Publishability rubric applied to three CLI entrypoints.

Challenge Responses

1. Project lock/config evidence (D8): Not a blocker. Plan names evidence source (deno.lock/deno.json), failure mode, and test strategy. Advisory: at IMPL-EVAL, verify handling of workspace imports and missing deno.lock.

2. Strict same-release matching (D8): Not a blocker. Design choice with rationale from feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 trap section. Fail-before-writes semantics correctly specified.

3. Clone-independent E2E (D3/D4/D5): Not a blocker. Plan specifies removal of agentic teardown imports, subprocess call to shipped validator, and missing-binary fixture. Advisory: verify no imports from ../agentic/teardown/* at IMPL-EVAL.

4. Path-closure and no-fixture-mutation tests: Not a blocker. Test strategy is comprehensive, will be proven by fixtures at IMPL-EVAL.

5. Two commit slices independently reviewable: Not a blocker. Slices prove distinct capabilities (tool bundle vs. docs bundle) and can be validated in isolation.

Advisory Notes

1. At IMPL-EVAL, verify exact lock/config parsing mechanism handles workspace imports and missing deno.lock.
2. Verify error handling structure catches Deno.Command throws and reports structured failed steps.
3. Verify host-port validator is called as subprocess (not imported) to maintain consumer tool boundary.
4. Verify generated TypeScript constant does not push CLI publish limits or introduce JSR slow-type diagnostics.
5. Verify built site bundle includes task router and installer asserts its presence.

Conclusion

The plan is complete and sound. All Plan-Gate checklist boxes satisfied. Implementation may begin.

---

This evaluation was performed by an AI agent (OpenHands) on behalf of the repository maintainers.

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

[rickylabs]

S1 — consumer agent tooling bundle

Commit: d6265fa52b22b8636edae9963a02b543828061b6

Implemented and independently reviewed:

• exact eight-tool consumer manifest and unconditional agent init installation;
• symptom-driven skill/help routing and explicit deno check excluded-target trap documentation;
• clone-independent scaffold smoke using the installed exact JSR release;
• critical host-port validation after the final plugin/registry/type-check artifact and before Aspire;
• structured missing-binary failure and foreign-CWD/project-root fixture coverage;
• generated barrel freshness gate.

Evidence: focused tests 26 passed, 0 failed; scoped check/lint/fmt 12 selected, 0 findings; quality:scan PASS; arch:check exit 0 with existing warnings only; CLI doc lint 3 entrypoints/0 diagnostics; regenerate-and-byte-compare PASS; opposite-family review SLICE_REVIEW: PASS.

Issue #1024 criteria 1–4 are evidenced and checked. Criteria 5–6 remain deliberately unchecked pending the guarded full scaffold/runtime proof.

[rickylabs]

S2 acceptance evidence — e1ba0b005

All five #1061 boxes are now evidenced and checked.

• Opt-in and unchanged default: focused tests assert no docs generator call/output without the flag and a path-closed .netscript/docs/** install with it. A real temp consumer invocation installed 168 files; without the flag the corpus is absent.
• Exact installed packages / every export: the real fixture used exact @netscript/config@0.0.3 and produced 4/4 export sections. Tests cover exact pins, lock-resolved ranges, workspace/file packages, missing evidence, and every export subpath.
• Version/provenance and loud failure: MANIFEST.json records CLI/framework versions, prose commit/time, API generation time, package versions, and counts. Tests prove CLI/package/prose disagreement, non-zero deno doc, empty output, and a thrown missing-binary launch all fail before any project write.
• Symptom discovery: installed help.md and netscript-build route “cannot find how to do X” to .netscript/docs/llms.txt, whose docs: add a task router above the llms.txt catalog (agents read six pages and never reach the web layer) #1068 task router was asserted in both source build and installed fixture.
• Informed size: CLI help/reference say “several-megabyte”; committed source gzip is 1.2 MB and the generated JSR-safe asset is 1.51 MB.

Commands and observed output

deno test --allow-all <combined S1+S2 focused files>
ok | 37 passed | 0 failed

run-deno-check/lint/fmt (agent/docs/assets scope)
31 files selected; 0 failed batches; 0 findings

deno task docs:links
docs=98 broken-links=0 broken-anchors=0

deno task docs:accuracy
docs accuracy: PASS

deno task quality:scan
ok=true; findings=[]

deno task arch:check
exit 0; existing warnings only

deno task doc:lint --root packages/cli --pretty
3 entrypoints; totalErrors=0; missingJSDoc=0

cd packages/cli && deno task publish:dry-run
Success Dry run complete
agent-docs.generated.ts (1.51MB), agent-tools.generated.ts, and skills.generated.ts are in the simulated file list

deno task gen:assets-barrel
docs/tools/skills SHA-256 values identical before and after regeneration

Pre-fix red proof

A detached worktree at the actual pre-slice commit d6265fa52 ran the real CLI help assertion:

deno run --allow-all packages/cli/bin/netscript.ts agent init --help | rg -- '--with-docs'
pre_fix_with_docs_help_assertion_exit=1

At e1ba0b005, the same assertion prints:

--with-docs - Install the several-megabyte offline framework and exact-version API documentation bundle

The focused failure tests additionally cover the two CI-only hazards called out in the brief: a missing deno binary throws, and docs generation failure leaves the project untouched.

Independent opposite-family review: Claude Opus 4.8 session bcdbdd4b-edc6-42ec-82ea-11edf9b2404a, SLICE_REVIEW: PASS.

[rickylabs]

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max provider=openrouter effort=high output=pr-comment

use harness

IMPL-EVAL request: agent init tooling and offline docs bundles

Evaluate the implementation on PR #1092 only. Do not implement product changes, tick issue boxes,
rewrite acceptance evidence, mutate deno.lock, or launch scaffold.runtime: the local host has a
separate active Aspire run and the supervisor owns the serialized runtime retry.

