Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension


Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,16 @@
# openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory-s5-impl — Codex implementation thread
- **Thread / session id:** `019fc9d0-5385-7710-ade4-a552ac9c9c10`
- **Rollout:** `/home/codex/.codex/sessions/2026/08/04/rollout-2026-08-04T00-48-21-019fc9d0-5385-7710-ade4-a552ac9c9c10.jsonl`
- **Worktree:** `/home/codex/repos/ns005-s5-impl`
- **Branch:** `agent/openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory-s5` (NO upstream by design).
- **Push rule:** explicit refspec only — `git push origin HEAD:refs/heads/feat/openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory`.
- **Requested route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=high
- **Observed route:** provider=openai · model=gpt-5.6-sol · effort=high
- **Route verdict:** matched
- **Runtime:** approval=never · sandbox=dangerFullAccess
- **Brief (staged):** `/home/codex/openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory-s5-impl-brief.md`
## Steering (same thread — never a second send-message-v2 at this worktree)
```bash
codex exec resume 019fc9d0-5385-7710-ade4-a552ac9c9c10 -- "<follow-up>"
```
_Written by `.llm/tools/agentic/codex/launch-codex-slice.ts`._
103 changes: 103 additions & 0 deletions .llm/runs/feat-openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory--s5/context-pack.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,103 @@
# Context Pack: OMB S5 ServiceEndpointDirectoryPort + adapters

## Run Metadata

| Field | Value |
| --- | --- |
| Run ID | `feat-openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory--s5` |
| Branch | `feat/openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory` |
| Current phase | `implement` (plan locked via composed waiver) |
| Archetype | `2 — Integration` slice |
| Scope overlays | none |

## Current State

Research and design are locked at clean `origin/main` `2c8865e8c`. Slices 1–3 now implement the
contract-first endpoint vocabulary, all four source adapters, deterministic composition, and the
bounded spec-first identity probe, with the complete surface published and documented through both
entrypoints. All implementation, consumer, JSR, and publish gates are green; supervisor evaluation
and merge-readiness actions remain deliberately unstarted.

## Completed

- Read issue #1131, RFC #1123, epic context, P1/P3 verdicts, canonical discovery design, required
harness/doctrine/Aspire/JSR/PR/tooling authorities, and package consumers.
- Confirmed baseline doc lint and publish dry-run clean, no lock churn.
- Recorded Design checkpoint and the milestone-run PLAN-EVAL composed waiver.
- Implemented discriminated source/directory/probe contracts and the named source precedence.
- Implemented override, Aspire CLI, run-manifest, and appsettings sources with injected IO seams.
- Proved 6/6 source fixtures, scoped check/lint/fmt, package-specific quality scan, and
`quality:gate` with no unsafe casts, lint ignores, or lock churn.
- Implemented deterministic precedence/conflicts, exclusions before fetch, bounded concurrency,
row-local timeout/error isolation, and parent abort propagation.
- Implemented credential-free, redirect-free OpenAPI-first probing, exact P3 401/403 guidance,
identity verification, response bounds, and opaque spec preservation.
- Proved 12/12 endpoint tests, 78/78 package tests, and 79-file scoped check/lint/fmt.
- Published the complete S5 surface from `.` and transitively `./cli`, documented default adapter
permissions/configuration, and regenerated the embedded README asset.
- Proved zero full-export doc diagnostics, JSR audit exit 0, clean publish dry run, and no dependency
or lock churn. Grouping the adapters/port kept folder-cardinality debt at baseline.

## In Progress

- Implementation handoff after the Slice 3 commit/push/comment. The provided PR worktree remains
owned by the Desktop supervisor session; this attached thread remains the sole staging sender.

## Next Steps

1. Supervisor performs substantive review and the composed evaluation protocol.
2. Supervisor decides when to update PR/issue acceptance state and mark the draft ready.
3. Keep S6 projection/tool registration and S7 run-token producer wiring in their owned slices.