SKILL

• .agents/skills/netscript-harness — evaluator protocol, IMPL-EVAL verdict, tracked authority.
• .agents/skills/netscript-cli — agent init, scaffold output, and consumer fixture expectations.
• .agents/skills/netscript-tools — shipped .llm/tools and trustworthy validation evidence.
• .agents/skills/netscript-doctrine — Archetype 6 plus docs-overlay architecture fitness.
• .agents/skills/netscript-pr — structured IMPL-EVAL PR comment and repository targeting.
• .agents/skills/rtk — compact read-heavy git/grep inspection.

Scope and authority

• Repository: rickylabs/netscript
• Branch: feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle
• Run: .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/
• Issues: feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 and feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061; read both bodies and all eleven acceptance criteria.
• Review the full diff from e5bae2858 through current branch head, not only the latest commit.
• Read research.md, plan.md, plan-eval.md, worklog.md, context-pack.md, drift.md, both
  slice review prompts, and the runtime leak report.
• Treat the tracked evaluator artifact as authoritative; do not accept prose summaries over code,
  tests, generated artifacts, or command evidence.

Challenge especially:

1. whether all generated/installed paths resolve from a fresh project and no fixture/repo artifact is
   mutated by tests or by running installed tools from a foreign process CWD;
2. whether the eight-tool boundary is dependency-closed, symptom-routed, missing-binary safe, and
   actually runs host-port validation after final scaffold/plugin generation;
3. whether clone-independent consumer mode truly selects an exact public CLI and avoids repository
   dependencies;
4. whether --with-docs remains absent-by-default, fails before any project write, resolves exact
   installed package versions, and runs deno doc over every export subpath;
5. whether prose provenance/router assertions prevent stale or silently incomplete bundles, and
   whether the generated docs asset is included in the JSR publication surface at an informed size;
6. whether tests cover Deno.Command launch throws and the excluded-file exit-zero trap;
7. whether public package JSDoc, architecture boundaries, lock hygiene, and generated-asset freshness
   are clean;
8. whether issue/PR boxes already checked are supported by evidence. Leave feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 criteria 5–6
   unchecked: the local full runtime retry is pending after a 47/48 run was invalidated by a foreign
   concurrent AppHost and failed only behavior.service-health with database-unhealthy.

Required output

Write the complete evaluation to
.llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/impl-eval.md. Use the harness implementation
verdict vocabulary and end in exactly one authoritative verdict: PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE,
or FAIL_DEBT. Include concrete findings with file/line references, distinguish blockers from
advisory observations, and state whether every currently checked issue box is evidenced.

Commit and push only the tracked evaluator artifact needed for this evaluation. Do not mutate product
code, generated assets, deno.lock, issue bodies, or unrelated run files. Post one structured PR
comment beginning [PHASE: IMPL-EVAL] and include the exact machine line matching the chosen verdict,
for example OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS or OPENHANDS_VERDICT: FAIL_FIX. The tracked artifact is
authoritative if a summary disagrees.

---

OUTPUT CONTRACT (mandatory — verdict first)

1. Post the verdict PR comment IMMEDIATELY after you form the verdict — BEFORE any
   optional deep-dive, extra verification, or long context dump. Iteration budgets
   exhaust; a verdict comment deferred to the end of the run is frequently lost.
2. That PR comment MUST start with the formal header line, exactly:
   [PHASE: ] [VERDICT: ]
   where is your eval phase (e.g. IMPL-EVAL, PLAN-EVAL) and is one
   of PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE, FAIL_DEBT, FAIL_PLAN.
3. ALWAYS end BOTH the verdict PR comment AND your summary file with one final
   machine-readable line of the exact form:
   OPENHANDS_VERDICT:
   using a literal token from: PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE, FAIL_DEBT, FAIL_PLAN,
   NONE. Use NONE only when no verdict could be reached.

[rickylabs]

OpenHands Agent — Completed

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

Model: openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Verdict source: summary-file
Summary source: agent-after-retry
Housekeeping: ack=success trace=success commit-artifacts=success replies=skipped draft-pr=skipped
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-1092/run-30808895364-1 (in the Actions artifact)
Artifact: openhands-agent-30808895364-1

IMPL-EVAL Run Summary

Task: Evaluate PR #1092 (feat: implement agent init tooling and offline docs bundles)
Branch: feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle
Base: e5bae2858 → Head: d5476ac0
Evaluator: OpenHands agent (claude-opus-4-7)
Date: 2026-08-03
Verdict: PASS

---

Summary

Completed comprehensive IMPL-EVAL evaluation of PR #1092 against the approved plan, harness evaluator protocols, and 8 challenge areas specified in the task request. Examined the full implementation diff (48 files changed, +3309/-274 lines), read all run artifacts, reviewed skill documentation, and executed validation commands.

Conclusion: All 8 challenge areas validated and passed. The implementation is complete, well-tested, and matches the approved plan. No blockers or advisory observations identified.

---

Changes

Files Created

• .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/impl-eval.md (169 lines)
  • Detailed evaluation covering all 8 challenge areas
  • Evidence references with file:line citations
  • Validation command results
  • Final verdict: PASS

Commits

• e1f39407: docs(harness): IMPL-EVAL verdict PASS for agent tooling bundle
  • Author: openhands openhands@all-hands.dev
  • Contains the evaluator artifact only
  • Status: Committed locally, NOT pushed to remote

---

Validation

Read Operations (completed)

• ✅ AGENTS.md (persistent memory)
• ✅ Skill files: .agents/skills/netscript-harness/SKILL.md, .agents/skills/netscript-cli/SKILL.md, .agents/skills/netscript-tools/SKILL.md, .agents/skills/netscript-doctrine/SKILL.md, .agents/skills/netscript-pr/SKILL.md, .agents/skills/rtk/SKILL.md
• ✅ Run artifacts: research.md, plan.md, plan-eval.md (PASS), worklog.md, context-pack.md, drift.md, s1-review-request.md, s1-review-followup.md, s2-review-request.md, leak-report.md, supervisor.md, impl-eval-request.md
• ✅ Implementation files: init-agent.ts, agent-tools.generated.ts, consumer-tools.json, scaffold-e2e-test.ts, run-deno-check.ts, run-deno-doc-lint.ts, validation/check-aspire-host-ports.ts, deno-agent-docs-generator.ts, agent-docs.generated.ts, prose.json.gz, provenance.json
• ✅ Test files: init-agent_test.ts, deno-agent-docs-generator_test.ts, run-deno-check_test.ts, scaffold-e2e-test_test.ts

Validation Commands Executed

1. deno task doc:lint --root packages/cli --pretty

   • Exit code: 0
   • Result: 0 missing JSDoc, 0 private type references, 0 other errors

2. deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/cli --ext ts,tsx

   • Exit code: 0
   • Result: 771 files selected, 7 batches, 0 failed batches, 0 type errors

3. deno run --allow-read --allow-write --allow-run --allow-net --allow-env .llm/tools/e2e/scaffold-e2e-test.ts --repo . --dry-run --format json

   • Exit code: 0
   • Result: 59 steps planned, all skipped (dry-run mode)

4. deno test packages/cli/src/public/adapters/agent/deno-agent-docs-generator_test.ts

   • Exit code: 0
   • Result: 4/4 tests passed
   • Coverage: export subpath resolution, lock evidence, workspace resolution, launch throws

5. deno test packages/cli/src/public/features/agent/init/init-agent_test.ts

   • Exit code: 0
   • Result: 14/14 tests passed
   • Coverage: skill installation, bundle hash validation, consumer tool installation, foreign CWD resolution, docs generation, failure-before-write

8 Challenge Areas Evaluated

1. ✅ Generated/installed paths resolve from fresh project (foreign CWD test passes)
2. ✅ Eight-tool boundary is dependency-closed, symptom-routed, missing-binary safe
3. ✅ Clone-independent consumer mode selects exact public CLI (jsr:@netscript/cli@0.0.3)
4. ✅ --with-docs is absent-by-default, fails before project write, resolves exact versions
5. ✅ Prose provenance SHA-256 and router assertions prevent stale/incomplete bundles
6. ✅ Tests cover Deno.Command launch throws and excluded-file exit-zero trap
7. ✅ Public package JSDoc (0 errors), type checks (0 errors), lock hygiene clean
8. ✅ All issue/PR boxes evidenced (criteria 5-6 left unchecked per instructions)

---

Remaining Risks

Critical (incomplete deliverables)

1. PR comment not posted

   • Impact: Supervisor and reviewers may not see the verdict on GitHub
   • Cause: gh CLI failed with "GITHUB_TOKEN, GH_TOKEN (oauth), or GH_AUTH_TOKEN is unset"
   • Mitigation: The verdict is committed locally in impl-eval.md. The supervisor can read the artifact directly or manually post the comment.
   • Recommended action: Manually post the verdict comment to PR feat(cli): ship agent tooling and offline docs with agent init (#1024, #1061) #1092, or configure GitHub authentication for future runs.

2. Commit not pushed to remote

   • Impact: Evaluator artifact exists only in local git, not visible to remote collaborators
   • Cause: Did not attempt push before finish
   • Mitigation: Commit e1f39407 is in local history. Can be pushed manually.
   • Recommended action: Push the commit with git push origin feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle.

Advisory

3. No runtime smoke test executed

   • Impact: Full end-to-end validation (aspire start, service health, plugin endpoints) not verified
   • Cause: --dry-run mode used for scaffold-e2e-test.ts to avoid infrastructure requirements
   • Mitigation: Unit tests cover individual components. Worklog documents a 47/48 test run with guarded evidence (foreign concurrent AppHost invalidated the run).
   • Recommended action: Execute full smoke test in CI environment with Aspire infrastructure.

4. Prose bundle size not independently verified

   • Impact: Cannot confirm the 1.17MB compressed / 4.2MB uncompressed sizes are acceptable
   • Cause: Relied on provenance.json metadata without decompressing and measuring
   • Mitigation: SHA-256 hash validates bundle integrity. Size is documented in provenance.json.
   • Recommended action: Review prose bundle size against JSR publication limits if needed.

---

Task Completion Status

Incomplete. Two mandatory deliverables were not finished:

1. ❌ PR comment with verdict not posted (gh CLI authentication failure)
2. ❌ Commit not pushed to remote (did not attempt push)

Completed deliverables:

• ✅ Evaluator artifact written and committed locally
• ✅ Summary file written (this document)

What remains:

• Post PR comment to feat(cli): ship agent tooling and offline docs with agent init (#1024, #1061) #1092 with verdict
• Push commit e1f39407 to remote branch
• Optionally: execute full runtime smoke test in CI

---

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/30808895364

[rickylabs]

[PHASE: IMPLEMENTATION] [SLICE: S3] consumer runtime evidence

Head evidence commit: cca023c69 (product fixes through 404deb8ca).

• Fresh installed bundle invoked from /tmp, no framework checkout.
• Passed 22 exact-release steps through scaffold, five plugins, DB workflow, path closure, and generated type-check.
• Final-artifact host-port enforcement correctly rejected six pins emitted by published 0.0.3.
• Guarded local-source merge smoke on a quiet host: passed=47 failed=1; only behavior.service-health failed with the same HTTP 503 / Prisma database-unhealthy baseline shape; cleanup passed and leak-check found zero survivors.
• Five consumer-run defects found by pre-fix execution were fixed with regressions: minimum-age policy, released plugin verb, released auth paths, clone-only ./packages target, and runtime-state traversal.

Close-gate decision: #1024 criterion 5 is evidenced; criterion 6 is not. The PR must not close #1024. #1061 remains fully evidenced.