## Key Decisions

| Decision | Source | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `override > aspire-cli > run-manifest > appsettings` | P1 + RFC | CLI is primary live; explicit override remains supreme. |
| Manifest requires expected current run id | plan D4 | Missing/mismatch is visible failure. |
| No S4 imports | user coordinate rule | S6 composes later. |

## Files Changed

| Path | Status | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `.llm/runs/feat-openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory--s5/` | updated | Slice 1 evidence, reconcile note, attached-thread metadata |
| `packages/mcp/src/ports/service-endpoint-directory-port.ts` | new | Discriminated contract and three consumed ports |
| `packages/mcp/src/infrastructure/service-endpoints/` | new | Four named sources, URL policy, and fetch probe |
| `packages/mcp/tests/service-endpoint-source*` | new | Aspire/source fixture matrix; 6/6 passing |
| `packages/mcp/src/application/service-endpoint-directory.ts` | new | Default composition, precedence, bounds, isolation |
| `packages/mcp/src/infrastructure/fetch-service-endpoint-probe.ts` | new | Spec-first identity probe and P3 mapping |
| `packages/mcp/tests/service-endpoint-directory_test.ts` | new | Complete status/timeout/probe fixture matrix |
| `packages/mcp/deno.json` | updated | Test-only write permission for existing temp-dir tests |
| `packages/mcp/mod.ts`, `README.md` | updated | Published S5 surface and consumer/config/permission docs |
| `packages/mcp/src/publish-assets.generated.ts` | updated | Regenerated embedded README corpus |

## Gates

| Gate family | Current status | Evidence |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Static | slices 1–3 PASS | 12 focused tests + 78 package tests + 79-file check/lint/fmt |
| Fitness | slices 1–3 PASS | package quality scan + `quality:gate` + JSR audit |
| Runtime | PASS | all source/status rows and hanging-row isolation fixture-proven |
| Consumer | PASS | both entrypoints check/doc-lint clean; publish dry run clean |

## Open Questions

- None blocking implementation.

## Drift and Debt

- Drift: composed evaluator waiver; true remote baseline; manifest run-id injection clarification.
- Drift: lint/fmt wrappers require the package config because the root workspace glob shape does not
parse for those Deno subcommands in this worktree; no source/config mutation was made.
- Drift fixed: the package test task lacked the test-only write permission required by existing
temporary-directory tests; adding it restored the exact locked task to 78/78.
- Drift fixed: flat owned files initially created a new infrastructure cardinality warning; the A2
port and adapters are now grouped under `src/ports/` and `infrastructure/service-endpoints/`.
- Tooling note: the JSR helper counts Deno's neutral slow-type progress banner as a warning; raw doc
lint and publish show no actual slow-type diagnostic.
- Debt: preserve existing `MCP-A6-V2-SHAPE`; no new debt planned.

## Commits

- See the draft PR's commit list + per-slice PR comments.
150 changes: 150 additions & 0 deletions .llm/runs/feat-openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory--s5/drift.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,150 @@
# Drift Log: OMB S5 ServiceEndpointDirectoryPort + adapters

Drift is append-only.

## 2026-08-04 — Attached implementation uses a run-owned staging worktree

- **What:** The canonical implementation lane runs in `/home/codex/repos/ns005-s5-impl` on local
branch `agent/openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory-s5`, then pushes each slice to the required PR ref.
- **Source:** The agentic sender registry refused a rival sender because the provided worktree is
durably owned by the live Desktop supervisor thread.
- **Expected:** The implementation lane would attach directly to the provided PR worktree.
- **Actual:** A separate run-owned worktree preserves the one-sender invariant; the PR branch,
explicit push refspec, commit order, and review surface remain unchanged.
- **Severity:** minor
- **Action:** accept
- **Evidence:** agentic launcher `duplicate_sender_risk`; implementation brief path/branch contract.

## 2026-08-04 — Milestone evaluator composition replaces local formal PLAN-EVAL

- **What:** No local formal PLAN-EVAL is launched; the plan gate is recorded as composed waiver.
- **Source:** User-relayed `.llm/harness/workflow/milestone-run.md` evaluator rule and orchestrator D6.
- **Expected:** Normal run-loop would require a separate local formal PLAN-EVAL.
- **Actual:** Draft→ready augment + OpenHands + orchestrator pre-merge evaluation compose per-PR
evaluation; implementation proceeds in the same run after plan lock.
- **Severity:** significant
- **Action:** accept
- **Evidence:** `supervisor.md`, `plan-eval.md`, `worklog.md` Plan Gate row.

## 2026-08-04 — True baseline is fetched origin/main

- **What:** Local `main` pointed to an older commit while this branch matched remote `main`.
- **Source:** raw git rev-parse/fetch/ls-remote.
- **Expected:** re-baseline against current `main`.
- **Actual:** fetched `origin/main` is `2c8865e8c`; branch is identical and clean.
- **Severity:** minor
- **Action:** fix
- **Evidence:** `research.md` re-baseline.

## 2026-08-04 — Current manifest run id must be injected

- **What:** S-8 says a manifest is eligible only when `runId` is current, but S5 has no independent
current-run token source; trusting the file's own token or wall clock would not prove currency.
- **Source:** canonical discovery design vs P1 experiment/evidence and S7 ownership boundary.
- **Expected:** identity binding `projectRoot + runId` before use.
- **Actual:** S5 will require an expected current run id at composition. A present manifest without
it, or with a mismatch, reports a failed source outcome. S7 can wire the token later.
- **Severity:** significant
- **Action:** fix
- **Evidence:** `research.md` finding 8/open-question resolution; `plan.md` D4.

## 2026-08-04 — Scoped lint and format need the package config

- **What:** The scoped lint/fmt wrappers failed before source analysis when Deno parsed the root
workspace glob entries; rerunning the same wrapper selections with
`--config packages/mcp/deno.json` passed with zero findings.
- **Source:** Slice 1 validation output from `run-deno-lint.ts` and `run-deno-fmt.ts`.
- **Expected:** The plan's wrapper commands would run from the repository root without an explicit
config.
- **Actual:** `deno check` accepted the selection, while `deno lint`/`deno fmt` reported
`invalid type: string "packages/*", expected struct WorkspaceConfig` until the package config was
supplied.
- **Severity:** minor
- **Action:** accept for this lane; use the package config for exact lint/fmt evidence and leave root
configuration changes out of scope.
- **Evidence:** `worklog.md` Slice 1 gate table; package-configured lint/fmt exit 0 over 76 files.

## 2026-08-04 — Package test task omitted test-only write permission

- **What:** The locked package-test command initially failed three pre-existing tests before their
assertions because they create temporary directories, while the task omitted `--allow-write`.
- **Source:** Slice 2 `deno task --cwd packages/mcp test` output for `drift-evidence_test.ts` and
`stdio_test.ts`.
- **Expected:** The package task would execute its complete test corpus and exit 0.
- **Actual:** The task definition now grants write access only to the test process; runtime and
published package permissions are unchanged. The exact task then passed 78/78.
- **Severity:** minor
- **Action:** fix
- **Evidence:** `packages/mcp/deno.json`; `worklog.md` Slice 2 package-test gate.

## 2026-08-04 — A2 port and adapters grouped after cardinality audit

- **What:** The Design file list described a flat domain contract and flat infrastructure adapters;
the first Slice 3 audit showed the five owned adapters would add a new `src/infrastructure`
cardinality warning and increase the inherited domain count.
- **Source:** Archetype-2 port ownership plus F-16/R-FOLD-CARD and the Slice 3 JSR audit.
- **Expected:** Preserve existing horizontal package debt without adding or deepening a violation.
- **Actual:** The consumed contract lives in `src/ports/`; owned source/probe adapters and their URL
policy live in `src/infrastructure/service-endpoints/` without a sub-barrel. Public exports and
behavior are unchanged. Final audit restores inherited `src/domain` and
`src/application/flows` counts to their baseline 13 and introduces no infrastructure warning.
- **Severity:** minor
- **Action:** fix
- **Evidence:** final JSR audit; zero-diagnostic scoped/doc gates in `worklog.md` Slice 3.