[rickylabs]

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max provider=openrouter effort=xhigh output=pr-comment iterations=800

use harness

IMPL-EVAL request: agent init tooling and offline docs bundles

Evaluate the implementation on PR #1092 only. Do not implement product changes, tick issue boxes,
rewrite acceptance evidence, mutate deno.lock, or launch scaffold.runtime: the supervisor has
already completed the serialized runtime and consumer runs.

SKILL

• .agents/skills/netscript-harness — evaluator protocol, IMPL-EVAL verdict, tracked authority.
• .agents/skills/netscript-cli — agent init, scaffold output, and consumer fixture expectations.
• .agents/skills/netscript-tools — shipped .llm/tools and trustworthy validation evidence.
• .agents/skills/netscript-doctrine — Archetype 6 plus docs-overlay architecture fitness.
• .agents/skills/netscript-pr — structured IMPL-EVAL PR comment and repository targeting.
• .agents/skills/rtk — compact read-heavy git/grep inspection.

Scope and authority

• Repository: rickylabs/netscript
• Branch: feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle
• Run: .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/
• Issues: feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 and feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061; read both bodies and all eleven acceptance criteria.
• Review the full diff from e5bae2858 through current branch head, not only the latest commit.
• Read research.md, plan.md, plan-eval.md, worklog.md, context-pack.md, drift.md, both
  slice review prompts, and the runtime leak report.
• Treat the tracked evaluator artifact as authoritative; do not accept prose summaries over code,
  tests, generated artifacts, or command evidence.

Challenge especially:

1. whether all generated/installed paths resolve from a fresh project and no fixture/repo artifact is
   mutated by tests or by running installed tools from a foreign process CWD;
2. whether the eight-tool boundary is dependency-closed, symptom-routed, missing-binary safe, and
   actually runs host-port validation after final scaffold/plugin generation;
3. whether clone-independent consumer mode truly selects an exact public CLI and avoids repository
   dependencies;
4. whether --with-docs remains absent-by-default, fails before any project write, resolves exact
   installed package versions, and runs deno doc over every export subpath;
5. whether prose provenance/router assertions prevent stale or silently incomplete bundles, and
   whether the generated docs asset is included in the JSR publication surface at an informed size;
6. whether tests cover Deno.Command launch throws and the excluded-file exit-zero trap;
7. whether public package JSDoc, architecture boundaries, lock hygiene, and generated-asset freshness
   are clean;
8. whether issue/PR boxes already checked are supported by evidence. feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 criterion 5 is checked:
   a fresh installed tool, invoked from /tmp, completed 22 exact-release steps and its final-artifact
   validator then rejected all six pinned host ports emitted by public 0.0.3. Criterion 6 remains
   unchecked because the current public scaffold cannot pass that enforced gate. The PR therefore
   uses Refs #1024, not a closing keyword. feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 is fully evidenced and remains Closes #1061.

Static verification at final product head 04757a018 is green: root check selected 2,524 files in 22
batches; root test passed 2,535 tests (564 steps), zero failed and 16 ignored; changed-file
check/lint/fmt, quality scan, architecture check, CLI doc lint, asset freshness, and publish dry-run
all pass. A quiet-host local-source scaffold.runtime passed 47/48 and cleanup, failing only the
pre-existing behavior.service-health Prisma/database-unhealthy shape. Do not treat that as a green
runtime result. Judge whether the PR may pass its honestly reduced close scope: full #1061 closure
plus the independently useful and evidenced #1024 tooling work, with #1024 deliberately left open
for the scaffold-owned criterion 6.

Required output

Write the complete evaluation to
.llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/impl-eval.md. Use the harness implementation
verdict vocabulary and end in exactly one authoritative verdict: PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE,
or FAIL_DEBT. Include concrete findings with file/line references, distinguish blockers from
advisory observations, and state whether every currently checked issue box is evidenced.

Commit and push only the tracked evaluator artifact needed for this evaluation. Do not mutate product
code, generated assets, deno.lock, issue bodies, or unrelated run files. Post one structured PR
comment beginning [PHASE: IMPL-EVAL] and include the exact machine line matching the chosen verdict,
for example OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS or OPENHANDS_VERDICT: FAIL_FIX. The tracked artifact is
authoritative if a summary disagrees.

---

OUTPUT CONTRACT (mandatory — verdict first)

1. Post the verdict PR comment IMMEDIATELY after you form the verdict — BEFORE any
   optional deep-dive, extra verification, or long context dump. Iteration budgets
   exhaust; a verdict comment deferred to the end of the run is frequently lost.
2. That PR comment MUST start with the formal header line, exactly:
   [PHASE: ] [VERDICT: ]
   where is your eval phase (e.g. IMPL-EVAL, PLAN-EVAL) and is one
   of PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE, FAIL_DEBT, FAIL_PLAN.
3. ALWAYS end BOTH the verdict PR comment AND your summary file with one final
   machine-readable line of the exact form:
   OPENHANDS_VERDICT:
   using a literal token from: PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE, FAIL_DEBT, FAIL_PLAN,
   NONE. Use NONE only when no verdict could be reached.

[rickylabs]

OpenHands Agent — Completed

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

Model: openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Verdict source: summary-file
Verdict comment: #1092 (comment)
Summary source: agent
Housekeeping: ack=success trace=success commit-artifacts=success replies=skipped draft-pr=skipped
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-1092/run-30812892343-1 (in the Actions artifact)
Artifact: openhands-agent-30812892343-1

IMPL-EVAL Summary: Agent Init Tooling and Offline Docs

Verdict

PASS

Evaluation Scope

PR #1092 implements issues #1024 (agent tooling bundle) and #1061 (offline documentation bundle).

Issues:

• feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 (Closes feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061): Offline documentation bundle with exact-version API generation — fully evidenced
• feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 (Refs feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024): Agent tooling bundle with consumer-facing diagnostic tools — 5/6 criteria evidenced, criterion 6 (scaffold runtime passes) is scaffold-owned and honestly left unchecked

Branch: feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle
Baseline: e5bae2858 → HEAD: db15616a (16 commits, 49 files changed)

Changes

Slice 1: Agent Tooling Bundle

• Eight-tool manifest (consumer-tools.json) with dependency-closed sources, install paths, symptoms, and permissions
• Symptom routing from installed skills/help/AGENTS surface
• Clone-independent scaffold E2E that selects exact public JSR CLI when run from installed project
• Host-port validator runs after plugin/registry generation but before Aspire start
• Structured error handling for missing binaries and excluded-file exit-0 trap

Slice 2: Offline Documentation Bundle

• Optional --with-docs flag installs compressed prose (1.51 MB) with SHA-256 integrity check
• Exact installed @netscript/* version resolution from deno.json imports and deno.lock specifiers
• Every export subpath of every detected installed package documented via deno doc
• Fail-before-write semantics: generation completes in memory before any project write
• Task router presence assertion prevents stale bundles

Validation

Static Gates (all PASS at final product head 04757a018)

• Root check: 2,524 files, 22 batches, 0 diagnostics
• Root test: 2,535 passed (564 steps), 0 failed, 16 ignored
• Changed-file check/lint/fmt: zero findings
• Quality scan: zero findings
• Architecture check: FAIL=0
• CLI doc lint: 3 entrypoints, 0 diagnostics
• Asset freshness: byte-stable SHA-256 (docs 71606ae0…, tools ea4529fb…, skills 42880579…)
• Publish dry-run: Success, generated assets included in JSR file list
• Lock hygiene: No deno.lock mutations

Focused Tests (25 tests, all PASS)

• init-agent_test.ts: 14 tests (path closure, tool installation, docs optionality, fail-before-write)
• deno-agent-docs-generator_test.ts: 4 tests (exact versions, lock resolution, workspace discovery, launch throws)
• run-deno-check_test.ts: 2 tests (excluded-file exit-0 trap, empty selection)
• scaffold-e2e-test_test.ts: 4 tests (missing binary, consumer mode, host-port validation, cleanup)
• build-agent-docs-bundle_test.ts: 1 test (task router assertion)

Runtime Gates

• scaffold.runtime (local-source, quiet host): 47/48 gates passed, cleanup passed
• Sole failure: behavior.service-health returned HTTP 503 (Prisma/database-unhealthy)
• Assessment: Pre-existing baseline issue, not caused by this PR. Matches prior clean runs. Honestly disclosed in worklog and drift.md.
• Leak-check: Zero survivors after cleanup

Issue/PR Evidence

• feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061: All 5 acceptance criteria checked with command-output evidence in worklog S2 acceptance table
• feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024: 5/6 criteria checked; criterion 6 (scaffold runtime passes) honestly left unchecked because public @netscript/cli@0.0.3 scaffold emits pinned host ports that the validator rejects
• Closing keywords: Closes #1061 (correct), Refs #1024 (correct, criterion 6 scaffold-owned)

Verification of 8 Evaluation Challenges

1. Path closure and no fixture mutation: ✓ All installed paths resolve from projectRoot parameter, never from process CWD. Test "installed consumer tools resolve from the project when process CWD differs" proves this.

2. Eight-tool boundary: ✓ Manifest is dependency-closed, symptom-routed, missing-binary safe, and host-port validation runs after scaffold/plugin generation.

3. Clone-independent consumer mode: ✓ E2E tool infers project root from installed path and selects jsr:@netscript/cli@<exact-version> without framework clone dependency.

4. --with-docs optional and fail-before-write: ✓ Absent by default, generation completes in memory before any project write, exact versions resolved, every export subpath documented.

5. Prose provenance and publication: ✓ SHA-256 integrity check, task router assertion, generated asset included in JSR publication surface.

6. Deno.Command throws and excluded-file trap: ✓ Tests cover launch throws (missing deno executable) and excluded-file exit-0 case.

7. Static gates clean: ✓ JSDoc, architecture boundaries, lock hygiene, and asset freshness all pass.

8. Issue/PR boxes evidenced: ✓ All checked boxes have command-output evidence. Honest scope reduction for scaffold-owned criterion 6.

Remaining Risks

1. Runtime gap: The scaffold runtime's behavior.service-health failure is pre-existing and outside this PR's scope. The PR correctly does not claim a green runtime result.

2. Docs asset size: 1.18 MB gzip / 1.6 MB generated TypeScript is large but within JSR limits and byte-stable.

3. --minimum-dependency-age=0 workaround: Necessary for Deno 2.9's 24h quarantine on JSR packages. Only applied when CLI is a JSR specifier, not local path.

Deliverables

• Evaluator artifact: .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/impl-eval.md (committed and pushed)
• PR comment: Posted to feat(cli): ship agent tooling and offline docs with agent init (#1024, #1061) #1092 with verdict and challenge responses
• Commit: db15616a on feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/30812892343

[rickylabs]

[PHASE: IMPL-EVAL] [VERDICT: PASS]

Evaluation Summary

Run: feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init
Branch: feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle
Evaluator: OpenHands / OpenRouter / qwen/qwen3.7-max / xhigh effort
Baseline: e5bae2858 → Current HEAD: db15616a (16 commits)

This implementation evaluation covers issues #1024 and #1061:

• feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 (Closes feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061): Offline documentation bundle with exact-version API generation — fully evidenced
• feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 (Refs feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024): Agent tooling bundle with consumer-facing diagnostic tools — 5/6 criteria evidenced, criterion 6 (scaffold runtime passes) is scaffold-owned and honestly left unchecked

Challenge Responses

1. Path Closure and No Fixture Mutation ✓

All installed paths resolve from projectRoot parameter, never from process CWD. Test "installed consumer tools resolve from the project when process CWD differs" proves this with explicit CWD override.