## 2026-08-04 — JSR audit matches Deno's slow-type progress banner

- **What:** `audit-jsr-package.ts` reports `slowTypeWarnings=1` because its `/slow type/i` matcher
captures Deno's neutral `Checking for slow types in the public API...` progress line.
- **Source:** Slice 3 audit output and the helper's `runDryRun()` matcher.
- **Expected:** Only an actual slow-type diagnostic would produce an audit warning.
- **Actual:** Raw `deno doc --lint` for both entrypoints and `deno publish --dry-run --allow-dirty`
pass; Deno emits no slow-type error/warning after the progress line. The shared audit helper was
not changed by this package-scoped lane.
- **Severity:** minor
- **Action:** accept
- **Evidence:** `worklog.md` Slice 3 doc/audit/publish rows.

## 2026-08-04 — Fable review primary unavailable at provider

- **What:** The canonical `review_codex_complex` primary could not start because the native provider
returned `model_not_found` for `fable-5` before review work or token use.
- **Source:** Claude session `1abc6d8e-4c4a-4677-81dd-057eaab9145d` launch result.
- **Expected:** Anthropic Fable 5 at medium effort performs the opposite-family substantive review.
- **Actual:** The configured Claude-family Opus 4.8 fallback ran at medium effort in separate session
`a5d06fbf-041d-4d6a-a4d1-a69fce9ed447`; it returned PASS, then re-reviewed its three addressed
findings and retained PASS. Generator/evaluator family separation remained intact.
- **Severity:** minor
- **Action:** accept for this run; preserve both route identities in the review artifact.
- **Evidence:** `review-codex-complex.md` §§1 and 6.

## 2026-08-04 — OpenHands completion used the verdict artifact, not its stale status comment

- **What:** The OpenHands workflow emitted an exact PASS verdict and committed `evaluate.md`, while
its earlier persistent status comment remained on `Running`; the workflow also did not emit the
optional trace directory.
- **Source:** Agentic watcher result, PR comments, Actions run `30862805934`, and commit
`3e26b2bee`.
- **Expected:** The persistent comment transitions to the terminal state and trace output accompanies
the evaluator artifact.
- **Actual:** The later verdict comment and tracked evaluator artifact are terminal and internally
consistent; the stale progress comment and absent optional trace do not weaken acceptance proof.
- **Severity:** minor
- **Action:** accept for this run; use the exact watcher verdict, final PR comment, and tracked
`evaluate.md` as the authoritative evidence.
- **Evidence:** https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/pull/1194#issuecomment-5172905933;
`.llm/runs/feat-openapi-mcp-endpoint-directory--s5/evaluate.md`.

## 2026-08-04 — Evaluator retained a stale identity-JSDoc advisory

- **What:** OpenHands says `FetchServiceEndpointProbe` JSDoc does not repeat the root identity JSON
contract, but the reviewed source already documents that the root endpoint must return a JSON
`service` field matching the candidate name.
- **Source:** `evaluate.md` finding F-3 compared with
`packages/mcp/src/infrastructure/service-endpoints/fetch-service-endpoint-probe.ts`.
- **Expected:** The final evaluator narrative reflects the post-review source fix.
- **Actual:** The advisory is factually stale but explicitly non-blocking; executable verification,
product behavior, and the PASS verdict are unaffected.
- **Severity:** minor
- **Action:** accept the immutable evaluator artifact and record the correction here.
- **Evidence:** OpenHands PASS artifact; current `FetchServiceEndpointProbe` JSDoc.
Loading
Loading