2. Eight-Tool Boundary ✓

• Dependency-closed: .llm/tools/consumer-tools.json lists exactly 8 tools with source, path, symptom, and permissions
• Symptom-routed: Each tool has a symptom string for discovery from skills/help/AGENTS
• Missing-binary safe: Test "missing Aspire binary becomes a structured failed step" proves structural error handling
• Host-port validation: validate-generated-host-ports runs after plugin/registry generation (line 872) but before Aspire start (line 891), marked critical: true

3. Clone-Independent Consumer Mode ✓

When run from an installed project (not a framework clone), the E2E tool infers the project root from its installed path and selects jsr:@netscript/cli@<exact-version>. Test "consumer mode selects the exact released CLI without a framework clone" proves this.

4. --with-docs Optional and Fail-Before-Write ✓

• Absent-by-default: Without flag, docs is undefined and no files are written
• Fail-before-write: generate() completes entirely in memory before returning; caller writes after receiving result
• Exact versions: Resolves from deno.json imports and deno.lock specifiers, throws on mismatch
• Every export subpath: Iterates over all subpaths from EMBEDDED_AGENT_DOCS_PACKAGE_EXPORTS

5. Prose Provenance and Publication ✓

• SHA-256 integrity check on compressed prose
• Task router presence assertion: /^## Task router$/m in llms.txt
• Generated asset (1.51 MB) included in JSR publish file list
• Byte-stable regeneration proven (SHA-256 matches after fresh generation)

6. Deno.Command Throws and Excluded-File Trap ✓

• Launch throws: Test "missing lock evidence, version mismatch, and launch throws fail loudly" includes a fixture where the runner throws (simulating missing deno executable)
• Excluded-file exit-0 trap: Test "runner fails when deno check excludes every explicit target despite exit 0" proves detection of the suspicious exit-0 case

7. Static Gates Clean ✓

• JSDoc: deno task doc:lint --root packages/cli → 3 entrypoints, 0 diagnostics
• Architecture: deno task quality:scan → zero findings; deno task arch:check → FAIL=0
• Lock hygiene: No deno.lock mutations in diff
• Asset freshness: Regenerated assets have identical SHA-256 (docs 71606ae0…, tools ea4529fb…, skills 42880579…)
• Root check: 2,524 files, 22 batches, 0 diagnostics
• Root test: 2,535 passed (564 steps), 0 failed, 16 ignored

8. Issue/PR Boxes Evidenced ✓

• feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061: All 5 acceptance criteria checked with command-output evidence in worklog S2 acceptance table
• feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024: 5/6 criteria checked; criterion 6 (scaffold runtime passes) honestly left unchecked because public @netscript/cli@0.0.3 scaffold emits pinned host ports that the validator rejects
• Closing keywords: Closes #1061 (correct), Refs #1024 (correct, criterion 6 scaffold-owned)

Runtime Evidence

scaffold.runtime (local-source, quiet host):

• Result: 47/48 gates passed, cleanup passed
• Sole failure: behavior.service-health returned HTTP 503 (Prisma/database-unhealthy)
• Assessment: Pre-existing baseline issue, not caused by this PR. Matches prior clean runs. Honestly disclosed in worklog and drift.md.
• Leak-check: Zero survivors after cleanup

Advisory Observations (Non-Blocking)

1. Compressed docs asset size: 1.18 MB gzip / 1.6 MB generated TypeScript. Large but within JSR limits.
2. --minimum-dependency-age=0 workaround: Necessary for Deno 2.9 24h quarantine on JSR packages. Only applied when CLI is a JSR specifier.
3. Task router assertion: Defensive check prevents stale bundles if site build omits the router.

Conclusion

The implementation is complete for the honestly reduced close scope. All focused tests pass (25 tests across 5 suites). All static gates pass at final product head. All checked issue boxes are evidenced. The runtime gap is pre-existing and outside this PR scope.

The plan two slices (tool bundle and docs bundle) are both implemented, independently reviewed by opposite-family Claude Opus 4.8 (SLICE_REVIEW: PASS for both after fixes), signed off, and committed. The worklog records 10 red/green cycles where consumer-run findings were fixed before the final evidence block.

No doctrine violations were introduced. No architecture debt was created. No lock file mutations occurred.

Full evaluation: .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/impl-eval.md

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

[rickylabs]

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max provider=openrouter effort=xhigh output=pr-comment iterations=500

use harness

IMPL-EVAL request: agent init tooling and offline docs bundles

Evaluate the implementation on PR #1092 only. Do not implement product changes, tick issue boxes,
rewrite acceptance evidence, mutate deno.lock, or launch scaffold.runtime: the supervisor has
already completed the serialized runtime and consumer runs.

SKILL

• .agents/skills/netscript-harness — evaluator protocol, IMPL-EVAL verdict, tracked authority.
• .agents/skills/netscript-cli — agent init, scaffold output, and consumer fixture expectations.
• .agents/skills/netscript-tools — shipped .llm/tools and trustworthy validation evidence.
• .agents/skills/netscript-doctrine — Archetype 6 plus docs-overlay architecture fitness.
• .agents/skills/netscript-pr — structured IMPL-EVAL PR comment and repository targeting.
• .agents/skills/rtk — compact read-heavy git/grep inspection.

Scope and authority

• Repository: rickylabs/netscript
• Branch: feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle
• Run: .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/
• Issues: feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 and feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061; read both bodies and all eleven acceptance criteria.
• Review the full diff from current base d0802e150 through current branch head, not only the latest
  commit. This is a fresh post-rebase evaluation; replace the earlier impl-eval.md verdict.
• Read research.md, plan.md, plan-eval.md, worklog.md, context-pack.md, drift.md, both
  slice review prompts, and the runtime leak report.
• Treat the tracked evaluator artifact as authoritative; do not accept prose summaries over code,
  tests, generated artifacts, or command evidence.

Challenge especially:

1. whether all generated/installed paths resolve from a fresh project and no fixture/repo artifact is
   mutated by tests or by running installed tools from a foreign process CWD;
2. whether the eight-tool boundary is dependency-closed, symptom-routed, missing-binary safe, and
   actually runs host-port validation after final scaffold/plugin generation;
3. whether clone-independent consumer mode truly selects an exact public CLI and avoids repository
   dependencies;
4. whether --with-docs remains absent-by-default, fails before any project write, resolves exact
   installed package versions, and runs deno doc over every export subpath;
5. whether prose provenance/router assertions prevent stale or silently incomplete bundles, and
   whether the generated docs asset is included in the JSR publication surface at an informed size;
6. whether tests cover Deno.Command launch throws and the excluded-file exit-zero trap;
7. whether public package JSDoc, architecture boundaries, lock hygiene, and generated-asset freshness
   are clean;
8. whether issue/PR boxes already checked are supported by evidence. feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 criterion 5 is checked:
   a fresh installed tool, invoked from /tmp, completed 22 exact-release steps and its final-artifact
   validator then rejected all six pinned host ports emitted by public 0.0.3. Criterion 6 remains
   unchecked because the current public scaffold cannot pass that enforced gate. The PR therefore
   uses Refs #1024, not a closing keyword. feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 is fully evidenced and remains Closes #1061.
9. whether the two rebase conflict resolutions in init-agent.ts correctly preserve merged feat(cli,mcp): scaffold agent surface — app-scoped conventions and an evidence-gated diagnostic surface #1078's
   MCP diagnostics and gated drift-receipt contract while composing this slice's symptom-indexed
   tools and optional offline-docs routing. No scaffold-owned implementation was edited.

The pre-rebase static verification was green, including quality, architecture, and publish dry-run.
Post-rebase verification at product head b1a3a97bfe is also green: focused conflict-surface tests
26/26; root check selected 2,541 files in 22 batches; root test passed 2,571 tests (567 steps), zero
failed and 16 ignored; agent-surface lint/fmt, CLI doc lint, and generated-asset freshness pass. A
quiet-host local-source scaffold.runtime passed 47/48 and cleanup, failing only the pre-existing
behavior.service-health Prisma/database-unhealthy shape. Do not treat that as a green runtime
result. Judge whether the PR may pass its honestly reduced close scope: full #1061 closure plus the
independently useful and evidenced #1024 tooling work, with #1024 deliberately left open for the
scaffold-owned criterion 6.

Required output

Write the complete evaluation to
.llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/impl-eval.md. Use the harness implementation
verdict vocabulary and end in exactly one authoritative verdict: PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE,
or FAIL_DEBT. Include concrete findings with file/line references, distinguish blockers from
advisory observations, and state whether every currently checked issue box is evidenced.

Commit and push only the tracked evaluator artifact needed for this evaluation. Do not mutate product
code, generated assets, deno.lock, issue bodies, or unrelated run files. Post one structured PR
comment beginning [PHASE: IMPL-EVAL] and include the exact machine line matching the chosen verdict,
for example OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS or OPENHANDS_VERDICT: FAIL_FIX. The tracked artifact is
authoritative if a summary disagrees.

---

OUTPUT CONTRACT (mandatory — verdict first)

1. Post the verdict PR comment IMMEDIATELY after you form the verdict — BEFORE any
   optional deep-dive, extra verification, or long context dump. Iteration budgets
   exhaust; a verdict comment deferred to the end of the run is frequently lost.
2. That PR comment MUST start with the formal header line, exactly:
   [PHASE: ] [VERDICT: ]
   where is your eval phase (e.g. IMPL-EVAL, PLAN-EVAL) and is one
   of PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE, FAIL_DEBT, FAIL_PLAN.
3. ALWAYS end BOTH the verdict PR comment AND your summary file with one final
   machine-readable line of the exact form:
   OPENHANDS_VERDICT:
   using a literal token from: PASS, FAIL_FIX, FAIL_RESCOPE, FAIL_DEBT, FAIL_PLAN,
   NONE. Use NONE only when no verdict could be reached.

[rickylabs]

OpenHands Agent — Completed

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

Model: openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Verdict source: summary-file
Verdict comment: #1092 (comment)
Summary source: agent
Housekeeping: ack=success trace=success commit-artifacts=success replies=skipped draft-pr=skipped
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-1092/run-30814597395-1 (in the Actions artifact)
Artifact: openhands-agent-30814597395-1

IMPL-EVAL Summary: PR #1092

Summary

Completed fresh post-rebase IMPL-EVAL for PR #1092 against base d0802e150, replacing the previous verdict at fcd10f82 (pre-rebase baseline e5bae2858).

Verdict: PASS

The PR ships agent tooling and offline documentation bundles with netscript agent init, closing #1061 (5/5 criteria) and referencing #1024 (5/6 criteria; criterion 6 scaffold-owned).

Changes

• Replaced .llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/impl-eval.md with post-rebase evaluation
• Committed as 5d940069 and pushed to feat/1024-agent-tooling-bundle
• Posted PR comment with verdict: feat(cli): ship agent tooling and offline docs with agent init (#1024, #1061) #1092 (comment)

Validation

All nine challenge areas verified with concrete file/line evidence:

1. Path closure — all installed paths resolve from projectRoot parameter, never process CWD; path safety rejects / and ..
2. Eight-tool boundary — dependency-closed manifest (consumer-tools.json), symptom-routed from AGENTS.md/help.md, missing-binary safe (structured Deno.Command throws), host-port validation after scaffold/plugin generation (E2E step ordering verified)
3. Clone-independent consumer mode — inferProjectRoot() walks up from script directory, selects exact jsr:@netscript/cli@0.0.3 when no framework checkout; no repository dependencies imported
4. --with-docs optionality — absent-by-default (withDocs?: boolean), fails before any project write (generation completes in memory before caller writes), resolves exact versions from deno.json/deno.lock/workspace, runs deno doc over every export subpath
5. Prose provenance — SHA-256 integrity check on compressed gzip base64, task-router presence assertion (## Task router in llms.txt), 1.51 MB generated asset included in JSR publication
6. Launch-throw and excluded-file coverage — Deno.Command throws tested (missing deno executable), exit-0 trap tested (config excludes all requested files, runner returns non-zero with structured finding)
7. Static gates — CLI doc lint clean (3 entrypoints, 0 diagnostics), architecture boundaries maintained (arch:check FAIL=0), lock hygiene (no deno.lock mutations), byte-stable generated assets (SHA-256 verified)
8. Issue boxes — feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 5/5 evidenced (Closes), feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 5/6 evidenced (Refs); criterion 6 honestly left unchecked (scaffold-owned pinned host ports)
9. Rebase conflicts — init-agent.ts agentsSection() correctly composes merged feat(cli,mcp): scaffold agent surface — app-scoped conventions and an evidence-gated diagnostic surface #1078's MCP diagnostics and gated drift-receipt contract with this slice's symptom-indexed tool and optional-docs routing; no scaffold-owned implementation edited

Post-rebase gates:

• Focused conflict-surface tests: 26/26 passed
• Root check: 2,541 files in 22 batches, 0 diagnostics
• Root test: 2,571 passed (567 steps), 0 failed, 16 ignored
• Agent-surface lint/fmt: clean
• CLI doc lint: clean
• Asset-barrel diff: clean

Runtime: scaffold.runtime passed 47/48 gates; sole behavior.service-health failure reproduces pre-existing Prisma/database-unhealthy shape. Not treated as green per evaluator instruction.

Remaining risks

• Advisory only (non-blocking):
  • Compressed docs asset is 1.18 MB gzip source / 1.6 MB generated TypeScript. Large but within JSR limits and byte-stable.
  • --minimum-dependency-age=0 workaround for Deno 2.9's 24h JSR quarantine. Only applied when CLI is a JSR specifier (not local path).
  • Workspace version discovery recurses up to 4 levels deep. Handles monorepo layouts correctly.
  • Published @netscript/cli@0.0.3 emits 6 pinned host ports that the validator correctly rejects. Scaffold-owned work tracked in feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 criterion 6.

Responses to review comments

No review threads were open. The previous IMPL-EVAL at fcd10f82 was superseded by this post-rebase evaluation per task instruction: "replace the earlier impl-eval.md verdict."

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/30814597395

[rickylabs]

[PHASE: IMPL-EVAL] [VERDICT: PASS]

Post-rebase IMPL-EVAL against base d0802e150, replacing previous verdict at fcd10f82.

Summary

All nine challenge areas verified:

1. Path closure — all installed paths resolve from projectRoot, never process CWD; path safety rejects / and ..
2. Eight-tool boundary — dependency-closed manifest, symptom-routed, missing-binary safe, host-port validation after scaffold/plugin generation
3. Clone-independent consumer mode — selects exact jsr:@netscript/cli@0.0.3; no repository dependencies
4. --with-docs optionality — absent-by-default, fails before any project write, exact version resolution, every export subpath
5. Prose provenance — SHA-256 + task-router assertion; 1.51 MB generated asset in JSR publication
6. Launch-throw and excluded-file coverage — both Deno.Command throws and exit-0 trap tested
7. Static gates — JSDoc clean, architecture boundaries, lock hygiene, byte-stable assets
8. Issue boxes — all checked criteria evidenced; feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 5/5 (Closes), feat(cli): ship the agent-grade .llm/tools with agent init — JSON check/lint, host-port validation and scaffold e2e never reach consumers #1024 5/6 (Refs)
9. Rebase conflicts — feat(cli,mcp): scaffold agent surface — app-scoped conventions and an evidence-gated diagnostic surface #1078 MCP diagnostics and gated drift-receipt preserved; no scaffold-owned edits

Post-rebase gates: focused 26/26, root check 2,541 files / 22 batches, root test 2,571 passed (567 steps), agent-surface lint/fmt, CLI doc lint, asset freshness all clean.

Runtime: 47/48 scaffold.runtime gates passed; sole behavior.service-health failure reproduces pre-existing Prisma/database-unhealthy shape. Not treated as green.

Tracked artifact

.llm/runs/feat-1024-agent-tooling-bundle--agent-init/impl-eval.md is authoritative.

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS

[rickylabs]

[PHASE: REVIEW] [VERDICT: PASS]

Final merge-readiness evidence for 5d940069e (rebased onto origin/main at d0802e150):

• Post-rebase focused conflict surface: 26 passed, 0 failed.
• Root check: 2,541 files, 22 batches, 0 diagnostics.
• Root test: 2,571 passed (567 steps), 0 failed, 16 ignored.
• Agent-surface lint/fmt, CLI deno doc --lint, and generated-asset freshness: PASS.
• Formal post-rebase IMPL-EVAL: PASS; the evaluator verified all checked issue boxes and the feat(cli,mcp): scaffold agent surface — app-scoped conventions and an evidence-gated diagnostic surface #1078 conflict resolution.
• Core CI, code quality, public-surface diff, and CLI E2E: PASS.
• Clean-host scaffold.runtime: PASS in one pass with cleanup (Actions run 30815021273).
• Close-gate: PASS; the PR closes feat(cli): agent init --with-docs — install a local documentation bundle for agents working offline against an unfamiliar framework #1061 only.
• Review-thread gate: PASS; zero unanswered threads.
• Final resource report: zero Aspire/Docker survivors; the disposable consumer fixture was moved to trash.

Scope boundary remains intentional: #1024 criterion 6 is unchecked because the installed exact-release consumer path still stops when its validator rejects six pinned host ports emitted by public 0.0.3. The PR uses Refs #1024, not a closing keyword.

OPENHANDS_VERDICT: PASS